Destiny Church called a 'money-making cult'

Last updated 09:55 03/03/2010
brian
DESTINY CALLING: Bishop Brian Tamaki.

Relevant offers

Former members of the Destiny Church say it is nothing more than a money-making venture.

The church has been heavily criticised by former members after more than half the congregation including Pastor Andrew Stock walked out of the Sunday service in Brisbane.

Those who walked out said they believed the church was no longer following the Gospel.

Since then former members had supported the walkout and said the church was a money-making cult.

Pastor Stock, his wife Helen and a significant part of the Brisbane congregation walked out over several issues, including money and a new covenant which they said went against the Gospel.

Under the covenant members were encouraged to buy a $300 signet ring, stop buying coffee and give up Sky TV so they could give more money to the church, the New Zealand Herald reported today.

However, the church said the criticism was not new, although the purchase of the covenant ring was not compulsory and was available to men only.

Church spokesman Richard Lewis said the church had a big vision.

"These kinds of comments are nothing new and we go about trying to build our vision as any other church in the country does and it costs money to do it."

The covenant also said that up to $1.3 million would be put aside so church founder Bishop Brian Tamaki could appear on his own television programme every weekday.

Former churchgoer Agnes Granada said she left the church in Auckland because she was "getting uncomfortable".

She told the newspaper making the $300 signet ring a compulsory purchase led her to believe Destiny was not a church, but a money-making cult.

She said God was spiritual and Bishop Tamaki was doing things materialistically.

Another member said Bishop Tamaki, a self-appointed bishop was moving away from the true faith and setting up his business empire.

Mr Lewis said the church had always been "focussed on the Gospel of Jesus Christ. It has been our message from the start and always will continue to be our message".

He said the tangible expression of the message was the church's work in the community and that cost money.

He would not speak about 'the handful' of people who had publicly criticised and left the church although it was disappointing.

However, Mr Lewis said if people were not happy and wanted to leave, they could leave but they would always be welcomed back.

Ad Feedback

- NZPA

77 comments
Bubba   #77   01:20 pm Mar 03 2010

So can we call him Bishop of The Rings or just Bishop Sauron? One Ring to rule them all, One ring to bring them all in and in the darkness bind them. In the land of Destiny where the shodows lie

LeagueFan   #76   01:19 pm Mar 03 2010

Coffee I could do but Sky TV!!....You crossed the line Brian...

Nathan   #75   01:18 pm Mar 03 2010

In answer to #53, in an ideal world, the money people give to their church is used in a number of way: upkeep of the church premises; support for overseas missionaries; funding for foodbanks; wages for staff including the pastor; etc.

Those who are paid this way work hard, often for less than they might get doing a similar job elsewhere, because they believe they are working for God and helping others.

It always makes me sad that this kind of article is the only face of Christianity that a lot of people see, not the one that generously gives to those in need, that helps people in distress and trouble and goes without so that others needs can be met.

Behemoth   #74   01:12 pm Mar 03 2010

Religion isn't made for making money, it has just been distorted that way by people. The belief behind religion, depending on which one you follow, is still important.

Gareth   #73   01:09 pm Mar 03 2010

Churches are tax free? That's outrageous.

james   #72   01:09 pm Mar 03 2010

It appears that some of the Australians that are a part of this 'church' are smarter than the New Zealand members who continue to throw their money away for no cause.

stryker   #71   01:08 pm Mar 03 2010

Jesus did all his work with no money whatsoever.... Works of charity are just that...they are done out of the goodness of your heart not to fund TV shows!

Kelly   #70   01:08 pm Mar 03 2010

Big Ups to those that can think for themselves! free thinkers unite lol.

tr3v   #69   01:02 pm Mar 03 2010

More news brought to you by "Captain Obvious".

Bill   #68   01:02 pm Mar 03 2010

If the Government had any balls at all they would cancel their Tax Free Status, then we would see how long Tamaki and his Gang last.


Show 18-67 of 77 comments
Special offers

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content

Omnivore blog pointer small

The Omnivore: Jeremy Taylor on food

Alex James - what are you playing at?

Moata

Moata's Blog Idle

A Sheep's Show

David Farrar blog pointer small

By the Numbers: David Farrar watches the polls

Mondayising Waitangi and Anzac Days