Stay out of trouble if you don't like prison food - Collins
STEVE HOPKINS AND ANDREA VANCE
Should prisoners be given a healthier range of food?
Relevant offers
Corrections Minister Judith Collins has a message for the long-term prisoner who is demanding healthier menus: "Stay out of jail if you don't like the food".
Dean Wickliffe, one of New Zealand's longest-serving inmates, wrote to Corrections boss Ray Smith asking for greater variety of more affordable and healthy food for purchase in prisons.
But Collins said: ''If he was so worried about the food in prison, he had choices in his life.
''One of them was to not commit crime to end up in prison for long stretches. Hopefully before committing any other crimes, he would like to remember the food he found so boring and tasteless.''
Collins said Corrections made no money from selling ''treats".
She said a smoking ban, in force from July, would mean prisoners would have more cash to spend on goodies.
Prisoners can spend up to $70 a week on food and toiletry items from a nationally-managed list which includes 13 items of confectionary but only three items of fruit.
Wickliffe, a connoisseur of prison food, having spent almost 36 years behind bars, wants more varieties of fruit and vegetables, and a selection of healthier cereals and biscuits added.
The 62-year-old convicted killer, who recently served almost three years jail for possession of a loaded Colt .45 revolver and Class B drug fantasy, said prisoners relied on ''the prison canteen'' because provided meals were often too small or inedible.
''Sometimes you just can't eat the dinner ... they give out ... it gets that bad,'' Wickliffe said from his home in the Bay of Plenty settlement of Maketu.
He said the canteen food was ''high-salt, high-fat, high-sugar rubbish'' and ''action needs to be taken now''.
''It is obvious that no regard was given to the nutritional value of the items we were allowed to buy ... the very worst type of foods which [affect] the health of prisoners over time, especially long-term inmates and which encourage unhealthy eating practises that result in obesity,'' Wickliffe wrote to Smith.
Wickliffe's complaint follows several similar ones during the last two years from career criminal Arthur Taylor concerning food prices at Auckland's high security prison at Paremoremo.
Taylor, who was earlier this month sentenced to seven years' jail for conspiracy to provide P from behind bars, successfully challenged Corrections, through the Office of the Ombudsmen, to reduce fruit prices.
Wickliffe said Taylor's complaint led to cheaper fruit but also a reduced quality. Wickliffe, who started fulltime work for a steel company in Tauranga last week, said that since leaving Springhill Prison the cost of a banana had almost halved from $1 each to 55 cents, ''which shows how much of a mark-up there was''.
''It's just not acceptable to allow prisoners to be exploited by greedy private contractors ... we are literally a captive market for them and are being held ransom while the department turn a blind eye,'' he said.
Wickliffe said canteen prices impacted heavily on inmates whose families often struggled to give them money to buy additional food.
Corrections said it regularly reviewed the prison canteen menu and acted on complaints and requests. In the last 12 months it had received 10 complaints.
Corrections said it was in the process of adding more healthy food options to the menu including a range of ''nuts, muesli bars and fruit teas''.
* In 1972 Wickliffe was convicted of murdering Wellington jeweller Paul Miet during an armed robbery. He maintained the death was accidental, but it took him 12 years to have the charge reduced to manslaughter. His life sentence, however, remained.
He received another life sentence in 1997 for the murder of Bay of Plenty man Richard Bluett, but that conviction was quashed in 1998 and he was acquitted on retrial in 1999.
Wickliffe is the only inmate to have escaped twice from Paremoremo prison.
Food prisoners can purchase:
Barley Sugar - Classic, 110G, $2.73
Party Pack, 225g, $1.71
Pineapple Bites, 250, $1.84
Strong Mints, 200G, $2.51
Fruit Bursts, 190G, $2.51
Crunchie, 50g, $1.03
Moro 60g $2.69
Peanut Slab, 50g, $1.24
Dairy Milk Chocoloate 50g
Tim Tams, 200g, $2.41
Chocolate Chip, 250g, $1.73
Gingernuts, 250g, $1.16
Creams, 375g, $2.04
Fruit, all each:
Apples $0.26
Oranges $0.41
Bananas $0.39
* Comments on this story are now closed
- © Fairfax NZ News
Sponsored links
yes these people did a crime and are doing the time. But why not give them a proper meal that they can eat. Alot of these people will come out of prison a better person and a new chapter will start so they can turn there lifes around to positive not negitive. Yes the prisons are ripping them off on prices with snacks etc so shame on them. Get a garden going in each prison and educate them on how to grow there own veges for when they come out of there. it will also give them something to do while in prison. I know ppl that have been inside and have done courses and have come out with a goal and now are in full time work. Give people a chance we all deserve it. yes they did wrong but most try and make it right and a more postive when they come out. plenty of thinking time they have had inside. I could go on but wont
They deserve the right to healthy food just like the rest of us. But why not put in a prison project to grow this food in their gardens. Get the prisoners to tend to it and they can eat what they grow.
Healthy food helps with the rehabilitation aspect of prison, do you REALLY want a bunch of prisoners, already cranky from nicotine withdrawal, jacked up on sugar?! It makes sense to provide healthy alternatives to prisoners, it's not that we're saying let's all feed them spirulina shakes, we're merely giving them some more choices, just like Maccas offering a salad range, it's still up to them to decide, but just having those alternatives in place will encourage them to eat healthy, learn to be responsible over their bodies and other things.
Prisoners of any kind deserve everything they get. Why should we focus on giving them better food when there are families in New Zealand where the mother or children don“t eat because it is too expensive for them.
If we feed prisoners unhealthy food they will become more of a burden to the tax payer. They will become overweight/obese which is a risk factor for many chronic diseases. Take away all the unhealthy sugary, fatty and salty foods and only give them healthy options. Prison is a prison bottom line; I do not think that following the national dietary guidlines is going to make prison more enjoyable for them. They just wont be in a high risk group of developing diabetes, cardiovascular disease ect.
When was prison meant to be a holiday resort? Surely when you commit crime against society you give away rights. Surely if the food was so terribly bad there would be no surviving prisoners. Wickliffe and others need remember that they took away all the rights of their victims, in total. And don't care.
I think giving them fruit and vegetables etc is a good idea...the food they receive does not have to be tasty but it should be healthy...I think Collins is stating that rather than saying prisoners should be fed unhealthy food...
These people waste OUR money. Taxpayers are paying for all this and it HAS to stop. We simply cannot afford it.
Sure - give them healthier foods, make a local deal with a super market for old stock. They don't need the best and the freshest meals.
Matter of fact is money, food and drugs in prison is currency. They should not be allowed to purchased anything additional than the rations they are given 3 times a day. They should be served meals in there cells and have all food not consumed taken from them after a set period of time.
Remember these people have done wrong. In order to be punished, there freedom and rights must be taken off them. Too many people are returning to prison's just because its easier and comfier. This is a prison, not a hotel.
I would be more inclined to make prisons a harsher environment and shorten sentences. The prison system can be a LOT more efficient than it currently is.
Remember this is YOUR money, NOT the governments. Do you want to pay for these people to have a better lifestyle than most kiwis?
Lots of opinions but perhaps some of you should read the article again. They are not given $70 from the government, they can spend up to $70 a week if it is provided by the family. As for the person who wants the family to pay for the meals, why blame the family for something an individual has done. I agree if you do the crime then you do the time, but don't blame the families.
Murder sentence 'not excessive'
Death threat emails 'clearly a hoax'
Climber dies in Fiordland fall
School bus crash accused in court
Heavy rains, wind pound country
Man jailed for crossbow, machete incident
Engineer denies conflict of interest'
Carterton tragedy: Safety chief would refuse balloon ride
Foreign Affairs Ministry confirms 305 jobs to go
Carterton tragedy: Safety chief would refuse balloon ride
Major courts overhaul proposed
Foreign Affairs Ministry confirms 305 jobs to go
Mob cancels star's performance
Kiwis not up with online security
Helena Bonham Carter 'honoured'
New hope for kiwifruit growers
Gender non-conformity linked to abuse
Nelsen cleared to lead NZ against Jamaica
Robinson starts for Chiefs against old team
Man's childhood comic collection fetches $4.2m
Carterton tragedy: Safety chief would refuse balloon ride
Mob cancels star's performance
Girl's three-hour punishment run fatal
Model ignores Victoria's Secret snub
Jennifer Aniston loves being lewd
Study looks at Kiwis' height, weight

Newest First
Oldest First







what about the low-income population who cant afford enough food to be full and struggle by feeling half-full each day?
prison life is not meant to be comfortable- these guys need to get their act straight. Next thing we know they'll be calling for 7-course meals as part of their basic "rights" and to have any less would be inhumane.