Schools check on cheating parents

Last updated 01:06 04/09/2008

Relevant offers

Christchurch school principals are personally door-knocking parents suspected of cheating controversial zoning rules.

Principals say they are accepting fewer students who live outside their enrolment zone, spurring determined parents to trick their way in to preferred schools.

Thirty-seven Christchurch primary schools were set down to hold ballots for out-of-zone applicants yesterday but The Press understands that few, if any, of the schools held ballots because no spaces were available.

"(There are) people who are absolutely hell-bent on getting around the system," Christchurch Boys' High School principal Trevor McIntyre said.

"They are basically deceitful."

During the last month, McIntyre said he had taken to stopping at the homes of students to check they were living in zone, as their parents claimed.

"We're at the point where we're having families ring us saying did you realise that so-and-so who says they are living in the zone is not living in the zone. That's starting to happen a bit it's that jealousness or that sense of fear."

A student was removed from the Christchurch Boys' High School last year when it was found his parents had forged documents to get their son into the school.

Some parents temporarily moved to an "address of convenience" or claimed they were about to move in to the area, McIntyre said.

"We get them to sign an affidavit through their lawyer to say that they will be living in that house that it's not just an investment house," he said.

Cobham Intermediate acting principal Kevin Rait said the traditional competitive streak over secondary school reputations was moving into primary and intermediate schools.

"We have real estate agents here talk about the Cobham zone they might lumber that in with the Burnside zone," he said.

Cobham Intermediate, in Fendalton, will hold a ballot for out-of-zone applicants on Monday.

Rait did not want to reveal exactly how many out-of-zone applicants were in the ballot, but he agreed scores of parents would be disappointed.

Rait said they had not got to the point of door-knocking suspected cheats, but he knew it was happening.

"We've had people try to up the system living with Auntie and all of this sort of nonsense."

Thorrington School principal Paul Armitage said they usually held two ballots a year but very few students from outside the Cashmere school's zone were admitted.

"For us, it's just new entrants level. We just don't have the places available, really," Armitage said.

Ad Feedback

He said out-of-zone parents tricking their way into primary schools was "most definitely" a problem.

"In fact I think it's actually more challenging for primary schools," he said. "Yes, we are getting tougher and tougher on addresses and I have been out to check addresses to make sure they are legit."

He had not experienced forged documents but said there were parents who stayed with a relative or took a rental address for a very short time.

"Once you've enrolled the child then that's it. The onus is on the school to prove they have used an address of convenience to gain entry and, crikey, it's not very nice stuff to be having to be going down that road."

Armitage said his personal checks on families were "as diplomatic as possible".

"You might send out a bill and it pops back and you think, whoops, hang on a minute. Or there is a change of phone number and you think, hang on, what's happened here."

Principal of Avonhead School Charles Levings organised the advertising for the 37 schools set down for balloting yesterday.

"Before the process of advertising starts, the board of trustees has the ability to say there may not be any vacancies available whatsoever," Levings said.

It was generally unusual to have a ballot at his school, he said.

"Although we would accept a person's application, we would also alert them to the fact that there are just simply no vacancies here because the classrooms are already over-crowded."

- © Fairfax NZ News

23 comments
Liz   #23   05:26 pm Jan 28 2009

Agreed about zoning being ridiculous. People deserve to go to the school that is best for them, regardless of where they live. If they want to travel then that should be their choice.

What is happening to democracy in NZ?

Liz   #22   05:26 pm Jan 28 2009

Agreed about zoning being ridiculous. People deserve to go to the school that is best for them, regardless of where they live. If they want to travel then that should be their choice.

What is happening to democracy in NZ?

dollyfan   #21   05:26 pm Jan 28 2009

Agree 100% dolly. and why would you make your kids commute to a far off school anyway if you didn't have to? we do enough commuting to work as adults as it is.

Mahara   #20   05:26 pm Jan 28 2009

Why shouldn't schools operate that way, you ask? Let me enlighten you. Firstly, maintaining a school takes alot of funding and is costly. Schools are having difficulty meeting funding needs as it is. Then you need to into account issues such as building permits, land availability, having to go through the time consuming process of gaining permission from nearby residents for expansion, etc. Secondly, to have more schools or to expand them you need more teachers. You can only get limited numbers of qualified teachers at any one time for any one sector depending on how many graduate with a qualification each year, and what region they live in or choose to travel to to work. Schools have a fininte number of spaces becuase they can't wave magic wands to change their environment to let everyone in just because a few out of zone people are having a moan about not having precedence over people close to the school.

Gerrade   #19   05:26 pm Jan 28 2009

Zoning laws. It sounds like a good way to keep the gap between the haves and the have nots wider. Zoning laws: All students are equal but some students are more equal than others.

Iris   #18   05:26 pm Jan 28 2009

Zoning only makes sense if all schools are the same. But in reality, they're not and never will be. Parents and students are entitled to go to the school that best suits their individual needs. But at the moment, only rich parents have the choice because they can afford to move or send their children to private schools. Rigid zoning is such a stupid 'one size fits all' policy which totally disregards the students' needs.

Dawn   #17   05:26 pm Jan 28 2009

My child deserves the best I can give him and if that means cheating the 'flawed' system, good luck as long as I can get away with it. If you think all schools are the same, this is the real world and the government does not treat them all the same, they are not funded all the same, therefore are NOT all the same.

Paul   #16   05:26 pm Jan 28 2009

Dolly, why should there be a finite number of places at a school? If a school is popular, it can grow, or establish new branches. If not, it can retrench, or close down.

Most service providers operate this way, why not schools?

Nic   #15   05:26 pm Jan 28 2009

in response to Tracey - the ballot is done randomly, how well your child acheives has nothing to do with it.

Brendon   #14   05:26 pm Jan 28 2009

Agree totally with post #5 ??? there are limited pupil numbers and zoning is the fairest way. Why should a child that lives 20min away get preference over a child that lives 1 min away? Without sounding too snooty if you can???t live in the zone then tough I say.


Show 1-13 of 23 comments
Special offers

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content

Blog on the tracks

Blog on the Tracks: Simon Sweetman on music

How to find the best new music

Moata

Moata's Blog Idle

A Sheep's Show

David Farrar blog pointer small

By the Numbers: David Farrar watches the polls

Mondayising Waitangi and Anzac Days