Penny Hoare wins battle with ACC over care for disabled son video


Penny Hoare has just won a ruling against ACC which will allow her to get 24 hour care for her son.

For the past 23 years, Penny Hoare and her son have lived through hell.

And for the last decade, the stress of battling ACC on behalf of severely disabled Kurtis has almost driven her over the edge.

"It's been a terrible, terrible struggle, it's almost done me in trying to get cover for Kurtis. I now know how people are driven to despair fighting ACC for anything."

Hoare recently won a major victory in her fight with the Accident Compensation Corporation, earning the right to 24-hour funding after a judge overturned the corporation's decision.

FROM THE ARCHIVES: Help for helpless Kurtis
Penny Larkin: A Mother's Story

The Lower Hutt woman has been caring for Kurtis since birth after he was starved of oxygen and born dead at Hutt Hospital, meaning he had to be resuscitated.

Stricken with a raft of medical issues, he continues to repeatedly suffer seizures and cannot see, talk, walk, eat or go to the toilet by himself.

Hoare always believed that medical error was the likely cause of the severe brain damage suffered by her son.

Just hours before Kurtis was born by emergency caesarean section, she went to Hutt Hospital after phoning her obstetrician because her baby was not feeling as active as usual.

She was sent home despite her poor obstetric history but soon returned and a caesarean was decided on, but not done immediately.

Ad Feedback

"About a month later we were told he was going to survive and I think I actually said thank you, even though at the same time they said that he was severely brain damaged."

In 2011, Hoare celebrated after winning a six-year battle to get ACC to accept Kurtis for cover, telling The Dominion Post how devastating the corporation's refusal had been.

But despite believing the saga was over, she has been forced to continue to fight ACC through the courts during the past four years for the level of cover she believes Kurtis deserves.

Soon after the court decision, ACC reduced the hours of care it would cover, claiming Kurtis did not require 24-hour care funding while being looked after by his family.

Hoare's lawyer argued that Kurtis was a "top of the pyramid" case and it was unreasonable to expect family members to provide a significant amount of his care.

ACC's decision was upheld by a reviewer, but overturned by a judge last month who awarded Kurtis 24-hour funding.

In her decision, Judge Nicola Mathers said she considered Hoare's care and devotion, while trying to run a household and work, to be "above and beyond the call of duty".

The ACC reviewer had failed to take into account all relevant matters when deciding the level of care, including the fact Hoare had been sentenced to a "lifetime of care", an oversight that was "startling".

Kurtis was now 23 and at the age most parents could expect their children to move out, go to university, or overseas but Hoare would never have that luxury, the judge said.

"In my view there has been an error of law, or the ACC decision is plainly wrong."

Hoare said battling ACC had been a horrible experience and one that was not yet finished, as she waited for another court date to decide on backdated care payments.

The most recent decision would allow her and her family to have a more normal life.

ACC media manager Sarah Martin said ACC had funded the hours of care based on the independent recommendations received.

The court disagreed with that assessment and ACC accepted that, she said.

 - The Dominion Post


Ad Feedback
special offers

Advantage Auckland City in final

Joao Moreira celebrates his second goal.

Team Wellington have a mountain to climb if they're to make a game of it in second leg of OFC Champions League final.

Masterclass in 'celebrating' fallen teacher's life

It's believed swimmer Leslie Gelberger was run-over by a boat in Auckland harbour.

Emotional scenes as family and friends say goodbye to Leslie Gelberger at the high school he taught at.

How about an underwater stadium?

An artist's impression of a possible underground stadium in Auckland.

A designer says another crater would fit right in on Auckland's waterfront.

Security guard drops burglar

"Stealing from hospice is pretty low," says Insite Security's Chris Martin.

A rugby league-loving security guard made the perfect tackle to bring down a burglar armed with a crowbar.


From 'Fats' to fighting fit video

Fats Moke is a big man with a gang history who has worked with Dr Tom Mulholland to get his diabetes under control.

After a shock diagnosis, former mobster 'Fats' Moke is fighting back against losing his legs.

Big bill from toxic sites

Contaminated Te Mome Stream - or Dead Man's Arm to locals - has priority status for a clean-up.

Taxpayers to foot the bill for more than 60 toxic sites across NZ that still require funding.

Back to school for Andrew Little

Labour Party leader Andrew Little will be stepping out from the comfort of Parliament to do admin at Island Bay School.

Labour Leader to take on his wife's job and run the admin office at a Wellington school.

Wine ... and eggs?

Winemaker Tony Bish imported an oak egg from France which will be used to make chardonnay.

An unlikely combination of wine and eggs is taking wine innovation to another level.


Thieves target high-end shops

Staff at The Collective at The Colombo are sick of thieves targeting their store.

Chch's The Collective hit three times in a week, with one thief taking jacket off a mannequin.

Car plunge mystery

Police say they received a call at 4.50pm about a car entering the Buller River.

A dog escaped, but the driver is yet to be found after car crashed into the Buller River.

Snow to hit Port Hills?

Christchurch Mayor Lianne Dalziel battles an umbrella in the wind on Sunday.

Worst of the chilly gales and rain will hit about 6pm - and snow could settle on the hills.

Coming in to land ... on SH1

Air Kaikoura Aero Club, pictured with its training plane near Mt Fyffe, supplied a service between Kaikoura and Clarence.

Cars cannot drive on it, so the Kaikoura aero club wants to use it for planes.


Architectural wonders revealed

The new law and management building at Waikato University was designed by Opus Architecture.

A lot of well known Waikato and Bay of Plenty buildings - and spaces - have earned accolades.

It's our turn to fix this

A medical school backed by Waikato Hospital, pictured, and Waikato University  seeks to train GPs to fill a critical ...

OPINION: The old boys have failed to fix New Zealand's doctor shortage, now it's our turn.

Join the fight for our med school

Waikato University vice-chancellor Professor Neil Quigley and Waikato District Health Board chief executive Dr Nigel Murray.

A proposed medical school in the Waikato has the Government interested.

Ref raids accounts

050711 NEWS. Robert Charles/Taranaki Daily News. Cheque/ cheque book. Money. Bank.

Colleagues blew the whistle on referee who swiped $13K and a video camera.


Campbell Lane opens

South Taranaki District mayor Ross Dunlop officiated at the ribbon-cutting ceremony.

New development in Hawera gets the thumbs-up from residents.

Crowds at health expo

There was a vast array of products and services available.

Health and wellness expo in New Plymouth boomed.

Faith in the future

Taranaki Cathedral of St Mary's, Bishop Philip Richardson, centre, blesses Dean of St Mary's Very Reverend Peter Beck as ...

New Zealand's oldest church is being strengthened and it's about more than bricks and mortar.

Mail delays irk posties

Postal Workers Union's Southern District president John Maynard said they want New Zealand Post investigated for serious ...

Reaction to a story on 'snail mail' was not new news to posties.


A look inside the stricken gorge video

The two slips are around two kilometres apart and it will take weeks for the road through the gorge to reopen.

The road through the Manawatu Gorge will be closed for weeks - and here's why.

Cyber act in action

The Harmful Digitial Communications Act was passed in July 2015.

Act helps as more than 20 people prosecuted for posting harmful content online.

Ram-raid attempt to steal cigarettes

The Feilding BP on Kimbolton Rd was ram-raided.

A stolen ute was used to ram into a BP station in an attempt to steal cigarettes

NZDF civilians take strike action

Civilian employees of NZDF are on strike about pay.

Union accuses the Defence Force of intimidation after strike action.


Not a house, it's a croquet shelter

Athol Turner has a few home comforts at the Hinemoa Croquet Club shelter, including coffee and a biography of Alec Guiness.

As the Nelson City Council looks to implement a new law banning sleeping in the city we meet a man who has made a croquet club his home.

Housing crisis help?

David Barnes, right, with his son Samuel Barnes who needs medical care, pictured with the dwelling David built for him ...

A Nelson man built a home on his property for his mentally-ill son. Could this solve our housing issues?

Guilty of murder

Philip Quayle died after being attacked on a street in Cairns, Australia, about 100 metres from home.

A man who choked a Nelson man to death during a random street attack in Cairns has been found guilty of murder.

Taking a leaf out of the future video

Nelson Mail Journalist Tim O'Connell with the Nissan Leaf electric vehicle(EV) that the Nelson Mail has had on loan from ...

Tim O'Connell shares the thrills, trials and tribulations of driving an electric vehicle.


Meat pies and babies

Blenheim-raised comedian Tony Lyall is performing his new show Happy Hour at the NZ International Comedy Festival next week.

 Blenheim-raised comedian Tony Lyall's new show is about the things, big and small, that put a smile on people's faces.

Sound of the future

The junior Blenheim Brass Band excelled at the New Zealand National Brass Band Championships in Wellington. They used a ...

Young brass band members may one day sport colourful, plastic instruments.

Jetset health staff costing millions

District health boards across the country are grappling with a specialist shortage.

Spending on overseas medical staff is in the millions, as a union warns NZ increasingly reliant on international workers.

Hockey trio off to tackle Aussies

Andrew Nation will represent the New Zealand 35-40 years side in Whangarei.

Three hockey players will represent their country at the 2017 Trans-Tasman Masters Challenge.

South Canterbury

Parents remember 'talented' son

Rowan Yeager died following a crash near Lake Ohau on Anzac Day. This photo, supplied by friend Andrew Weatherall, shows ...

Man killed in crash near Lake Ohau was just a week off moving into house he built by hand.

Cleverley 'exonerated'

Former South Canterbury District Health Board chair Murray Cleverley has spoken out for the first time about his ...

Former SCDHB chair Murray Cleverley says decision to resign as chair was tough.

Late-night quad bike death

The man crashed a quad bike just before midnight on Friday night.

A man was killed in a crash on a South Canterbury highway just before midnight.

'We have got a lot of work to do'

SCDHB chief executive Nigel Trainor says the DHB is going try and improve low rates of HPV vaccination by providing more ...

SC has a 'poor' HPV vaccination rate, prompting the DHB to turn to social media.


Volunteer firefighters getting medical training

Edendale Firefighters Brendon Cameron, Shane Elliott, Richard Hart, Scottie Cameron, Brian Coyle, Rudi Verplancke and ...

Some Southland volunteer fire brigades are taking on extra medical training to provide a service to fill a need within their community.

Visitor tax unlikely

Finance Minister Steven Joyce and Clutha Southland MP Todd Barclay in Queenstown.

Finance Minister says more money does need to be spent on tourism infrastructure.

Pros and cons of reform

Southland Regional Development Strategy governance group chair Tom Campbell.

Experts say the effect of the changes to immigration reform are uncertain at this stage, with both positives and negatives to come out of the new policy.

Walking for enjoyment

Recreational walking gives June Wilson, left, and Ngaire Evans immense pleasure.

Joining walking groups is good for exercise and making friends, June Wilson says.

Ad Feedback