Penny Hoare wins battle with ACC over care for disabled son video

CAMERON BURNELL/Dominion Post.

Penny Hoare has just won a ruling against ACC which will allow her to get 24 hour care for her son.

For the past 23 years, Penny Hoare and her son have lived through hell.

And for the last decade, the stress of battling ACC on behalf of severely disabled Kurtis has almost driven her over the edge.

"It's been a terrible, terrible struggle, it's almost done me in trying to get cover for Kurtis. I now know how people are driven to despair fighting ACC for anything."

Hoare recently won a major victory in her fight with the Accident Compensation Corporation, earning the right to 24-hour funding after a judge overturned the corporation's decision.

FROM THE ARCHIVES: Help for helpless Kurtis
Penny Larkin: A Mother's Story

The Lower Hutt woman has been caring for Kurtis since birth after he was starved of oxygen and born dead at Hutt Hospital, meaning he had to be resuscitated.

Stricken with a raft of medical issues, he continues to repeatedly suffer seizures and cannot see, talk, walk, eat or go to the toilet by himself.

Hoare always believed that medical error was the likely cause of the severe brain damage suffered by her son.

Just hours before Kurtis was born by emergency caesarean section, she went to Hutt Hospital after phoning her obstetrician because her baby was not feeling as active as usual.

She was sent home despite her poor obstetric history but soon returned and a caesarean was decided on, but not done immediately.

Ad Feedback

"About a month later we were told he was going to survive and I think I actually said thank you, even though at the same time they said that he was severely brain damaged."

In 2011, Hoare celebrated after winning a six-year battle to get ACC to accept Kurtis for cover, telling The Dominion Post how devastating the corporation's refusal had been.

But despite believing the saga was over, she has been forced to continue to fight ACC through the courts during the past four years for the level of cover she believes Kurtis deserves.

Soon after the court decision, ACC reduced the hours of care it would cover, claiming Kurtis did not require 24-hour care funding while being looked after by his family.

Hoare's lawyer argued that Kurtis was a "top of the pyramid" case and it was unreasonable to expect family members to provide a significant amount of his care.

ACC's decision was upheld by a reviewer, but overturned by a judge last month who awarded Kurtis 24-hour funding.

In her decision, Judge Nicola Mathers said she considered Hoare's care and devotion, while trying to run a household and work, to be "above and beyond the call of duty".

The ACC reviewer had failed to take into account all relevant matters when deciding the level of care, including the fact Hoare had been sentenced to a "lifetime of care", an oversight that was "startling".

Kurtis was now 23 and at the age most parents could expect their children to move out, go to university, or overseas but Hoare would never have that luxury, the judge said.

"In my view there has been an error of law, or the ACC decision is plainly wrong."

Hoare said battling ACC had been a horrible experience and one that was not yet finished, as she waited for another court date to decide on backdated care payments.

The most recent decision would allow her and her family to have a more normal life.

ACC media manager Sarah Martin said ACC had funded the hours of care based on the independent recommendations received.

The court disagreed with that assessment and ACC accepted that, she said.

 - The Dominion Post

Comments

Ad Feedback
special offers
Auckland

Court action over landslide

Road works have begun on a major slip above Jessica Mead's property on Waiheke Island.

A Waiheke Island property owner is taking Auckland Transport to court after a slip onto her land.

Buckle up in your vehicles

Howick Sergeant Brett Meale says motorists must ensure that their children are restrained every time they get in their ...

ON THE BEAT: A worrying observation is the number of children either unrestrained or restrained incorrectly in cars.

Gulf brimming with variety of fish

Jan Appelgryn caught this 63cm snapper on his jet-ski off Bucklands Beach, East Auckland.

FISHING REPORT: Fishos are experiencing plentiful catches of snapper, kahawai and kingfish across the Hauraki Gulf.

IT movie 'impacting' clowns

Ken Samson, also known as Cherry the Clown, says movies like IT give clowns a bad rap.

Horror movie IT hurting the business of professional clowns, Auckland performer says.

Wellington

Bank theft accused

Bank branch manager Fiona Barber is accused of taking funds from her bank.

Fiona Barber worked for ANZ for 32 years. She is accused of taking over $134,000 over six years.

Scared at the wheel

How courteous are you when driving?

Most Kiwis have no faith in other drivers, but apparently don't own their own bad driving.

Fired for swearing

Pak 'n Save.

Supermarket worker was heard bad-mouthing her manager, but should not have been fired for it, ERA says.

I salute your family: Judge

Kōhanga reo fraudster Frances Edmonds' family is to pay back the money she took.

Family paying more than $100k in reparation to the kōhanga reo she defrauded.

Canterbury

Residents react to flood options video

Warren Hensley outside his family home on Clarendon Tce.

When Heathcote River floods, Kit Mouat is one of many residents who fork out for damage.

'Special part of the city'

Landscape work on the CTV site is due to begin next week.

The site where 115 died in the February 2011 quake will be turned into a "peaceful place to sit and reflect".

Divers resume search

Missing West Coast fisherman Kieran Lynch, 22, with partner Jess Ford and their young daughter Ava Lynch.

Dive squad resumes search for fisherman and new dad Kieran Lynch, who's been missing for more than a month.

Vegan cafe a hit with meat-eaters

Our pick of the day - The Pumpkin One. Whether you're vegan or not there's no denying this is a tasty dish.

REVIEW: With queues out the door, the hype is real for the speciality Christchurch cafe.

Waikato

Toilet training in paradise

Raglan hopes to stop any unnecessary wastewater overflows by reminding people of what should and shouldn't go into the ...

Holiday destination plagued by sewage spills takes toilet etiquette to the street.

Casino robbery lead

Police want to speak to this man in relation to the robbery of a man from the Hamilton's SkyCity Casino.

Police want to speak to this man after a winner was followed and robbed at knifepoint.

Light at end of Cobham tunnel

Walk into the light of the Hamilton Gardens.

Underpass opening will end Russian roulette crossing to Hamilton Gardens.

Pupils thrive on unwanted laptops

Cambridge Primary School teacher Carol-Lynn Hill is on the hunt for old laptops to use in the classroom for pupils with ...

Old clunky laptops up-cycled and reused for children's learning in Cambridge classroom.

Taranaki

Tantrum free shopping

Holly Vandenberg, with niece India Miller Rain Vandenberg, has started up the Panda Crew website where people can ...

Would you use a subscription service to buy your baby clothes?

Vehicle under water

Dave Chadfield, of Chaddy's Charters, points to where a ute is submerged in the marina at Port Taranaki after two men ...

"I heard screaming, yelling and swearing and saw two guys walk ashore."

Victim's night of terror

A Hawera man deeply regretted assaulting his partner during  "one explosive incident", his lawyer said.  (file photo)

He choked, shoved and dragged his partner, then called her crazy.

Charges yet to be laid

A police investigation into hundreds of thousands of dollars going missing from a Taranaki hapu is ongoing. (File Photo).

Inquiries into theft allegations continue, as fall-out within hapu independently investigated.

Manawatu

A rural shemozzle

Libby Masefield having fun with bulls' balls in her mouth.

What started as a yarn at the pub has become a rural event attracting 5000 visitors a year. 

Appeal continues video

Mark Lundy, pictured at his 2015 retrial, is appealing his convictions for murdering his wife and daughter.

Lundy's appeal expected to cover petrol and public perception.

Milner-Skudder surgery complete

Nehe Milner-Skudder dislocated his shoulder after an awkward fall during the All Blacks' win over Springboks earlier ...

Injured All Blacks star hopes to be back in late April or May after successful operation.

Life-changing bikes introduced video

Tetraplegic Marina Theron hopes to one day use the bike freely.

Walking bikes put the rehabilitation of people with crippling illnesses into motion.

Nelson

Milk dance creative, entertaining

The Creamery was part of the Nelson Art's Festival.

The Nelson Musical Theatre was transformed into a cheese factory for The Creamery - an interpretive show about the world of cheese.

Final drop begins

A small number of protesters show their disdain for the third poison drop at the Brook Sanctuary.

Final poison drop starts as part of the Brook Sanctuary operation.

False alarm frustrates

Man having a rest next to state highway 6 north of Nelson sparks emergency call-out.

'Stop and check' fire serivce says, after cyclist resting sparks an emergency call-out.

Fanning the flames of friendship

12102017  NEWS PHOTO MARTIN DE RUYTER/stuff

Retired fire fighters Bob Finlayson, left, Peter Shea, Des Edwards, Doug ...

A weekly coffee group for retired firefighters has proven good for their mental wellbeing.

Marlborough

A rose for Red Cross

There are 2500 roses ready to sell at the fundraiser on Thursday.

Preparations are underway for Red Rose Day tomorrow.

Bridging the gap

Sounds Air chief executive Andrew Crawford says if the research stacks up 19-seater Beechcrafts could be flying between ...

Sounds Air could be flying 19-seaters between Christchurch and Blenheim by early next year.

Corporate rowing crews battle it out

30082017 News Photo: TOM LEE/STUFF - Sport - Rowing NZ team media day at Lake Karapiro. Mens eight

Corporate 8 crews optimistic at Wairau Rowing Club's annual challenge.

'Skylarking' caused fatal crash

Lara Glover, 16, died and four others were injured in the car crash on February 19.

Teen driver caused fatal crash by swerving his parents' SUV from side to side while doing close to 100kmh.

South Canterbury

First crack at musical direction

Matt Deavoll is trying his hand as musical director for upcoming South Canterbury Drama League show Variety.

Deavoll's been in the orchestra, and on the stage. Now, for the first time, he's the musical director

Fees for monitoring

South Canterbury Chamber of Commerce chief executive Wendy Smith said she hoped the move was a "genuine"  attempt to ...

Timaru residents who break the terms of their resource consents will have to pay.

Loan nearly paid off

Phar Lap Charitable Trust member Noel Walker says the trust is chipping away at the loan it received to cover the ...

Trust still chipping away at loan eight years after Phar Lap statue was erected outside race track.

Shearing shed gutted

Bruce Rogers surveys the damage to his shearing shed after the fire on Monday night.

Fire crews forced to cut holes in wool shed to extinguish "well involved" fire near Geraldine.

Otago

Mayor cuts ties with 'unlawful' group

Central Otago mayor Tim Cadogan above Clyde.

Central Otago Mayor Tim Cadogan says he has "no choice" but to remove himself from a business group.

Captain Cook closes again

The Captain Cook Hotel in Dunedin has closed until a "suitable" new operator can be found.

The Captain Cook, an iconic Dunedin bar, has shut its doors once more.

Tapanui girls turn into possum trappers

Blue Mountain College Duke of Edinburgh gold service project members with their possum trap, from left, Susan Whyte, 16, ...

Duke of Edinburgh possum trapping project engages Tapanui school girls.

Rail car captures nostalgia of Otago's rich railway heritage

Dunedin Railways' RM24 Silver Fern Railcar.

Railcar spotting on the Otago-Southland route.

Southland

The Lim hymn: Let's Eat

Celebrity chef Nadia Lim shares her latest book, Let's Eat, with Julie Allan, Sarah Johnson and Gabrielle Berger Sidwell ...

Despite releasing seven cookbooks in seven years, inspiration is never far away for celebrity chef Nadia Lim.

Bravery awards given

Nightcaps men Conrad Waihape, left, and Phil Manson were presented with Bravery awards at a Southland District Council ...

"It was pretty dark and bloody hard to see..."

Let's talk, Southland: Kirwan

Sir John Kirwan visited Northern Southland College, Lumsden, on Tuesday afternoon.

Mental health speeches "powerful, timely, relevant".

Aparima College to get new principal, board of trustees

Aparima College commissioner Nicola Hornsey.

Embattled Aparima College in Riverton is set to have elections to form a board of trustees after its new principal is recruited.

Ad Feedback