Penny Hoare wins battle with ACC over care for disabled son video

CAMERON BURNELL/Dominion Post.

Penny Hoare has just won a ruling against ACC which will allow her to get 24 hour care for her son.

For the past 23 years, Penny Hoare and her son have lived through hell.

And for the last decade, the stress of battling ACC on behalf of severely disabled Kurtis has almost driven her over the edge.

"It's been a terrible, terrible struggle, it's almost done me in trying to get cover for Kurtis. I now know how people are driven to despair fighting ACC for anything."

Hoare recently won a major victory in her fight with the Accident Compensation Corporation, earning the right to 24-hour funding after a judge overturned the corporation's decision.

FROM THE ARCHIVES: Help for helpless Kurtis
Penny Larkin: A Mother's Story

The Lower Hutt woman has been caring for Kurtis since birth after he was starved of oxygen and born dead at Hutt Hospital, meaning he had to be resuscitated.

Stricken with a raft of medical issues, he continues to repeatedly suffer seizures and cannot see, talk, walk, eat or go to the toilet by himself.

Hoare always believed that medical error was the likely cause of the severe brain damage suffered by her son.

Just hours before Kurtis was born by emergency caesarean section, she went to Hutt Hospital after phoning her obstetrician because her baby was not feeling as active as usual.

She was sent home despite her poor obstetric history but soon returned and a caesarean was decided on, but not done immediately.

Ad Feedback

"About a month later we were told he was going to survive and I think I actually said thank you, even though at the same time they said that he was severely brain damaged."

In 2011, Hoare celebrated after winning a six-year battle to get ACC to accept Kurtis for cover, telling The Dominion Post how devastating the corporation's refusal had been.

But despite believing the saga was over, she has been forced to continue to fight ACC through the courts during the past four years for the level of cover she believes Kurtis deserves.

Soon after the court decision, ACC reduced the hours of care it would cover, claiming Kurtis did not require 24-hour care funding while being looked after by his family.

Hoare's lawyer argued that Kurtis was a "top of the pyramid" case and it was unreasonable to expect family members to provide a significant amount of his care.

ACC's decision was upheld by a reviewer, but overturned by a judge last month who awarded Kurtis 24-hour funding.

In her decision, Judge Nicola Mathers said she considered Hoare's care and devotion, while trying to run a household and work, to be "above and beyond the call of duty".

The ACC reviewer had failed to take into account all relevant matters when deciding the level of care, including the fact Hoare had been sentenced to a "lifetime of care", an oversight that was "startling".

Kurtis was now 23 and at the age most parents could expect their children to move out, go to university, or overseas but Hoare would never have that luxury, the judge said.

"In my view there has been an error of law, or the ACC decision is plainly wrong."

Hoare said battling ACC had been a horrible experience and one that was not yet finished, as she waited for another court date to decide on backdated care payments.

The most recent decision would allow her and her family to have a more normal life.

ACC media manager Sarah Martin said ACC had funded the hours of care based on the independent recommendations received.

The court disagreed with that assessment and ACC accepted that, she said.

 - The Dominion Post

Comments

Ad Feedback
special offers
Auckland

Chef to MPI: 'Burger off'

Duke of Marlborough restaurant manager Kelsey Benefield tucks into a Governor's Burger - before it's cut from the menu.

New red tape will kill signature hamburger at NZ's oldest licensed restaurant, says chef.

Dad died in hand-me-downs

On Tuesday, Carolyn Diane Alleyne will be sentenced in the Manukau District Court after pleading guilty to six ...

War veteran died on Father's Day with nothing but the clothes on his back, having been fleeced by his daughter.

At home with a Maori healer

Gabrielle Sexton-McDevitt lives in Koutu in the Hokianga.

Gabrielle Sexton-McDevitt works as a nurse and Maori healer. She lives with with her husband John, three dogs, a cat, a mini horse and 22 chooks.

Victims demand apology from church

St Peters Anglican Church on Killarney St, Takapuna sits on the site where a trust foster home use to be.

Fresh claims of abuse in state care have surfaced – this time involving the Anglican Church.

Wellington

Geraint Martin: Museum Man

Geraint Martin, new CEO of Te Papa, for National Portrait.

Geraint Martin discovered the magic of museums when he was a small boy.

Yacht crew rescued

Peter McLean (left) aboard Jungle, the stricken yacht.

A Fijian naval boat has found the New Zealand yacht that ran aground on a reef near Fiji.

The age of umbrage weakens us all

Fun with guns: Military personnel from Linton Army Base visit Whakarongo School  - Maddison Brown (left) and Amy Van ...

 OPINION: Social media aided by a bottom-feeding media are weakening society.

Ready to roar

British and Irish Lions' fans are in good spirits after notching up victories against the New Zealand Provincial ...

All you need to know for the Lions' visit to Wellington.

Canterbury

Christchurch into 'Goldilocks years'

The Hoyts' EntX cinema complex is under construction in Colombo St.

City leaders say conditions are "just right" for big progress in the CBD in the next three years.

School defends ban

A school says kids can stay warm over winter without trousers. (File photo)

Chch primary school says pupils can wear long socks and a jacket if their shorts aren't warm enough.

Icy chaos in the south

Police are urging "extreme caution" after two cars slipped off the Te Anau-Mossburn Highway and another off the Cardrona ...

Southland's roads are icy challenge for hapless drivers with five crashes in 12 hours.

Murky politics in the deep south video

Tony Wilson, mechanic at Dipton Engineering, said many of the locals in the valley didn't bother themselves with ...

The mysterious machinations of murky Southland politics revealed.

Waikato

For the love of live music

Ivan Muir has hosted a multitude of acts at Nivara Lounge.

Ivan Muir is the main man behind a push to get touring bands to come and play in Hamilton.

Growers' $376m loss video

Growers are taking a class action against the Government over the Psa incursion.

Some kiwifruit growers lost millions – now they want the Government to be held accountable.

Days of the dead: Inside a mortuary

Garth Wright is a technician at the Waikato DHB mortuary at Waikato Hospital.

Garth Wright works with corpses, day in, day out. They come back to visit him in dreams.

Lifting weights and hopes

Temira Hetherington and Tai Mataroa with daughter Paris were in Hamilton to support the power-lifting event at Waikato ...

Losing two young children to a mystery disease that has no cure is Temira Hetherington and Tai Mataroa's reality.

Taranaki

Block couple buy first home video

The Block's Jeremy Hill and Cat Glass have bought their first home in Taranaki.

They vowed not to do another renovation project - but now The Block 2015 contestants Cat and Jeremy have their own villa to do up.

The last store standing

United Video owner Sam Bansal says he is still here and open for business.

They're becoming as rare as hen's teeth, and now New Plymouth only has one left.

Banking on the change in money

23062017 News GRANT MATTHEW/FAIRFAX NZ

Banking Industry. People use less cash and more tech to pay for goods.
Steve ...

We're spending more than ever before so why's it getting harder for banks to stay open?

Word to your mother

21062017 News Photo ANDY JACKSON/Fairfax NZ.   Brittany Bourgoise runs her own nail technician business from home.  Kids ...

Brittany Bourgoise is a mumpreneur and reckons other mothers can become one too.

Manawatu

Vision and culture

Te Kahurangi Skelton-Pue, 17, from Manakura, speaking in the Nga Manu Korero Manawatu competition.

​Visionary leaders, plans for success and strength in identity are on the minds of Manawatu youth.

More refugee support

Bhutan refugees Dirga Maya Poudel,  Bir Bahadur Poudel and Gopal Poudel could be joined in Palmerston North by more ...

More refugees could be calling Palmerston North home, if ideas escalate into funded plans.

Page the midwife

Firefighters and midwives are among those who will continue using pagers after Spark exits the public pager system at ...

Critical services will still use pagers after Spark opts out of the old technology.

Palmer slams Horizons

Sir Geoffrey Palmer, architect of the Resource Management Act

Council's court loss over farm runoff an example of local government failure, says former PM.

Nelson

Who killed Kevin O'Loughlin?

Kevin O'Loughlin, 30, who was stabbed to death on the corner of a Nelson carpark on May 2, 1993. His murder has not been ...

Who was the man behind one of Nelson's only unsolved murders?

Retirees for Richmond

Andrew Spittal says the aim is to develop about 550 to 650 sections on the site.

A $130m retirement village is tipped as part of a proposed $350m development in Richmond, near Nelson.

Conversations in virtual reality

Scott Cardwell of ImmerseMe with Nelson College for Girls year 10 student Alyah Archer at  demonstration of the ...

What if you could practice foreign languages in school while talking to real people, in real situation?

Experiencing volunteering firsthand

Nelson Mail reporter Carly Gooch volunteered at Nelson Hospital's Oncology Ward.

 Carly Gooch finds out what volunteering is really all about by spending some time helping out in the chemotherapy ward at Nelson Hospital.

Marlborough

Fisheries patrol vessel blessed for success

MPI chief compliance officer Anthony Little, left, with Archdeacon Andy Joseph while he blesses the new MPI fisheries ...

Longer, faster and harder to evade - The new fisheries patrol vessel in the top of the south is blessed and ready for action.

Weekend sport

Harlequins number eight Jono Nicoliason offloads during his side's division one match with East Coast at Lansdowne Park.

Moutere and Renwick moved clear of the pack with wins on Saturday.

New surgeon remodels service

Vascular surgeon Carmen Ruiz.

Nelson's new vascular surgeon is providing better care for those needing treatment for blocked arteries and aneurysms.

Blenheim's bug motel

Faalelei Sioveata, 7, Angel Quinton, 9, and PhilipJunior Fodow, 7, have created a bug-friendly motel.

There's a new motel in town, and it's full of creepy crawlies.

South Canterbury

Marking Matariki in Waimate video

Waimate Main School kapa haka group members are, from left, Summer Pay, 8, Maddison Longman, 8, and Ashley Guy, 7.

Attendee numbers have grown, and performances have improved, since Matariki celebrations began in Waimate six years ago.

RSA restructure looms

South Canterbury Returned and Services' Association president Greg O'Brien.

Restructure looms as South Canterbury RSA tries to improve its financial situation.

Clone sought for vet practice video

Stepping back after 40 years at the Veterinary Centre Waimate is vet Dougall McLachlan.

Dougall McLachlan's colleagues want his last pair of work gumboots to last a very long time.

$1.1m for new lights

Netcon chief executive Steve McCoy with an LED light of the type his company has already installed in Temuka. The Timaru ...

Work to replace Timaru's street lights can start next month thanks to boost.

Southland

Young performers face the music

Monique Clementson (Deloris), Annie Sherborne, and Rachael Scott (Sister Mary Patrick) at rehearsals for the ...

Young performers are gaining exposure and touring the country for Sister Act the musical.

Arrested after threats

08072016 Newsphoto. SIMON MAUDE / FAIRFAX NZ. Generic, stock, NZ Police, police car, The po po, police. 08-N-policeC

A 54-year-old man was arrested after threatening Work and Income staff.

Father 'evil', grief-stricken mum says

Police staff at the Riverton home where three-month-old Honour Ashworth was injured.

Grieving Southland mother says her soul was "ripped to pieces" when she found out her partner caused her infant son's death.

Green Party takes off

Green Party of Aotearoa New Zealand Invercargill candidate Rochelle Surendran speaks at a Green Party Launch in Invercargill.

Green Party co-leader comments on Clutha-Southland MP resignation during Invercargill visit.

Ad Feedback