Penny Hoare wins battle with ACC over care for disabled son video


Penny Hoare has just won a ruling against ACC which will allow her to get 24 hour care for her son.

For the past 23 years, Penny Hoare and her son have lived through hell.

And for the last decade, the stress of battling ACC on behalf of severely disabled Kurtis has almost driven her over the edge.

"It's been a terrible, terrible struggle, it's almost done me in trying to get cover for Kurtis. I now know how people are driven to despair fighting ACC for anything."

Hoare recently won a major victory in her fight with the Accident Compensation Corporation, earning the right to 24-hour funding after a judge overturned the corporation's decision.

FROM THE ARCHIVES: Help for helpless Kurtis
Penny Larkin: A Mother's Story

The Lower Hutt woman has been caring for Kurtis since birth after he was starved of oxygen and born dead at Hutt Hospital, meaning he had to be resuscitated.

Stricken with a raft of medical issues, he continues to repeatedly suffer seizures and cannot see, talk, walk, eat or go to the toilet by himself.

Hoare always believed that medical error was the likely cause of the severe brain damage suffered by her son.

Just hours before Kurtis was born by emergency caesarean section, she went to Hutt Hospital after phoning her obstetrician because her baby was not feeling as active as usual.

She was sent home despite her poor obstetric history but soon returned and a caesarean was decided on, but not done immediately.

Ad Feedback

"About a month later we were told he was going to survive and I think I actually said thank you, even though at the same time they said that he was severely brain damaged."

In 2011, Hoare celebrated after winning a six-year battle to get ACC to accept Kurtis for cover, telling The Dominion Post how devastating the corporation's refusal had been.

But despite believing the saga was over, she has been forced to continue to fight ACC through the courts during the past four years for the level of cover she believes Kurtis deserves.

Soon after the court decision, ACC reduced the hours of care it would cover, claiming Kurtis did not require 24-hour care funding while being looked after by his family.

Hoare's lawyer argued that Kurtis was a "top of the pyramid" case and it was unreasonable to expect family members to provide a significant amount of his care.

ACC's decision was upheld by a reviewer, but overturned by a judge last month who awarded Kurtis 24-hour funding.

In her decision, Judge Nicola Mathers said she considered Hoare's care and devotion, while trying to run a household and work, to be "above and beyond the call of duty".

The ACC reviewer had failed to take into account all relevant matters when deciding the level of care, including the fact Hoare had been sentenced to a "lifetime of care", an oversight that was "startling".

Kurtis was now 23 and at the age most parents could expect their children to move out, go to university, or overseas but Hoare would never have that luxury, the judge said.

"In my view there has been an error of law, or the ACC decision is plainly wrong."

Hoare said battling ACC had been a horrible experience and one that was not yet finished, as she waited for another court date to decide on backdated care payments.

The most recent decision would allow her and her family to have a more normal life.

ACC media manager Sarah Martin said ACC had funded the hours of care based on the independent recommendations received.

The court disagreed with that assessment and ACC accepted that, she said.

 - The Dominion Post


Ad Feedback
special offers

Lift refugee quota: Helen Clark

Helen Clark first opened Refugees as Survivors New Zealand in 2007.

Former Prime Minister Helen Clark has renewed calls for New Zealand to increase its refugee quota.

Auckland Transport finally helps with flooding

Julie Ingham has put sandbags around her Onetangi house to try to stop flooding.

Auckland Transport has finally responded to calls to stop water pouring off the road onto two properties on Waiheke Island.

Candidates unplugged: Marja Lubeck

Addressing the housing crisis is at the top of Marja Lubeck's list this election.

Dream big and you'll be amazed at what comes true, Marja Lubeck says.

Young man's death suspicious

Police are still investigating the suspicious death after the party turned fatal.

Reginald Sharma died in a driveway after a rowdy and violent Auckland house party turned fatal.


Highlighting a not-so-sweet subject

Jasmine Togo-Brisby's Bitter Sweet 2013 - 2015 is a sculpture made up of a pile of skulls cast in unrefined sugar.

A sculpture cast from unrefined sugar is a Wellington-based artist's way of telling her family's history in the sugar-slave trade.

Rude awakening

Whetu Leef said the car came dangerously lose to hitting him and his wife.

Driver fleeing police crashes into sleeping couple's bedroom, yelling out "sorry, bro" as he jumped fence.

Delays after truck rolls

There were significant traffic delays after a truck carrying a digger rolled at the intersection of Fergusson Dr and ...

Delays after a truck carrying a digger rolled in Upper Hutt

Runway safety in Supreme Court

While the court challenge ostensibly concerns a proposal to extend Wellington Airport's runway to enable long haul ...

Wellington Airport's ambitious plan to attract long-haul services could affect airports across New Zealand.


Sumner pride in spades video

Matuku Takotako: Sumner Centre has opened on Wakefield Ave. Hundreds gathered at the $10m building on Saturday for a ...

Hundreds gathered to mark the opening of Matuku Takotako: Sumner Centre on Saturday.

Child's death 'medical'

A six-month-old baby has died in central Christchurch (file photo).

Christchurch baby dies because of "medical event", ambulance spokesman says.

New Zealand's 'Minority Report'

Police arrested a burglar before the crime was reported in Dunedin, much like the 2002 Hollywood movie 'Minority ...

Police solve a crime before it was reported. Welcome to Dunedin's Minority Report.

Serious injuries after car rolls

A person has serious injuries after a car rollover on Lodestar Ave, Wigram, on Monday morning.

A person has been seriously injured after their car rolled in suburban Christchurch.


Sir Colin's hometown farewell video

Former All Black Sir Colin Meads in front of a statue of himself unveiled in Te Kuiti last year.

All Black legend Sir Colin Meads will be farewelled at a public service in Te Kuiti next Monday.

Paedo priest jailed

Mark Mannix Brown, 74, was jailed when he appeared in the Hamilton District Court on Monday, on four charges of indecent ...

Devastating effect of former Catholic priest's abuse heard as he's jailed for a second time for molesting boys.

Crash injures

A diversion has been placed at Cemetery Rd following a crash on Monday.

One injured after cars rolls on a Waikato road.

Smash and grabs

Thieves smashed their way into the Queenwood Ave Superette using a baseball bat.

The thieves took chocolate, cigarettes and the till in the first, and jackets in a second smash and grab.


Review: Rob Ruha

140916 News photo. SIMON O'CONNOR/Fairfax NZ.
Rob Ruha takes papa Haka masterclass before his gig on Thursday night.

A uniquely Aotearoa entertainment experience was a real treat for festival goers.

Library facelift closure

The ground floor and level one of Puke Ariki library will be closed for three days while new carpet is laid.

The library will be closed for three days while new carpet is laid.

Rain takes toll on farmers

Janet Schultz.

Rain has left Taranaki paddocks so sodden, farmers 'might as well plant rice'.

Moriori treaty deal struck

Rekohu (the Chatham Islands) are located 650 kilometres east off mainland New Zealand.

Crown gives $18m to first inhabitants of Chatham Islands, saying it contributed to myth they were inferior and extinct.


$10.5b roading plan

Manawatu Gorge will be a roading focus for the National Government.

Major upgrade to stricken Manawatu Gorge part of ambitious vision to improve New Zealand's roads.

Parking powers sought

Chief executive Ross McNeil says the council won't employ parking wardens.

The Rangitikei District Council is seeking the power to fine motorists.

Before and after 

Villagers have described the events that unfolded when NZ SAS troopers visited in 2004.

Calls for apology and punishment over firefight at centre of one of NZ's proudest military episodes.

Hidden history of war

Two New Zealanders and four Afghans died in the 2012 Battle of Baghak.

Documentary reveals secret details about operations involving our soldiers.


Transforming Nelson's transport

Press Drive August 9 Briefs

Driverless cars could radically change Nelson in the not-so-distant-future, says IT expert.

Tailwind for Tineli

Ali Kimber,left, Sandy Vincent, Tim Vincent and Jono Kalma are part of the Tineli team that have just received a $35,000 ...

Nelson-based firm Tineli is looking to break away from the peloton thanks to a $35,000 business award.

Fashion's the thing at Spring Fling

Meggan Toughey wore a pink leather skirt from V Designs at last year's Spring Fashion Fling at Nelson College For Girls.

Nelson College for Girls' annual Spring Fling fashion show is back for a new season.

Makos can learn from heavy defeat

Replacement midfielder Levi Aumua attempts to pierce the Canterbury defence at Trafalgar Park on Friday.

Friday's 39-0 hiding against Canterbury highlighted several areas that need improvement.


Unfair to 'single out' jet skis

Seamonkeez Jetski Hire owner Mike Stewart supports registration but says it is unfair to single out jet skis.

It's not just Ferraris and Lamborghinis that have to be registered on the road, so why single out jet skis on the water?

Back in the race

Marlborough Racing Club president Eric Bowers has previously opposed the sale of Waterlea Racecourse land. (File photo)

Hold your horses! All bets back on after ministry U-turn on campus site.

Hospital considers layoffs

The facilities services team at Wairau Hospital, in Blenheim, is being reviewed by Nelson Marlborough Health. (File photo)

Four maintenance workers could lose their jobs if outsourcing plans go ahead.

New heights for sauvignon

Brothers Ben and Luc Cowley, Auntsfield Estate's viticulturist and winemaker, with a bottle of their 'exceptional' ...

Marlborough wineries break new ground as the first in the world to gain 'exceptional' ratings from UK drinks magazine Decanter.

South Canterbury

TBHS First XV knock over Christ's

TBHS wing Tevita Eukaliti has too much pace for the defence on his way to scoring in the corner.

Timaru Boys' High School First XV show too much class in victory over Christ's College.

Police looking for Twizel man

Police are looking for Twizel man David Fountain, who was last seen in the early hours of Sunday morning.

Police looking for Twizel man last seen out with friends in the early hours of Sunday.

ESOL numbers rise

Waimataitai School ESOL students, from left, Bogdan Stoiljkovic, 8, Lusiana Isaako Tuala, 7, and Pratistha Naicker, 7.

Dairy industry and affordability linked to increase in number of ESOL students.

Offering support for fathers

Jason Brokenshire looks at a recent photo of him with his three children.  He hopes to set up a support group for fellow ...

Timaru man wants to create awareness and support for other fathers after separation.


Are you in?

Celebrate being a Southlander by taking part in Purple Work Shirt Day on Thursday, August 24.

The Southland Times and Rugby Southland are coming together this week to hold a purple work shirt day.  

South's top cop defends officers

Southern district commander Superintendent Paul Basham says "some things can go wrong sometimes".

Alleged murder, stalking and sexting cases involving police may harm reputation of hard-working officers, top cop says.

Police dog back at work

The scene on Dee St, Invercargill, where a car hit a police officer and dog.

A police dog pulled from under a car after a police pursuit came to an end is back at work.

A win that got away

Southland Stags midfielder Matthew Johnson scores a try in his debut game against Hawke's Bay in Napier on Saturday.

"It was just a couple of errors in the second half and Hawke's Bay punished us."

Ad Feedback