Auckland rail crossing death raises questions over safety

One of Auckland's major level crossings where a man was killed yesterday had just re-opened after a major rebuild.

A man in his early sixties was hit by the second of two opposite direction trains using the barrier-controlled road, rail and pedestrian crossing on Morningside Dr at about 6.50pm.

The fatality comes just short of two years after a woman using a wheelchair was hit by a train at the same crossing. She survived and KiwiRail accept that the incident, which saw her trapped in a poorly maintained crossing, was their fault.

Over the holidays all the tracks crossing Morningside were lifted off and the area was completely rebuilt.

Authorities are expected to release the dead man's name and details of the accident later today.

But it is raising safety questions around Auckland's 48 level crossings just as the city's electric train service markedly increases the volume of trains, including on the Western Line where yesterday's accident occurred.

A strong advocate of getting rid of level crossings, Graeme Easte of the Albert-Eden Local Board, said Morningside is one of the worst level crossings in Auckland.

A long term city plan existed showing $240 million in expenditure on level crossing removal but there was no cash committed to it and no timetable.

"The programme is no money, no programme and occasional tragedies," he said.

Morningside's current off-peak frequency was four trains per hour in both directions. It is about to go to 12 trains an hour.

Ad Feedback

"People and cars do not need to be on the tracks," he said.

At Morningside the trains are currently diesel but will be electric next year and people crossing may not hear them, especially in an era of headphones.

Easte said at the very least authorities could put warning lights into the ground on the pathway in the same way as is used experimentally on some pedestrian crossings in the city. 

An estimated $10 million programme to get a bridge across is not even planned and Easte is being denied access to an Auckland Transport report detailing ways of dealing with level crossings.

Many would need to be closed off and others bridged despite local objections.

"You cannot hide a $5 million bridge in the middle of suburbia."

Earlier KiwiRail spokeswoman Jenni Austin said the crossing was very busy but it had every safety measure possible, including flashing lights, half-barrier arms and a pedestrian maze.

There were two trains at the crossing at the time of the incident, she said. 

"One passed through and it appears the second train has hit the person."

On February 25, 2013, a 22-year-old woman, who has never been named, was hit by a train at the same crossing, suffering horrific injuries. 

She was in a wheelchair.

KiwiRail in a report into that accident accepted that the crossing was in a "degraded condition".

"We take our responsibility for meeting our own safety standards seriously and are very disappointed and apologetic for our failure in this instance," said KiwiRail chairman John Spencer.

The report found that the width and depth of the flange gap, the uneven surface of the crossing and the angle of the crossing at Morningside Drive were contributing factors to the accident.

"Despite the crossing being fully rebuilt in mid-2011, its condition had deteriorated rapidly mostly due to the combined impact of stormwater flooding and a broken water pipe beneath it," Spencer said.

He said level crossings it was critical that KiwiRail, relevant roading authorities and other agencies work closely together to ensure appropriate solutions and processes are in place to best manage the public risks around New Zealand's 4,000km long national rail network.

Only one of Auckland's 48 level crossings is targeted for closure according to Auckland Transport (AT). It is one of the least busy from a car and pedestrian point-of-view but crucial to the rail network.

The railway level crossing connecting Sarawia Street and Laxon Terrace in Newmarket is to be bridged at an estimated cost of $5.72 million.

"The Newmarket level crossing is the busiest and most complex in New Zealand in terms of rail movements, and is a major contributor to rail service disruptions," AT says.

"The main reason AT will close the crossing is to allow improvements to rail frequency to take advantage of the more efficient electric trains to be introduced over the next few years."

Sarawia Street is the only level crossing between Britomart and the Newmarket Junction.

 - Stuff

Ad Feedback
special offers

Emergency response at hospital

An burst water pipe at North Shore Hospital has now been repaired.

A water main burst and ambulances were being diverted away from North Shore Hospital.

Stop-go in place on SH1 near Puhoi

A stop-go system was in place on SH1 north of Auckland. (File photo)

SH1 affected by a slip north of Auckland, causing major delays.

Woman gives birth at shopping mall

The baby was rushed to Starship Hospital in critical condition after it was born at Sylvia Park mall. (File photo)

A baby has been born in the toilets of an Auckland mall and rushed to hospital with its mum, in critical condition.

New Zealand's spookiest movie

18072017 Feature Photo: JASON DORDAY/STUFF The opening night of the 2017 NZ Film Festival at the Civic in Auckland with ...

The director of Spookers says the documentary is as much about family as it is about fear.


'Grumpy' Canes get job done video

Hurricanes second five-eighth Ngani Laumape takes the ball into contact.

Hurricanes advance to the semis despite a third consecutive "sloppy, loose and ill-disciplined" effort.

How to stop begging? video

Marcus Pohio is homeless and regularly begs on Courtenay Place, in Wellington.

The only thing that will get Marcus Pohio off the street is death. But is public generosity speeding that up?

Wellington loses Si and Gary show

Wellingtonians won't hear Si & Gary on their breakfast show anymore.

But they'll get something more local in return - Polly and Grant.

Strong winds for Wellington

Police officers help a driver caught in floodwaters near Timaru on Friday. Wellington has largely missed the weather hit ...

Wellington has missed the worst weather, but there's still been slips and heavy rain.


State of emergency called in Chch

Christchurch's Heathcote River was in flood on Saturday morning.

Local state of emergency declared in Chch after Heathcote River burst its banks.

Live: Southern deluge 

The flooded Taieri river on Saturday morning.

State of emergencies declared in several areas as flood waters force scores of evacuations.

Photos: Christchurch floods

Flooding on Dyers Pass on the Port Hills in Christchurch has made driving treacherous.

The Heathcote River has burst its banks and flooded southern parts of the city.

Selwyn state of emergency declared

A state of emergency has been expanded to all of Selwyn.


Quad bike safety an attitude thing

Trauma data reveals a huge peak in quad bike injuries among the 55-to-65 age group.

Wintec students look to solve the problem of quad bike accidents.

Body in bale ruling

The body was found at OJI Fibre Solutions and FullCircle Recycling on June 28 in Frankton's Pukeko Street.

If it hadn't been raining, Daniel Bindner might not have crawled into a cardboard recycling cage.

Carjacking reported

No one has been arrested and a gun has yet to be found in the Frankton car theft.

Police are investigating a report that a car was taken at gunpoint on Friday night.

History should be honoured

Hamilton's Founders Theatre looks set for the scrapheap, just like Euphrasie House and so many others.

OPINION: The city's predilection to bowl every building with a bit of history is to be abhorred, Richard Swainson says.


Skills for a healthy future

Carol Wham PhD NZRD
Associate Professor of Nutrition and Dietetics, Massey

Does your intermediate child know how to cook a basic, healthy meal? And why does it matter.

'Enjoy Taranaki': judge

When Troy Gilchrist asked what he could do until his sentence started, Judge Chris Sygrove told him he could relax, or ...

A judge tells window-smasher to "enjoy the wonders of Taranaki" before his sentence starts.

Truck blocks highway

The trailer of a large truck has rolled and was blocking half of SH3 near Waitotara in Taranaki on Friday.

One lane was blocked on SH3 near Waitotara after a truck crash on Friday morning.

Pre-nup was unfair

The High Court has upheld a lower court decision for a couple to equal property shares after separating

A pre-nuptial agreement gave one partner $20,000, and the other partner $1.5 million worth of assets.


Bridal gowns from the ages

Aimee Perrett models Miranda Polson's 1976 wedding dress.

Some of the region's finest bridal gowns of the last century were in a unique display.

Gang-life redemption

Te Kai Po Ahuriri, captain of the Stormtroopers Outlaw chapter, spars at The Fight Shop gym.

Two gang members with separate lives talk about their similar roads to recovery.

Paediatrician jailed

Jonathan Walsh is in jail after pleading guilty to 17 charges relating to the making and distributing of indecent images ...

Paediatrician who worked in New Zealand jailed in the UK over indecent images of children.

No way in, no way out video

The trail's reconstruction has made life much easier for villagers.

After the 2015 quake, villagers in Uhiya, Nepal, were isolated, forced to fend for themselves.


Hospice event gets steam punked

21072017 NEWS photo / MARION VAN DIJK / STUFF

Paul Kelly, left and Ross Wearing at the Big Night Out,  ...

Sci-fi met Victorian class at the Nelson/Tasman Hospice Big Night Out event.

Trespass case win

Lawyer John Fitchett has won a trespass case against Nelson College.

Lawyer wins case against Nelson College board meetings, but judge unimpressed.

Nelson in the eye of the storm

While the rest of the South Island was battered by the weather, Nelson and Tasman escaped the worst of it.

The Nelson Tasman region is sheltered from weather "similar to a cyclone".

Finding a voice after cancer video

Bernard Sanders, left and Stephen Christie with Emma Burns, Speech and Language Therapist at Nelson  Marlborough Health. ...

Two throat cancer survivors aren't letting their loss of voice stop them from speaking out about the importance of HPV vaccinations.


All hands on deck

John's Kitchen supervisor Richard McDonald likes the idea that food can be an expression of care.

Blenheim charity kitchen takes on new staff to cope with high workload.

Team turned around

The MBC Falcons rugby team had a frustrating day on Friday.

MBC First XV rugby team spent around 14 hours in a bus yesterday, then never even got to pull their boots on.

The next big quake

The Adelphi Hotel, in Kaikoura, was pulled down due to earthquake damage.

It's impossible to say when an earthquake is going to strike. But the predictable patterns of aftershocks can help.

Exploring Africa

The Hansby family at Victoria Falls, from left, Luke Hansby, Fleur Hansby, Nick Hansby and Sam Hansby.

When you plan your trip to Africa, the animals and environment are expected to be the main attraction.

South Canterbury

Farmers combat deluge

Federated Farmers branch chairman Mark Adams said farmers always prepared for bad weather and made sure they had extra ...

Reports of farmers stranded after storm damages culverts, creeks and fences.

Mackenzie blanketed 

Heavy snow is falling in Tekapo.

Snow is still falling in the Mackenzie after a dumping overnight.

State of emergency to be lifted gallery video

Gus, left, and Tom Cameron check out the damage to Stanton Rd, at Kimbell near Fairlie, after it was washed out overnight.

Defence Force sends teams to worst hit parts of South Canterbury to check on residents.

Rugby semifinal washed out

Mackenzie rugby player Setafano Sauqaqa.

South Canterbury puts sudden death senior rugby semifinal on hold until Sunday.


Stewart Island heritage gets $1m

An artist's impression of the Rakiura Heritage Centre. The centre has received, over $1 million in Government funding to ...

The Government is to commit $1.08m to the Rakiura Heritage Centre Trust.

Post-funeral brawl

Police and ambulance were alerted to the incident, but were not eventually required.

A post-funeral gathering in Bluff on Thursday night ended with blood, broken glass and a visit from the police.

Irrigation scheme 'a win-win'

Dairy Creek Ltd director Tim O'Sullivan, Pioneer Energy chief executive Fraser Jonker and Pioneer Energy project manager ...

A $10m irrigation scheme near Alexandra, Central Otago, is going to deliver water to about 1800 hectares of barren land.

Gecko stolen from visitor centre

The Marlborough green gecko that was stolen from the Fiordland National Park Visitor Centre in Te Anau.

An at risk gecko has been stolen from the DoC visitor centre in Fiordland.

Ad Feedback