Lecretia Seales did not have right to die, High Court rules video


Lecretia Seales' husband has made an emotional plea to parliament to address the right to die.

Lecretia Seales learned on her death bed that she had been denied her dying wish. 

Her grieving husband, Matt Vickers, has revealed her deep hurt and disappointment when he told her on Tuesday evening that Justice David Collins had decided it was against the law for her to be allowed a doctor's help to die at a time of her own choosing.

"Even though she couldn't speak, she was able to share her feelings through her expression. There was no mistaking her response. She was hurt and disappointed. She fixed me with a stare with her good eye as if to say "Isn't this my body? My life?" Her breath slowed and she turned her head away. Her reaction utterly broke my heart," Vickers said at a media conference in Wellington on Friday afternoon.

The family of Wellington lawyer Lecretia Seales' will not appeal the decision to deny her the right to die at the time ...

The family of Wellington lawyer Lecretia Seales' will not appeal the decision to deny her the right to die at the time of her choosing with help from a her doctor.


Tributes flow for right-to-die campaigner Lecretia Seales 

Decision for terminally ill Wellington lawyer Lecretia Seales to be released 

Lecretia Seales lived with passion, determination and autonomy 

Parliament may take up issue of voluntary euthanasia

Seales, a Wellington lawyer who died of a brain tumour early on Friday at age 42, had asked the court to clarify the law so she had the option of having a doctor's help to die if her suffering became intolerable. Collins ruled that only Parliament could make a law change to allow such a step to legally occur.

Vickers stoically maintained his composure for most of his reading of a prepared statement at the media conference on Friday about the family's shocked reaction to Collins' judgement. His legal team, Andrew Butler and Catherine Marks, also attended the conference, along with Seales' former colleague and close friend, Cate Brett.

Lecretia Seales, seen with her husband Matt Vickers in 2009, passed away early Friday.
Kevin Stent

Lecretia Seales, seen with her husband Matt Vickers in 2009, passed away early Friday.

He said the family was given an interim results judgement on the case on Tuesday so that Seales, whose health was rapidly deteriorating, could be aware of the outcome and know whether she could lawfully have a doctor to help her to die.

Collins' full judgment from the High Court at Wellington was made public on Friday afternoon and explained Seales' doctor risked prosecution for murder or manslaughter if she administered a fatal drug to Seales, intending to kill her. It also said Seales' doctor risked prosecution for assisting suicide if she provided Seales with a fatal drug, intending Seales to take that drug and if Seales died as a consequence.

"We are dismayed by Justice Collins' judgement. In some ways, I am relieved that Lecretia was unconscious and unresponsive when we received it," Vickers said.

Lecretia Seales passed away from terminal brain cancer in June 2015.

Lecretia Seales passed away from terminal brain cancer in June 2015.

"It just so happens that sometimes, when that suffering is so great, the only release from that suffering is death. That is not murder. That is not suicide. That is mercy."

Ad Feedback

He said Collins' interpretation of the law meant he could not find aid in dying was available to Seales or was inconsistent with the Bill of Rights.

The judgment had "starkly highlighted that the status quo is not ideal" and that people were at risk of intolerable suffering and of ending their lives earlier than they would otherwise.

Lecretia Seales' husband, Matt Vickers.

Lecretia Seales' husband, Matt Vickers.

"Justice Collins was clear that it is for Parliament to address these issues," Vickers said.

He implored Prime Minister John Key to initiate the debate, saying Key publicly stated two weeks ago that he welcomed such debate.

"This debate needs to happen now. Prime Minister, I urge you to give the public what they want and start the debate. I urge you to follow my wife's example and to be a courageous leader. I urge you to lead on this issue. It is long overdue. Now is the time. Let us give Lecretia her legacy."

Should Kiwis have the right to die with 'dignity'?

Share your stories, photos and videos.

It was understood Seales' death did not rule out the possibility of an appeal over Collins' ruling. Her funeral would be held on Wednesday in Wellington.


Seales, 42, had begun the court proceedings in March when it was expected she might live between three and 18 months. By the time the case was heard in late May, her outlook was worse.

Matt Vickers, Seales' husband, has called the judgement "terribly disappointing".

Matt Vickers, Seales' husband, has called the judgement "terribly disappointing".

She had not given up on life but she had been told she might have just a few weeks, and at most a very few months, left.

Seales was in the High Court at Wellington twice during the three-day hearing, on the first and last days. She appeared in a wheelchair, eyes mostly closed, with a family member by her side.

Justice Collins said in his judgement that Seales' attendance at the court during the hearing "illustrated her courage and commitment at a time when she knew she may only have a few weeks to live".

Both times, she heard her lawyer, Andrew Butler, speak. He said the case was only about her and her circumstances and what her options were.

Her claim was to clarify the law and how Crimes Act sections, including on homicide and suicide, should be read in light of the Bill of Rights, Butler said.

It was said the guarantee not to be deprived of life was infringed if Seales could not get aid in dying, as this would force her to prematurely take her own life while she was still able to do so without help.

She also had the right not to be subject to cruel, degrading or disproportionately severe treatment and it was said that would be infringed if her choices were to take her own life or face the prospect of intolerable suffering.

Her lawyer said aid in dying was either not banned under the Crimes Act for a person in Seales' position or, if it was banned, that was inconsistent with her rights.

Her general practitioner, whose name was suppressed, was willing to help her die if it was legal.

The Attorney-General was named as defendant to the claim. His lawyer, Solicitor-General Mike Heron, QC, said the law was clear that aid in dying was not available, regardless of the Bill of Rights.

Her options also included quality palliative care to avoid or lessen pain and suffering, Heron told the court.

He said if Seales' claim was accepted it would have implications beyond her case.

Three groups were allowed to make submissions on the case, even though they were not parties.

The Care Alliance, a group opposed to euthanasia, echoed the Attorney-General's submissions that if Seales won it would impact others. The alliance said it would amount to euthanasia on demand for all terminally ill, mentally competent adults, and potentially put at risk the lives of vulnerable people, such as the disabled, elderly and frail, and the mentally ill.

The Voluntary Euthanasia Society said Seales should win. Giving her a prescription for medication that would end her suffering would be a continuation of her medical care.

The Human Rights Commission was neutral on Seales' ultimate question but said if the law was inconsistent with the Bill of Rights then the court should say so.

Already this year courts in Canada and South Africa have said doctors can help terminally ill people die. Other countries have laws that specifically allow doctors to give patients aid to die, either by giving access to lethal medication or administering lethal medication.

 - Stuff

Ad Feedback
special offers

Man dead at container yard

The man was critically injured but later died at the scene.

A man has died after getting trapped at a south Auckland container yard.

Phone app's sole purpose

Angad Nayyar is the chief executive of Strutagio, an app designed to help shoppers find the perfect-sized shoe.

Auckland friends develop app that lets customers try on shoes without setting foot in a physical store.

Pregnant? Eat salmon

Freshly cooked salmon carries a low risk of mercury contamination, and is fine to eat when pregnant, Massey researchers say.

Shunning fish during pregnancy for fears of toxicity has meant women are lacking in nutrients essential for a growing fetus.

NZDF to the rescue video

HMNZS Endeavour heads for Marsden Point oil refinery, to help ease the fuel shortage crisis.

The army, air force and navy will redistribute fuel across the country by land and by sea.


Wild WOW opening in Wellington video

'Theodore', by Marie Wright and Taralee Freeman, of New Zealand, is modelled in the Weta Workshop Science Fiction section

More than 100 garments made out of everything from bicycle tubes to latex.

Man on fire dies

Cordons were set up around Parliament after the incident.

The man who reportedly set himself on fire outside Parliament has died overnight, police say.

Slip at Rimutaka Hill

The NZTA are investigating a possible slip on State Highway 2 at the Rimutaka Hill.

There are reports of a slip blocking the southbound lane halfway up SH2 at the Rimutaka Hill.

Pregnant? Eat salmon

Freshly cooked salmon carries a low risk of mercury contamination, and is fine to eat when pregnant, Massey researchers say.

Shunning fish during pregnancy for fears of toxicity has meant women are lacking in nutrients essential for a growing fetus.


High temperatures coming

The sun sets over the Pacific Ocean behind Bixby Bridge on Highway 1 north of Big Sur, California, December 19, 2013. ...

Warm air set to bake Australia will hit NZ from Sunday, MetService says.

Third lane approved

Congestion on the northern motorway just south of the Waimakariri Bridge. A third lane for "high occupancy vehicles" has ...

Green light for extra lane and cycleway on the Waimakariri Bridge across SH1.

Astonishing kidnap escape

Police guard a Andrew Cameron's house near Hanmer on Tuesday morning.

With a gun held to his neck, Hanmer kidnap victim jumped from the car he was forced to drive.

People missing from rebuild

OPINION: It's fast becoming apparent the rebuild will take somewhere between the expected lifespan of a heavy smoker and that of Queen Liz.


Monster slip chases woman video

A slip, estimated between 10 and 20 hectares, has fallen from private farm land in Waitomo.

Joanne Tapara outran an avalanche of rock and mud that claimed 6 cows, 40 ewes and 70 lambs.

High temps to roll in

The sun sets over the Pacific Ocean behind Bixby Bridge on Highway 1 north of Big Sur, California, December 19, 2013. ...

Warm air set to bake Australia in temperatures above 30C will then hit NZ, MetService says.

Dental pros win $30m Lotto prize

Tina from Taupō and nine of her friends won Saturday's $30 million Lotto jackpot.

Tina from Taupō and ten of her posse are all smiles after winning enormous Powerball jackpot.

Fleeing driver on the run

The driver of a Mazda fled from a drink drive checkpoint in Hamilton at midnight (file photo).

Driver wasn't stopping for the booze bus and managed to run from the crashed car shortly after.


Dementia: a love story video

11092017 News Photo ANDY JACKSON/STUFF.  The Ticking Timebomb, a series looking at the rising issues of alzheimers ...

Tom Matiaha's 24 years as a soldier could not prepare him for his family's battle against a hidden foe: Alzheimer's disease.

The 'downhill slide'

11092017 News Photo ANDY JACKSON/STUFF.  The Ticking Timebomb, a series looking at the rising issues of Alzheimers ...

He's forgotten how to peel potatoes but fears forgetting his children most.

Unlocking dementia's secrets video

A team of scientists at the Centre for Brain Research  process a human brain that has just been donated.

Dementia has a terrible effect on many Kiwi lives, and the situation will get worse. 

Dementia a life-changing loss for all

Margaret Lacy with a picture of her late husband Peter.

Dementia affects tens of thousands of Kiwis, eventually taking everything from them. 


Birthing centre delivered

Palmerston North's new birthing centre is almost open. Annie Kinloch, left, and Chloe Wright check out the new building.

Pink or blue lights will flash when a new baby is born at Palmerston North's new centre.

No more snooping

Horowhenua mayor Michael Feyen refused to vote on a new email blocking policy.

The Horowhenua District Council is changing the way it screens emails.

83-year-old dies in crash

A car and a truck crashed at an intersection in Levin.

The man died on Monday after his car collided with a truck in Levin.

The one poll that matters

Labour leader Jacinda Ardern and National leader Bill English say the 2017 election race is very tight.

OPINION: The debates have been robust, but the arguing is nearly over.


New SHAs approved in Nelson


The former Green Grocer Store on the corner of Grove St and Tasman St in The ...

Seven new SHAs approved by the Nelson City Council including a tiny house project.

Tight race draws voters

Tasman Makos Pari Pari Parkinson, left, Rupena Parkinson, Siua Halanukonuka and Viliami Lolohea vote at the advance ...

Make your vote count in what's tipped to be a tight race for the Beehive.

Blue whale washes ashore gallery video

A blue whale carcass washed ashore at Glenburn Station in Wairarapa on Wednesday.

A dead blue whale first spotted off d'Urville Island has washed up on a Wairarapa beach.

Working mum sleeping in shed

Cath has been looking for somewhere to live, and is forced to live in a shed with no windows until something better ...

She's separated from her six kids as she struggles to get even motel accommodation.


When the voting's done

Labour candidate Janette Walker has to juggle her work at Crossroads Charitable Trust with her campaign work.

Two will be at the pub, one will be at home, the incumbent has hired a hall. But who will be celebrating?

Leap in rateable values

New capital values across Marlborough show a big increase for Picton properties. (File pic)

Some properties have seen their capital value incease by a whopping 28 per cent.

History can be cool

Archives manager Megan Ross goes through the massive collection at the Marlborough Museum.

"It's 13.4 degrees in here," says Megan Ross, pointing at the thermometer flanked by shelves and shelves of negatives and other memorabilia.

Māori school for everyone

Kiley Nepia at Omaka Marae, which will launch a Māori immersion school next year.

"If this Māori way resonates with other people, then they would be considered as well."

South Canterbury

A toast to the bicycle video

Graeme Simpson is preparing to take a collection of old bikes to Waimate to celebrate 200 years of the bicycle.

Bicycles of all shapes and sizes to be celebrated in 200th anniversary event.

Air plan approved

South Canterbury Regional Air Plan Liaison Committee chairman Mark Rogers with committee members Doug Cleveland, centre, ...

Grey Power president says it was "too much" to expect woodburner rule to be ditched.

Church parking concerns

Lake Tekapo Church of the Good Shepherd. The Mackenzie District Council proposes a raft of measures to reduce the impact ...

Buses may soon have to park further away from Tekapo's popular lakefront church.

Swaps for councils, schools

Aoraki Development CEO Nigel Davenport, who was invited to go on the delegation to sign the agreement, said it was "a ...

MOU will allow council staff to exchange with  sister city and could bring raft of benefits.


Residents unsatisfied with DQ

Blue Peaks Lodge manager Michael McMillan was appointed to the Destination Queenstown board to represent the ...

Queenstown had a four per cent increase in visitors to about 3.2 million in the 2016/17 year.

Highlanders land prop early

Tyrel Lomax played his first game for Tasman last weekend.

Son of former Kiwis league player will join Highlanders next year after Melbourne Rebels cut him loose.

Fears community heart will be lost

Queenstown Arts Centre coordinator Andie King said an art gallery, community groups and workshop spaces should be ...

The council says the location could provide "a combined Council office and a community heart."

Riley Baker memorial to stay?

Dunedin photographer Riley Baker with his partner, Amy McPherson. He died in hospital from injuries after a tourist ...

Mayor tells Dunedin crash victim's family his ashes can stay put, but NZTA says that's not confirmed.


70 years and still going strong

John and Joan Welsh with their wedding day photo from 1947.

On September 22, John and Joan Welsh celebrated their 70th wedding anniversary.

Trust announces it will seek review

Community Trust of Southland chair Margot Hishon

The Community Trust of Southland will seek a ministerial review into the circumstances surrounding the departure of its former chief executive. 

Bluff sign bluff

Scottish tourist Geoff Mumford a little confused by the directions for Wellington and Cape Reinga which pointed in ...

Bluff's famous signpost is all over the place.

Voters harassed

Entrance to the polling booth at the Menzies Building on Esk St.

Early voters in Invercargill have been subject to intimidation and verbal abuse on their way to cast their ballots.

Ad Feedback