Fatal hit-and-run charges dropped

JONATHAN CARSON
Last updated 05:00 09/07/2012
FATAL ACCIDENT: Scene investigators at the site of the hit-and-run on the corner of Marychurch Rd (State Highway 1B) and Bellevue Rd, Matangi, on January 15 this year.
BEN CURRAN/Fairfax NZ

FATAL ACCIDENT: Scene investigators at the site of the hit-and-run on the corner of Marychurch Rd (State Highway 1B) and Bellevue Rd, Matangi, on January 15 this year.

CHARGES DROPPED: David Gregory Mascelle.
CHARGES DROPPED: David Gregory Mascelle.
FAMILY GRIEVES: William Gregory Hoskins, 26, who died after being run over on State Highway 1B at Matangi early on January 15.
FAMILY GRIEVES: William Gregory Hoskins, 26, who died after being run over on State Highway 1B at Matangi early on January 15.

Relevant offers

The father of a man who died after being hit by a car on a Waikato road is furious that police have dropped all charges against the man who was accused of the fatal hit-and-run.

Hawke's Bay man William Gregory Hoskins, 26, died after being run over on State Highway 1B at Matangi early on January 15.

David Gregory Mascelle, 47, handed himself in to police the following day, more than 24 hours after the incident.

He was charged with careless driving causing death in Hamilton District Court.

Mascelle was scheduled to reappear in court tomorrow, but police on Friday confirmed via a press release that the charge had been withdrawn.

Mr Mascelle declined to comment when approached at his Matangi home yesterday.

Waikato district commander Superintendent Win van der Velde said, following legal advice and evidence presented by forensic experts, the case against Mascelle "lacked the evidential sufficiency to successfully prosecute" him.

Greg Hoskins, William's father, was visited by police on Wednesday and told the charges would be dropped. He was furious about the decision when contacted yesterday afternoon.

"It's a joke, mate. It's just how it is."

He believed his son would have been treated differently if he had been the driver.

He said the family, who live in Hastings, were still coming to terms with the loss of their son and brother.

"You don't get over ... this," he said. "It's for life."

Mascelle's wife Ngaire – a community magistrate – was a passenger in the car on the night William Hoskins was run down.

She was removed from the community magistrate roster while her husband was before the court.

Mr Hoskins claimed Mr Mascelle had reasoned that visibility was poor the night William Hoskins was hit.

But Mr Hoskins claimed otherwise: "I was on the road only an hour before them."

He was outraged that the man who had been accused of his son's death had been let off the hook.

The first man on the scene of the accident – and a key police witness – was also informed on Thursday night that his services in the case would no longer be needed.

The man found William Hoskins on the side of the road in the early morning of January 15.

Police told the man, who asked to remain anonymous, that the case against Mr Mascelle had been dropped.

The witness, who was due to appear before the court tomorrow, was told Mr Mascelle had hired another lawyer and said he understood it had been determined that "he couldn't have stopped" the car on the night William Hoskins was run down.

TIMELINE

January 15 - William Hoskins died after being run over on State Highway 1B, Matangi.

January 16 - David Mascelle attends the police station.

January 19 - Mascelle appears in court charged with careless driving causing death.

Ad Feedback

January 28 - The Times reveals a community magistrate was a passenger in the car the night Mr Hoskins was hit.

February 17 - Name suppression lapses for Mascelle. The Times reveals Mascelle is the driver and the community magistrate is his wife, Ngaire.

July 9 - The Times reveals that police have dropped the charge against Mascelle.

- © Fairfax NZ News

Special offers

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content

Cats peering blog pointer small

Four Legs Good: The blog about pets and animals

Places to peer at you from (pictures)

F5 blog pointer small

F5: Henry Cooke blogs about the internet

TGIF: Nuclear Submarine edition

Chris Philpott

On the Box: What's on TV with Chris Philpott

Can Dynamo save magic on TV?

Colin Espiner

Bull Dust!: Colin Espiner calls it

Captain Sensible got too near the flame

We're Building a House blog

Jon Bridges builds a house

Win 7 Days tix, insulation, Woolly Pockets!

In Our Nature blog

In Our Nature, with Nicola Toki

Showing love for longfins

Game Junkie

Game Junkie - Gerard Campbell's gaming blog

Scary games scare the crap out of me

Blog on the tracks

Blog on the Tracks: Simon Sweetman on music

What's the best gig merch you've seen?

Karen Tay

Reading Is Bliss: Karen Tay on the joy of books

The paradox of reading choice

Greer wedding blog pointer small

Ready or Knot: Greer's wedding journey

Wedding woe: Too many BMs