THE ALLEGED OFFENCE: Brett Mainey's car in Cambridge Terrace, with the offending cones.
Relevant offers
Brett Mainey does not have a law degree, but he does have a High Court victory over Wellington City Council.
Without any help from a lawyer the Wellington builder has persuaded the High Court to overturn a $221.56 fine for parking in a temporary disabled park, which he says was marked after he parked there.
The council is now reviewing the ruling to see whether it will force changes to how it deals with temporary signs around the city.
Mainey was fined on October 9.
He parked his car in a pay- and-display in Cambridge Tce about 11.30am and returned about 30 minutes later to find a parking warden had ticketed it and called a tow truck.
The warden said the parks had been transformed into disabled spaces while the Rugby World Cup was on. He pointed to signs attached to road cones on the footpath next to Mainey's car that explained as much.
Mainey argued that the signs were not there when he parked. Despite never having set foot inside a courtroom, he represented himself at a defended hearing against the council in April and lost.
But Mainey appealed, and went back to court to defend himself, this time in front of Justice Alan Mackenzie.
In a decision released late last week, Justice Mackenzie quashed the district court finding and set aside the ticket, agreeing with Mainey's argument that the council had not proven the signs were there first.
Mainey said he knew the signs were not there to begin with because one was sitting beside the passenger door of his car, and his girlfriend would not have been able to get out without knocking it over.
"It just goes to show that you don't have to take these things lying down if you feel like you're being had-on," he said.
The whole exercise ended up costing Mainey nothing, aside from a few lost days at work.
Council spokesman Richard MacLean said the final bill from its lawyers Phillips Fox was still being worked out but it would be paid by the council's parking contractor, Tenix Solutions NZ, and not ratepayers.
"Of course, it would be the same whether we win or lose a case," he said.
The council would look at the ruling to see if it needed to rethink its processes, but Mainey's case appeared to be unique.
- © Fairfax NZ News
Sponsored links
Anguish at fatal fire in Hokitika
'Battery farm' puppies die in pet stores
Pastor visits arsonist who torched church
Four-hour wait to get stitched up
Rain for the north, winds for the south
Fighting to restore her mum's name
Police investigate Auckland shooting
'Perfect end' to 58-year love story
Cloud again over Titahi Bay brigade
Woman critical after being 'dragged behind car'
Anguish at fatal fire in Hokitika
Scam spread may have snared socialite
Seriously happy to upset the status quo
Paroled killer's 'risky' actions
Oversized truck caused US bridge collapse
Rain for the north, winds for the south
Jet deployed after incident on-board flight
Daytona 675R is NZ's finest supersports bike
Shaun Johnson 'hurt' but no rift with Elliott
Force may feel all of Highlanders frustration
Rain washes out opening day of second test
Mitch Evans on podium in Monaco GP2 race
How important is NZ's anti-nuclear policy to you?
Related story: It's all good, just don't mention the nukes












