Abused sisters lose High Court bid to name attacker video

Anne-Marie Forsyth and Karen Beaumont went to court to have their own name suppression lifted.
JOHN KIRK-ANDERSON/FAIRFAX NZ

Anne-Marie Forsyth and Karen Beaumont went to court to have their own name suppression lifted.

Two sisters who fought to unmask their abuser four decades after they were sexually assaulted have failed to convince a High Court judge.

Anne-Marie Forsyth and Karen Beaumont from Christchurch, have been engaged in a lengthy and expensive legal battle to expose the man who committed sex crimes against them.

Stuff.co.nz

Christchurch abuse victims Anne-Marie Forsyth and Karen Beaumont talk about their dismay that their abuser has his name suppressed.

As victims, they won the right to have their name suppression lifted in August last year. They wanted their abuser exposed, but the judge allowed a suppression order granted to the man in 1994 to continue.

Billed as a test case for other survivors who wanted to stop sex offenders hiding behind victims' statutory protection, they asked the High Court to review the court's decision last month.

In a just-released judgment, Justice Mander refused to quash their attacker's name suppression.

Two decades had passed, the man had rehabilitated and not reoffended in the belief he had permanent name suppression. 

Mander had to consider the man's situation in 2015, not at the conclusion of his trial in 1995.

Removing his name suppression after such a long period would have "disproportionately punitive consequences", would cause extreme hardship and could repunish him.

Recent publication of his name on the internet, and potential further publicity, had caused significant financial and personal problems and he had lost a job, Mander said. 

Ad Feedback

"These are consequences which are commonly associated with being convicted for sexual offending and would not ordinarily justify name suppression. However, for such repercussions to be visited upon a person for the first time some two decades after the criminal justice process has ended is, to my knowledge, unprecedented."

The man's lawyer, Jonathan Eaton QC, said at the hearing last month the man believed final name and occupation suppression order was made at his sentencing in the Lower Hutt District Court in May 1994. It would be unfair to revisit the issue. 

The sisters' lawyer, Nikki Pender, who declined to comment on the judgment until she had spoken with her clients, said last month there was only a record of an interim suppression order.

Mander found error in the trial court's approach as to whether the man's name should be permanently suppressed. 

The women were abused in the 1970s when they were 10 and 14. They complained to police in 1994. A year later the man was convicted of three offences of performing an indecent act and two counts of indecent assault and sent to prison.

The sisters argued the man's identity was not made public only because of suppression orders protecting their own identities, which became obsolete after their suppression was lifted.

Eaton said if suppression orders could be reconsidered at any time, offenders would never be able to move on with their lives, he said.

Prior to the hearing, one of the sister said the legal fight had cost $13,500 so far and could top $30,000. She said they had to show they could fund the legal action and any costs if they lost by proving the equity in their homes.

 - Stuff

Ad Feedback
special offers
Auckland

Billboards up for longer?

21122016 newsphoto: SUPPLIED. Otara-Papatoetoe Local Board chair Lotu Fuli.

Lotu Fuli says removing the nine-week limit on political billboards will be unfair.

'I don't think it's quite sunk in yet'

Phillis Meti says her world record drive was a rare occasion where everything happens as it should.

Phillis Meti says her world record drive was a rare occasion where everything happens as it should.

'Beautiful women' gunned down video

Natanya Campbell and her mum Wendy Campbell Rodgers were killed when they were carrying out a property inspection in ...

Jeff Pipe escaped with a bullet wound in his back and a hole in his car windscreen while a mother and daughter were shot dead when they turned up for a property inspection.

Visa crackdown worries sector

Summerset plans to spend $1.3 billion on building villages in Auckland over coming years.

Retirement villages will lose valuable staff if overseas workers can't get visas, major operator says.

Wellington

Plastic bag petition presented

Four students from Samuel Marsden Collegiate School presented a 17,800-signature-strong petition calling for a plastic ...

A 17,800-strong petition calling for a levy on plastic bags was presented to the Government.

Final cycleway options

The layout of Wellington's Island Bay cycleway, which places the bike lane between the kerb and parked cars, has been ...

Cost of solving Island Bay cycleway dilemma could top $7m and see up to 57 car parks removed.

Viagra hoarder's hard times

Police found 1188 Viagra pills, worth about $12,000, at the home of Hastings man Elijah Nuku.

Man caught with almost 1200 of the blue tablets was in a 'downward spiral'.

Crash causing delays on SH1

Traffic was banked up between Churton Park and Tawa on State Highway 1 north of Wellington after the crash.

Two people treated for injuries after highway crash north of Wellington.

Canterbury

Crusaders 'ready' to fire

The Crusaders, who beat the Highlanders 17-0 in the Super Rugby quarterfinal in Christchurch last weekend, will field ...

Coach Scott Robertson names an unchanged team for the semifinal against the Chiefs.

More wintry weather video

Cold Antarctic air is behind the front bringing snow to Tekapo and other parts of the South Island.

Access to Tekapo reopens, but bad weather pattern isn't letting up yet.

Gloriavale reports downturn

Gloriavale Christian Community, across from Lake Haupiri, on the West Coast.

Gloriavale's tax-exempt charity reports a six-figure deficit in the year to July 2016.

Player jailed for attempted rape

Kolinio Yabia Tamanitoakula was jailed for three years, four months and two weeks.

The rugby player's distressed victim was covered in mud when she ran in front of a car to get help.

Waikato

Que back being a typical Kiwi kid

Que Langdon is settling back into normal activities after sailing with her father to Australia from Kawhia.

After spending 27 days sailing to Oz with her father, life is back to normal for Que Langdon.

Migrants grow dope

Professionally installed heat lamps and hydroponic equipment were set up in various rooms, including bedrooms, of the ...

Illegal immigrant ring caught growing commercial amounts of cannabis in three rental houses.

Cops swoop on school

Police look for evidence at the back gate of Knighton Normal School.

Officers patrolling grounds after incident at primary school in Hamilton East.

Waikato support for plastic bag levy

90 per cent of mayors support a compulsory levy on plastic bags.

Plastic bag levy will see the cost of groceries go up.

Taranaki

Firewood supplies running out

27072017 News Photo ANDY JACKSON/STUFF.   New Plymouth firewood suppliers WoodWard's Firewood have all but run out of ...

Stock up in summer to avoid being left out in the cold.

A 'hybrid event' flood

Traffic is reduced to one lane just south of Inglewood.

The amount of rain to fall "far exceeded" standards for severe heavy rain warnings.

Drugs and cash seized

Methamphetamine and cash were recovered when police raided four houses in North Taranaki on Thursday morning. (file photo)

Methamphetamine, cash and vehicles seized in a series of raids in Taranaki this morning.

Woman clung to moving car

Members of the public witnessed one woman's horror as her partner tried to push her out of a moving car on a state ...

Her partner tried to push her out as they drove on the highway. When they stopped, she fled and hid under a truck.

Manawatu

A garden of thoughts

Carly Thomas and her eldest daughter Ava Thomas wander through their large garden.

Reporter Carly Thomas gets philosophical about her crazy garden.

Game could move

Access to upper levels of the Central Energy Trust Arena grandstand has been stopped while fire safety work is carried out.

Fire risk closes upper levels of Central Energy Trust Arena grandstand.

Rail the key - Greens video

A new slip fell on the already-closed Manawatu Gorge road last weekend.

The Green Party proposes a twice-daily passenger train as a Manawatu Gorge alternative.

Levin landfill too smelly

The Horowhenua District Council has been slapped with an abatement notice, after residents complained about a stench ...

A pong permeating from a landfill could bring two councils to the Environment Court.

Nelson

Log truck overturns

A logging truck overturned at Appleby near Nelson.

Logging truck crash closes road near Nelson.

Battle in the skies

Passengers disembark the first Jetstar flight from Wellington to Nelson. (File photo)

Regional airline boss says "it's a race to the bottom, and we're caught up in it".

Chocolate cake heaven

Phil Lash of Chocolate Velvet.

Chocolate Velvet specialises in happiness; glorious cake happiness.

Crime spree arrest

One man has been arrested as police continue to search for two others following a number of crimes across Nelson last ...

Police have made an arrest in relation to several incidents last weekend.

Marlborough

Ice skating, minus the cold

One of Ice Skate Tour's artificial ice rinks will be set up in central Blenheim for four days in December.

It looks like ice, skates like ice, but a rink bound for Blenheim over summer is definitely not ice.

Highway move to make Kaikoura safer

The proposed road realignment will come out opposite the Kaikoura Top 10 Holiday Park.

A deviation to State Highway 1 is planned to help manage safety and traffic at Kaikoura's busiest intersection.

Cloud of fatal crash still hangs

Lara Glover, 16, died in the car crash on February 19.

Eight teenagers were in the car, but Jayne Glover says the whole region felt the crash that killed her daughter.

Call for new radiotherapy unit

Patients in Nelson Marlborough who need radiotherapy have to travel to Christchurch or Wellington for treatment.

Cost of sending patients away for radiotherapy tops $1m.

South Canterbury

Roads reopen, rain continues video

Contractors clear snow from the road at Tekapo on Thursday morning.

Roads to Tekapo reopen as schools send  students home early to avoid flooding.

Rugby player jailed

Kolinio Yabia Tamanitoakula was jailed for three years, four months and two weeks.

His distressed victim was covered in mud when she ran in front of a car to get help.

Boy seriously injured in Timaru

A 12-year-old Westmount School - South Campus Timaru pupil was taken to Timaru Hospital on Thursday with serious ...

Twelve-year-old taken to Timaru Hospital with serious injuries following incident in CBD.

Love is the answer

Mike King's speech in Timaru focused on King's struggles in the past as well as calling parents to become more involved ...

Unconditional love and communication will help improve mental health, Mike King says.

Southland

Invercargill i-Site to trial pilot to lure migrants

Venture Southland general manager of tourism, events and community Bobbi Brown and Invercargill i-Site supervisor ...

The Invercargill i-Site has been selected by the Ministry of Business, Information and Employment to run a pilot looking to entice visitors to the region to migrate.

The 9-day garage sale

A vinyl record collection does not reflect the tastes of the current owner, Smith says.

Riversdale hoarder's "rationalisation" leads to nine-day garage sale.

Fishermen demand answers

CRA8 Lobster Industry Association chief executive Malcolm Lawson said consultation on the regulation changes have been ...

Southern fishermen want Primary Industries Minister Nathan Guy to front up over concerns regarding new commercial fishing regulations.

Tougher biosecurity wanted

Ministry for Primary Industries Aquaculture analyst Finn Sumner speaks to the audience at an Invercargill public meeting ...

Southlanders have made it known to MPI staff they want to see tougher biosecurity standards for the marine aquaculture industry.

Ad Feedback