Abused sisters lose High Court bid to name attacker video

Anne-Marie Forsyth and Karen Beaumont went to court to have their own name suppression lifted.
JOHN KIRK-ANDERSON/FAIRFAX NZ

Anne-Marie Forsyth and Karen Beaumont went to court to have their own name suppression lifted.

Two sisters who fought to unmask their abuser four decades after they were sexually assaulted have failed to convince a High Court judge.

Anne-Marie Forsyth and Karen Beaumont from Christchurch, have been engaged in a lengthy and expensive legal battle to expose the man who committed sex crimes against them.

Stuff.co.nz

Christchurch abuse victims Anne-Marie Forsyth and Karen Beaumont talk about their dismay that their abuser has his name suppressed.

As victims, they won the right to have their name suppression lifted in August last year. They wanted their abuser exposed, but the judge allowed a suppression order granted to the man in 1994 to continue.

Billed as a test case for other survivors who wanted to stop sex offenders hiding behind victims' statutory protection, they asked the High Court to review the court's decision last month.

In a just-released judgment, Justice Mander refused to quash their attacker's name suppression.

Two decades had passed, the man had rehabilitated and not reoffended in the belief he had permanent name suppression. 

Mander had to consider the man's situation in 2015, not at the conclusion of his trial in 1995.

Removing his name suppression after such a long period would have "disproportionately punitive consequences", would cause extreme hardship and could repunish him.

Recent publication of his name on the internet, and potential further publicity, had caused significant financial and personal problems and he had lost a job, Mander said. 

Ad Feedback

"These are consequences which are commonly associated with being convicted for sexual offending and would not ordinarily justify name suppression. However, for such repercussions to be visited upon a person for the first time some two decades after the criminal justice process has ended is, to my knowledge, unprecedented."

The man's lawyer, Jonathan Eaton QC, said at the hearing last month the man believed final name and occupation suppression order was made at his sentencing in the Lower Hutt District Court in May 1994. It would be unfair to revisit the issue. 

The sisters' lawyer, Nikki Pender, who declined to comment on the judgment until she had spoken with her clients, said last month there was only a record of an interim suppression order.

Mander found error in the trial court's approach as to whether the man's name should be permanently suppressed. 

The women were abused in the 1970s when they were 10 and 14. They complained to police in 1994. A year later the man was convicted of three offences of performing an indecent act and two counts of indecent assault and sent to prison.

The sisters argued the man's identity was not made public only because of suppression orders protecting their own identities, which became obsolete after their suppression was lifted.

Eaton said if suppression orders could be reconsidered at any time, offenders would never be able to move on with their lives, he said.

Prior to the hearing, one of the sister said the legal fight had cost $13,500 so far and could top $30,000. She said they had to show they could fund the legal action and any costs if they lost by proving the equity in their homes.

 - Stuff

Ad Feedback
special offers
Auckland

'Phantom' to remain jailed

Loizos Michaels, pictured before being sent to prison. He has been decline parole twice.

A conman who calls himself 'The Phantom' and once duped Jonah Lomu has been denied parole.

Thousands gather in Auckland

The Anzac service at the Auckland War Memorial on Anzac Day 2017.

A crisp, clear morning greeted thousands of Aucklanders at the War Memorial Museum Anzac Day service.

One house but two homes video

The house is designed with two distinct "wings" to give each couple their own space. The only shared space is the foyer.

Buying a first home in Auckland's Grey Lynn was little more than a dream for two young couples - until they pooled their resources.

'We're just thrilled he's here'

Alec Gannaway celebrates his birthday at Auckland City Hospital surrounded by family. From left: sister Rose, mum Joy ...

Two weeks ago, Alec Gannaway was dragged by a car and put in a coma. Today, he's 21.

Wellington

Dawn service draws thousands

Following the dawn service, many people chose to leave their poppies on the Tomb of the Unknown Warrior.

As the sun rose in the capital, thousands stood in silence in remembrance of those who have fought under the Anzac banner.

Live: Anzac Day 

Anzac Day dawn parade and service at Anzac Memorial Park, Nelson.

Crowds gathered on a crisp autumn morning to pay their respects on Anzac Day.

Rare falcon shot dead

DOC is outraged after a kareakea was killed in Nikau Valley, Paraparaumu. (FILE PHOTO)

DoC furious over killing of protected bird, which could lead to jail sentence or a $100k fine.

Capital's mystery jet

A jet with blocked details landed at Wellington Airport on Monday evening.

Gulfstream jet with blocked flight tracker credentials touches down in Wellington.

Canterbury

Tactix in strife

Netball Mainland board chairwoman Anne Marett says the retention and recruitment of players at the top level is a ...

There's no shortage of issues for the Tactix. Solutions must be found says Netball Mainland chairwoman.

Firearms scare in Chch

Armed police blocked off Rex St in Riccarton after a firearms scare on Tuesday morning. (File photo)

Police cordoned off a Christchurch street after a firearms scare.

Students dig in for Anzac

Jess McHale, of the Student Volunteer Army, helps out at North New Brighton Beach on Anzac Day.

There may be no world wars to run off to but young New Zealanders are finding their own way to serve their country.

Immigration suppressing pay rates

Telani Esene, left, Kristine Bartlett and Eneata Apineru celebrate their historic pay equity.

OPINION: NZ's immigration settings are keeping Kiwis out of jobs and impacting house prices.

Waikato

Car park for Garden Place?

Extra parking spaces are sought in central Hamilton - and a couple of options involve Garden Place.

A shared lane or car parking are both suggestions for Hamilton's central square.

Medals come home

Sam Healy and daughter Jorja, 9, are reunited with their family's war medals.

A year ago thieves stole Sam Healy's grandfather's war medals. On Anzac Day eve, she got them back.

Shed fire injures one

A shed on this Hakarimata Rd property250417 news A shed at this property on Hakarimata Rd near Huntly went up on flames, ...

Explosions heard as workshop went up in flames shortly before noon.

Man punched toddler in fit of rage

Jermaine Tuau, 33, was sentenced in the Hamilton District Court, when he appeared via video link this week.

Jermaine Tuau punched a three-year-old in the head after a long history of family violence.

Taranaki

Anzac Day in Waitara

The Anzac Day Parade in Waitara before the civic service.

The weather was perfect for the Anzac Day services held around the mountain on Tuesday.

Stratford at Dawn

Isaac Burroughs, 15, from the Stratford District Air Training Corps stood guard among the crosses.

Stratford's dawn service was one of many held around Taranaki this Anzac Day.

Five days of fun

24042016 NEWS Photo CHARLOTTE CURD/Fairfax. Fowler Homes Taranaki Mega Fun Carnival at the old countdown carpark this ...

After a hugely successful event last year, the carnival is back in New Plymouth.

Jala the otter has died

Jala was 16 years old when he died, just three days after his birthday party.

He was beloved by New Plymouth and his great mate Jemima. Jala the otter will be missed.

Manawatu

Town recreates Passchendaele

25042017  News  photo: Warwick Smith/Fairfax NZ  
Halcombe Anzac Day parade  -  parade 'dismissed'.

Halcombe put on a historical spectacle as they recreated Flanders Fields.  

Child basher in denial

Peter Ross Moran wants to live near a child whose brain he damaged.

He caused his victim's brain to become "watery mush", but still denies doing anything wrong.

Manawatu Gorge could be closed for weeks

The Manawatu Gorge is closed following a slip.

Manawatu Gorge set for another long closure after two slips block lanes.

Thousands at Anzac remembrance

25042017 News photo DAVID UNWIN/FAIRFAX NZ
Anzac day dawn service in The Square, Palmerston North.

"This is the better world that our soldiers died in the hope of."

Nelson

Flowers revive wartime memories

World War II veteran Allan Carson holds poppies from Flanders Fields in Belgium, brought back from a visit there in ...

A Nelson man's souvenir from a WW1 battlefield stirs up two generations of memories.

Rising to remember video

Anzac Day dawn parade and service at Anzac Memorial Park, Nelson.

Thousands woke before dawn to attend Anzac Day dawn service in Nelson.

Doctor's costly error

Kenneth Michael Wolnak has admitted careless driving causing death and injury.

Heart surgeon ordered to pay $165,000 for causing two deaths in a horrific Nelson crash.

New life for Anzac solider's Rolex

Joel Whitwell of Benjamin Black Goldsmiths and Jackie Cook with a World War I era Rolex watch. Cook asked the Goldsmiths ...

Harold Williams left a wartime watch to his family, now they have given it new life.

Marlborough

'It's a reality check'

Dawn services at the Seddon Memorial Hall.

Friends, family remember those who made the ultimate sacrifice in Anzac commemoration.

Anzac day treats

Kaikoura council earthquake recovery economic lead Mel Skinner with a plate of Anzac cookies from Wellington's Good ...

The Good Bitches' homebaking brings a sweet reassuring note to earthquake recovery effort.

'The supreme sacrifice'

Australian Army veteran Betty Binnie gets her two remounted medals pinned to her chest by RAAF Squadron Leader Marcus Watson.

Rocked to the core by earthquakes, the people of Ward stand strong to remember the fallen this Anzac day.

Food, glorious food

Paula Theodore, Mario Dussurget (Cloudy Bay) Georgie Leach (Wine Marlborough) and Chris Shaw.

Marlborough produce is set for its time in the sun at an exciting new event.

South Canterbury

New book on war hero

Tom O'Connor has published a book on Waimate war hero Eric Batchelor.

The life of one of New Zealand's most decorated soldiers has been detailed in new book.

Honouring sacrifice

War veterans march on Memorial Ave towards the cenotaph at the Anzac Dawn Service in Timaru.

A crowd of a few hundred stood at the cenotaph in Timaru to commemorate Anzac Day.

Man killed in crash

A man is dead after a crash on Freehold Creek Bridge at Lake Ohau.

One person has died after a single-vehicle crash on a bridge in the Waitaki District.

Charging stations for Mackenzie

The kind of electric charging station Alpine Energy is looking to install in Fairlie, Tekapo and Twizel.

New Zealand's ever-expanding electric car infrastructure is headed for the Mackenzie.

Southland

The watchmaker at Cassino

Cassino under bombing.

Warren Warburton's working life was about beauty and precision. His war wasn't.

Fragility and vigour

Dawn Parade at the Invercargill Cenotaph.  The Ascot Park Hotel Brass Band of Invercargill's Ethan Hellyer, left, with ...

The corrosions of age and the vigour of youth stood shoulder to shoulder in Invercargill's dawn service.

Gore's Anzac service

Gore High School pupil Jake Miller with Gore RSA padre Bruce Cavanagh before he left on the Anzac exchange.

A Tamworth student carried Australia's flag at Gore's Anzac Day service.

Live: Anzac Day services

Anzac Day dawn parade and service at Anzac Memorial Park, Nelson.

Crowds gathered on a crisp autumn morning to pay their respects on Anzac Day.

Ad Feedback