Abused sisters lose High Court bid to name attacker video

Anne-Marie Forsyth and Karen Beaumont went to court to have their own name suppression lifted.
JOHN KIRK-ANDERSON/FAIRFAX NZ

Anne-Marie Forsyth and Karen Beaumont went to court to have their own name suppression lifted.

Two sisters who fought to unmask their abuser four decades after they were sexually assaulted have failed to convince a High Court judge.

Anne-Marie Forsyth and Karen Beaumont from Christchurch, have been engaged in a lengthy and expensive legal battle to expose the man who committed sex crimes against them.

Stuff.co.nz

Christchurch abuse victims Anne-Marie Forsyth and Karen Beaumont talk about their dismay that their abuser has his name suppressed.

As victims, they won the right to have their name suppression lifted in August last year. They wanted their abuser exposed, but the judge allowed a suppression order granted to the man in 1994 to continue.

Billed as a test case for other survivors who wanted to stop sex offenders hiding behind victims' statutory protection, they asked the High Court to review the court's decision last month.

In a just-released judgment, Justice Mander refused to quash their attacker's name suppression.

Two decades had passed, the man had rehabilitated and not reoffended in the belief he had permanent name suppression. 

Mander had to consider the man's situation in 2015, not at the conclusion of his trial in 1995.

Removing his name suppression after such a long period would have "disproportionately punitive consequences", would cause extreme hardship and could repunish him.

Recent publication of his name on the internet, and potential further publicity, had caused significant financial and personal problems and he had lost a job, Mander said. 

Ad Feedback

"These are consequences which are commonly associated with being convicted for sexual offending and would not ordinarily justify name suppression. However, for such repercussions to be visited upon a person for the first time some two decades after the criminal justice process has ended is, to my knowledge, unprecedented."

The man's lawyer, Jonathan Eaton QC, said at the hearing last month the man believed final name and occupation suppression order was made at his sentencing in the Lower Hutt District Court in May 1994. It would be unfair to revisit the issue. 

The sisters' lawyer, Nikki Pender, who declined to comment on the judgment until she had spoken with her clients, said last month there was only a record of an interim suppression order.

Mander found error in the trial court's approach as to whether the man's name should be permanently suppressed. 

The women were abused in the 1970s when they were 10 and 14. They complained to police in 1994. A year later the man was convicted of three offences of performing an indecent act and two counts of indecent assault and sent to prison.

The sisters argued the man's identity was not made public only because of suppression orders protecting their own identities, which became obsolete after their suppression was lifted.

Eaton said if suppression orders could be reconsidered at any time, offenders would never be able to move on with their lives, he said.

Prior to the hearing, one of the sister said the legal fight had cost $13,500 so far and could top $30,000. She said they had to show they could fund the legal action and any costs if they lost by proving the equity in their homes.

 - Stuff

Ad Feedback
special offers
Auckland

Best spring foods

Spring can mean a health food kick for those wanting that perfect summer-bod.

Get your hands on these seasonal spring foods to liven your meals.

Fletcher workers to strike

Workers at a Hunua quarry site owned by Fletcher Building will picket in protest over hours and pay.

Auckland quarry workers' union says their pay doesn't keep up with cost of living.

Mt Tiger resident concerned over poisoned bait

Andrew Randall says he is hesitant to  eat wild pork hunted on his property for fear the meat will contain brodifacoum  ...

Poisoned bait in a Whangarei forestry block has a resident concerned people and animals could unwittingly eat residual toxins.

This ain't no air-mageddon

Our jet fuel crisis has been handled a lot better than British Airway's IT meltdown in May.

OPINION: Another aviation snafu shows that New Zealand travellers could have it much worse.

Wellington

Eli gains loyal, helpful friend video

Six-year-old Eli Burkhalter with  his new assistance dog Taffy.

Taffy the golden labrador is a welcome companion for six-year-old Waikanae boy.

Kids sick on synthetics

Synthetic drugs, often mixed with dried leaves resembling cannabis, have claimed at least 20 lives in New Zealand this ...

Youngest was just 5 as three Porirua kids taken to hospital severely ill.

SH1 blockage cleared

NZTA advised of delays on around the Paremata roundabout and Mana on State Highway 1 after a three-car crash at Plimmerton.

Minor delays continue after a two-car crash near Plimmerton.

Capital train strike likely

Capital commuters are likely to face disruptions as rail workers prepare to strike.

Disruptions ahead for Wellington rail commuters as employment dispute boils over.

Canterbury

'Bound together by cancer' video

Christchurch father of two Kevin "Chalky" Carr received the news that his pancreatic cancer was back and his prognosis ...

Chalky Carr could have focused on his own cancer fight. Instead, he's raising $100,000 for a girl he'd never met.

Mum 'cannot grieve' video

Michelle Bishop is upset at the service received by funeral home Poppy Funerals following the death of her daughter ...

Michelle Bishop feels let down by funeral director who gave her Thin Lizzy for body and booked funeral at buffet restaurant.

Who won the final debate? video

AUCKLAND, NEW ZEALAND - SEPTEMBER 20:  Labour party leader Jacinda Ardern speaks during the TVNZ Vote 2017 2nd Leaders ...

Jacinda Ardern looked and sounded like someone in a fight for their political life. And she is.

Just smile at the road rage video

30082018 News: GEORGE HEARD/STUFF

Stuff Reporter Julian Lee takes a day out in Christchurch to really see what people ...

They may not be rich, but these three blokes don't want for much.

Waikato

Fatal police shooting 'justified'

The grieving family of a man shot dead by police in the Karangahake Gorge near Paeroa.

Officer used fatal force because he believed machete-wielding man was about to kill.

City's $1b water park

The site could be home to an adventure park where visitors can try wakeboarding or scramble over an inflatable aquatic ...

Plans for a water adventure park, including housing, have been revealed.

Threatened at knifepoint

Police received reports of the robbery in Tokoroa at 10.05pm (file photo).

A dairy worker was threatened with a knife during a late night attempted robbery.

Massive slip crosses river

A slip, estimated between 10 and 20 hectares, has fallen from private farm land in Waitomo.

Rain-soaked landslide was so big and so fast that rolled over a river and onto a road.

Taranaki

Death of monkey at Brooklands Zoo

150816 News Grant Matthew/Fairfax NZ 

Cotton-top tamarin monkeys at the Brooklands Zoo in New Plymouth.

Nephrite leaves behind her 5-year-old daughter Inca, and Inca's dad.

Tight result predicted 

New Plymouth candiates
Clockwise from top left: Murray Chong (NZ First), Jonathan Young (National), Corie Haddock ...

Six New Plymouth electorate candidates still have more to do before they can relax

Ngā Manu Kōrero begins

Dr Ruakere Hond addressed the manuhiri (visitors).

Students from 52 schools across Aotearoa have arrived in New Plymouth for a speech competition.

Principal search

Lynda Stuart, president of the NZEI, said there are ore principal vacancies than usual.

Four schools are looking for principals, and another four are looking for deputies and assistants.

Manawatu

Another feather in artist's cap

13092017 Photo: MURRAY WILSON/STUFF		
Artist Joe Mcmenamin has worked with Lytton St School kids making a large, ...

Artist brightening up Manawatū streets with mural artwork.

Convicted killer sues 

Convicted murderer Stephen Hudson appeared by audio-visual link to the High Court in Wellington. (File photo)

Stephen Hudson was in Whanganui Prison, he's now in Rimutaka, but he wants to be at Tongariro.

Two service stations held up

The BP service station in Main St, Palmerston North, was robbed by two armed men on Wednesday.

Armed men entered a BP in Palmerston North and a Mobil in Levin.

House fire investigated

Firefighters put out a house fire in Eyre St, Feilding, early on Thursday.

Investigators are looking into the cause of a fire in an empty Feilding house overnight.

Nelson

Great Kererū Count due to start

Nelsonians have been invited to do their bit to help keep count of the nation's kererū.

It's time to get our your notebooks and keep your eyes peeled for New Zealand's native wood pigeon.

'What's a candidate?' video

Birchwood School students from left Jacob 8, Talei 9, Mia 8, talk to Stuff about their thoughts on the election and politics.

They can't legally vote until 2029, but they still have strong views on the election.

Who are you voting for?

Who are you voting for?

How are you voting on Saturday? Have your say in our election poll.

Home detention for sexual assaults

Ian Hopkins has been sentenced to home detention after being found guilty of indecent assault against three women.

A 75-year-old Nelson man given home detention over indecent assaults on three women.

Marlborough

Recycling in the bag

Pak 'n Save owner Mark Elkington with their new soft plastics recycling bin.

Millions of plastic bags destined for landfill can now be recycled.

The generation game

The chutney-taste test is a serious business for members of the Women's Institute.

The cavalry is coming for one of New Zealand's oldest institutions - and they've brought chutney.

'Taylor-made' for trees

The first planting event in 2014 saw  Marlborough Landscape Group members, from left, Helen Ballinger, Ralph Ballinger ...

 It began as an idea to enhance the river and has branched out into something much bigger.

When one door closes ...

Business owners Holly Bonnington, right, and Kay Nicholls (centre) at the Sneaky Beach Cafe in Havelock.

The Sneaky Beach Cafe opened this week in Havelock, much to the excitement of locals.

South Canterbury

Men's health focus of campaign

Jonty Penney from Timaru is participating in the Distinguished Gentleman's Ride to raise funds for men,s health.

Two Timaru men are taking the health message on the road.

Flow-on concerns

David Hurst, from A J Engineering in Washdyke, is concerned about the impact of the water levy.

Businesses concerned about impact of Labour's water levy, spokesman says concerns unjustified.

New Mackenzie CEO

New Mackenzie council chief executive Suzette van
Aswegen.

A current staff member will take on the top job at the Mackenzie District Council.

'He's a hero,' neighbour says

The remains of the Waipopo property on Wednesday afternoon.

Waipopo man who rescued wife from fire would have used 'every bit of strength'.

Otago

Search for missing man

Missing Dunedin man Stephen Lowe.

More than 30 ground searchers, three search dogs and an aerial search have failed to find any further sign of missing Dunedin man Stephen Lowe

Serial sea lion killer at large video

A sea lion found shot on a Catlins beach in Southland in April.

A serial killer may be targeting New Zealand sea lions, with a $5000 reward on offer in exchange for the culprit.

Fired while on sick leave

The Employment Relations Authority (ERA) has ordered Oamaru-based P&W Painters (PWP) to compensate former employee Paul ...

Company that unfairly fired brush hand while on sick leave also had to compensate an ex-staffer who was called a "baby killer".

Kidnapping duo plead guilty

Nick Miles, 24, and Gary Michael Wilson, 46, have admitted kidnapping a man and dumping him on the outskirts of Dunedin.

Two men kidnapped and dumped another man on the outskirts on Dunedin.

Southland

Youth organisations make appeal

Sam Balloch was one of dozens of volunteers seeking signatures for a petition to keep Number 10 One Stop Shop and ...

Number 10 Youth One Stop Shop and the Invercargill Secondary Schools Network are gathering support for their petition to remain at their current location.

Pound in clear

An animal group and the Invercargill City Council are at odds about how a dog was treated. (File photo)

Ministry for Primary Industries clears the Invercargill City Council over captive bolt use.

Forestry gets favour: ES

Nicol Horrell, chairman of Environment Southland.

''Forestry operators will be able to operate at lower environmental standards than other resource users in Southland."

Quake off Southland coast

A magnitude 5.8 quake struck near Southland.

A 5.8 earthquake hit off the coast of Southland - but its shaking was unnoticeable, GeoNet says.

Ad Feedback