Kim Dotcom loses extradition case, files immediate appeal video

LAWRENCE SMITH/Stuff.co.nz

Kim Dotcom and his co accused to appeal extradition decision

A judge has ruled internet mogul Kim Dotcom is eligible for extradition to face charges in the United States. 

However, Dotcom immediately said he would file an appeal, ensuring the long-running courtroom drama will continue for some time yet.

Following lengthy arguments in the North Shore District Court Judge Nevin Dawson called a last minute hearing on Wednesday to give his ruling. 

Kim Dotcom awaits the judge's decision in his extradition case to the US on charges of copyright infringement and ...
LAWRENCE SMITH/FAIRFAX NZ

Kim Dotcom awaits the judge's decision in his extradition case to the US on charges of copyright infringement and illegal file sharing.

He said all four Megaupload founders named in the application were eligible for extradition. 

It followed nine weeks of submissions from Dotcom's lawyer Ron Mansfield, and counsel for the United States, Christine Gordon QC.

READ MORE:
Nothing unusual about Kim Dotcom fraud case, says US
Judges' job impossible in the latest Dotcom extradition case, lawyers told
Kim Dotcom case finally under way
Kim Dotcom tells court he is 'broke, destitute and penniless'
US court prevents Kim Dotcom from fighting asset seizure

Kim Dotcom's extradition decision was delivered on Wednesday.
PETER MEECHAM/FAIRFAX NZ

Kim Dotcom's extradition decision was delivered on Wednesday.

The US also sought to extradite Dotcom's Mega cofounders and colleagues Mathias Ortmann and Bram van der Kolk, who were represented by Grant Illingworth QC, Fin Batato was represented by himself.

All four are facing money laundering, racketeering and breach of copyright charges in the United States, following allegations from the US that the founders of Megaupload, formerly a popular file sharing website, were knowingly allowing copyright material to be shared on a large scale. 

During court hearings Mega was said to be one of the most successful internet service providers in history, with more than one billion unique visitors in its lifetime. 

Although the US didn't need to prove the charge, counsel had to at least prove there was an answerable case overseas to fulfil extradition requirements. 

Ad Feedback

Lawyers for the four argued that the court didn't have jurisdiction to order extradition and that copyright law showed they weren't required or expected to filter every single piece of copyright material on Mega.  

Gordon, for the US, said the four had made millions from the cloud storage venture and had ignored or only partially heeded takedown notices. She also said frequent users were rewarded for sharing copyright-breaching files. 

On Wednesday the courtroom was packed with media and supporters of Dotcom and his co-accused, including Dotcom's ex wife Mona Dotcom. 

Judge Dawson said he wouldn't read his entire decision aloud, because it would take too long. The formal judgment would be made available to all parties, including media. 

He first addressed an earlier stay application applied for by Dotcom, which he rejected. 

He then said that the the US had a "large body of evidence" which supported a prima facie case. 

"The respondents fall well short of undermining the case," he said. 

Batato's wife sobbed as the verdict was read.

DOTCOM TO APPEAL

Speaking outside court after the ruling, Dotcom said simply, "This is not the last word on the matter. We've filed an appeal.

"I'm disappointed. That's all I have to say and I wish everybody a very merry Christmas. I'm going home now." 

Dotcom's lawyer, Ron Mansfield, said the hearing had grappled with "novel" and "complex" issues and that an appeal and a review would be launched in the court on Wednesday afternoon. 

Prior to that Judge Dawson said although there was a "heightened flight risk" there was no reason the men's bail shouldn't continue, saying they had complied with their strict conditions ever since their arrest. 

Justice Minister Amy Adams said that given the intention to appeal, it would be inappropriate for her to comment.

"The first step is to wait and see if the judgment is appealed.  If it is not then I will need to consider the court's determination and receive advice from the Ministry of Justice on the relevant issues under the Extradition Act.

"As the court's decision may be appealed, it would be inappropriate for me to comment further at this time."

Under the Extradition Act 1999, both the courts and the minister have roles in an extradition process.

While the court considers whether the evidence establishes that there is a case to answer, the Justice Minister determines whether extradition should be carried out.

"However, I haven't begun to turn my mind to that question," Adams said. "Such a decision would not arise until after the conclusion of any appeal of the legal finding that the respondents are eligible for extradition."

Outside court Illingworth said it was obviously a disappointing day for both his clients and both had immediately filed an appeal following the decision. 

He said he wouldn't like to predict how much longer the matter would drag on for.

Batato and his wife left the court quickly without speaking to reporters. 

A SHORT HISTORY OF DOTCOM 

In 2010 Dotcom was granted permanent residency in New Zealand. He is originally from Germany. 

Attempts by the US to extradite him began in 2012, following a raid at his Coatesville mansion

Months later a High Court judge ruled the raid was illegal. Years later the Supreme Court ruled it was indeed legal

Over the ensuing years three stay applications made by Dotcom's lawyers were rejected by the courts.

In the meantime Dotcom produced and heavily marketed an album called Good Times, despite the courts stripping him of most of his cash

And there was a shortlived political bid with the Internet Party, after teaming up with Leila Harre. 

The extradition hearing began in the North Shore District Court jurisdiction in September, held in a central Auckland courtroom 

 - Stuff

Ad Feedback
special offers
Auckland

Road map for Henderson-Massey

Henderson-Massey Local Board chairman Shane Henderson said they've adopted their local board plan for the next three years.

Auckland local board reveals its vision for the next three years.

NZ wins at world Irish pub awards

Phill Judd and Maire Burns raise a toast after winning an award for Best Craft Beer Experience.

Pub co-owner first thought news of being on awards shortlist was a prank.

Child trapped in hospital ceiling

A child became stuck in the ceiling at Starship Children's Hospital in Auckland overnight, and fire crews have been ...

Parents of a child patient hiding in a hospital ceiling for hours could sue for negligence, says lawyer.

Fan fun in Pukekohe for Supercars

Pukekohe will host a Fan Day, where Supercar fans get to meet the drivers.

Meet the drivers at the ITM Auckland SuperSprint Pukekohe Fan Day.

Wellington

Wellington boss to stay

Wellington City Council CEO Kevin Lavery has signed on for another two years.

The Wellington City Council chief executive gets contract extended, pay rise pending.

30,000 tickets sold

Chris James celebrates scoring against Mexico in 2013.

The "full house" sign is nearly ready with only a few thousand tickets left for the All Whites World Cup playoff.

The battle to sell booze

The foodmarket on Mt Victoria was unable to renew its off-licence last year, and is trying to get it back.

In a bid to get a liquor licence shop's lawyer lists cereals in stock - then he's told to stop.

Peter Jackson's new menu

An Impossible Foods burger. The company has attracted investment from the likes of Bill Gates and Hong Kong billionaire ...

Led by Sir Peter Jackson, NZ may become a force in the plant-based protein business.

Canterbury

Too many to name

Some of the 55 hutches in Deborah McNeil's suburban back yard where she keeps 80 rabbits.

A Christchurch woman who keeps 80 rabbits at her suburban flat says her bunny buddies are happy, healthy and well loved. 

Bypass opening soon

Traffic builds up on the northern motorway between Belfast and the Waimakariri River bridge.

Traffic will be switched onto Christchurch's new Western Belfast Bypass in stages from early November.

Cycling in Chch, ugh

Stuff reporter Monique Steele cycles in Kyoto in Japan during their piping hot summer back in July.

OPINION: Is Christchurch ready to become a cycle city? Or rather, is Christchurch ready to join the rest of the world?

Concrete truck crashes into house

A concrete truck crashed into Kazimir Podstolski's house.

Homeowner may not sleep in his bedroom tonight after a truck crashed through the wall.

Waikato

Retired farmer sailing away

Roy Woolerton, 80, spent 16 years building his catamaran, but it's now in the water at Westhaven Marina in Auckland.

The hand-built 14.5m offshore cruising cat has two engines and four double berths

Surviving Labour Day

Expect heavy traffic this Labour weekend (file photo).

 It's been carnage on the roads this year. Here's how to take it easy this long weekend.

Emotional send-off for solider

Sergeant Wayne Taylor, 42, died during a maritime counter-terrorism training exercise off the Coromandel Peninsula on ...

The death of Sergeant Wayne Taylor has left a huge hole, his family say.

Pair trapped in crash

Two cars have collided in the Athenree Gorge.

Two trapped and two more injured after smash in gorge near Waihi.

Taranaki

Cato needs a co-host

Suzy Cato is famous for her Children's TV show Suzy's World

Children's TV star Suzy Cato now hosts a radio show and wants a Taranaki kid to join her on it.

Sex case verdicts

A jury has returned its verdicts in a Taranaki sex abuse case which was heard in the New Plymouth District Court. (File ...

A jury has found a man guilty of half the historical sex abuse charges he was alleged to have committed.

Traffic light knocked down

The crash happened at the intersection of Devon St East and State Highway 3.

Traffic on New Plymouth's northern route is down to one lane as a result of a crash.

Returning Kiwi's prison stay

After years of living outside of New Zealand, a Taranaki man spent a stint behind bars after being arrested for a ...

A decade old criminal offence caught up with a Taranaki man when he returned from living overseas.

Manawatu

Hemopo clearly Turbos' best

There was no better for the Turbos this season than Jackson Hemopo, who was also the team's top lineout target.

With the Turbos' season over, rugby writer Shaun Eade looks at the top performers.

Crown: Lundy guilty gallery

Justices Helen Winkelmann, Mark Cooper and Raynor Asher are hearing Mark Lundy's appeal in the Court of Appeal.

Crown says times of death in Lundy case may have changed between trials, but  key evidence remains the same.

Car flips outside school

A wrecked car's tyres and brake pads were still smoking as police and a witness rushed to help the driver who crashed ...

Witnesses shocked to see a car smash into two parked cars before flipping in front of school.

Hartley in for high-stakes debut video

NZ motorsport ace Brendon Hartley will make his F1 debut at the US Grand Prix.

Kiwi driver in lions' den at Circuit of the Americas with Lewis Hamilton racing for the F1 crown.

Nelson

Military manoeuvres

Military light operational vehicles involved in Exercise Southern Katipo 2017 roll off the HMNZS Canterbury at Port Nelson.

 Nelson gets a glimpse of the Southern Katipo military exercise as soldiers and supplies roll out of Port Nelson.

Charge follows scare

A policeman at the Stoke Railway Reserve looks for a man who was allegedly seen with a knife in the area.

Police charge teenager with possession of an offensive weapon after knife scare saw schools locked down.

Higher-density housing plan

Deputy mayor Tim King says there is increasing demand for small, compact properties in central Richmond.

Would you like to see more, smaller houses in central Richmond?

Man faces 30 drug dealing offences

A "point bag" of crystal methamphetamine.

Stoke man faces 33 charges relating to methamphetamine and cannabis.

Marlborough

Bar gets new lease of life

Paddy Barry's Irish Bar, on Scott St, closed in 2017.

The owner of two popular night spots in Blenheim is seemingly looking to open a third.

Charity shop to close

Pams Shop Charitable Trust president Bev Dixon says the trust tried everything they could to keep the store open. (File ...

Sales had dropped significantly to the point where the shop had not made a charitable donation in a year.

Embracing cultural differences

The Yealands Wine Group, based in Seddon, is one of the largest wine companies in New Zealand.

It's easy to dish out the criticism when corporates don't do their bit for ethical practices, so it's important to recognise when they do.

Hijacker could get $25,000

Abdille said a government rule change stopped her reuniting her family in 2004.

Asha Abdille injured two pilots in 2008. Now, she's out of jail and could be in the money.

South Canterbury

When Taiyo met Tom video

Japanese student Taiyo Watanabe finally met his hero gold medal winning shot put world champion Tom Walsh in Timaru on ...

Aspiring Japanese shot putter surprised by unexpected meet and greet with hero Tom Walsh.

No word on SH1 call

Mid-South Canterbury area commander Inspector Dave Gaskin

Pareora residents renew calls for lower speed limit after three-car crash in September.

Slight setback for Tekapo hotel

An aerial view showing developments at Lake Tekapo.

Latest hurdle in consent process of luxury hotel a 'slight' set back, developer says.

Ute crash near Hampden

06062016 News Photo: Christel Yardley/Fairfax NZ
News: A fatal crash has happened on Harris Street near Riverlea Dairy ...

Woman being taken to Dunedin Hospital after a crash north of Hampden.

Otago

Racing boss turns to golf tourism

Owner of Highlands Motorsport Park and Hampton Downs, Tony Quinn.

Highlands Motorsport Park boss Tony Quinn wants to build a golf course and residential development at the back of his racetrack.

Pilot Graeme Frew confirms Full Noise for Wanaka

Reno rookie of the year, Graeme Frew.

Record-breaking rookie Reno racer Graeme Frew to bring V-12 powered Yak-3 aircraft to Wanaka's airshow.

Aerial rat attack in Matukituki Valley

Native robins are thriving at Aspiring Flat after being reintroduced to the area several years ago.

DOC opens new front in the Battle for our Birds in the Mt Aspiring National Park near Wanaka.

Ngāi Tahu elder dies

Kuao Langsbury speaks during a Waitangi Day celebration at Ōtākou Marae.





Copyright Photo, Otago Daily Times, ...

A tangi has been held for Kuao Langsbury, a Ngāi Tahu elder and key negotiator of their settlement with the Crown.

Southland

Unique tanker in truck parade

Bill Richardson Transport World tourism co-ordinator Amelia Munro will accompany the museum's Texaco Tanker in Sunday's ...

A one-of-a-kind Texaco tanker will be paraded in Invercargill for possibly the last time.

Principals praise parent volunteers

Invercargill Middle School principal Stan Tiatia.

"I think we are really lucky that the good old Southland way is to get in and help."

Kiwis need to talk about driving

NZ Transport Agency regional relationships director Jim Harland with a steering wheel tag that provides tourists with ...

Before criticising out international drivers, Kiwis need to start looking at their own driving ability, an NZ Transport Agency director has said.

Gore dairy owner wary of safety

Sunbeam Milk Bar owner Eddie Cooney is appreciative of support from the Gore community following an armed robbery in his ...

Three robberies have taken their toll on Gore dairy owner Eddie Cooney but he's not hanging up the closed sign.

Ad Feedback