Kiwi teenager forced to do Singaporean national service or risk jail time and fines

Brandon Smith, 18, said if he returned to Singapore to complete his national service he would be treated as an outsider.

Brandon Smith, 18, said if he returned to Singapore to complete his national service he would be treated as an outsider.

A New Zealand teenager born in Singapore has been threatened with jail time and hefty fines unless he returns to the Asian nation to complete two years of national service in the army.

Brandon Smith,19, moved to Dunedin with his family when he was eight years old and holds dual citizenship with New Zealand and Singapore.

But Singaporean authorities are demanding he report for a pre-service medical or face two years in jail, or a S$10,000 (NZ$10,780) fine. 

Brandon with his mother Cindy, who was born in Singapore, and his NZ-born father Shane.

Brandon with his mother Cindy, who was born in Singapore, and his NZ-born father Shane.

Brandon said spending two years doing national service would be difficult and pointless. 

"I don't see the point of it, really. It's sort of a waste of time to go there and just come back anyway," he said. 

Brandon said he does not speak Chinese, and as a New Zealand citizen he would be treated as an outsider. 

After an initial three-month training period in which service personnel are housed and fed, they are then expected to find their own accommodation. 

Although they receive a small monthly payment, it would not be enough to cover rent and food, and he would not want to impose on family, he said. 

Under Singaporean law, Brandon cannot relinquish his citizenship until he is 21 years old.

An application to defer his national service until the age of 21 has been declined on numerous occasions, despite the Singaporean authorities granting his younger brother Kristen a deferment. 

Ad Feedback

His father, Shane Smith, said after a long battle with bureaucrats in Singapore they have run out of options.

"Obviously for Brandon, it's not what we want. If he doesn't go back to Singapore to serve his NS, then he can never enter Singapore because he runs the risk of being arrested," said Shane.

Shane, a New Zealand-born Kiwi, served in the New Zealand Air Force and married Brandon's mother Cindy , who was born in Singapore but is a permanent resident in New Zealand. 

Shane has been corresponding with Singaporean MPs and bureaucrats for years in a desperate bid to help his son avoid conscription. 

"Absolutely no one would accommodate us. It was always the same answer; 'we regret to inform you that Brandon has to serve National Service'," he said.

Dunedin South MP Clare Curran said in September last year she appealed to Minister for Foreign Affairs Murray McCully in a letter to help the family. 

"We have a 19-year-old who has left school with his life in front of him, he considers himself a New Zealand citizen and has no identification with Singapore and yet he is expected to do a national service," she said.

"I think it's a really good case for New Zealand to be sticking up for its citizens."

In a statement released on Saturday, McCully apologised for the late response to Curran's letter and said he had received it shortly before he took time off work to have major surgery to remove a tumour.

He said that he intended to take the matter up.

"While the Singapore Government is responsible for determining their own citizenship policies, I have considerable sympathy for the situation this family has found themselves in," he said.

 - Sunday Star Times


Ad Feedback
special offers

Pupils paint a fan trail for rugby supporters

Creative Northland's Keely Quaid, marketing assistant and support/liaison, sealing the fan's before they were erected ...

Whangarei children's art forms a fan trail for rugby supporters of the DHL New Zealand Lions Series 2017 when they visit the city.

Neridah's talents knew no limits

Neridah Haworth was a talented designer, dressmaker and artist in the 1980s and 90s.

Family inspired to share a photo book of the works of talented designer and artist Neridah Haworth, now 86, with the community.

Telling Qatar's untold story

Editor Lauren Wellbrock said this film is an honest telling of an untold story.

A Kiwi film-maker tells the story of Qatar's unskilled labourers in the upcoming documentary festival.

Time for feedback from ratepayers

Howick Local Board members will be at pop-up events, public forums, to hear from residents and ratepayers about their ...

Howick ward's draft annual plan is out, with the local board floating the idea of a new targeted rate.


From overweight to iron woman

Marama Puke before she got involved and inspired by the Iron Maori event.

Heather Skipworth has inspired Maori women to get off the couch and get fit.

Pedestrian killed

The crash happened on Monday afternoon but the pedestrian who was hit died overnight, police said. (FILE PHOTO)

A pedestrian has died overnight being hit by a car in Masterton on Monday afternoon.

Funeral for fallen player

Daniel Baldwin, a colts player for the Wellington Football Club, died in Wellington Hospital, days after a club rugby ...

Hundreds at farewell for Wellington rugby player Daniel Baldwin, who died after playing the game he loved.

Sex hallucinations 'unlikely'

Former Hastings doctor David Lim faces charges of stupefaction and performing indecent acts on patients.

Doctor on trial was "overtly gay" and this created a situation "ripe for misunderstanding", lawyer says.


Big bucks on campaign

Kerrie Bloomfield and Tim Glasson were happy to support the Restore Christchurch Cathedral campaign.

Trust lobbying to restore Christ Church Cathedral spends "hundreds of thousands" on advertisements.

Boozed driver, 160kmh

A man driving a Volkswagen Golf was clocked at 164kmh on Christchurch-Akaroa Rd on Saturday (file photo).

A man caught driving at over 160kmh blew more than four times' the drink-driving limit.

EQC 'cocked up' home claim

Rodgers and Scott after their house fire last year.

Lawyer says EQC and insurer IAG both in wrong over Heathcote home wrecked by fire and quake.

Man died in a ditch

Ashburton man Kooly Managki Te Tomo is on trial for the manslaughter of Arran Paul Gairns in June 2014.

Ashburton man was allegedly threatened and chased into water, where he drowned.


Costumes at the ready

Debee-May McCarthy, owner of Tops 'N' Tales Costume Hire shop in Hamilton East, is excited the Sevens is coming to town.

The Sevens move to Hamilton is good news for the town's longest running costume store.

Nan guilty in baby case

Donna Catherine Parangi is on trial in the High Court in Rotorua charged with the manslaughter of her grandson Isaiah Neil.

A grandmother charged with manslaughter over the death of her grandson Isaiah Neil has been found guilty.

Tourist lost in the frost

The mission began around 5.15pm on Monday when the woman, with seven per cent battery on her phone, managed to call ...

Rescuers bunked down in sub-zero conditions with a lost Israeli tourist. 

Business backs Sevens video

Lawrenson Group chief executive John Lawrenson is quietly optimistic about Hamilton hosting the sevens.

Bar owner John Lawrenson is optimistic about the Hamilton Sevens, since Dallas Fisher is in charge.


Infection is spreading 

There are now 10 properties infected with myrtle rust in Taranaki.

Malcolm Hine is in the middle of the myrtle rust outbreak, he knows his 100 feijoa trees will get it.

A farmer's fear

There are an estimated 50 Filipino farm workers around Taranaki.

OPINION: Immigration policy changes could leave farms left short-staffed.

Beware league tables

Bali Haque helps explain how NCEA is designed and why league tables aren't a helpful tool any more.

OPINION: Looking at NCEA pass rates on their own in a "league table" is a dangerous activity.

Turbine deal breaker

Debbie Ngarewa-Packer, Te Runanga o Ngati Ruanui Kaiarataki, wants to protect culturally important sites near a proposed ...

A South Taranaki iwi doesn't want wind turbines built beside important cultural sites


Skilled staff tackle grudge calls

At the Palmerston North City Council call centre, Te Rangiamohia Nikora-Davis is one of the faces behind a voice ...

UNDER THE RADAR: The council creates an art and a business out of answering phones.

DHB fails woman video

A baby was stillborn after the MidCentral District Health Board failed to see signs of a life-threatening condition.

Slip-ups from the district health board led to a woman's unborn baby dying.

Teens charged with robbery

Police have arrested two people in relation to an armed robbery at a BP in Pahiatua.

A 16 and 18-year-old will appear in court over the BP Pahiatua robbery.

Locking up smokes

Summerhays dairy owner Manhar Patel, right, and  Central Districts Indian Association vice-president Paul Patel want ...

Business owners see it as a good step, but don't think it will stop robberies.


On The Edge of a world record

The Edge radio station's Jono Pryor, Ben Boyce and Sharyn Casey attempt to break a world record for the amount of people ...

Radio show hosts get caught with their pants down on Tahunanui Beach.

Hunt for a home video

Hannah Johnson says the search for a home was disheartening.

Securing a roof over her head helped one Nelson mum turn her life around.

54-day ordeal of bed bug bites

Helmut Kazmaier, right, and his family, daughter Marla, son Emiliano, and wife Verena Goelkel were infected with bed ...

Campervan renters thought the bites were from sandflies. Then they found the real culprits.

Player still in coma

Bevan Moody suffered a cardiac arrest as he ran back to halfway for a restart in a club rugby game in Nelson.

Tasman Rugby Union offers full support to Bevan Moody, who collapsed during a match.


The battle back from brain surgery

Vernon Fredericks

The road to becoming Crusader No 213 has been far from smooth for Vernon Fredericks.

Love bites in Blenheim

Tom Knowles brings 'Allergic To Love: Curse of the 80s' home to Blenheim before touring the US.

Rock opera in the pub for rugby mates who don't do theatre about to tour the United States.

Chamber chief resigns

Marlborough Chamber of Commerce chief executive Stephen Gullery. (File photo)

After a little more than a year at the top, the Marlborough Chamber of Commerce chief executive has resigned.

Truckie admits guilt in fatal crash

Three vehicles were involved in a crash on State Highway 1 at Greta Valley, killing one and injuring four.

Courier Post driver to meet Noel Campilan's family after causing fatal crash.

South Canterbury

School heads back to the 80s

Timaru Girls' High and Timaru Boys' High School students rehearse for their joint production Back to the 80's. Pictured ...

Dig out your leg warmers, crop tops and head back to the 80s with Timaru Girls' this week.

Attack was 'planned'

Ashburton man Kooly Managki Te Tomo is on trial for the manslaughter of Arran Paul Gairns in June 2014.

Trial of Ashburton man charged with manslaughter of Arran Gairns underway.

Air standards breached in Timaru

Smoke rises from a chimney on a chilly morning in Timaru. Timaru has experienced its third high pollution day this year.

Timaru has had it third day of bad air.

Health boost sought from Budget

Presbyterian Support South Canterbury chairman Michael Parker says more money for staff in aged care was a key want for ...

Pay parity and spending on older people sought from Government budget.


Limehills school's $400,000 makeover

Limehills School teacher aide Kerry Henderson works with Emma Gill, Makayla Marshall and Liam Hartley, while Angus ...

Limehills has begun the new term with a $400,000 makeover which has transformed the school.

Schools ditching fizzy

Middle School pupils are excited about drinking water at school as part of a Healthy Families programme Rethink the ...

A local health campaign is encouraging Southland schools to choose water or plain milk.

Gore man jets for Thai waters

Dwayne Terry, left, and Paul Cross of Keelowcraft boat builders in Gore. The commercial sized twin engine jet boat has ...

Thai holidaymakers will soon be enjoying a supercharged sea monster from Gore.

Brothers attack off-duty policeman

An Invercargill policeman was unable to work for a week after he was assaulted while off-duty.

Two Invercargill brothers who attacked an off-duty policeman have been sentenced.

Ad Feedback