Anti-vaccine group sends letter to schools against Gardasil vaccine

The widely-distributed email calls for schools to immediately suspend the Gardasil programme.
123RF

The widely-distributed email calls for schools to immediately suspend the Gardasil programme.

An anti-vaccine group which sent a letter to schools stating their disapproval of the Gardasil vaccine has been called "misinformed" by experts. 

Director of Research at the Immunisation Advisory Centre, Dr Helen Petousis-Harris, has warned people not to pay attention to the letter. 

The widely distributed email called for schools to immediately suspend the Gardasil programme and said it was "unethical and a breach of your health and safety obligations" to continue the vaccinations at schools.

Sent by Gardasil Awareness New Zealand, it warned schools they would be "personally criminally liable" and civil action could be taken.

READ MORE: 
No evidence that HPV vaccine caused an Upper Hutt teenager's unexplained death
Genital wart cases drop with introduction of free vaccine
* Australian cancer vaccine inventor wins award
HPV vaccination report should not scare parents, health professionals say

The letter described some of the "harmful effects" of the Gardasil vaccine, which is used to target the types of HPV responsible for 70 per cent of cervical cancer and 90 per cent of genital warts. 

"How can you, with all due respect, continue to promote HPV vaccination programs within your school," the letter asked.

Petousis-Harris said the letter was "fairly classic" anti-vaccination material that was usually distributed. 

"There are no scientific reasons to be concerned about the vaccine, it's all just misinformation," she said. 

She was contacted by health professionals after being sent the letter, who were concerned about the harm the scaremongering tactics could create. 

Ad Feedback

"What concerns them is that sort of thing can get distance, and that's not helpful.

"By sending out misinformation, it can play on people's fears in the absence of good, factual information," she said. 

Gardasil Awareness New Zealand (GANZ) said in a 10-page response it was "heart-breaking" Petousis-Harris had not responded to any of the scientific questions it had raised. 

"Dr Petousis-Harris needs to stop posturing, stop spouting the usual antivax line, and start answering the very serious allegations made against her, and the even more serious data that clearly shows that this is a vaccine that fails to do what is supposed to do," said Gayle Dickson, spokeswoman for GANZ.

Dickson said she stood by the email, which was sent to around 2500 schools and relied on "scientific studies". 

She received a mixed response from schools, she said - some returned her queries asking for more information and others ignored it. 

Petousis-Harris hoped that principals who were sent the letter did not distribute it within the school and they did not take it seriously. 

There was no basis for the information in the letter, she said and no reason to be concerned about the Gardasil vaccination - which had been controversial in the past. 

However, Dickson called Petousis-Harris's response to the allegations "puffery with absolutely no science-based evidence".

The information in the letter claimed an open email was written to the director of the World Health Organisation (WHO) which alleged "misconduct, malfeasance and what could be potentially be criminal behaviour by certain officials to mislead the global public on the safety of Gardasil".

Petousis-Harris said the WHO in every country supports the vaccine. 

It's really important to reflect on the importance the vaccination has had on the disease, she said. Already there had been a significant reduction in cervical cancer and genital warts. 

"We are potentially seeing a decrease in a whole lot of other cancers that this little malicious virus can do as well."

However, countries like Australia which had a higher vaccination percentage, had significantly lower numbers of the disease than New Zealand, she said. 

Among the controversy more than six years ago, an Upper Hutt teenager's death was blamed on the Gardasil vaccine.

However, the recently released coroners findings into the death of Jasmine Nicole Renata found no evidence of an abnormal reaction to the  vaccine. 

Petousis-Harris said it was a "shame" that the teen's parents did not go through with the cardiac testing to rule out an inherited heart disorder as advised, and instead kept blaming her death on the vaccination. 

When somebody gets sick or even worse dies without explanation, everyone wants an answer , Petousis-Harris said.

"Every year hundreds of young people get sick and a portion of those are unexplained. When you don't have a reason for that, that's when people go looking."

The risk of unexplained illnesses was just the same as whether you were vaccinated or not, she said. 

She encouraged people to look at those who had been vaccinated, and those who had not and compare the difference. 

Anti-vaccine groups have done this sort of thing in the past, she said, comparing it to a "spam email". 

"They've made up their minds about something and are pretty intent on disseminating claims that support their view," she said. 

CORRECTION: This story was originally run saying Gardasil Awareness New Zealand had been approached for comment. Their comment has since been added in.

 - Stuff

Ad Feedback
special offers
Auckland

Citrus drive for southern friends

Donate some of your excess citrus.

The call is out for all unwanted citrus for the people of Christchurch and Dunedin.

Police paws on purr-trol

Snickers patrols the streets but has a weakness for treats.

With his on point outfits, and a habit for purr-trolling the local beat, Snickers the police cat now has his first Instagram account.

Murder in a tight-knit town video

Quinn Patterson is said to have liked guns, which he fired off "on a daily basis".

Wendy and Natanya Campbell were kind and respected. But their killer had a violent history and was "done" with life.

Rental homes risky for kids

Research from Growing Up in New Zealand's Now We Are Four report showed private rentals had significantly fewer home ...

Children living in rentals are more exposed to safety risks than those whose families own a home, study shows.

Wellington

Work to clear two slips video

A slip on Evans Bay Parade, Wellington, came down on to the road. The home above has been evacuated.

Major Wellington slips trigger road closures and one home is evacuated in the Aro Valley.

Log hits worker

A forestry worker was in great pain after being struck by a log in rural Wairarapa. (File photo)

Injured worker struck by log winched out of forestry block and flown to hospital.

Winter's bite is back video

Cold Antarctic air is behind the front bringing snow to Tekapo and other parts of the South Island.

Wellington in the firing line with gale-force southerlies on the way.

The disappearing price of premium

2032016 News Photo: Marion van Dijk/Fairfax NZ

Petrol price sign at BP2go Haven Road.

Petrol stations don't show premium fuel prices anymore and it allows gouging, AA says.

Canterbury

Truck tips, loses load video

Emergency services at the scene of a truck roll-over in central Dunedin on Friday morning.

The truck lost its load, damaging at least three cars outside a Dunedin haberdashery shop.

'Should be red zoned'

This post-quake rebuild is in one of Christchurch's lowest-lying areas. Now it will have to go to make way for a flood ...

A newly-built home is one of 13 properties to make way for a council flood protection scheme.

Raf Manji's $1b election pitch

Independent candidate for Ilam Raf Manji has launched his election campaign on Friday.

He calls for $1b fund and Commonwealth Games for Chch in Parliament bid. 

School lock-down 'resolved'

Police cordoned off a street near Broomfield School, north of Amberley, after the potential of a firearm risk at a ...

Staff and pupils locked themselves in classrooms during domestic incident nearby.

Waikato

Migrant renters' cannabis rort

Professionally installed heat lamps and hydroponic equipment were set up in various rooms, including bedrooms, of the ...

Illegal immigrant ring allegedly caught growing commercial amounts of cannabis in rentals.

Home burns to ground

Neighbours were the first to spot the flames surging from the 30m by 15m building around 11.30am on Thursday.

Residents were in a nearby town when they heard the fire siren.

Chris Bush cold case lead

Chris Bush was shot dead in 1987 at the Red Fox Tavern.

New information reopens case of Waikato barman shot in 1987 Red Fox Tavern hold-up.

Maitland's top weekend markets

Plenty of options at a range of markets on in the Waikato to support your community and buy fresh fruit and vegetables.

Stalls brimming with goodies are popping up left, right and centre in the Waikato. Te Ahua Maitland brings you all the details.

Taranaki

New owners for burger joint

New Prohibition owners Andy Le and Gabby Tran will be keeping the burger restaurant much the same.

A popular New Plymouth burger joint is under new ownership but the burgers won't change.

Collecting for a tangi

The men had collected 251 paua between them.

Two men were caught with 251 paua, 191 of them undersized.

Fail and move on

New Plymouth man Paul Feltoe swam more than 32 kilometres across the Catalina Channel in July.

 A couple of weeks ago New Plymouth man Paul Feltoe got a boat from Los Angeles to Catalina Island - then swam the 32.3kms back.

Firewood running out

A roaring fire maybe a thing of the past unless you've stocked up as supplies of firewood  run out in Taranaki with ...

Stock up in summer to avoid being left out in the cold.

Manawatu

Wowed over WOW

Jennie Munro in her workshop with costumes that have been finalists in Wellington's international World Of Wearable Arts ...

A Palmerston North designer has made the finals of September's wearable arts show.

No intercepting emails

Horizons Regional Council chief executive Michael McCartney sees no reason to intercept emails, unlike Horowhenua ...

Council chief executives see no reason for intercepting emails - unlike Horowhenua council's boss.

Collar-dragging teacher cleared

Clive Stevens with his grandmother Maureen Stevens.

Teacher who dragged special needs student along floor did nothing wrong, investigation finds.

Back to school

Greens co-leader Metiria Turei stopped to talk with Tanika Jeffery, 14, who was learning speech writing in te reo, at ...

Greens co-leader Metiria Turei talks education at her old high school.

Nelson

Car crashes into house

A house that was damaged after a car drove into it on Toi Toi St, Nelson.

A car has crashed into a Nelson home causing substantial damage.

Man critically injured

A man has critical injuries after a car hit a tree on the Coastal Highway.

A man is trapped in a car with serious injuries after a car hit a tree near Nelson.

Restructure puts kids at risk

Concerns have been raised over a proposal to consolidate the on-call crisis services in Nelson Marlborough.

Proposed restructure of child mental health could have dire consequences for vulnerable youngsters.

Grandstand gets short reprieve

The grandstand may be a drawcard for spectators again.

Golden Bay Grand Stand supporters have three months to come up with a preservation and funding plan.

Marlborough

'Our niche is Marlborough'

Dog Point Vineyard co-owners and event sponsors Ivan Sutherland, left, and James Healy read up for the Marlborough Book ...

With intimate venues and stunning surrounds, the Marlborough Book Festival is a little different.

Bigger planes?

Sounds Air chief executive Andrew Crawford inside the cockpit of one of the company's 9-seat Pilatus PC-12s.

Demand for flights prompts Marlborough airline to investigate "quantum leap" to larger planes.

Blenheim bemoans unfair fares

Air New Zealand said it would not be reinstating direct flights to Christchurch from Marlborough Airport.

"It's almost like we've offended Air New Zealand somehow and they're making us pay." 

Nurses to move to hub

The district nurses will have a similar amount of storage space at the health hub, the review panel says.

Where they need more staff, new technology and better communication, review finds.

South Canterbury

Region poised for milk boost

While the forecast price rise from Fonterra is good new for South Canterbury dairy farmers, regional Federated Farmers ...

Another $25m added to South Canterbury farmers' milk payout.

Rugby player jailed

Kolinio Yabia Tamanitoakula was jailed for three years, four months and two weeks.

His distressed victim was covered in mud when she ran in front of a car to get help.

Change possible - Falloon

National Party candidate Andrew Falloon met ECan representatives on Thursday, following heated public debate about the ...

Retrofitting plan still on the table, National Party candidate suggests.

Roads reopen, rain continues video

Contractors clear snow from the road at Tekapo on Thursday morning.

Roads to Tekapo reopen as schools send  students home early to avoid flooding.

Southland

Hall off to world champs

New Zealand discus thrower Marshall Hall practices ahead of the 2017 IAAF World Championships.

Invercargill discus thrower 'committed and focused' ahead of IAAF Athletics World Championships.

Ice causing crashes

10082016. News.Kavinda Herath. Southland Times/Stuff-Ice on the Winton Lorneville Highway

Police are warning drivers to take it slow and beware of ice on the roads.

House fire in south Invercargill

A house on Dalrymple St was "well ablaze" when fire crews arrived on Thursday morning.

One person is being treated for smoke inhalation following a house fire in Invercargill.

Data won't be public

Primary Industries Minister Nathan Guy.

Primary Industries Minister Nathan Guy said the ministry had no intention to make information about individual fishing locations public.

Ad Feedback