National Portrait: Inspector-General of Intelligence and Security Cheryl Gwyn

Inspector-General of Intelligence and Security Cheryl Gwyn.

Inspector-General of Intelligence and Security Cheryl Gwyn.

Cheryl Gwyn knows she could be seduced by the spies. There is a risk, says the Inspector-General of Intelligence and Security, "that you become seduced by the secrets, that you feel important that you're part of that world."

One "surprisingly useful" aid against seduction is Twitter. Twitter, she says with a smile, can be brutal, and that's good.

Tweets help burst the bubble world where spy watchers risk starting to think like spies.

"I may have been under surveillance," she says. "I don't know and I haven't checked." - Cheryl Gwyn.

"I may have been under surveillance," she says. "I don't know and I haven't checked." - Cheryl Gwyn.

Gwyn is the official spy watchdog, and she bites. .

* National Portrait: Children's Commissioner Russell Wills
National Portrait: Jane Taylor
National Portrait: Sir Gordon Tietjens
National Portrait: Greg O'Connor
National Portrait: Gareth Morgan
National Portrait: Dame Susan Devoy

Her report on the "dirty politics" scandal involving blogger WhaleOil and the Prime Minister's office was humiliating for then-SIS director Warren Tucker.

She found the SIS had released incomplete, inaccurate and misleading information that led to misplaced criticism of Labour leader Phil Goff. Tucker "failed" to correct that impression.

The SIS had to say sorry.

Gwyn has begun a series of inquiries which ask dangerous questions about both the SIS and the other intelligence agency, the GCSB.

Gwyn herself is a controversial figure, a former Marxist activist who would once have been of great interest to the spies.

Ad Feedback

Gwyn is a modest character with a lawyer's precision and a sense of humour. The traditional face of intelligence is an ageing robot – spy-master, spy-watcher or politician - telling the public to mind its own business.

That's not Gwyn.

As a young law graduate and freezing worker she belonged to the Socialist Action League, a far-Left group closely watched by the SIS. Her comrade Keith Locke, later a Green MP, gained access to his file and found the spies had been following him for decades.

"I may have been under surveillance," she says. "I don't know and I haven't checked." As inspector-general, of course, she has access to all the SIS files.

But in those days, "there was much more of a sense that political dissent… was fair game for security surveillance and I think we have moved on from that in New Zealand."

Is she still a socialist?

There is an unusually long pause.

"I have I suppose what would be characterised as liberal views. I'm interested in social democracy, in fair play in a general sense, um, rather than fitting into a categorisation."

In an email later she says she wants to avoid labels "because focusing on my personal views becomes a distraction and risks compromising the ability of my office to do an effective job."

This sounds more bureaucratic than she usually is.

Gwyn was raised on a dairy farm near Whangarei and didn't get her Left-wing politics from her Social Credit parents. She became politically active at Auckland University and joined SAL, which encouraged its members to join the workers.

At Whakatu freezing works in Hawke's Bay she campaigned for women to become butchers on the chain, eventually winning the right to be "bored to death" processing eight lambs a minute.

She left and rose rapidly through the ranks of law and the government, ending up as deputy solicitor-general.

In that role she helped lead the government's action against Algerian Ahmed Zaoui, declared a security risk by the SIS and jailed. A long legal battle eventually led to his release.

Does she think that was the right outcome? "No comment."

Her inquiries could cause a lot more trouble for the spies.

Did the GCSB use its powers to help former Trade Minister Tim Groser in his (unsuccessful) bid to become head of the World Trade Organisation?

Were New Zealand spies involved with the CIA's torture of prisoners between September 2001 and January 2009?

Does the GCSB snoop on the communications of New Zealanders working or holidaying in the South Pacific?

This could be a breach of the law preventing the GCSB from bugging New Zealand citizens or permanent residents. It was the bureau's illegal bugging of permanent resident Kim Dotcom that lit a firestorm under the GCSB.

Is Gwyn making enemies of the spooks?

"I don't think so," she says, but with a beefed-up inspector's office "asking more questions, requiring more of them… that does put a strain on them. That's something that has from time to time created a tension in our relationship."

How about political enemies? If Gwyn causes too much trouble, Prime Minister John Key can just decline to renew her three-year contract when it ends next year (although Sir Michael Cullen's just-released review of the intelligence laws recommends the inspector be appointed by parliament not the PM).

"It's possible that I might not be reappointed - or that I might be offered a reappointment and decline," she says coolly.

The opposite risk, she notes, "is that an Inspector-General wanting reappointment could decline to or be reluctant to inquire into things that ought to be inquired into."

There's also a risk that the spy agencies could "deflect hard questions by saying, 'Well, you should be reassured we are acting lawfully because the Inspector-General has full access to everything we do.'

"[But] a small office such as mine can't possibly scrutinise every decision and every action of the SIS and the GCSB."

Of course "there are findings we reach that may not show the agencies in a good light and no-one's going to like that".

"No-one likes their auditor."

Gwyn would like the agencies to disclose what actual powers they have. Historically spy legislation is "pretty opaque".

Former CIA contractor Edward Snowden's disclosures, showing the agencies scoop up enormous quantities of digital information, had led to a "really important public debate about what powers do the agencies have".

SIS head Rebecca Kitteridge called Snowden a traitor. "I didn't say he was a traitor," says the Inspector-General.

Gwyn says there's a gap in the intelligence world. Snowden revealed how closely the international spy agencies work together, but their oversight agencies can't do this.

"How do I know that what the [Kiwi] intelligence agencies get from other jurisdictions is lawfully and properly sourced?" she asks.

"[And] how do we know what use other jurisdictions put our intelligence to?"

The ultimate solution, she says, would be to allow, say, the Inspector-General of the CIA and her to carry out a joint inquiry.

Watchdogs of the world, unite.

 - The Dominion Post


Ad Feedback
special offers

Video is 'the best evidence'

Police will  interview family violence victims on scene and on video in a similar set up to above.

Courtrooms may soon hear and see a family violence victim's statement rather than hear a written statement as part of a new trial.

Developing 'leadership potential'

Five South Auckland high schools joined up for a career advice workshop day in Papakura.

A life skills and career advice workshop day is helping students get ahead.

Bonobo, a cult attraction

FILE PHOTO - UK DJ Bonobo performed to a sold-out Auckland Town Hall on Thursday night with a live band.

REVIEW: A lot of strange things happen in town halls. This was one of them.

Learning football business at super-club

Steph Trowill, left, playing for Auckland in the ASB women's national football league, has been selected for a ...

Talented rep player Steph Trowill is off to football powerhouse FC Bayern Munich on a once-in-a-lifetime job experience.


The secret possum rescuers video

Dawn the baby possum is four months old and thriving.

They're one of our most hated pests. But there's an underground network trying to save them.

Our crumbling capital

A car was crushed by a slip on Palliser Rd, Roseneath,Wellington.

Wellington has become slip city, with about 400 reported this winter already, far more than usual. But why?

Police defend sneaky snaps

Police photograph protesters at the 350 Aotearoa climate change protest outside Parliament in June.

Cops delete their pics of Rex Tillerson protesters, but their actions have drawn criticism.

Log hits forestry worker

A forestry worker was in great pain after being struck by a log in rural Wairarapa. (File photo)

Injured worker struck by log winched out of forestry block and flown to hospital.


Nurse shuns diets, loses 46kg video

Lisa Press says at 55 she feels better than she has ever felt in her life.

She's gone from 114kg and breathless to 68kg and "the happiest and strongest" she's been.

300m Canty car roll

A man has crashed 300 metres down a bank in Canterbury. (File photo)

 A man has serious injuries after rolling his car over 300 metres down a bank on a windy Canterbury road.

Sex grooming arrest

A 51-year-old man has been arrested after meeting a young person following online sexual grooming.

A man has been arrested after meeting a young person following sexual grooming online.

A reinvented dream home

Bedrooms and living areas wrap around a fully enclosed, private, central courtyard.

A retired Cashmere couple loved their old home so much they had a new one built in its likeness.


Ferrari clocked at 210kmh

A Ferrari California T similar to the one Hui Zhang was driving when he was pulled over after speeding at 210kmh on the ...

Businessman roared on when cop spotted late model Ferrari California on expressway.

Rennie airs Chiefs' 'hate' video

Chiefs coach Dave Rennie will join Scotland club Glasgow Warriors after Super Rugby.

Chiefs and Crusaders have hardly had a cosy relationship since Dave Rennie took over.

Home burns to ground

Neighbours were the first to spot the flames surging from the 30m by 15m building around 11.30am on Thursday.

Residents were in a nearby town when they heard the fire siren.

Growth gobbles up rural roads

Roadworks on Hamilton's Kay Road are a blessing in that they slow drivers down, resident Sian Wilson says.

Residents ask council for footpaths and lower speed limits on what were once rural roads.


Asbestos removal continues

Ambulances at the ready at their Barrett Street Hospital base in New Plymouth circa 1981.

The demolition work at Barrett St Hospital has no set end date and will "cost us just over a million dollars".

Te reo? No problem

Most Taranaki secondary schools offer both compulsory and optional te reo Maori classes

Did you learn te reo Maori at high school?

The rich and the richer

mazon President, Chairman and CEO Jeff Bezos has been named the richest person in the world.

OPINION: Bill Gates and Jeff Bezos are obscenely wealthy but they've also made the world a more convenient place. Is that enough?

New owners for burger joint

New Prohibition owners Andy Le and Gabby Tran will be keeping the burger restaurant much the same.

A popular New Plymouth burger joint is under new ownership but the burgers won't change.


Wowed over WOW

Jennie Munro in her workshop with costumes that have been finalists in Wellington's international World Of Wearable Arts ...

A Palmerston North designer has made the finals of September's wearable arts show.

No intercepting emails

Horizons Regional Council chief executive Michael McCartney sees no reason to intercept emails, unlike Horowhenua ...

Council chief executives see no reason for intercepting emails - unlike Horowhenua council's boss.

Collar-dragging teacher cleared

Clive Stevens with his grandmother Maureen Stevens.

Teacher who dragged special needs student along floor did nothing wrong, investigation finds.

Back to school

Greens co-leader Metiria Turei stopped to talk with Tanika Jeffery, 14, who was learning speech writing in te reo, at ...

Greens co-leader Metiria Turei talks education at her old high school.


Cafe plans for historic building


The former Green Grocer Store on the corner of Grove St and Tasman St in The ...

After 20 years as a greengrocer, a heritage building in The Wood could be home to a new cafe.

Man critically injured

A man has critical injuries after a car hit a tree on the Coastal Highway.

Driver trapped in a car with serious injuries after a car hit a tree near Nelson.

Tool time returns to preschool video

Phoenix Brimble-Morrison uses tools donated by Mitre 10 Mega to Healthkids Preschool after its previous tools were stolen.

Hand drills, hammers and saws stolen from a Nelson preschool have been generously replaced.

Calls to defer Waimea dam plan

Lindsay McKenzie says the degree of uncertainty about the level of commitment to the dam project is of concern.

Lack of binding commitments by other potential funders of the dam frustrates TDC.


'Our niche is Marlborough'

Dog Point Vineyard co-owners and event sponsors Ivan Sutherland, left, and James Healy read up for the Marlborough Book ...

With intimate venues and stunning surrounds, the Marlborough Book Festival is a little different.

Power to the people

Marlborough Lines managing director Ken Forrest shows off the newest addition to the company fleet, an all-electric ...

A lines company is letting residents take a spin in its new electric car.

Bigger planes?

Sounds Air chief executive Andrew Crawford inside the cockpit of one of the company's 9-seat Pilatus PC-12s.

Demand for flights prompts Marlborough airline to investigate "quantum leap" to larger planes.

Blenheim bemoans unfair fares

Air New Zealand said it would not be reinstating direct flights to Christchurch from Marlborough Airport.

"It's almost like we've offended Air New Zealand somehow and they're making us pay." 

South Canterbury

Troops stage op in Waimate

Private  Nathan Hammond keeps a watchful eye out at a vehicle checkpoint in Waimate.

Waimate has been turned into a foreign nation infiltrated by insurgents- but only for a week.

Disease hits top farm

Aad and Wilma van Leeuwen's herd has been struck by the cow disease Mycoplasma bovis, and 150 of their cattle will have ...

Rich-list farming dynasty which owns world's "largest robotic farm" devastated by cow disease.

Region poised for milk boost

While the forecast price rise from Fonterra is good new for South Canterbury dairy farmers, regional Federated Farmers ...

Another $25m added to South Canterbury farmers' milk payout.

Oamaru firearm theft

Police are investigating a targeted firearms burglary in Oamaru.

Police are investigating a targeted firearms burglary in Oamaru.


Fire guts city house

Firemen at the scene of the gutted house, which was owned by former mayor Eve Poole, on Friday morning.

A fire has gutted the house of former mayor Eve Poole in Invercargill this morning.

Mass killing fantasies

Southland man Tony Gow has been sentenced in the High Court at Invercargill after admitting a raft of firearms offences, ...

A Southland man who fantasised about mass killings could not get the mental health help he needed, court told.

World champs beckon

New Zealand discus thrower Marshall Hall practices ahead of the 2017 IAAF World Championships.

Invercargill discus thrower 'committed and focused' ahead of world championships.

Ice causing crashes

10082016. News.Kavinda Herath. Southland Times/Stuff-Ice on the Winton Lorneville Highway

Police are warning drivers to take it slow and beware of ice on the roads.

Ad Feedback