Police won't lay charges but du Plessis-Allan still potentially under the gun


Heather du Plessis-Allan talking about the police decision not to charge her

A gun shop owner says he is "80 per cent certain" he will pursue a private criminal prosecution against Heather du Plessis-Allan, after police decided to drop gun charges against the journalist.

TV3's Story co-host has been let off the hook by police who, after an investigation, opted not to charge du Plessis-Allan for purchasing a gun in an episode of the show, ostensibly to expose loopholes in how guns can be bought online.

Police announced on Wednesday afternoon they instead issued formal warnings to three TV3/MediaWorks staff.


Segment from Story in response to the police search on Heather du Plessis-Allan's apartment.

On Wednesday night's episode of Story, du Plessis-Allan and co-host Duncan Garner said they were grateful to police.

When having a nose for a story lands a journalist in trouble
Opinion: Problems with gun laws go well beyond Heather du Plessis-Allan's stunt
Reporter's gun purchase 'like a terrorist activity'

"We want to say thank you to the police. We understand why they needed to investigate and we welcome the outcome of the investigation, of course," du Plessis-Allan said.

"But most importantly, we want to say thank you to the police for so quickly shutting down the flaw that we exposed. They did that within hours of us calling them in October, and that was the point of doing our story, so thank you."

Disappointed by police, Gun City owner David Tipple said he was looking to bring his own case against the television presenter.

Story co-host Heather du Plessis-Allan was investigated over the  mail-order purchase of firearms from Gun City for a ...

Story co-host Heather du Plessis-Allan was investigated over the mail-order purchase of firearms from Gun City for a story - but police have announced they will not pursue charges against her.

"It's really disappointing," Tipple said of the police decision. "I was hoping for something that would stop a ratings chaser doing this again.

"They got ratings. Legitimate gun owners need to be protected from media stunts like that," he said.

"At the end of that, police decide not to prosecute - it's sad."


Heather du Plessis-Allan refutes police claims about the gun purchase.

Tipple was working with "specialist firearms lawyer" Nicholas Taylor, he said.

Ad Feedback

"We haven't prepared a case but that's something we are looking at now. We are 80 per cent that we will."

Auckland city district commander Superintendent Richard Chambers said police took legal advice and a review of the case was undertaken by a senior officer.

Story co-host Heather du Plessis-Allan said buying a gun was so easy it was like finding money on the ground.

Story co-host Heather du Plessis-Allan said buying a gun was so easy it was like finding money on the ground.

"Police are satisfied that in this instance, there is no evidence that the acquisition of the firearm was for a sinister purpose, a factor which was taken into consideration in reaching this decision," Chambers said.

Changes were made to the way guns were bought and sold after the Story episode on October 21, 2015, which showed the purchase of a .22 rifle from Gun City.

At the time, du Plessis-Allan said the purchase was made in the public interest and showed the rules around mail ordering guns should be tightened.


Barry Soper and partner Heather du Plessis-Allan's home searched after gun purchase.

"What we've uncovered has exposed how worryingly easy it is to get a gun when you shouldn't be able to," she said.

Her journalist husband Barry Soper said the police decision was "clearly a great relief to Heather". 

"She's been living with this now for some months. I think police have taken a reasonable path here and they've done a good investigation and the best thing about their statement to me is that they say they don't stand on the rights of journalists to investigate matters such as this."

A complaint to police about du Plessis-Allan's action was made the night the story aired, alleging that false details had been used to fraudulently obtain a firearm.

The Wellington home du Plessis-Allan shares withSoper was raided in December as police investigated whether she should face charges. 

Making an unlicensed purchase of a firearm is an offence which carries a sentence of up to three months' imprisonment or a fine of up to $1000.

Another charge police stated early on they were looking at, obtaining by deception, carries penalties ranging from three months to seven years in jail, depending on the value of the item obtained.

Story broadcaster MediaWorks backed du Plessis-Allan's actions throughout the saga.

A MediaWorks spokesperson said in a statement the intention behind the story "was to put a spotlight on an issue rather than any one individual business".

"Story regrets any impact that may have inadvertently been caused to Mr Tipple as a result of the story."

Police said on Wednesday their investigation focussed on the actions of MediaWorks staff members in the creation of a forged document and the use of the document to obtain a firearm. 

They had become involved because MediaWorks staff had sought to surrender a firearm that had been illegally purchased from a licensed Auckland firearms dealer, Chambers said.

The story and subsequent investigation provoked national debate about gun laws and when journalistic privilege extends to breaking the law to expose issues in the public interest.

Chambers said police were aware of some commentary suggesting the story was in the public interest and should not have been investigated.  

He said the question of public interest did not determine whether police should proceed with a criminal investigation - instead such considerations were applied at the end of an investigation.

"Police view this case as no different to any other matter where criminal offending is disclosed. The circumstances of individual cases are routinely assessed to ensure that an appropriate investigation is initiated.

"We would also like to be clear that the freedom of journalists to report on any matter is fully accepted without question by police.

"The law, however, applies equally to everyone, including members of the media and police do not accept that it is appropriate to commit a criminal offence purely to publicise the ease with which something can be done."

* Comments on this article have now closed.


 - Stuff


Ad Feedback
special offers

Writing improves overnight

Northcross Intermediate principal Jonathan Treadway said marking writing was subjective.

A new method of teaching writing has seen achievement rise at one Auckland intermediate school

Blank round fired in court

Gustav Sanft is on trial for the manslaughter of his two-year-old daughter.

Gustav Sanft wailed in court as the sawn-off shotgun which killed his two-year-old daughter was fired as evidence.

Invitation to 'Hikoi for Hope'

Flowers and a photo of Haami Manahi were placed on the steps on which he was found during a recent memorial service for him.

Marchers seeking to raise awareness of homelessness in south Auckland.

Council: Wharf-jumping OK

Wharf-jumping - or dive-bombing - is a popular Kiwi summer past-time, but left 100s injured in the past year.

Popular pastime leaves Kiwis seriously injured or even dead - but Auckland Council says previous bans have failed.


Land slip in Lower Hutt

A land slip blocks a road in Lower Hutt.

Large rock blocking one lane of Normandale Rd, near State Highway 2.

Porirua rates shock 

The hilltop suburb of Camborne, overlooking Pauatahanui Inlet, has had the highest average rates increase in Porirua ...

Many residents have been flabbergasted by double-digit increases on their bills.

Matterhorn bar to close

Matterhorn restaurant has called Cuba St home for 54 years.

Wellington bar will have to shut so old Farmers building can be strengthened.

Motorcyclist in hospital after crash

The propped-up bike, which was initially lying on its side after colliding with a car.

A man is in a serious condition after accident in Masterton on Tuesday.


Abseilers on a mesh mission

Abseilers working at the top of a bluff at Ohau Point, with a view down to the Pacific Ocean.

Ohau Point is the only place roading contractors can't reach, but abseilers with a head for heights are working to change that.

Assault ends career

The relief teacher grabbed the boy's backpack, but the strap broke and the boy fell between closing doors.

Teacher grabbed the boy's backpack for a word, but the strap broke and the 12-year-old fell between closing doors.

Sheep to the rescue

Rabbits catch a ride out of floodwaters on a flock of sheep on a Taieri Plains farm.

A small colony of rabbits rode a flock of sheep to safety from the floodwaters in Otago.

New flood warning for Canterbury

The Heathcote River at Clarendon Tce, Opawa, on Monday.

Incoming heavy rain could bring more flooding to saturated Christchurch.


Storm set to roll in from Tasman

A brief respite from rain won't last long, with more forecast towards the end of the week.

Heavy rain and possible thunderstorms on horizon before cracker weekend.

Brother's final minutes

Anthony Hallmond died on Sunday night after what was believed to be an altercation on a Te Awamutu street.

Family arrived to find paramedics trying to revive Anthony Hallmond on a Te Awamutu street.

ACC U-turn on glasses

Hamilton man Glenn Hodges' eyesight was damaged following a crash at Hampton Downs Motorsport Park in December.

After an eight-month battle, motoring enthusiast Glenn Hodges has scored a win.

Outrage over skids on cemetery

Skid marks from vandals are all that remain at the Ngaruawahia Cemetery

The Ngaruawahia Cemetery has been targeted three times since June by drivers skidding on the grass.


Protecting Taranaki's historic bridge

A cyclist has absolutely no problems with the new width restrictions at the Bertrand Rd suspension bridge.

"It's not something that you need to race over anyway, just take your time."

Couple rescued 

The Taranaki Rescue Helicopter was able to get to the couple in time before the cloud came in. (File Photo)

If the helicopter hadn't reached the injured German couple, it would have meant an extra six hours stuck on Mt Taranaki.

Man attacked abuser

On Monday in the New Plymouth District Court, a man avoided convictions for burglary and assault, after a successful ...

After he was taken advantage of while drunk, a man sought retribution against his abuser.

Agency in liquidation

Liquidators were able to recover fees from a failed debt collection business.

High Court gives liquidator permission to recover fees but customers owed almost $200,000 will miss out.


Unlikely key to America's Cup win

Palmerston North's secret weapon in the America's Cup racing Ryan Thomas.

Engineer Ryan Thomas was programming machinery for factories when he was discovered by Team New Zealand.

House prices spike

Feilding's Smeaton family sold their home in just eight days. From back left: David holding Evie, 1, and Hayley holding ...

House sales prices in Feilding are at a 20-year high but that hasn't stopped them selling fast.

Hospital is often full

Palmerston North Hospital is often operating at capacity.

Additional staff and resources are needed to cope with high patient numbers.

When rural pests invade the city

A possum trapped.

UNDER THE RADAR: What to do if you live in suburbia and spot a stoat or possum.


New plan to save grandstand

The fight goes on to save the grandstand.

It all looked done and dusted for Takaka's grandstand. But could it get a last gasp reprieve?

Shooting 'justified'

The shooting of Ford Hurinui, by police during an alleged armed standoff in Motueka in 2015 was justified, an inquest ...

Nelson police officer who shot a wanted man cleared of any wrongdoing after inquest.

Time to fix 'scary' highway

The section of State Highway 6 from Okaramio to Havelock is the most dangerous stretch on the Blenheim to Nelson road, ...

The Nelson-Blenheim road has claimed 12 lives in 10 years. NZTA says it's unacceptable.

Judge's blunder boosts jail time

A woman convicted in the Nelson District Court earlier this year on drugs charges has had her sentence quashed and ...

Woman convicted of meth dealing will spend longer behind bars after a sentencing error.


Burglar caught by paper trail

The diamond ring was pawned at a Cash Converters in 2010. (File photo)

Seven years after burglar pawns diamond ring, police realise he gave Cash Converters his real name.

Picture perfect

Marlborough photographer Jessica Jones won four awards at the annual Iris Awards for professional photographers.

Professional photographer Jessica Jones impresses judges in one of New Zealand's most prestigious competitions.

Guerrilla knitters yarn-bomb town

West End retailers Stephanie Thompson and Jacqui Harnett are behind Kaikoura's yarn-bombing project.

Many a good yarn has come out of quake-hit Kaikoura over the past few months, and that doesn't seem to be wrapping up anytime soon.

Teen denies knifepoint robbery

Dylan Joseph Dredge admitted seven charges at the Blenheim District Court. (File photo)

He wasn't trying to rob the woman, he was just attacking her with a knife, court hears.

South Canterbury

Keeping culture alive

Ti Kouka Kindergarten children sang some of the waiata they will perform at the festival in front of Beaconsfield School ...

Hundreds of children are gearing up for events designed to help keep Maori culture alive in South Canterbury.

Disease reaches NZ

Cows on a South Canterbury farm have been found infected with the disease Mycoplasma bovis, the first time it has been ...

A highly contagious cattle disease has infected a South Canterbury dairy herd in the first recorded case in NZ.

New burner rule pitched

The warm glow of a good log fire: a residents' group says the resource consent process could keep older burners burning ...

Retrofitting old burners should be made official, group says.

Climate change pledge not signed

Fixing slippery tiles in Timaru's CBD and revamping the Theatre Royal should take priority over climate change, council ...

Council candidate says local body politicians should stay away from climate change.


ILT prank 'disappointing'

The "GET LIT" T-shirts are advertised on the Bunker Bar Facebook page.

Young people using the Invercargill Licensing Trust's logo to promote drinking is being called "disappointing".

Pedestrian hit by car

Emergency services were called to the intersection of Don and Kelvin streets, Invercargill, after an elderly pedestrian ...

An elderly man was struck by a car in central Invercargill.

Early start for Barclay

What exactly Barclay has been doing in his electorate has been in the spotlight as he continues to sit on a $170,000 ...

Disgraced MP arrives back at work with smile on his face.

Factory worker awarded $30,000

Image ID : 21188809
Image Type : Stock Photo
Copyright : Matthew Benoit
attorney, auction, authority, brown, ...

An Invercargill factory worker has successfully claimed over $30,000 from his former employers, after being unjustifiably dismissed.

Ad Feedback