Council puts secret listening device in couple's garden after dog complaint video

JOHN KIRK-ANDERSON/Stuff.co.nz

Dog owner Jenny Bennett, the subject of noise complaints, was shocked to discover a council bugging device in her garden.

A Christchurch couple were shocked to discover the city council was spying on their dogs using a listening device covertly placed in their garden.

The move has astounded Jenny and Tim Bennett and a human rights lawyer, who said the couple's right to privacy has been breached. 

The Christchurch City Council admitted on Tuesday it used the devices and normally sought permission before installing them.

Jenny Bennett with four-year-old schnauzer, Arthur, left, and six-month-old bitzer, Jeb.
JOHN KIRK-ANDERSON/FAIRFAX NZ

Jenny Bennett with four-year-old schnauzer, Arthur, left, and six-month-old bitzer, Jeb.

That did not happen in the Bennetts' case.

It has now recalled all listening devices until its animal management officers have received refresher training to ensure they followed correct procedure.

The council has 18 devices and has used them for the last five years.

The box Jenny Bennett found in her garden, planted without her knowledge by the city council, contained a recording device.
JOHN KIRK-ANDERSON/FAIRFAX NZ

The box Jenny Bennett found in her garden, planted without her knowledge by the city council, contained a recording device.

Jenny Bennett found the device under a shrub on her Avonside property last week.

"I thought it was a piece of rubbish and went to pick it up," she said.

What she found was a beige box with "Dog Control" written on it and a phone number for the head of the council's animal management team.

Bennett opened up the box and found a recording device with a microphone inside.

"I'm pretty shocked. We just didn't think they could do that."

She said she would have consented to it being there if the council had asked them.

The Bennetts, who have responsible dog owner status with the council, received a complaint about their four-year-old schnauzer, Arthur, barking about eight months ago. They said they had done everything dog control asked of them to prevent him barking.

They got him a mate to play with, Jeb, a six-month-old bitzer, and that seemed to work for a while, but about three weeks ago they received another visit from dog control. On the advice of the dog control officer they installed a gate, so the dogs could not see people walking by. 

Ad Feedback

Dog control visited again last week and the officer did not mention the device, but when she left the property Tim Bennett saw her go to the shrub and look for it. When she could not find it, she left the property without talking to him again.

Human rights lawyer Michael Bott said the council's action's were "outrageous" and breached the couple's right to privacy.

"It's the sort of thing you would expect by someone from the KGB or more lately the GCSB (Government Communications Security Bureau)."

He said the council's actions seemed "excessive, disproportionate and on the face of it unlawful".

"The dogs might be barking but in another sense the council seems to be barking itself."

He did not know of any statutory power the council would have to covertly placesurveillance equipment on someone's property. 

Council regulatory compliance head Tracey Weston said the listening devices were used once all other steps had been taken to determine excessive dog barking.

She said the device on the Bennett's property was the only one placed without permission.

"The council's practice is to only use these listening devices on a property with the permission of the owner."

The device was able to pick up voices, but animal management officers could not recall a situation where they had heard conversations on a recording. The council's policy was to disregard anything heard on the recording other than barking, Weston said. 

The council received 6282 complaints about barking dogs, fouling and bylaw breaches in the 2014/15 year, up from 5772 the previous year.

*Comments have now closed on this story*

 

 

 

 - Stuff

Comments

Ad Feedback
special offers
Auckland

Tensions high at Lit Quiz video

Kids Literature Quiz winners Wellesley College team members Jack Morrah, left, and Harry Hampton debate an answer.

Are you as well read as these 12 year olds? Take our quiz.

Steel win game of two halves

Southern Steel player Jhaniele Fowler-Reid with the ball against Northern Stars GK Sulu Fitzpatrick, left.

The Southern Steel juggernaut rolls on with an 82-58 win over the Northern Stars.

Woman with lupus faces deportation

A woman's suffering from lupus has had her application for judicial review declined.

The woman has had $192,000 of treatment in New Zealand and if she was to stay would cost more, court says.

Sunday crash snarls motorway

The crash involving two cars caused minor injuries to the occupants, Auckland police said.

It's not only the week days where Aucklanders have to put up with traffic.

Wellington

All you can carry

28052017 News photo Monique Ford / FAIRFAX NZ
The Food Show Wellington @ Westpac Stadium 
beverage vendor business ...

Some filled suitcases with goodies as roughly 14,000 whet their appetites at The Food Show.

Boardwalk to the bay?

An artist's impression of the proposed Shelly Bay development, depicting a cantilevered boardwalk.

A cantilevered walkway could feature in Shelly Bay development but ratepayers look set to foot some of the bill.

Quake stretched steel

36 Customhouse Quay had steel stretch during the Kaikoura quake.

Some tenants of 36 Customhouse Quay have relocated pending a closer look at an engineer's report.

Seven months to fix tip

T&T Landfills will take seven months to do remediation work to stop contaminating Owhiro Stream.

Do the work and worry about the paperwork later, Wellington council tells landfill operators.

Canterbury

Winter pollution crackdown

03062015 News Photo:Dean Kozanic/FairfaxNZ.  Smoke from a chimney in the Christchurch suburb of Waltham.

Smokebusters are back hunting down Christchurch's dirty chimneys.

Shop's ninth robbery

Sujan, left, and Chandana Burra after the last robbery at the Ferry Rd store, in April.

Woolston Discounter dairy owner says he may be forced to start closing the store earlier.

System 'promoting disability'

Barry Adams, 35, needs surgery for a prolapsed disc in his spine.

Barry Adams needs back surgery, but won't get it unless he cannot work or walk.

Winston's cathedral pledge video

New Zealand First leader Winston Peters is pledging to restore Christ Church Cathedral.

Splash more cash on quake-damaged cathedral, NZ First tells Govt.

Waikato

Earthworks start on city park

Earthworks are happening as construction gets under way on the Victoria on the River project.

Construction on a new Hamilton park by the river in the central city is well under way.

Tourists' $160m bill

District health boards spent about $160 million treating patients ineligible for public healthcare between 2013 and 2016.

Crook overseas visitors put the squeeze on health budgets. And a third of the bills are written off as bad debt.

Four Square jumping video

Thames Four Square owner Sukhpal Singh was a happy chap on Sunday morning.

Four Square owner Sukhpal Singh could not be happier after selling a $27 million Powerball ticket.

How to spend $27m in Thames

All the windows look out on the sea from this multi-million dollar home in Whangamata.

You could buy a lot with that cash. How about an air hangar, and a plane to put in it?

Taranaki

Steampunk races - whacky fun video

Andrew Butturini hat maker and goggle extraordinaire shows his fine hat ware.

Small rural town hosts Steampunk Taranaki Teapot Racing Championships.

E-coli in the water

E-coli has been discovered in Waverley's water supply.

Residents advised to boil all water used for drinking, brushing teeth or for food preparation until further notice.

Company helps workers kick habit

McKechnie employees take on the quit smoking challenge and win with the help of Tui Ora quit smoking coach George ...

Quit smoking programme a success for McKechnie employees.

Medicinal horseradish and garlic

Winter's here, and with it the dreaded lurgy.

OPINION: The trick to beating a cold - and worse.

Manawatu

Duo defy the odds

Vicki Walsh, who has been diagnosed with terminal brain cancer, finished the Manawatu Striders half marathon with the ...

She was told she wouldn't run again, but despite her cancer, she crossed the finish line.

A place of inclusion

Jonny Kan and Mitchell Pera concentrate on their artwork during a NOA session in the Te Manawa foyer.

Te Manawa's NOA is a group set apart by its inclusiveness. Creativity flourishes there.

Arms Fair a hit

Yvonne Clarke all kitted up at the annual Arms Fair 2017.

Guns, bullets, knives and antique gas masks were all shown off in Palmerston North.

A stroll down memory lane

Neil Oliver, host of Coast New Zealand.

TUNNEL VISION: From Patriot's Day to Jean Batten, history was presented on the screen.

Nelson

Waimea Combined stun Nelson College

Waimea Combined Schools celebrate their stunning UC Championship rugby win over Nelson College on Saturday.

Waimea Combined score a stunning upset win over Nelson College.

Right to protest

Lewis Staton aka Hone Ma Heke at the protest at the 1903 Square during Saturday's protest, having recently been released ...

Former prime minister calls on the council to withdraw a draft bylaw that would require a permit to protest.

Suburbs step up in second spell

Suburbs striker Ben Wright broke the deadlock in Sunday's 4-0 win over Universities.

Nelson Suburbs beat Universities by scoring four goals in the second half.

The waisted years

There's no real mystery to middle-aged spread.

OPINION: Middle-aged spread has turned up uninvited.

Marlborough

The church needs saving

The future of St Oswald's Anglican Church, near Wharanui, has yet to be decided.

The distinctive stonework church has been a lasting sight on the South Island's east coast. But it's in trouble.

Just doing my job, sir

Seizing overpriced wine was part of the job for Justices of the Peace 700 years ago. (File photo)

Seizing overpriced wine was once part of the job for Justices of the Peace.

Moutere reach semifinals

East Coast No 8 Billy Collins, right, is tackled by Marist loosie Ryan Dafel in Seddon on Saturday.

Moutere will be the only Marlborough-based side contesting the Tasman trophy semifinals.

Life-saving drug comes at a cost

Maddy Cooper took Herceptin after being diagnosed with breast cancer. She says the drug worked well for her.

It costs more than $100,000 to treat cancer sufferers, but is credited with saving many lives.

South Canterbury

Dredge on final visit to Timaru video

The Pelican Dredge has dredged the sands of the Timaru Harbour for the last time.

After almost 30 years the Pelican Suction Dredge has sailed out of Timaru for the last time.

'Deeply concerned'

Ara Institute of Canterbury's Washdyke training farm.

Polytechnic to meet with key stakeholders over "deep concerns".

Family Works under pressure

Counsellor Glenn Smith works with adults who have addiction problems. Smith thinks a three-month wait for family ...

Three-month wait list for Family Works' counselling service prompts DHB assistance.

'Out of character'

Timaru police are looking for 53-year-old Murray Wall, missing since Thursday.

Police urge public to report sightings of missing Timaru man Murray Wall.

Southland

Te Anau fights for maternity centre

A large crowd of supporters turned out in Te Anau on Saturday afternoon to march.

The Te Anau community bands together to fight for better rural maternity funding and to save the Lumsden Maternity Centre.

Budget 2017 

.

Clutha-Southland candidates discuss their high and lowlights of Budget 2017

Your chance to cast a vote

Cyclist Eddie Dawkins.

Your chance to have your say for the 2016/2017 Southland Sports Awards.

Busman's holiday gets beached video

Jeff Leeden got his 1964 VAL Bedford bus, Chubby Cheeks, stuck in the sand on Oreti Beach.

Aussies thought they'd take their housebus for a jaunt on the sands. This was nearly its final stop.

Ad Feedback