Auckland University hate-crimes professor leaves job after remark about Jews

The New Zealand Jewish Council wants University of Auckland to publicly distance itself from Professor Scott Poynting's ...
FAIRFAX NZ

The New Zealand Jewish Council wants University of Auckland to publicly distance itself from Professor Scott Poynting's remark.

A University of Auckland professor is to leave his job after an anti-Semitism row sparked by a letter to the Waikato Times.

Acclaimed hate crimes expert Professor Scott Poynting​ compared an Israeli company employing Palestinians to a German company employing Jews. The commentary rankled various groups, including the New Zealand Jewish Council and a fellow academic, who complained to the university, branding the professor's letter to the editor as anti-Semitic.

University Vice-Chancellor Stuart McCutcheon addressed the complainants in a letter, which he detailed investigations had been undertaken.

Lecturer Scott Poynting is leaving his job.
UNIVERSITY OF AUCKLAND

Lecturer Scott Poynting is leaving his job.

The institution had found Poynting not guilty of professional misconduct and it had been suggested to Poynting he should write a second letter to the editor of the Waikato Times clarifying he was not intending to make anti-Semitic remarks, McCutcheon said.

Poynting had refused to write a clarification, so McCutcheon apologised on behalf of the educational institution.

"... I do acknowledge that the way in which Scott Poynting expressed himself caused considerable distress to many members of the community. On behalf of the University of Auckland, I offer my own sincere apologies for that distress," McCutcheon wrote.

However, the final line of McCutcheon's letter saw the New Zealand Tertiary Education Union (TEU) wade into the debate. 

"Professor Poynting's employment with the University of Auckland concludes on 30 June 2016."

It was important to note Poynting was retiring in June, as had always been the case, TEU organiser Enzo Giordani said.

The university, however, would not confirm the manner of his departure. 

Ad Feedback

The union believes the final line made it seem as though Poynting had been pressured to leave the university as a result of the fracas, he said.

"The letter is misleadingly written. No action was taken against Scott Poynting," Giordani ​ said.

Although Giordani would not expand what action could be taken, a response to the university had been drafted.

When questioned whether Poynting was retiring, the university said it had no further comment on this matter, other than what was in the letter was accurate.

The New Zealand Jewish Council was not satisfied with McCutcheon's letter, either.

​In a joint statement, New Zealand Jewish Council chairman Geoff Levy and president Stephen Goodman said they were still seeking an apology from Poynting, and wanted the University of Auckland to publicly distance itself from the remarks.

"The hateful views expressed by Professor Poynting in his letter to the Waikato Times have no place in New Zealand, let alone within our academic institutions. While it is reassuring to know that Poynting will not be working at the University of Auckland much longer, the private nature of the apology from Professor McCutcheon does not promote transparency or proper accountability.

"The New Zealand Jewish Council would have expected the University of Auckland to publicly distance itself from the views of Professor Poynting, as other universities have done in similar situations, rather than privately apologise for any distress caused."

Poynting had written, "Thank you for explaining in your article how SodaStream generously provided work for Palestinians (Waikato Times, November 26). I understand that IG Farben provided work for large numbers of Jews. Not that I have anything against Germans, mind you."

He signed it Scott Poynting and did not make any mention of his professional capacity.

The letter was written as a private citizen and should not be considered as a work-related matter, nor should it come under the guise of academic freedom, Academic Freedom Aotearoa co-founder and TEU president Sandra Grey said.

Academic freedom is the belief that scholars should be able to criticise or comment on ideas or facts that may be controversial to political groups or authorities without being targeted for repression, job loss, or imprisonment.

"He wasn't speaking as an academic ... There was no misconduct, so the matter ends there. Just because people were made uncomfortable doesn't mean it is misconduct," Grey said.

She also believed more was being made of it than needed to be.

"Letters to the editor cause distress quite often. This is not, by any stretch of the imagination, new that someone has been upset by a letter to the editor."

Poynting could not be contacted. An out-of-office email stated he was on study and research leave from January 1 to June 30.

 

 

 - Stuff

Ad Feedback
special offers
Auckland

Death at King's College

A person died "suddenly" at south Auckland's Kings College on Saturday evening.

The man is understood to have suffered a medical event in the school's dining hall.

Why I've got to keep the faith

Young fans show their support.

OPINION: Just as the Vanilla Ice days of hip-hop gave way to better times and tunes, so the Warriors are bound to be on song eventually.

A place where bad things happen

Hayden Poulter pictured shortly after his arrest in 1996.

Vanishings and killings of beautiful women on K Rd cemented its seedy status - but was it a myth?

Award finalists announced

20052015 news supplied
Superette store in Newmarket, Auckland.

The Newmarket business award finalists are announced after categories receive the highest number of entries ever.

Wellington

Finding a home for stories

Brucey Downs, 27, is one of the many Kiwis affected by homelessness.

"Being homeless is a roller coaster that goes up and down, it's complicated that way."

Gran attacked in Porirua

Police are investigating a home invasion in Porirua. (File photo)

A grandmother was attacked in her own home.

Shot theory no joke

Jim Morton lost his left eye, on the right of this photo as you look at it, in a shooting incident. A Fish and Game ...

All hunters should start wearing safety glasses, says man who claims shot can ricochet off ducks.

A market for drugs

Associate Health Minister Peter Dunne's dramatically changed his views on drug policy over the past eight years.

Government minister says legalisation of cannabis is the 'logical way forward'.

Canterbury

Helping our kids cope with terror

Ruby Tindall,3, holds a rose as she takes part in a vigil for the victims of an attack on concert goers at Manchester ...

9/11, Chch, Manchester. In terror attacks and disasters, children are more resilient than we think.

Dad facing charges

Emily Saunders, 2, was swept away. Her body was never found.

His little girl was swept away when he tried to drive across a river. Almost a year on, he's charged over her death.

Water bottling consent $63 per year

Blair Colligan plans to bottle water alongside the Waimangaroa River in Buller.

There may soon be signs of life in a dormant, West Coast town: a water bottling plant.

Man killed in crash

The cause of the crash is not yet known.

A 26-year-old man is dead and another seriously injured after crashing into a house in Chch.

Waikato

Rotorua getaway, with baby video

The hot pools were a hit for young and old.

Jealous of babyless friends taking cheeky weekend getaways? Is it still possible to do a plus one retreat with an additional little one?

$27m Lotto winner

Only a handful of people have won $27 million or more.

The jackpot matches Lotto's most famous millionaire, Trevor Cooper. The ticket was sold in Thames.

Woman rescued from floods

The fire service rescued a woman from floods near Katikati on Saturday night.

The fire service has rescued a woman who drove into floodwaters near Katikati.

Suspicious blaze at car yard

The Fire Service received a call about the blaze at 3.10pm. Two crews from Waipa attended the scene, plus two trucks ...

At least one person has suffered burns in the Te Awamutu blaze.

Taranaki

Sale from beyond the grave

The Tariki Hall committee members want to sell the hall and give the proceeds to charity because the income doesn't meet ...

To sell this rural hall, permission was needed from the original trustees - who have long been dead.

Winery trial to come

In times past Tim Finn, Bic Runga, Dave Dobbyn  performed at the Sentry Hill Winery.

The liquidation saga of Sentry Hill Winery is heading to trial.

Goons make it two

Suburban Goons were winners of the best band in the Taranaki regional final of Smokefreerockquest for the second time ...

They won last year and now the Suburban Goons have done it again.

Sacrificing your self 

A longing for relationships is hard wired into our DNA.

OPINION: To be in community we need to sacrifice some measure of individual right and freedom.

Manawatu

Lifetime of work destroyed

John Bramley, with his dog Moose, lost 50 years worth of woodturning work and equipment in a shed fire at his Palmerston ...

It was a shed holding half a century of his life. It was gone in minutes.

Three car pile-up

Police were called to a minor car crash at George St on Saturday.

A person is in hospital after three-car pile-up at a busy Palmerston North street.

Shot theory no joke

Jim Morton lost his left eye, on the right of this photo as you look at it, in a shooting incident. A Fish and Game ...

All hunters should start wearing safety glasses, says man who claims shot can ricochet off ducks.

Fed up in Foxton

Flooding on Wednesday morning, at the Blue Bell motel on SH1 in Foxton.

Frustrated residents say Foxton's stormwater system can't cope, after repeated floods.

Nelson

Protesting for right to protest

Lewis Staton aka Hone Ma Heke at the protest at the 1903 Square during Saturday's protest, having recently been released ...

Former prime minister calls on the city council to with withdraw a draft bylaw that would require a permit to protest.

Fatal crash near Mot

Motueka Volunteer Fire Brigade volunteers divert traffic on the Coastal Highway after a fatal car crash.

A person has died and another is seriously injured in a two-vehicle crash near Motueka.

What now for Tom?

Thomas Lay is being evicted from  Bridge Street Backpackers and is looking for a new place to live.

Thomas Lay is worried. A Nelson backpackers - his home of seven years - has been forced to sell up.

'Cowboy poachers' under spotlight

Bryce Buckland saw six of the runaway deer at Marsden Valley Cemetery last month. Three men face prosecution after ...

Three men who shot at deer from a car in a residential area could face hefty charges.

Marlborough

The church needs saving

The future of St Oswald's Anglican Church, near Wharanui, has yet to be decided.

The distinctive stonework church has been a lasting sight on the South Island's east coast. But it's in trouble.

Just doing my job, sir

Seizing overpriced wine was part of the job for Justices of the Peace 700 years ago. (File photo)

Seizing overpriced wine was once part of the job for Justices of the Peace.

Moutere reach semifinals

East Coast No 8 Billy Collins, right, is tackled by Marist loosie Ryan Dafel in Seddon on Saturday.

Moutere will be the only Marlborough-based side contesting the Tasman trophy semifinals.

Life-saving drug comes at a cost

Maddy Cooper took Herceptin after being diagnosed with breast cancer. She says the drug worked well for her.

It costs more than $100,000 to treat cancer sufferers, but is credited with saving many lives.

South Canterbury

Rural location no barrier video

Kate Ivey juggles her expanding business with caring for her three children and helping run the family farm.

Mother of three says living in the 'middle of nowhere' is no barrier to business success.

'Out of character'

Timaru police are looking for 53-year-old Murray Wall, missing since Thursday.

The disappearance of a Timaru man is "completely out of character", police say.

Guilty of manslaughter

Timaru Court.

Kooly Managki Te Tomo found guilty of the manslaughter of Arran Gairns.

Accommodation boost

Finance Minister Steven Joyce announced his first Budget on Thursday.

The Government has recognised parts of SC have become more expensive.

Southland

Your chance to cast a vote

Cyclist Eddie Dawkins.

Your chance to have your say for the 2016/2017 Southland Sports Awards.

Busman's holiday gets beached video

Jeff Leeden got his 1964 VAL Bedford bus, Chubby Cheeks, stuck in the sand on Oreti Beach.

Aussies thought they'd take their housebus for a jaunt on the sands. This was nearly its final stop.

Health professionals unhappy

Association of Salaried Medical Specialists Ian Powell.

A medical union has accused the Government of "continued neglect" with its annual health budget announcement on Thursday.

Council's 'Gypsy Day' u-turn

Cows are moved, near Rakaia.

It's deemed too offensive so a new name for sharemilkers moving cows to farms is needed.

Ad Feedback