Peeping incidents among drone-related complaints made to Civil Aviation Authority

Drones have been blamed for a number of peeping incidents, information from Civil Aviation shows.
123RF

Drones have been blamed for a number of peeping incidents, information from Civil Aviation shows.

Tech-savvy peeping Toms are taking to the skies to peer into people's homes using drones.

Peeping and peering incidents involving drones figure numerous times in information on drone-related incidents released by the Civil Aviation Authority under the Official Information Act 

The incidents feature the machines, which can carry cameras, hovering outside homes at night, and sometimes targeting several neighbouring properties in succession. 

Wellington barrister Stephen Iorns says legislation has some catching up to be effective in holding drone pilots to account.

Wellington barrister Stephen Iorns says legislation has some catching up to be effective in holding drone pilots to account.

But a legal expert is warning that victims have very few means of defending their privacy from prying drones, especially if they cannot identify its pilot.

READ MORE:
How much control do we have over drones?
Pilots' union upset with drone regulations
Drone operators may need flying permit
Drone wars take of in New Zealand 

The report comes as the high-flying technology drops in price, with video-ready drones becoming much cheaper.

In a typical incident from the CAA report, a Christchurch resident reported a drone flying close to their window one night last May.

"Complainant closed curtains and soon afterwards the [drone] moved to the neighbouring property," the file notes.

A Petone, Lower Hutt resident complained in April this year about a drone appearing at night over homes and "hovering around windows of houses at close proximity".

Another, in Auckland in December, also had a drone over their property.

Ad Feedback

"I noticed it then go and hover over at least three of our neighbours' properties."

CAA has released rules for drones, acknowledging: "Aviation regulators around the world are grappling with how to integrate [drones] into existing aviation safety systems".

Those rules include provisions not to fly at night, to get consent from anyone you want to fly above, and to get permission before flying over properties.

But Wellington barrister Stephen Iorns said there were currently very few criminal charges that could be laid if someone broke the authority's rules. 

"It's only a criminal offence under the Crimes Act if someone is naked or engaged in intimate behaviour," he said.

"There might be a civil breach, but if they are just hovering around someone's house, current law falls short.

"Legislation hasn't caught up with the technology, both in drones and other mediums of technology." 

Peeping and peering into a dwelling at night without reasonable excuse was an offence under current law, but Iorns said it would be up to the courts to decide whether this stretched to cameras.

It left people who had reasonable expectations of privacy with very little power, Iorns said.

"The Privacy Commissioner can't investigate without [someone] identifying who the party who did the filming is." 

And the Privacy Commission did not have the power to issue fines.

Instead, victims would have to go through the Human Rights Tribunal for that, but only once their complaint had been investigated by the Office of the Privacy Commissioner.

You can't shoot it out of the sky either, because then you'd be liable for wilful property damage, Iorns said.

Model Flying New Zealand secretary Des Richards said some of the reported incidents could have innocent explanations, such as people filming a sunset but accidentally hovering outside a window.

Members of the flying club were well-trained in where to fly, but many non-members simply picked up a "toy version" and flew it with no knowledge of the rules.

"We have no way of getting to them."

A drone, complete with video camera, could be picked up for about $800, Richards said.

To date the Privacy Commissioner has completed just one drone-related investigation. 

In that case a Sky TV operator was filming a cricket match but flew a drone within 10m of a man's apartment.

The man gave the fingers to the drone and complained it "may have captured highly sensitive information in an unreasonably intrusive manner".

Sky TV said the drone had flown past the apartment but it had not recorded or broadcast images of the complainant, or the inside of his property.

No privacy breach was found.

 - Stuff

Comments

Ad Feedback
special offers
Auckland

Waiheke restauranters say immigrant workers vital

Hon Nikki Kaye MP met with Waiheke Oyster Inn co-owner Johnathan Rutherfurd-Best (pictured) and others to discuss ...

Waiheke restaurant owners are warning they're 'in crisis' because of immigration rule changes.

Historic gun to be fired

The 6 inch Mark VII on Devonport's North Head historic reserve will be fired for the third time on Monday.

A "disappearing" cannon more than 100 years old will be fired in Auckland.

Punching evidence 'unreliable'

Corey Webster in his playing days for the New Zealand Breakers.

The Judge in the trial of Corey Webster has ruled evidence that he punched a bystander to a bar fight last year as unreliable.

EV drivers get VIP treatment

Electric vehicles could get priority access to the motorway under proposed bylaw.

Electric vehicles could get priority access to the motorway under a new bylaw.

Wellington

The red fans are here

Johnsonville Rugby Football Club's Mike Segetin (centre) shows British and Irish Lions' supporters the meaning of Kiwi ...

Johnsonville is being invaded by red shirts, much to the delight of locals.

Sporting hub for Hutt

Mayor Ray Wallace turns the ceremonial sod to begin stage two of Fraser Park Sportsville.

$12m facelift for park will make it one of the region's premier sporting facilities.

Sexton, Farrell both to start

Johnny Sexton will start the second test at No 10 for the Lions.

Star midfielder Ben Te'o moves to the bench as the Lions pick two playmakers to start second test.

Burglary accused on the run

Police are seeking Eugene Te Amo in relation to burglary offences.

Te Amo is believed to be in the Kapiti Coast/Wellington area.

Canterbury

Secret meeting to save Cathedral

The cathedral has been sitting derelict in the city centre for over six years.

Councillors will meet on Friday to consider giving money to restoring Christ Church Cathedral.

KiwiRail apologises

KiwiRail has apologised to 50 Christchurch residents after trying to force them to sign a "licence to occupy" land ...

KiwiRail says sorry to residents for mishandling a Heathcote Valley rail corridor agreement.

Bus trial for hospital staff

Afternoon and night shift staff get priority use of an Antigua St car park building as the Canterbury DHB scrambles to ...

A new Christchurch Hospital park-and-ride service will help - just not night shift nurses. 

Peter Thiel here just 12 days

Peter Thiel's application form for New Zealand citizenship.

Controversial US billionaire in NZ for 12 days as a resident before becoming a citizen.

Waikato

Flock of ducks befriend captain

They flock in numbers, trying to be the first to get the bread.

A flock of ducks joins this Taupo cruise captain everyday as he motors around the lake.

Man chases child in fog

Cambridge East School principal Hamish Fenemor said the man took advantage of the thick fog in the area to try and chase ...

Driver follows pupil to school before jumping out and chasing child through thick fog just a block from school.

City's River Plan gets going

The Hamilton River Plan is expected to take about 30 years to roll out.

Three River Plan projects have been given the go ahead for Hamilton.

Calves found suckling on killed cow

"They just couldn't understand why she wasn't standing up," farmer Noel Hair said (file photo).

Farmer found calves hungry for milk and a bullet in the eye of their mother.

Taranaki

Tramper found dead

Officials were waiting for daylight to break on Mt Taranaki before airlifting the man's body off.

Police searching for a tramper walking to the summit of Mt Taranaki have found a body.

Woman's cancer shock

Nicole Huston and Emma Wilson were enjoying a girls' trip to Hawaii at this time last year.

She went to the doctor expecting to be given iron pills but was diagnosed with leukaemia.

Injure cyclist, buy her a $3k bike

A female cyclist was taken to hospital after she was knocked off her bike by a motorist. (File Photo).

To make amends this motorist shelled out $3400 to buy a new bike for the female cyclist he knocked over and injured.

Pub punches plague man

Reginald Pearce was sentenced in the New Plymouth District Court on Thursday after a violent assault in a city bar last ...

Victim says he's a different person after being concussed during a violent pub attack.

Manawatu

Physicality key for Laumape video

Ngani Laumape will become All Black No 1160 if he makes it on the field on Saturday.

Moving from the loose forwards to midfield started the rise of Ngani Laumape in rugby.

700 new jobs needed

Bidfoods assistant general manager Adam Rapson shows work experience pupils Reece Hodgson, right, and Josh Alexander the ...

Quick action is needed to make sure Manawatu is ready for logistics boom, CEDA says.

Missing the point

The One Plan is supposed to preserve the Manawatu River for future generations.

OPINION: Horizons was asleep at the wheel and ignoring its One Plan obligations.

Home is where the words are

Thom Conroy is the editor of Home: New Writing.

What home means to some of New Zealand's best writers is housed in a new book.

Nelson

Donald Trump comes to Nelson

Wellington actor Alexander Sparrow impersonates Donald Trump in his DJ Trump shows.

One of the world's top Trump impersonators is bringing his show to Nelson.

Socks, sex and school

Nelson College for Girls student Madi Fulton Buckle wearing her over-the-knee socks.

A Nelson school's ban on 'creepy porn looking' socks has sparked a student documentary.

Driver injured after failed overtake

Emergency services attend the scene of a crash involving a truck and a 4WD near the Whangamoa Saddle on Wednesday night

A  truck fire which led to a separate crash near Havelock left a driver with critical injuries.

'Good-guy' farmer's free motocross

Travis Langford hosts motocross for kids every Wednesday after school on his track.

A farmer has turned a paddock into a free motocross "playground" for local kids.

Marlborough

SH6 reopens after truck fire

Emergency services had to cut a driver from his car after and attempt to overtake vehicles banked up from the previous ...

One lane of the road between Havelock and Nelson has reopened following a truck fire on Wednesday evening

Clean pee pays off

Charles Wiremu Maru used codenames such as "garlic bread" to offer drugs to people through text messages. (File photo)

Man who used codenames including "garlic bread" to sell cannabis and meth is now off drugs.

Maori school

Omaka Marae general manager Kiley Nepia, back left, with Renwick School principal Simon Heath, back right, and some of ...

"Where succeeding as Maori and being Maori is not an extra curriculum activity, but is at the centre and heart of everything we do."

The little weed threatening NZ

Seddon farmer Tim Struthers discusses the spraying programme he has introduced to fight Chilean Needle Grass on his property.

It used to be a farmers' problem, but it could threaten the country's other 'cash cow': tourism.

South Canterbury

Young footballer US bound

Timaru Hearts team member Michael Henderson, 19, has been selected for the men's football programme at the United States ...

Timaru footballer busy raising funds after being selected to study at Californian college.

Low levels lift prices video

An aerial view showing Tekapo B power Station at Lake Pukaki. The lake level is currently at 524 metres above sea level, ...

'Spot' power prices could continue to rise as South Island hydro lakes drop.

Cyclists scaring pedestrians video

Geraldine Environmental Trust members Graeme Wills, Peter McCabe and Dave Attwood have taken issue with cyclists ...

Cyclists hurtling down track "like a bat out of hell" scare elderly walkers, group says.

Car rolls off railway

Police abandoned a pursuit after the vehicle entered the railway tracks at the junction of Seadown and Meadows Rd, near ...

Pursuit ends with fleeing  driver crashing car off railway near Timaru.

Southland

Steel dominate Premiership final

Ginna Crampton, Wendy Frew (centre) and Shannon Francois celebrate Premiership success.

 The Southern Steel complete the perfect season with a big win over the Central Pulse.

Pet goat killed

22022017 Photo: ROSS GIBLIN\Fairfax
Generic pic: emergency services, police, police car, ambulance, Wellington Free ...

Police are investigating reports of illegal hunting after a pet goat was killed.

Milford tourist boom's problems

The stunning Mitre Peak rising 1.6km vertically out of Milford Sound.

Visitor numbers to Milford Sound are expected to reach 875,000 in 2017 and exceed one million by 2019.

Southland Arts Festival runs at loss

Southland Festival of the Arts organiser Angela Newell ahead of the 2017 festival held in April and May.

The month-long Southland Arts Festival ran at an $8000 loss this year and changes may be afoot.

Ad Feedback