Peeping incidents among drone-related complaints made to Civil Aviation Authority

Drones have been blamed for a number of peeping incidents, information from Civil Aviation shows.
123RF

Drones have been blamed for a number of peeping incidents, information from Civil Aviation shows.

Tech-savvy peeping Toms are taking to the skies to peer into people's homes using drones.

Peeping and peering incidents involving drones figure numerous times in information on drone-related incidents released by the Civil Aviation Authority under the Official Information Act 

The incidents feature the machines, which can carry cameras, hovering outside homes at night, and sometimes targeting several neighbouring properties in succession. 

Wellington barrister Stephen Iorns says legislation has some catching up to be effective in holding drone pilots to account.

Wellington barrister Stephen Iorns says legislation has some catching up to be effective in holding drone pilots to account.

But a legal expert is warning that victims have very few means of defending their privacy from prying drones, especially if they cannot identify its pilot.

READ MORE:
How much control do we have over drones?
Pilots' union upset with drone regulations
Drone operators may need flying permit
Drone wars take of in New Zealand 

The report comes as the high-flying technology drops in price, with video-ready drones becoming much cheaper.

In a typical incident from the CAA report, a Christchurch resident reported a drone flying close to their window one night last May.

"Complainant closed curtains and soon afterwards the [drone] moved to the neighbouring property," the file notes.

A Petone, Lower Hutt resident complained in April this year about a drone appearing at night over homes and "hovering around windows of houses at close proximity".

Another, in Auckland in December, also had a drone over their property.

Ad Feedback

"I noticed it then go and hover over at least three of our neighbours' properties."

CAA has released rules for drones, acknowledging: "Aviation regulators around the world are grappling with how to integrate [drones] into existing aviation safety systems".

Those rules include provisions not to fly at night, to get consent from anyone you want to fly above, and to get permission before flying over properties.

But Wellington barrister Stephen Iorns said there were currently very few criminal charges that could be laid if someone broke the authority's rules. 

"It's only a criminal offence under the Crimes Act if someone is naked or engaged in intimate behaviour," he said.

"There might be a civil breach, but if they are just hovering around someone's house, current law falls short.

"Legislation hasn't caught up with the technology, both in drones and other mediums of technology." 

Peeping and peering into a dwelling at night without reasonable excuse was an offence under current law, but Iorns said it would be up to the courts to decide whether this stretched to cameras.

It left people who had reasonable expectations of privacy with very little power, Iorns said.

"The Privacy Commissioner can't investigate without [someone] identifying who the party who did the filming is." 

And the Privacy Commission did not have the power to issue fines.

Instead, victims would have to go through the Human Rights Tribunal for that, but only once their complaint had been investigated by the Office of the Privacy Commissioner.

You can't shoot it out of the sky either, because then you'd be liable for wilful property damage, Iorns said.

Model Flying New Zealand secretary Des Richards said some of the reported incidents could have innocent explanations, such as people filming a sunset but accidentally hovering outside a window.

Members of the flying club were well-trained in where to fly, but many non-members simply picked up a "toy version" and flew it with no knowledge of the rules.

"We have no way of getting to them."

A drone, complete with video camera, could be picked up for about $800, Richards said.

To date the Privacy Commissioner has completed just one drone-related investigation. 

In that case a Sky TV operator was filming a cricket match but flew a drone within 10m of a man's apartment.

The man gave the fingers to the drone and complained it "may have captured highly sensitive information in an unreasonably intrusive manner".

Sky TV said the drone had flown past the apartment but it had not recorded or broadcast images of the complainant, or the inside of his property.

No privacy breach was found.

 - Stuff

Comments

Ad Feedback
special offers
Auckland

Crayfish-stealing gangs?

Gang members are stealing crayfish and using the proceeds to fund criminal activity, a Northland politician says.

Politician says poachers are using crayfish to fund the P trade. No evidence, say authorities.

Mum, son missing five days

Haamiora is described as bright and cheeky.

"We just want to make sure that bubba's OK," distraught family says.

School visit to promote agricultural careers

Two former ACG Strathallan students, Lisa Kendall and Annaliese Gottlier, visited the college  this month.

Two former ACG Strathallan students visited the college to inspire students looking to work in agribusiness.

Ngaro aims to be active for Te Atatu

Alfred Ngaro is running for the second time in the Te Atatu electorate, for the National Party.

Te Atatu electorate battle heats up as Alfred Ngaro eyes win.

Wellington

Two survive chopper crash video

The downed helicopter was on a training flight. The two people on board were not seriously injured.

Two people escaped after a helicopter crashed onto a farm  in the Horowhenua.

Killer in the dog box video

Marion Sturm with 6-year-old Paige, who has been classified as menacing and must wear a muzzle when out in public.

A chicken-killing jack russell has had her "menacing" status confirmed.

Council backs rental WoF

Wellington Mayor Justin Lester, with Philippa Howden-Chapman, Professor of Public Health at the University of Otago, and ...

Wellington rental WoF gets councillors' tick - but will it make a difference?

Synthetic drugs seized by police

A Napier man and woman face drug charges after police seized synthetic cannabis. (File photo)

Pair face supply charges after Napier police find synthetic cannabis.

Canterbury

English pulls crowds in Chch

Prime Minister Bill English during his tour of Misco Joinery in Kaiapoi on Thursday.

OPINION: National leader Bill English relishes some intensive political questioning on the Canterbury hustings.

House destroyed in fire

A house fire gutted a home on the corner of Tika St and Centennial Ave on Thursday.

A house in Riccarton, Christchurch, has been fully gutted by flames.

$40m complex in CBD

An artist's impression of the new Sudima Hotel complex, including offices and shops, to be built on the corner of ...

Work starts on complex that will include offices, shops, restaurants and a five-star hotel.

SH1 reopening set for December 15

North Canterbury Transport Infrastructure Recovery alliance crews opened up a working track around Ohau Point last week.

MP lets slip planned reopening day for the quake-hit State Highway 1 north of Kaikoura.

Waikato

Fatal ute plunge rescuers thanked

The Nissan Navara ute is pulled from the river after being floated by police divers.

Rescuers prevented second life being lost by diving into freezing, turbulent Waikato River after ute plunged and sunk.

Meads funeral details

All Black legend Sir Colin Meads died on Sunday after a year-long battle with pancreatic cancer. He was 81.

If you are attending Sir Colin Meads' funeral on Monday, plan to arrive early.

Who pays for theatre?

An artist's impression of what the new Waikato regional theatre could look like from the river. Full designs are still ...

Some donors have already come forward to chip in for Waikato's new theatre

110kmh limit coming

A 110kmh speed limit on some roads will be in place by the end of the year. Digitally altered photograph.

Speed limits on Waikato expressway will be raised to 110kmh by the end of the year, Government says.

Taranaki

Big changes on bench for Taranaki

All Blacks wing Waisake Naholo will come off the bench against Wellington for Taranaki.

Taranaki team bolstered for trip to the capital.

Dogs kept captive

A man will be sentenced in the New Plymouth District Court next month after he pleaded guilty to charges related to ...

After a public tip-off, an animal welfare inspector helped to free two dogs who were kept as prisoners in a house.

Saw waved in assault

Alcohol was a factor in the assault of a Taranaki woman, whose partner held a saw to her throat during an argument. ...

An alcohol fuelled argument over the state of a couple's finances boiled over into violence.

A meticulous businessman

New Plymouth businessman Vivian Newton King with his wife, Pat.

Vivian King also enjoyed rose gardening and catching up with friends at the local RSA.

Manawatu

Pilots escape chopper crash video

The downed helicopter was on a training flight. The two people on board were not seriously injured.

An instructor and a trainee pilot were able to walk away from crash near Levin.

Reports released

Horowhenua mayor Michael Feyen released two self-funded council building inspection reports.

Horowhenua's mayor's publicly releases self-funded reports on council building.

Meth crackdown

A man has appeared in Palmerston North District Court charged with manufacturing methamphetamine. He was arrested on ...

Another drugs bust in Palmerston North sees a man arrested for making P.

More funding promised

Wairarapa candidates, from left, Ron Mark, Alastair Scott, John Hart and Kieran McAnulty.

Wairarapa candidates say more education funding needed. National MP not so sure.

Nelson

Rough sleeping ban may be tested

Lawyer Steven Zindel speaks at the protest at the 1903 Square opposing the Nelson City Council's draft City Amenity Bylaw.

A Nelson lawyer expects council's controversial bylaw to be challenged in the courts.

Pooch poo pollution

Littered dog waste is not just a nuisance but also an environmental hazard.

Lazy owners not picking up dog poo isn't just an eyesore, it's affecting Nelson's waterways.

Therapy an adventure

Richard Wilkins, pictured here at Whenua Iti, is organising the first adventure therapy course in Nelson.

Can "adventure therapy", immersive courses in the great outdoors, help troubled youth?

Candidates front up

Forum chairwoman Judene Edgar, right, introduces the candidates, from left, Nick Smith, Sue Sara, Rachel Boyack, Richard ...

Election hopeful answer questions from Nelson's volunteer and community sector.

Marlborough

Teen's three-week meter raid

Dozens of parking meters in Blenheim were vandalised in May. (File photo)

He pried open the parking meters with a screwdriver, returning several times at night as they filled up again.

SH1 opening let slip

North Canterbury Transport Infrastructure Recovery alliance crews opened up a working track around Ohau Point last week.

Road trip to Kaikoura: December 15. Mark it in your calendar. Maybe in pencil for now.

Victims' stories

Lara Glover, 16, died and four others were injured in the car crash on February 19.

The crash killed one but affected many, and some of those affected want to speak at the driver's sentencing.

Vineyards: Investment with 'sex appeal'

Misty Cove founder Andrew Bailey is selling a vineyard the company co-owns with Moa founder Josh Scott in Onamalutu, ...

It's like any commercial investment really, except you get to say you own a vineyard.

South Canterbury

Timaru's new pilot boat on its way

The Kiva, PrimePort Timaru's new pilot vessel, before it left Australia for South Canterbury. The boat is due in Timaru ...

The Kiwa is en route to Timaru.

District is booming

Wendy Smith  chief executive for the South Canterbury Chamber of Commerce says business confidence is holding in Timaru.

Timaru District's growth outstrips Canterbury average.

Regional roads miss out on funding

Provincial councils miss out on a large portion of national roading funds, making it hard for councils to be able to ...

District councils miss out on a large portion of roading funds, Mackenzie District Mayor Graham Smith says.

Poison bliss balls for wallabies

Environment Canterbury is dosing bliss balls with cyanide and giving them to wallabies in a bid to reduce the population.

A cafe staple will be used to kill a rampant pest.

Otago

Adaptive skier aims for Paralympics video

American adaptive skier Patrick Halgren, 25, lost his leg in a motorcycle crash three years ago.

Alpine adaptive ski racer Patrick Halgren is training to get into the Paralympics in memory of his twin brother.

Assault claims 'unfounded'

A police investigation into the alleged sexual assault of a Queenstown woman has ended.

Reports a woman was sexually violated by a stranger in her Queenstown home were unfounded, police say.

Staff save elderly man from scammers

Scammers tried to get the man to purchase hundreds of dollars worth of supermarket vouchers.

Overseas scammers who tried to dupe an elderly Alexandra man out of his savings underestimated the power of the community.

A masters thesis in One Direction

One Direction scholar Millie Lovelock, of Dunedin.

Of One Direction's 40 million fans, only one has written a thesis on them. Meet Dunedin's Millie Lovelock.

Southland

Celebrate being a Southlander

Sport Southland staff members, from left, Suzie Harrington, Laura Faherty, Nathan Burdon, Gareth Scott, Georgia Timpany, ...

Today is the day to embrace being a Southlander, put your purple shirt on and get behind the Ronald McDonald House and the Southland Stags.

Stags set to play

Southland Stags players unite at the end of the Stags captain's run at Rugby Park on Wednesday before the game against ...

Can Rugby Park's Stags faithful provide the kick-start they need for their 2017 campaign?

Attacked for looking like a boy

The mother took her daughter to the police station after the attack and when they came out the girls were waiting ...

Video of Central Otago schoolgirl being punched and taunted for looking like a boy posted online.

Dog handler's 'horrible' moment

Invercargill police dog handler Constable Adam Thomas and his police dog Zero.

When police dog handler Constable Adam Thomas saw his dog Zero being crushed by a car, he though he was watching his best mate die.

Ad Feedback