Dame Lowell would have preferred to work alone as head of sex abuse inquiry: Committee

Dame Lowell Goddard was appointed in early 2015 and resigned in August.
BEN PRUCHNICE

Dame Lowell Goddard was appointed in early 2015 and resigned in August.

The Kiwi judge who was the head of the United Kingdom's controversial inquiry into historical sex abuse cases would have preferred to work alone, British MPs have been told.

Dame Lowell Goddard's time as the chair of the Independent Inquiry into Child Sex Abuse and the circumstances of her resignation were discussed at a home affairs select committee hearing in London on Tuesday.

The new chair of the inquiry, Professor Alexis Jay, denied the inquiry was "an unhappy ship".

Independent Inquiry into Child Sex Abuse panel member Ivor Frank, new chair Professor Alexis Jay, and panellist Drusilla ...
Parliamentlive.tv

Independent Inquiry into Child Sex Abuse panel member Ivor Frank, new chair Professor Alexis Jay, and panellist Drusilla Sharpling at the home affairs select committee.

Goddard has strenuously denied allegations of using derogatory language and mistreating staff while she was the head of the wide-ranging inquiry, described as "mired in chaos" by one British opposition MP.

READ MORE:
Dame Lowell denies using racist language
Dame Lowell's statement on press claims
Judge quits as head of UK inquiry
Justice Goddard to head UK abuse inquiry

Several allegations were made in The Times of London in a series of articles, which Goddard said were "totally false".

UK home secretary Amber Rudd, who was asked urgent questions in the House of Commons on Monday about the abuse inquiry.
Dan Kitwood

UK home secretary Amber Rudd, who was asked urgent questions in the House of Commons on Monday about the abuse inquiry.

Jay, a former member of the inquiry advisory panel, told MPs that every effort was made to make the arrangements work.

She was asked to describe the relationship with the New Zealander and said it was clear from the beginning that Goddard would have preferred to work on her own without the assistance of the panel set up to work with the head of the inquiry.

In reply to questions from the select committee, she said:

The new chair of the inquiry, Professor Alexis Jay.
Parliamentlive.tv

The new chair of the inquiry, Professor Alexis Jay.

"We were not redundant and there are specific legal requirements that the chair and panel make certain decisions but many are for the chair on her own.

Ad Feedback

"The panel felt like they were kept at a distance from a lot of the activities of the inquiry."

Goddard's tenure as the head of the inquiry into cases of institutional abuse in hospital, schools, and care homes has been the subject of intense scrutiny. She was the third inquiry chair to resign.

The Times published articles containing claims of mistreating staff and using derogatory language, claims Dame Lowell denies.

The Times published articles containing claims of mistreating staff and using derogatory language, claims Dame Lowell denies.

The inquiry's most senior lawyer also resigned recently.

Inquiry panel member Ivor Frank, asked whether Goddard was a "nightmare to work with", said he would prefer not to use such language and there were different working methods involved.

Frank said the inquiry sought assistance in an effort to establish a better rapport between the panel and Goddard.

"I would prefer to say there were challenges.

"There were times when things were perfectly amicable and perfectly professional, there were other times when it was less the case.

"The chair was not always present within the UK throughout that entire 16 month period."

Panellist Drusilla Sharpling told MPs she reported concerns about the inquiry to the Home Office in April and no permission was given to spread the concerns, which were not referred to as a complaint, or take any action.

Responding to a question about The Times' allegation of mistreating staff - which Goddard denies - she said it was entirely inappropriate to comment.

"I am not going to engage in the sort of character issues that have been published across the press...The panel had concerns about the qualities of leadership that were being evidenced throughout the course of the inquiry.

"I did not give anyone permission to spread those concerns among anybody else. I did not require any action to be taken."

Goddard did not give evidence to the committee directly but in a letter to the select committee dated Monday, she said she all matters regarding resignation were finalised by August 11. 

She had produced evidence for the committee, in which she said the job was not an easy one.

"It was never easy operating in an environment in which I had no familiar networks and there were times when it seemed a very lonely mission. However, I am pleased I was able to set it on its way. Ultimately however I had to face a situation which I could not solve and which would continue unless challenged. I resigned to make that challenge occur."

She also said she was concerned about articles in The Times which "appeared to derive from a member of your committee which alleged I have wilfully refused to cooperate with the House of Commons investigation."

"I hope you will agree from the sequence of events I have outlined that this allegation is totally untrue."

Before the select committee convened, a statement to Stuff from Goddard and her husband Christopher Hodson QC said Dame Lowell had not been asked to participate in the select committee hearing, or declined to appear.

"To avoid any misunderstanding Dame Lowell notes that [since August 31] she has not received any communication from the UK Home Secretary; nor from any other person on behalf of her or the [Home Affairs Select Committee] seeking information or her attendance at any meeting.

"On October 6 the UK Permanent Secretary advised her that members of the [committee] had expressed to him a wish to meet with her, and that this was a matter for the [committee] to deal with, as it has now done in its October 14 letter."

 - Stuff

Ad Feedback
special offers
Auckland

Shooting death: not guilty

Bodi McKee has been found not guilty of  murdering Leslie Putt.

Jurors had to decide if shooting could be justified as self-defence in south Auckland murder trial.

Two cycleways connect

A section between Surey Cres and Firth St is being redeveloped to make way for new cycleways.

Work has started to join two central Auckland cycleways.

A tilt at rapid rail

The proposal would invest $400 million in 17 tilt trains during stage two, which can travel at 160kmh.

A three-stage, $1.45 billion proposal could connect Auckland and Hamilton at 160kmh.

Bashed prisoner sues Serco

Alex Littleton says Serco allowed a culture of violence to exist at Mt Eden Corrections Facility.

He claims he was punched and kicked by three inmates and wants $500k from the private prison operator.

Wellington

Lessons from our major reno stuff nation

The new kitchen benches are made of natural concrete.

A Wellington couple chose renovation over building, and it worked a treat.

Window blown out video

Around 5am, MetService meteorologist Stephen Glassey said a wind gust of 126kmh was recorded at Mt Kaukau in Wellington ...

Just when we thought it was over, winter is once again rearing its head in Wellington.

Accused acquitted in biting case

An Indian businessman made a $10,000 promise to return to New Zealand for his trial, but never did. He's unlikely to get ...

Judge doubts sex worker's evidence and finds absent Inderjyot Singh not guilty.

Police storm Hutt house  video

Armed offenders squad members used the weapons before entering the property off Kings Crescent, near Hutt Hospital.

Watch the moment police storm a hostage situation in Lower Hutt with stun grenades.

Canterbury

Serial pub robber jailed

Douglas Roake has been jailed by the Christchurch District Court for six pub robberies around Canterbury and shooting ...

Man who worked as security guard at Richie McCaw's wedding jailed for over 13 years after shooting two women and robbing six pubs.

Chairman steps down

David Bedford, chairman of Environment Canterbury, has stepped down for three months.

Environment Canterbury chairman David Bedford has stepped down from his role due to health issues.

Knife-wielding robber found

Police were called to the Lincoln Rd dairy after a robbery about 10am on Thursday.

A man has been arrested shortly after allegedly robbing a dairy at knifepoint.

Shapeshifter headlining park gig

More than 10,000 people attended the Six60 Live in the Park event last year.

Kiwi bands Shapeshifter, Shihad and Kora will play at a popular music festival in Hagley Park.

Waikato

New leads in cold case

Chris Bush was shot dead in 1987 at the Red Fox Tavern.

New information leads police probing 1987 murder of Chris Bush to "persons of interest".

Driver rams cop car

Ali Taipari, 26, was sentenced in the Hamilton District Court on Wednesday.

It was third time unlucky for Ali Taipari in his attempts to stay one step ahead of the police.

Nationwide hunt for gunman video

Police are looking to locate Rollie James Heke, 36. He is believed to be armed and dangerous and should not be approached.

The search for "unpredictable" Rollie James Heke has been elevated to a national level.

Ghost school to be bulldozed

The Ministry of Education says some of the buildings had asbestos.

Buildings at the Hamilton school have sat vacant for 13 years.

Taranaki

From bombings to pancakes

22092016 SUPPLIED. Marcel's Pancakes' Marcel Naenen, left, Rafael Porto Carrero and Ingrid Vercammen.

A former freelance reporter tells of terror overseas and how he's come to the sweet life in New Zealand.

Arts Festival begins

160817 News Photo. SIMON O'CONNOR/STUFF
Taranaki Arts Festival Story in the Crystal Palace.
L-R Cleo Wood and Suzanne ...

It really does sound like one of the best jobs...where we do we sign up?

Sports clubs targeted by thieves

Thieves stole two outboard motors from Waitara's Clifton Rowing Club.

Police are seeking information about sports club burglaries.

Heavy rain warning

Get the wet weather gear ready, a weather warning has been issued for Mt Taranaki.

Up to 90mm of rain could fall on the mountain today.

Manawatu

Weaving cultural ties

Tanemahuta Gray in his Feilding home.

Tanemahuta Gray is a choreographer and director who now calls Feilding home.

Pei prison assault

Faraniko Pei blasted holes in two police stations in frustration at the care his sister was getting in hospital.

The anger of a man who blew holes in police stations with a shotgun boils over in prison.

Police investigate sudden death

Flowers have been placed on the letterbox the property where a 53-year-old woman died suddenly.

A 53-year-old woman was found dead in her home.

The political outsider

Adrienne Pierce is aiming to take Palmerston North for National at the election.

A newbie to the Manawatu political scene has an uphill battle to turn Palmerston North blue for National.

Nelson

Squire gets nod over Kaino video

DUBLIN, IRELAND - NOVEMBER 19: Liam Squire of New Zeaand is tackled  during the international rugby match between ...

Homegrown Tasman star Liam Squire is in the ABs starting lineup for Bledisloe opener.

Mumps spread south

Some people with mumps get a fever and headaches, and can spread the virus by coughing and sneezing. (File photo)

Two cases of mumps have been reported in Nelson after an outbreak in Auckland.

Final credits roll for DVD store

The decline in customers over the last three years was noticeable, says Stoke Video Ezy owner Sean Davis.

When Sean Davis took over Video Ezy in Nelson, there were 60 others. Now there are just 17.

More rain on the way

Pedestrians battle with wind and rain in Nelson's CBD this morning.

Wild weather expected to ease by afternoon ... but more rain is forecast for the weekend.

Marlborough

Your far flung fish and chips video

Witherlea Takeaways owner Sharyn Hiltz says frozen fish is just as good as fresh fish for your Friday night takeaway.

It's Friday night and that means one thing: takeaway time. But under the batter, where does your fish come from?

Mumps spread south

Some people with mumps get a fever and headaches, and can spread the virus by coughing and sneezing. (File photo)

Three young people in Marlborough have contracted the mumps.

Big win for Blenheim

A million-dollar winner, but Powerball not struck.

Blenheim Lotto player strikes it lucky with $1m win.

Procession for crash victim

Marlborough 19-year-old George Holland died in a crash in Wairau Valley.

A motocross-loving teenager was farewelled with a 50-strong procession of brightly-coloured motorcycles in Marlborough.

South Canterbury

Getting in shape a success

Kicksports Timaru founder Scott Tweedie established a  MuayThai gymnasium in 2014 with two members. Membership has since ...

Scott Tweedie left fulltime work to pursue his dream, and he's sharing that dream with others.

Hospital rebuild plan

South Canterbury District Health Board chief executive Nigel Trainor said it had decided to shift a planned ...

Proposal to redevelop Timaru Hospital moves up a gear with plans afoot to rebuild.

Rape charge dismissed

Ashburton man Angus Mackenzie had a charge of rape dismissed at the Timaru District Court due to a lack of evidence to ...

Ashburton man on trial in Timaru for rape has charge against him dismissed.

Walking for hope

Timaru woman Michelle Cogger has organised a hope walk to raise awareness of suicide prevention.

Timaru mother organises community Hope Walk to create awareness around suicide.

Southland

Invercargill reinvents itself as... 

The new "Invercargill" logo can be used by businesses for marketing.

Mayor Tim Shadbolt says new brand "isn't as pretentious" as previous efforts... "It's the only city in the world called Invercargill."

Police officer under investigation

Southern District Commander Superintendent Paul Basham confirmed an investigation was under way.

Southland police constable allegedly sent inappropriate text messages to a woman who had sought out police assistance.

Cow neglect bad for 'Team NZ'

One of the animals neglected in the Castlerock Dairies in Southland.

Ministry for Primary Industries says animal welfare cases like recent Castlerock Dairies cow neglect court case are bad for "Team NZ".

Face reconstruction success

Christine Brown after her face reconstruction at Dunedin Hospital.

A 16 hour face reconstruction operation should be life changing for Christine Brown.

Ad Feedback