Government's 'third power' move on Christchurch red-zoning impinged human rights, report says

Ralph Bungard had to wait years for certainty about his red-zoned home and his stress levels to fall.

Ralph Bungard had to wait years for certainty about his red-zoned home and his stress levels to fall.

The Government's use of a "third source of power" in the earthquake red-zoning process eroded property rights and affected the mental wellbeing of those who chose to stay, a report says.

The Human Rights Commission has surveyed more than 100 people who still live or own land in the residential red zone to gauge the effect the process had on them.

In its report released on Thursday, it concluded the Government's decision to "do anything not prohibited by law" affected stayers' human rights. It called for a change to the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act to better protect the right to property.

The Government should have taken a more "people-focused" approach to making policy on quake-damaged land in ...

The Government should have taken a more "people-focused" approach to making policy on quake-damaged land in Christchurch, the Human Rights Commission says.

It also found the mental wellbeing of red-zone stayers had fallen sharply since the earthquakes, while stress levels continued to rise. Many respondents said their overall quality of life was much worse.

* Opinion: Red zoning shows New Zealand needs to do more to protect property rights
HRC asks Brownlee to extend red-zone deadline
Public input sought on red-zone compensation
David Rutherford – Standing up for our human rights

Greater Christchurch Regeneration Minister Gerry Brownlee rejected the "third source" claim. Cabinet was entitled to approve the zoning policy, he said, when the Government was under "huge pressure" to make a decision.

Human Rights commissioner David Rutherford says the Government's "third source of power" impinged red-zoners' rights.

Human Rights commissioner David Rutherford says the Government's "third source of power" impinged red-zoners' rights.

Human rights commissioner David Rutherford said the Government should have used powers granted to it under the Canterbury Earthquake Recovery Act to deal with property and property owners. It could have written a recovery plan, which would be publicly notified, giving red-zoners a chance to "participate in decisions about [themselves]".

"That was really the key opportunity that was lost by the way they chose to do the red zone using the third source of power. The act actually required them to consult with the community.

"At the time that the red zoning happened a lot of people were wondering, how did that happen? Was it some planning act? Because they didn't use the Act of Parliament given to them. That's when it really dawned on us that they'd decided to use this so-called third source."

Gerry Brownlee says the Government was under "huge pressure" to make a decision on quake-damaged land.

Gerry Brownlee says the Government was under "huge pressure" to make a decision on quake-damaged land.

That move affected red-zone stayers grappling with insurance issues, loss of equity, delayed compensation offers and the possibility of losing services like power and water supply, the report said.

Ad Feedback

The Government had helped many people move on by making red zone offers and bailing out AMI Insurance, he said, but would have done better with a "people-centred" approach.

The survey found just a third of respondents felt their quality of life since the earthquakes was good or better. Before, the rate was 97 per cent. Stress levels were high and had risen in the last year. Fifty-six per cent of respondents scored in the bottom half of a World Health Organisation wellbeing measure, indicating risk of poor mental health. In wider surveys of red-zoners and Christchurch residents, that figure was no higher than 38 per cent.

Brownlee dismissed the "third source" claim.

"Had we gone down the recovery plan path [a zoning decision] could have been some later time [in 2011] and then it would have been subject to all sorts of legal review and perhaps blocking."

The psycho-social effects of the earthquakes had largely mirrored what the Government was advised to expect, he said, allowing it to "try and stay just a bit ahead of the curve in providing services and facilities for people".

Avoca Valley resident and survey respondent Ralph Bungard had his property red-zoned because of rockfall risk. Delays in zoning and insurance negotiations meant repairs had only just started.

His family's stress levels peaked two to three years ago while awaiting zoning confirmation and working to lift a notice barring entry to the property over the rockfall risk.

They flouted the prohibition notice and lived at home out of necessity, he said. Relief came only when protective fences got the notice lifted and the family resolved to stay.

"We lied about it, and I have no regrets about that at all. That's what we were forced into, because the alternative was incredible financial hardship."

 - Stuff


Ad Feedback
special offers

Shop talk: Shut the Front Door

Sarah Parker, owner of Shut the Front Door.

Meet the mind behind this fast-growing, quirky and colourful design store chain.

Learning from Big Apple's finest

Demitra Sealy as Doll Common in the play Playhouse Creatures by April De Angelis.

Demitra Sealy is accepted for The Actors Studio in New York City to study under Ellen Burstyn, Harvey Keitel and Al Pacino.

Business group aims to connect NZ and China

Anson Li, Haijian Lie and Ailian Su at the event that established the New Zealand Shunde Chamber of Commerce.

A new Kiwi-Chinese chamber of commerce is founded to assist entrepreneurs with information, consultancy and cooperation.

92-year-old's 7 speeding tickets video

All of Harris' fines have been in his Suzuki Alto – his first brand new car he bought in 2014.

A 92-year-old Auckland grandfather has clocked up seven speeding tickets in five months and says the speed limit needs to rise.


Election 'delaying Basin plans'

Wellingtonians have been waiting years for a solution to the rush hour traffic that clogs up the Basin Reserve ...

Councillor claims Government is playing politics with Wellington's transport system.

Investigation widens

Former MoT manager Joanne Harrison had a stint at Corrections - before she was jailed.

Another public agency has had to investigate after hiring fraudster Joanne Harrison.

More plans for Eva St

Student housing in the Eva and Leeds Street Laneway could be refurbished for another restaurant to be added to the urban hub.

Wellington's most hipster laneway could see more redevelopment in two buildings that house students.

Fraudulent beggar is back

Hawke's Bay beggar Frank Lovich was on Napier's Emerson Street this week.

A beggar sent to jail because he was asking for money is back on the streets with the same sign and has no plans to stop.


Belief in dog wins it a home

Holden wrapped in a blanket in his first night at home with Carole Worley

All he wanted to do was be with people, but people did not want him.

Thick fog hid crash video

A member of public came across the crash about two hours after the car hit a tree on Tuesday morning.

Locals heard the crash, but could not find the wreckage. Two hours later, a young man was found dead.

Can we fix Cathedral Square? video

Architect and town planner James Lunday has ideas for how the Square can be brought back to life.

Overhead gondolas, new laneways and underground streams proposed for city's heart.

Brownlee's funding freeze

St Asaph St is set to be altered again to reinstate car parks, while Armagh and Colombo streets will get a re-think.

Ex-rebuild minister suspended Accessible City funding amid discontent over road changes.


Bye Tinder, hello speed dating

There's promise in speed dating, Tomek Pietkiewicz says.

After failing on Tinder, one Hamilton man thinks he has the answer for singles in the city.

Couple $27m richer

The winning lotto was brought from Thames Four Square owned by Sukhpal Singh.

A Thames couple have come forward with the golden Lotto ticket.

Stuck car hit by train

A car got stuck on train tracks in Hamilton, no one was injured. (FILE PHOTO)

A driver and passenger managed to escape their station wagon, stuck on the tracks, before a train smashed into it.

Cricketer chokes pregnant partner

Northern Districts and Auckland representative cricketer Cody Andrews was sentenced in Hamilton District Court on Monday.

Judge says his heavily pregnant partner "must have been terrified".


Hall to turn 100, present planned

The Whareroa Social Hall of 1918, better known as the Ramanui School Hall today.

A hall that is turning 100 has been moved and had a 'bit of a whack up' in the past, will hopefully be renovated again.

Big Jims to reopen

Taranaki plant nursery Big Jim's has been cleared to reopen, two weeks after after myrtle rust was detected on plants.

Positive myrtle rust findings grow as nurseries reopen

Mum to many video

Cherie Bidois was killed in a car crash near Gore almost a fortnight ago.

Cherie Bidois was the type of person who would give to others, no matter what.

Euthanasia in NZ liable to abuse

Professor Jan Berheim is a Belgian medical expert and euthanasia advocate. He was invited to New Zealand by the ...

A law change would protect caregivers from undue prosecution.


Robber's 'slasher-like' weapon

Footage from the robbery of a Liquorland store in Palmerston North.

Police release CCTV showing the thieves, who hit a shop attendant  in a Palmerson North robbery.

Unexplained death

Shaun Gray died in ward 21, the mental health unit at Palmerston North Hospital, in 2014.

"This man was in their arms looking for support and he ended up dead."

Retail receivership angst

Shoe Connection's Plaza  outlet is facing an uncertain future as its parent company goes into receivership.

PK Furniture and Shoe Connection will stay open for now.

Letting in the light

Feilding artist Sue James has used the unusual medium of venetian blinds for her new art exhibition.

Feilding artist Sue James has used an interesting medium for her new exhibition.


Iwi challenges water bottling

Te Waikoropupu Springs is considered sacred to local iwi.

A plan to bottle thousands of cubic metres of water from a Tasman spring has been dealt a blow after a local iwi appeal.

Nelson still top

Housing construction has helped fuel Nelson's run at the top of an economic scoreboard.

Nelson stays New Zealand's top-performing region in an economic scoreboard.

Poverty hitting region's youngest

Kay Guyton runs Angel in My Street and works to support Stoke families and children in poverty.

The 2016 Technical Report on Child Poverty found more than 1400 children in Nelson and Tasman were living below the poverty line. 

Talley's fighting consent terms

Talley's has applied for a 35-year term for a bundle of permits it seeks.

Talley's is challenging some of the proposed conditions to its continued discharge from its Motueka site.


Paradise found in Pelorus

Debra and Michael Brennan moved to Pelorus after seeking an alternative to city life.

Exhausted by city life, Debra and Michael Brennan sought a change... and boy did they find it.

Beer burglar jailed

Walter Narayan was told about the outdoor fridge as a place where he could get beer, his lawyer said. (File photo)

He went back to the well one too many times. The well being someone else's outdoor fridge.

Praise the paua pearl video

Pearl inserts are used to grow the stones.

Paua farmers on the edge of the Marlborough Sounds say their love of the marine mollusc borders on worship.

Meth accused back in court

Four men facing meth-dealing charges are back at the Blenheim District Court.

Four men were charged after police raided six properties earlier this month.

South Canterbury

Seeking right woman for the job

The rights say one actor must be white, one must be black and the third must be Asian

Timaru show could be abandoned unless actor found for very specific role.

Rubbish fire suspicious

A fire at the back of the Sanford factory is being treated as suspicious

 A fire near Timaru's port is being treated as suspicious

Protection help sought

Urban designer Nigel Gilkison made a submission on behalf of the Timaru Civic Trust. The trust bought the 1871 Landing ...

"The onus is put on the owners... essentially they get no compensation for having to do that."

Dollar-a-stay plan for Mackenzie

Tourists at Lake Pukaki, Aoraki (Mount Cook) near Twizel.

New scheme to encourage visitors to donate to Mackenzie fund.


Bluff oyster numbers decline

Bluff Oyster Festival Chairman John Edminstin in front of the crowd at the Bluff Oyster Festival.

The results of a recent NIWA survey has shown replenishment rates in the Foveaux strait Oyster fishery have lowered since 2012.

Aurora on show

Te Anau resident Chris Watson captured this stunning panorama from the Ivon Wilson Park on the outskirts of the town.

Photographers were out in force on Sunday capturing the dazzling Southern Lights.

Barclay supporting centre

Lumsden Maternity's contract with the Southern District Health Board expires on July 31.

Clutha-Southland MP Todd Barclay says he will not let the Lumsden Maternity Centre close.

Sea lions could scupper fishery

A juvenile sea lion in Port Pegasus in January 2016. In New Zealand sea lions are ranked as "nationally critical" on the ...

Would a new aquaculture project on Stewart Island affect the sea lion colony?

Ad Feedback