Government's 'third power' move on Christchurch red-zoning impinged human rights, report says

Ralph Bungard had to wait years for certainty about his red-zoned home and his stress levels to fall.
JOSEPH JOHNSON/FAIRFAX NZ

Ralph Bungard had to wait years for certainty about his red-zoned home and his stress levels to fall.

The Government's use of a "third source of power" in the earthquake red-zoning process eroded property rights and affected the mental wellbeing of those who chose to stay, a report says.

The Human Rights Commission has surveyed more than 100 people who still live or own land in the residential red zone to gauge the effect the process had on them.

In its report released on Thursday, it concluded the Government's decision to "do anything not prohibited by law" affected stayers' human rights. It called for a change to the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act to better protect the right to property.

The Government should have taken a more "people-focused" approach to making policy on quake-damaged land in ...
IAIN MCGREGOR/FAIRFAX NZ

The Government should have taken a more "people-focused" approach to making policy on quake-damaged land in Christchurch, the Human Rights Commission says.

It also found the mental wellbeing of red-zone stayers had fallen sharply since the earthquakes, while stress levels continued to rise. Many respondents said their overall quality of life was much worse.

READ MORE:
* Opinion: Red zoning shows New Zealand needs to do more to protect property rights
HRC asks Brownlee to extend red-zone deadline
Public input sought on red-zone compensation
David Rutherford – Standing up for our human rights

Greater Christchurch Regeneration Minister Gerry Brownlee rejected the "third source" claim. Cabinet was entitled to approve the zoning policy, he said, when the Government was under "huge pressure" to make a decision.

Human Rights commissioner David Rutherford says the Government's "third source of power" impinged red-zoners' rights.
MAARTEN HOLL/FAIRFAX NZ

Human Rights commissioner David Rutherford says the Government's "third source of power" impinged red-zoners' rights.

Human rights commissioner David Rutherford said the Government should have used powers granted to it under the Canterbury Earthquake Recovery Act to deal with property and property owners. It could have written a recovery plan, which would be publicly notified, giving red-zoners a chance to "participate in decisions about [themselves]".

"That was really the key opportunity that was lost by the way they chose to do the red zone using the third source of power. The act actually required them to consult with the community.

"At the time that the red zoning happened a lot of people were wondering, how did that happen? Was it some planning act? Because they didn't use the Act of Parliament given to them. That's when it really dawned on us that they'd decided to use this so-called third source."

Gerry Brownlee says the Government was under "huge pressure" to make a decision on quake-damaged land.
CAMERON BURNELL/FAIRFAX NZ

Gerry Brownlee says the Government was under "huge pressure" to make a decision on quake-damaged land.

That move affected red-zone stayers grappling with insurance issues, loss of equity, delayed compensation offers and the possibility of losing services like power and water supply, the report said.

Ad Feedback

The Government had helped many people move on by making red zone offers and bailing out AMI Insurance, he said, but would have done better with a "people-centred" approach.

The survey found just a third of respondents felt their quality of life since the earthquakes was good or better. Before, the rate was 97 per cent. Stress levels were high and had risen in the last year. Fifty-six per cent of respondents scored in the bottom half of a World Health Organisation wellbeing measure, indicating risk of poor mental health. In wider surveys of red-zoners and Christchurch residents, that figure was no higher than 38 per cent.

Brownlee dismissed the "third source" claim.

"Had we gone down the recovery plan path [a zoning decision] could have been some later time [in 2011] and then it would have been subject to all sorts of legal review and perhaps blocking."

The psycho-social effects of the earthquakes had largely mirrored what the Government was advised to expect, he said, allowing it to "try and stay just a bit ahead of the curve in providing services and facilities for people".

Avoca Valley resident and survey respondent Ralph Bungard had his property red-zoned because of rockfall risk. Delays in zoning and insurance negotiations meant repairs had only just started.

His family's stress levels peaked two to three years ago while awaiting zoning confirmation and working to lift a notice barring entry to the property over the rockfall risk.

They flouted the prohibition notice and lived at home out of necessity, he said. Relief came only when protective fences got the notice lifted and the family resolved to stay.

"We lied about it, and I have no regrets about that at all. That's what we were forced into, because the alternative was incredible financial hardship."

 - Stuff

Comments

Ad Feedback
special offers
Auckland

Power outage in Grafton

The outage affected businesses in the Grafton area

A digger has cut power cables in Grafton, cutting power to Auckland Medical School, near the Auckland City Hospital.

Mapping out times past

Old Waiheke ferry Baroona, leaving Auckland.

Relive or get acquainted with the old days of the ferries at Waiheke Library this October.

Far North council to rewrite controversial dog rules

The Bay of Islands WatchDogs are relieved the dog bylaw will be revisited by the council.

The Far North District Council will rewrite its draft dog bylaw following protests by dog lovers.

Holidays stage show tickets up for grabs

The upcoming Horrible Histories stage show in Auckland will showcase Britain's history, leaving in all the "nasty" bits.

The Eastern Courier has two tickets to win to the British-themed Horrible Histories stage show for children.

Wellington

'Gay village' vetoes church union

Sara Rimmer, left, and Alexandra Saunders were refused a church wedding in St Peter's Anglican Church in Paekākāriki, on ...

Paekākāriki is known for being liberal. But not when it came to Alex and Sara's wedding.

Downpours and gales 

12072017 News photo MONIQUE FORD / STUFF
Wellington rain and wind weather

Motorists warned, windows blown out as gales picked to gust to 130kmh with heavy rain.

Gorge options discussed

The 13 alternative route options are available for public viewing and comment on the NZTA website.

Thirteen alternative routes to the Manawatū Gorge have been laid out for the public to discuss.

Who'll be Lester's new 2IC?

Wellington Mayor Justin Lester, right, will announce his replacement for Deputy Mayor Paul Eagle within the next ...

Councillor with less than a year's experience in the mix to be new deputy mayor.

Canterbury

Whitebaiter's river death 'tragic'

Helen Wood died at Kairaki Beach, in North Canterbury, on Friday night. The beach is popular with fishers and ...

Helen Wood reversed her trailer onto the beach before her car went into the river with her inside.

1600 delegates coming

The Piano in the preforming arts precinct is another piece of the venue jigsaw puzzle for the conference.

With no convention centre built, Christchurch's largest post-quake conference required a venue "jigsaw"

Doctor loses citizenship fight

Dr Robert Taylor has twice fought a decision to revoke his citizenship. He won the first time but the second time a ...

Robert Taylor didn't mention a sex offence arrest when he applied to be a Kiwi.

Two accused of raping teen

Parampreet Singh, left, is charged with two counts of rape and one of sexual violation, and Amritpal Singh, is charged ...

Two men have gone on trial for the alleged rape and sexual violation of a 17-year-old girl.

Waikato

Search for fisherman resumes

The man's fishing rod was found where he was last seen at Papanui Pt.

Searchers to scour the coastline of Papanui Pt for missing Hamilton fisherman.

Fears for missing man

John Lee, 80, was reported missing from Mt Maunganui on Monday afternoon.

John Lee, 80, has been found and is "safe and well".

Peak kitten season

Waikato SPCA expects to help at least 3000 animals this calendar year, many of them kittens.

Breeding season is getting longer and this year is expected to be the busiest yet.

Bad egg confusion unscrambled

New Zealand egg farmers produce more than one billion eggs every year. (File photo).

Egg loving Kiwis are eating more than ever.

Taranaki

'Undesirable' gully

Lucy's Gully is part of the Egmont National Park.

There's towering redwoods, native ferns and birdsong whistling through the bush. But there's also a lot of old rubbish.

Blind biking challenge

Jan Tyson is helping Teena McEwen, who is blind, prepare for Taranaki Around The Mountain Cycle Challenge.

She can't see, but Teena McEwen is still gearing up for next year's Around the Mountain cycle challenge.

Heavy rain warning issued

Rough weather has descended onto Taranaki as MetService issues severe weather watch. (View in New Plymouth and Hawera)

It's going to pour down on Mt Taranaki and gale force northwest winds could batter the region today.

New lattes: Novelty or nutritional?

Turmeric and beetroot lattes are becoming popular but won't be replacing anyone's flat white or cappuccino any time soon.

Turmeric and beetroot lattes are trendy and tasty but aren't a miracle health cure.

Manawatu

Red Nose Day is ready to roll

The Manawatu Turbos in support of Red Nose Day join Tai Te Awa with asthma, Kase Williams, 10, with cystic fibrosis and ...

Cure Kids Red Nose Day organiser Laurel Winiata is hoping for a spring break.

Fighting to live video

Kerry McGrath wants to live her dream and travel the country in her house bus. But she needs some help to do so.

Kerry McGrath just wants to get to living in her gypsy house bus, cancer-free.

Gorge options given

The 13 alternative route options are available for public viewing and comment on the NZTA website.

Thirteen alternative routes to the Manawatū Gorge have been laid out for the public to discuss.

Greens in difficult position

Green Party leader James Shaw knows siding with National is too risky.

OPINION: The Green Party faithful seem quite grateful to be back in Parliament.

Nelson

Farewell to kindly street 'godfather'

Ron Brinsdon, pictured in 2005, on his dawn can collection run in Hardy St. He was remembered as an intelligent and ...

Farewell to the Tin Man: a homeless man who touched many lives was described as an intelligent and caring man at his funeral.

Revved up over hobby

04092017 NEWS PHOTO BRADEN FASTIER / STUFF
Preston Brunell of Stoke Mechanical and Tyres.

Nelson man Preston Brunell has got plenty of mileage from his lifelong love of custom cars.

Making his mark

Justin Ferguson discovered his love for making jewellery following a course.

A Nelson silversmith is taking pleasure out of creating eye-catching pieces out of silver.

New marine frontiers

Dr Serean Adams, Cawthron aquaculture group manager at the Cawthron Aquaculture Park.

New species and technologies will increase resilience of aquaculture stock for the future, industry told.

Marlborough

Trek almost turns tragic

Waihopai Valley woman Del Bissell, right, fell ill while trekking in the Mongolian mountains, pictured here with fellow ...

Four days into a two-week horse trek in the isolated Altai Mountains, Del Bissell realised she was in serious trouble.

Muddy cover-up fails

Reid Kevin Heyward has been caught poaching up the Awatere Valley in Marlborough. (File photo)

The number plates were carefully covered in mud so no-one could identify the truck. But then the farmer showed up.

Potholes made him swerve

Robert James Pickering was caught drink-driving on State Highway 63 near Wairau Valley. (File photo)

Drink-driver who "works hard, plays hard" drives into oncoming traffic with bottle of booze in hand.

Pushing aquaculture frontiers

Dr Serean Adams, Cawthron aquaculture group manager at the Cawthron Aquaculture Park.

New species and technologies will increase resilience of aquaculture stock for the future, industry told.

South Canterbury

Craigmore a designer's 'dream' video

Olympian Jock Paget is being hosted at Craigmore Station for the first fundraising event for a proposed new eventing course.

Olympian throws support behind proposed world class eventing course at Craigmore Station.

Fine weather back

A severe weather warning was in place for heavy winds in Canterbury on Monday morning.

The majority of South Canterbury is expected to have fine weather on Tuesday.

Call for model plane size limits

South Canterbury Model Aero Club vice-president Robbie Hellewell launches his Parkzone Visionair AS3X aircraft into the ...

Safety concerns prompt SC Aero Club to call for more rules around model aeroplanes.

Mechanics recall bygone era

Former workmates, from left, Bernie Foster, Allan Averis and Gordon Hutcheon check out some of the old tractor models ...

Three former Timaru colleagues take a trip down memory lane.

Otago

Canterbury coach defects to Highlanders

Canterbury coach Glenn Delaney, right, chats with Luke Whitelock after a Mitre 10 Cup match this year. Delaney has ...

If Glenn Delaney was working elsewhere, he could be told to clear his desk and scuttle for the nearest exit.

Ride the Lake charity fundraiser looms

Tina Simmonds is doing the Ride the Lake event on October 8 to help raise funds for mental health.

Riding around Lake Dunstan for mental health.

Team NZ bringing America's Cup to Central Otago

The Wanaka Yacht Club will get sailing's version of a royal visit on October 16.

Wanaka and Queenstown yachting enthusiasts get to see the Auld Mug on October 16.

Fire victim's family 'gutted'

A Housing New Zealand house where the body of a man was found after a fire.

Heartbroken family speaks of their devastation in losing their father in a house fire.

Southland

Centenarian receives more family after birthday

Wallace Price, left, with his son Graeme at the Grasmere Kindergarten to vote in the 2017 general election.

Among the gifts Wallace Price received for his 100th birthday he got a whole new side to the family.

Meridian 'flooding my family farm' video

Looking out over the Hollyburn creek which has been flooded by water from the Waiau river.

Every time Meridian Energy releases the Manapouri dam, Thomas O'Brien loses another chunk of farmland.

Dig This founder visits 

Dig This creator Ed Mumm, Southland District mayor Gary Tong, HWR Group director Scott O'Donnell and Dig This ...

Dig This founder Ed Mumm paid a visit to the Invercargill franchise to help fine-tune the attraction.

Family 'wrecked', search suspended

Police are still appealing for sightings of missing Dunedin man Stephen Lowe.

The search for missing man Stephen Lowe has been suspended.

Ad Feedback