Government's 'third power' move on Christchurch red-zoning impinged human rights, report says

Ralph Bungard had to wait years for certainty about his red-zoned home and his stress levels to fall.
JOSEPH JOHNSON/FAIRFAX NZ

Ralph Bungard had to wait years for certainty about his red-zoned home and his stress levels to fall.

The Government's use of a "third source of power" in the earthquake red-zoning process eroded property rights and affected the mental wellbeing of those who chose to stay, a report says.

The Human Rights Commission has surveyed more than 100 people who still live or own land in the residential red zone to gauge the effect the process had on them.

In its report released on Thursday, it concluded the Government's decision to "do anything not prohibited by law" affected stayers' human rights. It called for a change to the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act to better protect the right to property.

The Government should have taken a more "people-focused" approach to making policy on quake-damaged land in ...
IAIN MCGREGOR/FAIRFAX NZ

The Government should have taken a more "people-focused" approach to making policy on quake-damaged land in Christchurch, the Human Rights Commission says.

It also found the mental wellbeing of red-zone stayers had fallen sharply since the earthquakes, while stress levels continued to rise. Many respondents said their overall quality of life was much worse.

READ MORE:
* Opinion: Red zoning shows New Zealand needs to do more to protect property rights
HRC asks Brownlee to extend red-zone deadline
Public input sought on red-zone compensation
David Rutherford – Standing up for our human rights

Greater Christchurch Regeneration Minister Gerry Brownlee rejected the "third source" claim. Cabinet was entitled to approve the zoning policy, he said, when the Government was under "huge pressure" to make a decision.

Human Rights commissioner David Rutherford says the Government's "third source of power" impinged red-zoners' rights.
MAARTEN HOLL/FAIRFAX NZ

Human Rights commissioner David Rutherford says the Government's "third source of power" impinged red-zoners' rights.

Human rights commissioner David Rutherford said the Government should have used powers granted to it under the Canterbury Earthquake Recovery Act to deal with property and property owners. It could have written a recovery plan, which would be publicly notified, giving red-zoners a chance to "participate in decisions about [themselves]".

"That was really the key opportunity that was lost by the way they chose to do the red zone using the third source of power. The act actually required them to consult with the community.

"At the time that the red zoning happened a lot of people were wondering, how did that happen? Was it some planning act? Because they didn't use the Act of Parliament given to them. That's when it really dawned on us that they'd decided to use this so-called third source."

Gerry Brownlee says the Government was under "huge pressure" to make a decision on quake-damaged land.
CAMERON BURNELL/FAIRFAX NZ

Gerry Brownlee says the Government was under "huge pressure" to make a decision on quake-damaged land.

That move affected red-zone stayers grappling with insurance issues, loss of equity, delayed compensation offers and the possibility of losing services like power and water supply, the report said.

Ad Feedback

The Government had helped many people move on by making red zone offers and bailing out AMI Insurance, he said, but would have done better with a "people-centred" approach.

The survey found just a third of respondents felt their quality of life since the earthquakes was good or better. Before, the rate was 97 per cent. Stress levels were high and had risen in the last year. Fifty-six per cent of respondents scored in the bottom half of a World Health Organisation wellbeing measure, indicating risk of poor mental health. In wider surveys of red-zoners and Christchurch residents, that figure was no higher than 38 per cent.

Brownlee dismissed the "third source" claim.

"Had we gone down the recovery plan path [a zoning decision] could have been some later time [in 2011] and then it would have been subject to all sorts of legal review and perhaps blocking."

The psycho-social effects of the earthquakes had largely mirrored what the Government was advised to expect, he said, allowing it to "try and stay just a bit ahead of the curve in providing services and facilities for people".

Avoca Valley resident and survey respondent Ralph Bungard had his property red-zoned because of rockfall risk. Delays in zoning and insurance negotiations meant repairs had only just started.

His family's stress levels peaked two to three years ago while awaiting zoning confirmation and working to lift a notice barring entry to the property over the rockfall risk.

They flouted the prohibition notice and lived at home out of necessity, he said. Relief came only when protective fences got the notice lifted and the family resolved to stay.

"We lied about it, and I have no regrets about that at all. That's what we were forced into, because the alternative was incredible financial hardship."

 - Stuff

Comments

Ad Feedback
special offers
Auckland

Urgent sugary drinks tax needed

An expert panel says the Government needs to do more to improve New Zealanders' health.

Experts call for action to fill gaps on healthy food policies

No reward despite effort

NZ Warriors Mason Lino steps Cowboys Te Marie Martin.

OPINION It did not go our way again, my Vodafone Warriors losing in Townsville to the North Queensland Cowboys 24-12.

Fleeing motorcyclist killed

The serious crash occurred on the corner of Buckland Road and Royton Avenue.

Speeding motorcyclist dies in police pursuit after failing to stop in south Auckland.

Funding to support 23,000 new homes

Prime Minister Bill English has pledged a $600m housing injection.

The Government is pouring $600m into infrastructure that will support 23,300 new Auckland homes.

Wellington

Corgis worth a queen's ransom video

Jack and Joyce Luo spent more than $20,000 to bring their beloved welsh corgis Amy and Lucky from Beijing when they ...

Couple shell out $20,000 to bring their beloved dogs to join them in NZ.

Person trapped in car

The single car crash was on a tricky road, north of Wellington. (File photo)

Emergency services respond to a person trapped in a car on a rural road.

Car buried by slip

The buried Mazda in Palliser Rd, Roseneath, on Sunday morning.

Owner was at a party when he discovered his Mazda 6 under a pile of dirt.

Kapiti calls for its own hospital

K Gurunathan says: "We have particular needs with more than 26 per cent of our population over 65 years old. You can't ...

Nearly 10,000 people have signed a petition, citing "critical need" for better care.

Canterbury

Floodwater breaches home video

230717 NEWS Photo: Joseph Johnson/Stuff
Deborah Buchanan stands in her water damaged house looking located in Clarendon ...

Resident returns to find floodwater has washed through her quake-damaged home.

Dad dies on Coast farm

Bryan Edmonds leaves behind his partner Alana Tait and two sons Rawiri,1, and 11-month-old Tipene.

Bryan Edmonds stopped for a glass of water. An hour later he was found dead on the West Coast dairy farm.

Immigration U-turn?

Prime Minister Bill English won't rule it backing down on the proposed changes.

The Government is likely to scrub out major changes to immigration law that were announced in April.

Fire installs causing concern

The chimney cavity where a fire broke out in a Queenstown house early Sunday morning.

Builders failing to install multi-fuel fireplaces to NZ standards responsible for a spate of fires.

Waikato

Curfew to curb boy racers? video

More than 100 residents, boy racers, police and regional council representatives turned out for the meeting on Onion ...

Boy racers and residents met face to face to talk about rising tensions in Te Kowhai.

Spending questioned

Waikato District Health Board chief executive Nigel Murray.

Waikato DHB remains tight-lipped over private meeting regarding chief executive Nigel Murray's expenses.

'Kiwi culture' turns deadly video

Making a summer splash at locations such as the Raglan footbridge is seen as a Kiwi tradition but the consequences can ...

Four suffered life-changing injury diving off a wharf. Now, councils are taking action.

Hooves on the beat

Senior Constable Bill Eivers and Ali are known to patrol Benneydale together.

Senior Constable Bill Eivers has been patrolling on horseback for the past 15 years.

Taranaki

High steaks for cattle breeders

Jacqueline and Robin Blackwell have a friendly rivalry.

It's just as much about bragging rights at home as it is about national recognition for the Blackwell family.

NZ's first virtual medical centre

Dr Lance O'Sullivan is running the pilot project in Patea.

Patea's only doctor left, so the small town is now embracing new virtual technology to find a solution to its vacancy.

Author writes for herself

The book follows the story of a New Zealander who goes over to fight in the Vietnam war.

"I like to write what I like to read, and I figure if I'd like to read it than other people will want to read it as well."

Light pole hit-and-run

Police were alerted to the incident and located the driver a short time later.

The pole was left blocking an intersection.

Manawatu

"Can-do" Kiwi laid to rest

22072017 news photo DAVID UNWIN/STUFF
Colin Stevenson's funeral. A Traction Engine called "Dixie Flyer" takes Colin's ...

 Colin Stevenson, the man who "put Tokomaru on the map" died aged 87, and was ferried to the cemetery by steam-powered traction engine.

Miles in memory 

Crystal Johnston from Bulls and Liz Peters from Palmerston North cycling for 24 hours in a Sands Manawatu-Horowhenua ...

Two mums and three dads cycled on spin bikes for up to 30 hours as part of the fundraiser for lost babies.

Millions spent fixing police cars

A police car comes to a final halt after crashing through a Hamilton property in June.

More than $8 million has been spent fixing damaged police cars in the past three years.

No random drug tests 

Only following a police shooting do officers undergo drug and alcohol testing. (File photo).

Police are only given drug and alcohol testing if they fire a gun during an incident.

Nelson

Fake News and tinfoil hats

12052017 News Photo: TOM LEE/FAIRFAX NZ - MP Peter Dunne speaks at Cafe Agora in Hamilton. 4 members of the audience ...

OPINION: As Trump and his supporters bang on about "alternative facts", the concept is very much alive and well here in the provinces.

Nelson reign supreme

22072017 NEWS PHOTO MARTIN DE RUYTER/ STUFF

Nelson players and support staff after winning the  Nelson Bays Division 1 ...

Nelson turn it on to hammer Wanderers in Nelson Bays club rugby final. 

Stage set for Ma's Place fundraiser

The Split Apple Rockers Andrew Palmer, Dave Baker, Craig Starrenburg, Ernie Tarling and John Foes-Lamb are due to ...

Support group Ma's Place to benefit from proceeds of variety concert.

Breaking up bad

It all starts innocently enough.

In this week's Middle-aged Man Stu Hunt combs through the wreckage of his dating history.

Marlborough

Renwick denied 'fairytale' finish

Moutere captain Baxter Wilson holds up the champion of champions trophy.

Moutere ensured there would be no happy ending to Renwick's "fairytale" season with a 22-19 grand final victory.

Old Boys get job done

Marlborough College Old Boys celebrate with their supporters after beating Moutere in the division two final at ...

Marlborough College Old Boys gained sweet revenge for their 2016 final defeat when they overcame Moutere 27-15.

Chinese keen on pricey NZ crays

New Zealand crayfish is a premium product in China where it can fetch $1000 a kilo.

When it comes to high end gourmet goods the Chinese have a growing appetite for New Zealand wine, water and crayfish.

Escaping the Beast of Blenheim

Stewart Murray Wilson talks to journalist Harrison Christian while fishing at the Whanganui river mouth.

Even though he lives far away under strict conditions, Stewart Murray Wilson still haunts his former partner.

South Canterbury

A metre of snow in one day gallery

Staff clear snow from the base building at Mt Dobson on Sunday.

South Canterbury's ski fields will be primed for the rest of the season after huge snow dumps.

Response praised gallery video

A car stuck in the middle of Evans St with two occupants. Two police officers pushed the car off the road.

Timaru mayor praises response to storm, as attention turns to the clean up effort.

Working in the wild weather video

Lance Corporal Gerald Hart, Third Combat Support Services Battalion member, left, and Staff Sergeant Jason Segal look at ...

Hundreds of people worked tirelessly behind the scenes during SC's wild weekend.

Chickens lost in flood video

The Tin Shed owner Lesley Limbe at her property in Rangitata, which was hit by extensive flooding.

Retailer left questioning why her property was hit so badly by rapidly rising floodwaters.

Southland

"The culinary world has just lost a gentleman"

Scott Richardson, pictured here in 2015, in his role as a catering and hospitality teacher at Southland Boys' High School.

Well-known Invercargill chef Scott Richardson died this morning in Dunedin Hospital.

'Business as usual'

Aparima College principal Kaye Day. The latest Governmental report on the College said "urgent" improvement in ...

A troubled Southland secondary school is to continue as usual, despite its leadership coming under fire.

Hotel facing potential delays

Invercargill Licensing Trust general manager Greg Mulvey in front of the proposed site of the ILT's new multi-million ...

The Invercargill Licensing Trust has unearthed some speed bumps in its plans to build a new inner city hotel.

Defending champions on fire

Wensley's Fire cyclists from left to right, Nick Barclay, Marty Jillings, Ben Coley and Tai-Anne Blair set off in the ...

The fire service team has confirmed its the fastest emergency service in Invercargill.

Ad Feedback