Remanding children to solitary confinement 'degrading' breach of rights

Judge Andrew Becroft, Children's Commissioner, says it's not right to treat children worse than adults.

Judge Andrew Becroft, Children's Commissioner, says it's not right to treat children worse than adults.

The "degrading" law that allows children to be locked up in police cells ought to be scrapped, says the Children's Commissioner.

The call follows stinging criticism of the detention of a 15-year-old boy in Christchurch's police cells, a situation police admitted was "not uncommon".

Judge Andrew Becroft, the Children's Commissioner, said the rebuilding of Child, Youth and Family (CYF) next year would be a "wonderful opportunity" to get rid of the legislation that allowed a Christchurch youth to be remanded in police custody for six days.

Social Development Minister Anne Tolley at the UN Committee on the Rights of the Child in September.

Social Development Minister Anne Tolley at the UN Committee on the Rights of the Child in September.

A Christchurch judge criticised the Government for allowing the 15-year-old boy to be held in solitary confinement. He called the confinement a breach of the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child.

Christchurch judge accuses Government of breaching child's rights
Children's commissioner dishes out first 'detrimental' finding to Te Puna Wai 
Teenage boy held in police cell for three nights over Easter over lack of CYF beds 
Teenage girl locked in police cell for four days not an isolated case
Documents reveal extent of issues at Christchurch youth corrections facility
Caution over CYF bed cuts

The boy moved to a youth justice residence on Tuesday.

The Ministry of Social Development is considering using more beds at Te Puna Wai o Tuhinapo youth justice facility, near ...

The Ministry of Social Development is considering using more beds at Te Puna Wai o Tuhinapo youth justice facility, near Rolleston, in response to increased demand.

Becroft agreed with the judge's assessment, saying New Zealand signed up to the United Nations Convention and had to take it seriously.

"No child should be subjected to inhuman and degrading treatment. Arguably the sort of police cell confinement I've talked about is certainly degrading, and arguably inhuman," he said.

New Zealand was reviewed by a United Nations committee in September, which criticised the practice of remanding children in police cells.

"On the face of it, we're in breach of the convention, especially a six-day remand. No adult would ever spend six nights in a police cell. They'd be in a purpose-built prison with proper facilities," Becroft said.

Ad Feedback

"We're treating children worse than we would adults, and that just can't be right."

It was important to remember these children had only allegedly committed offences, he said.

The Children, Young Persons and Their Families Act 1989 gives authorities five options for remanding children beyond their first court appearance.

They can be released, released on bail, remanded into the care of a social worker, or remanded into the custody of the chief executive of the Ministry of Social Development (MSD), which could then place them in a designated facility.

Becroft said the fifth option – remanding them in police custody – was only intended as a fall-back if "residences" or youth prisons were full.

The Government plans to replace CYF next year with the Ministry for Vulnerable Children, otherwise known as Oranga Tamariki.

Becroft said it was an opportunity to remove or limit the option of remanding children into police custody.

"There's lots of places, creative, safe places, where we can put young people other than behind bars. They're the sort of resources we need more of."

Inspector Glen Nalder said it was "not uncommon" for youth aged 14 to 16 to be remanded into police custody in Christchurch.

There was a provision under the legislation allowing judges to do so, Nalder said.

"In general, it's a day at a time and it's reviewed daily by the court." 

Asked whether six days was unusual, Nalder said: "It's certainly longer than is desirable."

"Obviously the welfare of young persons is foremost in our minds when they are in our detention."

Nalder said youth were kept separate from adult prisoners. They were given access to reading material and were able to receive visitors.

He declined to comment about Christchurch's youth justice facility, Te Puna Wai, or the motivation behind the judge's comments.

The judge criticised the "mothballing" of a wing Te Puna Wai, located near Rolleston, south of Christchurch.

CYF spokesman Phil Dinham said the wing was not mothballed, but only 30 of the facility's 40 beds were operational.

"We are aware of judges' concerns about placing young people in cells and we will be meeting with them soon to discuss their concerns and work on solutions. We will also be meeting with police."

CYF was also working to increase the number of youth beds available, he said.

"The fourth unit at Te Puna Wai o Tuhinapo in Christchurch is one of a number of options for increasing our capacity, and we are exploring this."

 - Stuff


Ad Feedback
special offers

Party's $100K damage bill video

The walls of the house were tagged and riddled with holes.

An open invite on Facebook, an empty house and the trail of destruction caught on video.

Woman hit by car dies

A woman is dead after being hit by car in Northland overnight.

A 67-year-old woman is dead after being hit by a car near Kaikohe.

'Business as usual' soon video

Tanker HMNZS Endeavour is back on standby because of Auckland's ground fuel re-supply efforts, Judith Collins said.

Energy Minister Judith Collins says Auckland airport's fuel crisis is coming to end.

Connecting through memories

Year 5 Albany Primary School pupil Yash Arora, 10, said the game was fun for residents and students.

Albany Primary pupils are taking part in a programme to form connections with older adults with dementia.


How the sevens were lost

In total, less than 18,000 spectators attended the Wellington Sevens across both days - the stadium's capacity is 32,500.

Organisers were in losing battle for an event Wellington had fallen out of love with, emails show.

Sunny stroll to vote

The sun is shining in most of the country on election day (file photo).

Most of the country has a good chance of sunshine on election day.

Fire victim's protest

A cordon was put up outside Parliament after the man set himself alight.

Man who died after setting himself alight had been in dispute with Family Court.

Parties for the nearly departed video

Ken Turner and partner Sarah Angus.
Ken has terminal cancer and held a "living wake" for family and friends last weekend.

"Living wakes" have become a final festivity of life in the face of death.


'This can never happen again'

Neil Jones died after what the coroner called an "appalling" failure of care by the Canterbury District Health Board in 2013.

Neil Jones was more than a homeless alcoholic left at a bus stop. He was a father, a son, a brother and a friend.

Flaws in Watson case video

Ben Smart and Olivia Hope disappeared in the Marlborough Sounds in 1998.

Even now, almost 20 years on, Guy Wallace still has moments when he racks his brain for details lost to time.

A lifetime of compassion

Pauliina at her home in Little River.

Doctor in a rural African village, psychiatrist, language buff and art history graduate – Pirkko Verrier Jones was a woman of varied talents.

New shops and foodcourt planned

A new foodcourt and seating areas for diners will be added at the southern end of Northlands mall.

Christchurch's Northlands Mall is planning to embark on another extension.


Lisa Vanin places at WOW

The Cloak of Pīwakawaka, by Lisa Vanin, onstage on Friday night.

Cambridge designer Lisa Vanin places second in the Aotearoa section at WOW.

'Wave saved my life' video

McCoy surfing Kandui in the Mentawai Islands, Indonesia, where he was for four months before coming home to New Zealand.

GRAPHIC CONTENT: Doctors patching up a surfer after accident discover brain tumour.

Bar robbed at gunpoint

Two armed with guns robbed the Waikato Club at midnight on Friday.

They were wielding guns when they burst into a King Country bar at midnight.

Kiwis face airbag 'time bomb'

The replacement part that is being fitted to faulty airbags.

Tens of thousands of Kiwi drivers are putting themselves at risk by ignoring airbag recall.


Living on with a head injury

Riki Hoeata has found success in smoothies after having to move on from rugby.

Former rugby lock tackles healthier life after concussion forces him to move on from the sport he loves most.

Three siblings guilty

Having no money was a factor for Benjamin Hayes, who stole cars and committed burglaries in June and July this year. ...

A unusual court session provided a glimpse into what drives people to turn to crime.

Unlocking dementia's secrets video

11092017 News Photo ANDY JACKSON/STUFF.  The Ticking Timebomb, a series looking at the rising issues of alzheimers ...

Dementia has a terrible effect on many Kiwi lives, and the situation will get worse. 

Sir Richard's award

Sir Richard Faull holds up his "second brain", as he explained to the students at New Plymouth Boys' High that they were ...

"If you're a plumber, be the best plumber in the world, if you're a jet pilot, be the best jet pilot in the world."


Law career comes to an end

Peter Coles talks to reporters after Ewen Macdonald is declined parole in 2013.

The curtain is coming down on the legal career of a canny courtroom operator.

Teachers investigated

One teacher has been struck off and two others are under investigation after behaving inappropriately towards students. ...

One teacher struck off and two others investigated for inappropriate relationships with students.

Dairy robbery terror

The Rangiora Mini Mart was targeted by robbers in December and May.

Armed bandits make off with $7000 worth of loot, including 175 packets of cigarettes.

Welcome to town: Colyton video

Dairy cows and cattle make up a good portion of the Colyton population.

The small settlement isn't a dream destination for tourists, but it keeps good time.


WOW tribute to late designer

The Art of New York City created by Martin de Ruyter, Karen Stade and Troy Stade, modelled by Nicole Gibson.

The memory of a young designer who took out the World of WearableArt Awards top prize is being kept alive in a garment at this year's finals.

Death of a gentleman

Ron Brinsdon, pictured in 2005, on his dawn can collection run in Hardy St. He and a friend would flatten the cans and ...

Homeless man Ron Brinsdon died after collapsing in Nelson. Behind the familiar face was a hidden story.

Hansen to give Havili ABs shot?

David Havili has reached a point where his coach feels he is now comfortable in the All Black environment.

Is it time to hand David Havili his debut against Argentina?

Flaws in Sounds murder case video

Ben Smart and Olivia Hope disappeared in the Marlborough Sounds in 1998.

Some things come to mind easily in the Scott Watson case, then it gets murky.


Flaws in Sounds murder case video

Ben Smart and Olivia Hope disappeared in the Marlborough Sounds in 1998.

Some things come to mind easily in the Scott Watson case, then it gets murky - not just because it's decades on.

New boat in the post

Jim and Amanda Baillie are the ninth owners of the Pelorus Mail Boat in 100 years. The new boat will be revealed next ...

For a century, the mail boat has provided a vital link to families cloistered in secluded bays.

Best foot forward for Alzheimers

Barry Brown of Blenheim led last year's memory walk, and will be back with his bagpipes for Alzheimers Marlborough this year.

Blenheim bagpiper Barry Brown will call the tune once again for Alzheimers Marlborough's Memory Walk.

New life on the Kaikōura seabed

Life returns to areas of the Kaikōura Canyon where nothing existsed after the November earthquake. The picture shows a ...

The Kaikōura earthquake caused a violent current that swept away seabed life, but it is coming back.

South Canterbury

Hydro 'dangerous'

Timaru's Hydro Grand Hotel has been assessed as being a dangerous building likely to cause injury or death.

Damning report says Hydro Grand is dangerous, likely to cause injury or death.

Time to spring forward

Butcher Jim Bower's early mornings will be even darker and busier when Daylight Saving kicks in on Sunday.

Dust off the barbecue, it's time for long evenings as Daylight Savings starts.

Gully change approved

An aerial view of Broughs Gully, in the Timaru suburb of Oceanview.

The Brough's Gully site could yield at least 180 sections if the decision survives appeal.

Timaru's next tourism attraction?

In May a High Court Judge ruled the Rangatira be sold to pay off more than $170,000 owed to PrimePort.

Fisherman hopes community will save ship with Hollywood connection from the scrap heap.


Person dead after Dunedin fire

The fire was in one unit in a block of four.

A Dunedin flat where a person was found dead was well ablaze when firefighters arrived.

Woman rescued, police thank app

A Christchurch woman was found on Ben Lomond, near Queenstown, about 12am on Friday.

A Christchurch woman was rescued from a Queenstown mountain after her husband tracked her location through a phone app.

Eyes to the sky in Alexandra

Neil Sutherland, who lives at the Alexandra Airport at his hanger, will be displaying his home-built plane at the Wings ...

It's not every day planes down the main street of Alexandra.

Budding booze baron busted

Richard Gray in the Dunedin District Court

A Dunedin man says he feels better after he was busted for selling home brew to two teens who later ended up in hospital.


Prendergast wants dialogue before ministerial review

John Prendergast, former chief executive of the Community Trust of Southland.

"An independent set of eyes transparently reviewing and reporting publicly on this matter would be very beneficial ..."

Where is Amber-Lee?

Amber-Lee Cruickshank, pictured age one, went missing on October 17, 1992.

Police travelled to Australia looking for answers about what happened to toddler Amber-Lee Cruickshank 25 years ago.

Fighting for those who can't

Southland Boys's High School student  Malachi Agnew, 12, in front, has organised students at his school to have a mufti ...

When Malachi Agnew is rasing money he's trying to save the lives of his mates.

Ballet etiquette 101

I've seen Romeo and Juliet, I don't need the story narrated to me.

OPINION: I love a trip to the ballet but not when the person behind me can't stop talking.

Ad Feedback