High-flying women lose money in secret spiritual movement with 'hallmarks of pyramid scheme'

MARTIN DE RUYTER/FAIRFAX NZ

Fran Halford of Nelson talks about why she is speaking out about Circle.

New Zealand women are losing thousands of dollars to so-called women's gifting circles that purport to offer friendship and spiritual guidance but have all the hallmarks of a pyramid scheme. 

The Commerce Commission is warning women to steer clear of the circles, which claim to be women's empowerment groups that have the power to transform lives.

The leaders invite women to make a one-off gift ranging from US$1500 to $5000, and when eight women are eventually recruited the leader of the group can take the entire cash gift. If they are unable to recruit others the groups can collapse. 

Soreya James says gifting circles transform lives.

Soreya James says gifting circles transform lives.

About 100 New Zealand women are known to have been conscripted, under strict instructions to keep it "private". Some have been able to live off the proceeds of the gifting; others have been left thousands of dollars out of pocket and considering legal action. 

READ MORE:
* Spiritually transmitted disease – the poison lotus
'Naive' investors claim $650,000 lost to suspected Ponzi
Is Herbalife a pyramid scheme? Billionaires at odds over the question

The Commerce Commission confirmed it has received four complaints about gifting circles. Stuff has published a three-month investigation into the circles by journalist Anke Richter.

David White

Once she learned more about Circle, Kattia Wong decided she no longer wanted to be part of it.

Numerous former members of the circle have identified self-proclaimed wellness expert Soreya James (also known as Sheree Carbery) as being at the centre of the circles. 

James, 45, was one of the first women to join the circle, when it came to New Zealand more than three years ago. In that time she has completed five circles, but says rumours she lives off the proceeds are exaggerated.

Persuaded to speak publicly for the first time, she said she had received less than $100,000 from the circles.

Fran Halford, a Nelson doctor, spoke out about the Lotus women's gifting circles last year and likened them to a pyramid ...
MARTIN DE RUYTER/STUFF

Fran Halford, a Nelson doctor, spoke out about the Lotus women's gifting circles last year and likened them to a pyramid scheme.

In an interview at her unpretentious Mt Maunganui apartment, James said she lived modestly and at times had been on a benefit or living "hand to mouth" to make ends meet. 

"Women have perceived that I have received a lot more than I have ... There have been times where I have received, but I have also given a lot in this work. I've backed quite a few women and I've gifted other women.

Ad Feedback

"The money I've received from this is to support my family in a time of need, it's not like I've bought an apartment. Financially I'm not struggling, but I'm not wealthy by any means." 

"This supports women to live a much more abundant lifestyle and still do what they love to do – write their books or create their music," she continued.

"Conceptually, women understand giving and receiving. That's who we are, that's our nature. Men understand paying for things and investing in things."  

"This is not a pyramid scheme because a pyramid scheme is when somebody receives more and more and more money at the top … and the people at the bottom really struggle.

"But there's nobody at the top, there's no hierarchy. There's no leader, there's no organisation, there's no management,  and there's no woman anywhere, collectively, that is receiving more money than anybody else, and that's the difference." 

Women who have escaped the circles have a different story. "It's a spiritually-transmitted disease," Fran Halford told Richter.

The Nelson doctor was told she would enter a circle as a Seed, then move on to Sapling, then Blossom and finally be a Lotus herself to receive her gift of US$40,000 (NZ$56,000) from eight new women, plus coaching and sisterly support on the weekly group calls online.

Halford was urged to keep it private, especially from men, and told not to read anything online about the circles. "They had this evangelical glow and chased me hard. I trusted them."

She took out a bank loan to join a circle. She lost it all, but is more disappointed at her own gullibility.

Another woman, 45-year-old Auckland fashion designer Kattia Wong, decided to walk away from her circle and her money after reading criticisms online.

"I was so stressed I couldn't sleep," she told Richter. "They are twisting spirituality for personal gain. They have lied to me by saying it is legal and not a pyramid scheme. Many women would not join in the first place if they knew the truth."

The Commerce Commission says the gifting circles have the hallmarks of a pyramid scheme. The Commission was aware of at least one circle that required a $5000 buy-in, competition general manager Antonia Horrocks said. 

"Gifting circles first emerged in North America and are reported to have operated as pyramid schemes. We haven't investigated the New Zealand incarnations at this time and we don't have information to suggest these circles are common or widespread," Horrocks said.

"However, we strongly advise New Zealanders not join up. Hallmarks of pyramid schemes are that they require continued recruitment of new members, who have to pay to join, and there is an expectation members will eventually profit from being involved. These schemes collapse and those at the bottom lose their money. In addition, anyone operating or promoting a pyramid scheme risks prosecution."

Although the Commission has received complaints they were not investigating the circles. 

Most women spoken to who had been part of a circle asked not to be named because they were embarrassed and fearful of the repercussions of their name being associated with the circles, and expected a backlash from the women who had been successful at them. 

Others felt guilty that women who had scraped their money together as a gift, were later left penniless. 

One Auckland professional, a manager, was considering consulting a lawyer after losing US$5000 to a circle leader. The woman had backed out of the circle but the leader had made tens of thousands of dollars off the group. 

She warned women to do their research if they were invited into a group.

"I would say look, this happened to me, and I wouldn't recommend that to you. If you research it more thoroughly you will find it will fall over and people will lose out," she said.

"I would say it's a bad investment but a good learning experience. I met some good people, but I'm not sure if it was worth that much money."  

James insisted she felt a sense of responsibility to the women who had lost money in the scheme, but said those women wrongly believed the circle was an investment. She said it was women who were focused on the financial benefit rather than the personal gain who often lost out. 

"The ones that generally leave circle at the ones there for the money only."​

 - Sunday Star Times

Ad Feedback
special offers
Auckland

Man dead after crash

The Highway is closed in both directions following the crash.

A man has died and another person taken to hospital with serious injuries after a three-car crash in Kumeu, West Auckland.

Dog walker hit by car

Auckland's Tamaki Drive is a busy thoroughfare.

Woman critically injured and one of her dogs dead after being hit by car near Auckland yacht club.

NZ's 'face of poverty' video

Lynley Beazley says she would not be able to survive without food parcels from The Salvation Army.

Lynlie Beazley has $22 a week left for food. It's been two years since she ate fresh fruit.

Gang beneficiary runs $6m property video

Head Hunters east chapter president Wayne Doyle (file photo).

Notorious gang leader believed to the target of major police operation.

Wellington

'Gay village' vetoes church union

Sara Rimmer, left, and Alexandra Saunders were refused a church wedding in St Peter's Anglican Church in Paekākāriki, on ...

Paekākāriki is known for being liberal. But not when it came to Alex and Sara's wedding.

Winds close hill road

The Rimutaka Hill Road was closed due to high winds on Monday night.

Strong winds cause closure of SH2 over Rimutaka Hill, and disrupt flights.

Who'll be Lester's new 2IC?

Wellington Mayor Justin Lester, right, will announce his replacement for Deputy Mayor Paul Eagle within the next ...

Councillor with less than a year's experience in the mix to be new deputy mayor.

Turfed out by Wellington's wind video

Karori artificial turf blown away.

Contractors laid artificial turf in Karori, but underestimated the capital's infamous breeze.

Canterbury

Christchurch rolls out red carpet video

The Changeover's two leads. Kiwi Erana James plays Laura Chant, while British actor Nicholas Galitzine plays Sorensen ...

The stars were out for the premiere of The Changeover, based on Margaret Mahy's spooky novel.

$3.4m budget blowout

Christchurch City Council chief executive Karleen Edwards. The council has overspent by $3.4 million on personnel, ...

The council's spend on personnel has blown out by $3.4m – mainly due to hiring consultants to fill vacancies.

Whitebaiter river death 'tragic'

Helen Wood died at Kairaki Beach, in North Canterbury, on Friday night. The beach is popular with fishers and ...

Helen Wood reversed her trailer onto the beach before her car went into the river with her inside.

Sex worker bylaw faces axe

Police no longer support a bylaw preventing prostitutes working in residential areas. Christchurch City Council staff ...

Residents enraged at council back-down from banning sex work outside their homes.

Waikato

Preparing for peak kitten

Waikato SPCA expects to help at least 3000 animals this calendar year, many of them kittens.

Breeding season is getting longer and this year is expected to be the busiest yet.

Search for fisherman

Police and the coastguard looking for a missing fisherman at Papanui Point at Ruapuke.

Emergency services are searching for person who fell into the water at Ruapuke, near Raglan.

Powered parachute crashes

The powered parachute crashed on takeoff.

Man in powered parachute crashed on take-off, hitting a metal bollard.

Man struck by tree dies

The man was out chainsawing trees when one fell and struck him. He died at the scene.

Man chainsawing on a rural Coromandel property has died after a tree fell on him.

Taranaki

New lattes: Novelty or nutritional?

Turmeric and beetroot lattes are becoming popular but won't be replacing anyone's flat white or cappuccino any time soon.

Turmeric and beetroot lattes are trendy and tasty but aren't a miracle health cure.

'Undesirable' gully

Martin Moeller goes through Lucy Gully a few times a week and is disappointed that it has become a dumping ground.

A scenic redwood forest in Egmont National Park is becoming a dumping ground, a neighbour says.

'I want my pig back'

The wild pig that had been wandering around New Plymouth has been caught and will be taken to live on a farm.

A suburban sow gone wild has been caught, but her owner will huff and puff for the return of the piggy, pig, pig.

Taranaki lifesavers scoop awards

Todd Velvin won the DHL Instructor of the year award at the Surf Life Saving awards.

Todd Velvin, DHL Instructor of the Year, says surf lifesaving is "pretty hard" to give up.

Manawatu

Loud jets irk residents video

Sanson resident Bill Tooley points to where fighter jets have been flying over his home.

Could howling pets and shaking houses become the new norm in Sanson?

Gorge options given

The 13 alternative route options are available for public viewing and comment on the NZTA website.

Thirteen alternative routes to the Manawatū Gorge have been laid out for the public to discuss.

Immigration fraud

Mohammad Khan was under pressure from family when committing immigration fraud, the Palmerston North District Court heard.

His mother was denied entry to New Zealand eight times, so he lied to authorities to get her in.

Fletcher Reinforcing expands

Fletcher Reinforcing Levin branch manager Donny Smith and administrator Jen Syme at the company's Main Rd South site.

Fletcher Reinforcing's Levin branch is to hire 25 new staff.

Nelson

Revved up over hobby

04092017 NEWS PHOTO BRADEN FASTIER / STUFF
Preston Brunell of Stoke Mechanical and Tyres.

Nelson man Preston Brunell has got plenty of mileage from his lifelong love of custom cars.

New marine frontiers

Dr Serean Adams, Cawthron aquaculture group manager at the Cawthron Aquaculture Park.

New species and technologies will increase resilience of aquaculture stock for the future, industry told.

Life-changing loss

15092017 NEWS PHOTO BRADEN FASTIER / NELSON MAIL
Margaret Lacy holds a picture of her late husband Peter Lacy who had ...

Dementia affects tens of thousands of Kiwis, eventually taking everything from them.

Wet spring for region

It's been a wet September in the Nelson/Tasman region, with higher than average rainfall.

Spring starts out on the wrong foot in Nelson but it's not all bad news.

Marlborough

Love is wild

Rebecca Stoner, a florist at Forget Me Not, left, and Jessica Bunting, designer at Betty and Co, work on one of their al ...

It can be pretty wild trying to organise a wedding, especially these days.

Looking to the future

National's Stuart Smith, centre, celebrates with his family, from left, Hugo Smith, Fenella Smith, Julie Smith and Louis ...

As results are revealed, what's next for the winners and losers?

Librarian appeals apology order

Former Rai Valley Area School librarian Faye Leov in 2010 after receiving an apology from the school board for her ...

A former school librarian behind a defamatory letter claiming her former boss was a bully is to appeal a judge's decision to make her apologise.

Care switch 'upsetting'

Pamela Duffy has built up a close relationship with her carers, who will no longer be visiting her at home after the ...

For the past two years, she has built up a relationship with her carers. Next week, she may never see them again.

South Canterbury

Craigmore a designer's 'dream' video

Olympian Jock Paget is being hosted at Craigmore Station for the first fundraising event for a proposed new eventing course.

Olympian throws support behind proposed world class eventing course at Craigmore Station.

Fine weather back

A severe weather warning was in place for heavy winds in Canterbury on Monday morning.

The majority of South Canterbury is expected to have fine weather on Tuesday.

Call for model plane size limits

South Canterbury Model Aero Club vice-president Robbie Hellewell launches his Parkzone Visionair AS3X aircraft into the ...

Safety concerns prompt SC Aero Club to call for more rules around model aeroplanes.

Mechanics recall bygone era

Former workmates, from left, Bernie Foster, Allan Averis and Gordon Hutcheon check out some of the old tractor models ...

Three former Timaru colleagues take a trip down memory lane.

Otago

Fire victim's family 'gutted'

A Housing New Zealand house where the body of a man was found after a fire.

Heartbroken family speaks of their devastation in losing their father in a house fire.

False alarms go off due to thunder

A thunder and lightning storm hit Queenstown and Central Otago on Monday morning.

Lightning and thunder storm cuts keep fire brigade volunteers busy in Queenstown.

Family 'wrecked' as search suspended

Police are still appealing for sightings of missing Dunedin man Stephen Lowe.

The search for missing man Stephen Lowe has been suspended.

Two MPs for Clutha-Southland

Clutha-Southland New Zealand First candidate Mark Patterson watches his leader Winston Peters, give his coalition speech ...

Clutha-Southland has a new New Zealand First MP, Lawrence farmer Mark Patterson.

Southland

Meridian 'flooding my family farm' video

Looking out over the Hollyburn creek which has been flooded by water from the Waiau river.

Every time Meridian Energy releases the Manapouri dam, Thomas O'Brien loses another chunk of farmland.

Family 'wrecked' as search suspended

Police are still appealing for sightings of missing Dunedin man Stephen Lowe.

The search for missing man Stephen Lowe has been suspended.

And then there were four

Mark Patterson: secure at 7th.

Southland will have four MPs. How much influence is that?

South's election night

It was all smiles for Invercargill MP Sarah Dowie, pictured here with her husband Mark Billcliff.

Invercargill will have two MPs in Parliament, Labour's Liz Craig and National's Sarah Dowie.

Ad Feedback