No deal on Christ Church Cathedral before Christmas video

Stuff.co.nz

The Christ Church Cathedral restoration deal misses deadline.

Central city landowners and developers are frustrated at further delays on a deal to restore the Christ Church Cathedral.

An agreement to restore the quake-damaged cathedral in central Christchurch will not be made before Christmas.

Anglicans had previously stated there would be an announcement on the future of the cathedral before December 25 this year.

No announcement will be made on the future of the Christ Church Cathedral before Christmas after parties failed to reach ...
GRANT MATTHEW

No announcement will be made on the future of the Christ Church Cathedral before Christmas after parties failed to reach an agreement.

The Government and Anglican property trustees were unable to agree on the terms of a deal that would see the cathedral in central Christchurch restored, Stuff understands.

The talks may have faltered because the Government this week changed the terms of the deal, it is understood.

READ MORE:
New Cabinet considering Christ Church Cathedral restoration plans
Christ Church Cathedral announcement before Christmas
Cathedral working group investigate restoration
Govt announces 'working party' for cathedral
Anglican Bishop returns to NZ to consider cathedral plans - sources

A spokeswoman for Greater Christchurch Regeneration Minister Gerry Brownlee said the Government contribution to cathedral restoration had not altered.

"The Crown contribution has not changed," she said.

A statement from the Anglican diocese said Bishop Victoria Matthews was "greatly saddened" a deal could not be reached this year "given the tireless work of the Cathedral Working Group and Church Property Trustees and staff".

The statement said that on Tuesday Matthews and trustees were "sure there would be a positive announcement in this week before Christmas".

Ad Feedback

​"The trustees will keep working towards a resolution in the new year," Matthews said.

A Brownlee spokeswoman said the talks had not collapsed and would continue next year.

"While nothing has been concluded at this stage, discussions will resume in the new year," the spokeswoman said.

Christchurch developers were frustrated at the delay. City Owners Rebuild Entity chairman and developer Ernest Duval said landowners were back to the "waiting game".

"People were hoping to get some level of closure by the end of the year so they could have certainty in the new year," he said.

"We are approaching six years now and that should be enough time to make a decision on which way to go."

Property developer Miles Yeoman owns the former Press building site on Cathedral Square. He said he would not develop the site until a cathedral decision was made.

"It is frustrating that a decision can't be made. It is not that hard. We have built 14 buildings in the last five years and had to battle bureaucracy."

It is understood church trustees are hopeful of a resolution in the new year. Trustees met several times this week to try and reach a restoration deal before Christmas.

Great Christchurch Buildings Trust co-chairman Jim Anderton, who has campaigned to restore the building, said the delay was disappointing.

"We have to be optimistic. [The delay] is not a matter of whether restoration is viable, it is a matter of funding, I think."

Restoration options for the cathedral were considered by Prime Minister Bill English's new cabinet on Tuesday. The options were proposed by a working group formed by the Government in June to break the deadlock over the cathedral.

After the cabinet meeting, Brownlee said talks were continuing with the Anglican diocese.

"Proposals from the working group were considered by cabinet today, however discussions continue with the church property trustees," he said.

"Details about what was discussed at cabinet will remain confidential."

The working group was tasked with finding a solution for the cathedral, which has been sitting derelict in central Christchurch for nearly six years since the deadly earthquake that struck the city on February 22, 2011.

It was asked to identify "feasible, achievable and fully-costed options to progress the reinstatement of the Christ Church Cathedral".

Working group chairman Geoff Dangerfield said in September that "reinstatement" meant a "mixture of restoration, repair and rebuild".

The group made non-binding recommendations on the building to the Government and Anglican church trustees on November 28.

In November, the Anglican church posted a statement on its website saying an announcement would be made before Christmas.

"Because of the travel commitments of both Bishop Victoria Matthews and Minister Gerry Brownlee, any announcement will not be made until the second half of December."

Timeline:

October 2011 - Bishop Victoria Matthews announces cathedral will be deconsecrated and partially demolished.

November 2011 - Cathedral is deconsecrated.

December 2011 - Dean Peter Beck resigns.

February 2012 - Matthews calls cathedral a "very dangerous building" in a Press ad.

March 2012 - Matthews announces the cathedral will be partially demolished down to the windowsills.

April 2012 - Demolition of damaged cathedral tower commences.

July 2012 - Great Christchurch Buildings Trust (GCBT) claims cathedral could be restored safely and $50 million could be raised in private funding.

August 2012 - GCBT take Anglican church to High Court to stop demolition.

November 2012 - High Court preliminary ruling puts hold on demolition.

February 2013: Matthews says cathedral is "being left to die with no dignity" because of legal action.

April 2013 - Anglicans present three options for building - Restore, rebuild in modern style and rebuild in traditional style.

July 2013 - Court of Appeal gives Anglicans green light to demolish.

September 2013 - Anglicans choose to replace cathedral with new, modern building.

December 2013 - Supreme Court rejects appeal to preserve cathedral.

October 2015 - Mediator Miram Deans QC appointed by the Government to break cathedral deadlock.

December 2015 - Church leaders and government announce "reinstatement" of cathedral is being considered.

June 2016 - The Government appoints a working party to consider restoration options and break deadlock on cathedral.

November 2016 - Working party delivers non-binding restoration recommendations to the Government and Anglicans.

 - Stuff

Ad Feedback
special offers
Auckland

Pacific youth suicide risk

A study of Pacific suicide deaths over a 17-year period found boys aged between 12 and 18 were most at risk.

Young Pacific people three times more likely to attempt suicide than European youth, study shows.

Minority depression 'missed'

Despite reporting higher levels of distress and depression than New Zealand Europeans, Asian immigrants often go ...

Maori, Pacific and Asian Kiwis are more at risk of mental illness, but diagnosed less often than Europeans, study finds.

Probe into cop sex abuse claims

Police confirmed the officer faced a criminal investigation, but would not say whether he had been stood down.

Criminal investigation into woman's claims she was sexually abused by a senior policeman.

'Still numb and disbelieving'

Massey High School supplied this picture of Keenan Matthes, who died after being hit by a train on April 20.

School to hold celebration for star pupil tragically killed by a train while out running.

Wellington

Transmission Gully sneak peek video

The 27-kilometre, four-lane motorway will run inland between Wellington northern suburbs and Paekakariki on the Kapiti ...

After two million man hours, the highway north of Wellington still isn't halfway built.

Twin fires shock town

The backyard of Corrinne Oliver's home in Mauriceville. In the foreground is her daughter Chance's Yamaha motorbike.

Good neighbour tried to help a stranger. It cost her her home.

Sevens decision still pending video

No decision yet on whether Wellington's Westpac Stadium will be given another try at hosting the annual Sevens tournament.

Could a meeting in Tokyo next month say sayonara to Wellington's hosting rights?

Return of the cluster flies

Cluster fly larvae have had perfect conditions with the wet warm weather recently, and many people are finding the flies ...

It sounds like a horror movie plot - swarms of cluster flies besieging North Island homes.

Canterbury

Collapsed home survivor dies

Margaret Edgar, who was pulled from the rubble of the historic Elms Homestead after the Kaikoura earthquake in November, ...

Woman pulled from wreckage at Elms Homestead after Kaikoura quake has died.

'Calm' shark victim  video

The French tourist arrives at Dunedin Hospital by helicopter after she was attacked by a shark while bodyboarding in ...

A shark had the legs of a bodyboarding tourist in its mouth during an attack at a popular Southland surf spot.

The man who's 'addicted' to crime

Jason Goldsworthy has had 491 convictions in the past 25 years. (File photo)

With 491 convictions and 19 jail terms, prison "clearly isn't working". The judge has other plans.

'Swimmability' only part of story video

Freshwater quality debates largely focus on swimming, not what lives there 24/7.

ANALYSIS: The longfin eel, whitebait and lamprey. All are threatened, and it is our fault.

Waikato

Saving lives at 88 video

Bill Goodwin on duty back in 2010 with Sam Cowley.

Years ago they called the surf lifeguard Mr Goodie. But after 38 years on the beach, most just call him granddad.

Riders hit head-on

Traffic was backed up near the scene of the fatal crash north of Tokoroa.

Two motorcyclists who died in a crash with a tanker north of Tokoroa did not know each other.

Matariki-inspired waka sculpture

Lighting and sound on the sculpture will change based on information from a network of sensors.

An interactive steel structure is planned for Hamilton's Ferrybank precinct.

Trailer load of chips crashes

State Highway 27 is under Stop-go after a truck and trailer crashed.

A refrigerator truck full of frozen chips has overturned blocking part of a Waikato highway.

Taranaki

Dman and Ironman

Dinnie Moeahu aims to complete the Taupo Ironman on March 3,  2018.

He may hate running, but that won't stop Dinnie Moeahu becoming an Ironman.

Man, 72, offered child bribe for nude pics

On Thursday, a Taranaki man was sentenced in the New Plymouth District Court for asking a 10-year-old girl to supply ...

A 72-year-old man described his 10-year-old victim as "a sparkling lass".

Admitted together, staying together

Ann and Harry Smith do, quite literally, everything together. They were even admitted to Taranaki Base Hospital together ...

Man and wife who do "everything together" share an ambulance ride to hospital.

Balancing generosity and business

Joe's Garage general manager Candice Matthews.

One bad apple doesn't spoil the whole barrel, according to scammed restaurants.

Manawatu

Free al fresco films

Frozen proved popular on the big screen in The Square.

The Square transformed into an impromptu picture-palace, picnic ground and play area.

Work begins on slip video

Work began on the larger of the two slips in the Manawatu Gorge, on Thursday.

Work has finally begun to clear the large slip blocking the Manawatu Gorge.

Off the top of my dome

The aurora at Lake Rotoiti on April 23, captured by Nelson photographer Terry Urban.

Celestial bodies will soon be visible from Palmerston North once more.

Goodies for women

At an earlier Women's Expo, Sara Noaro, right, from Gorgeous, a fashion shop in Shannon, shows a dress to Amy Cousins ...

More than 140 stalls to tempt women shoppers and some men, at the women's expo.

Nelson

Soviet-era jet fighter up for sale

Alan Caudwell with his Aero Vodochody L-39C Albatros jet.

Is there something missing in your life? Say a jet that is capable of getting up to 750kmh?

Prison for $240k fraud

Candice Preston and her husband Phillip Walker were found guilty of benefit fraud worth nearly $330,000.

A couple stood in the dock together to be sentenced for "one of the highest ranking" NZ benefit frauds.

Hone sleeping ban plan

Protests such as this in the Nelson CBD will soon be subject to a permit process under a new council bylaw.

A proposed new bylaw out for public consultation bans sleeping in the CBD and requires permits for protests.

Aurora lights up Lake Rotoiti

The red light featured is the top of the aurora. The further south, the more yellow it gets.

A strong geomagnetic storm caused a rare Aurora Australis to be visible at Lake Rotoiti.

Marlborough

Property hunters turn to 'P houses'

This one-bedroom, one-bathroom house in Blenheim is going under the hammer with methamphetamine contamination.

As this "cosy" meth-ridden Blenheim flat shows, people know a bargain when they see one.

Yealands opts for trial

Peter Yealands won the Lincoln University Foundation's South Island Farmer of the Year in 2013. (File photo)

One of NZ's leading wine producers denies allegations he illegally dumped a winemaking byproduct.

Pokie scheme 'netted $1m a year'

Michael Joseph O'Brien was allegedly at the centre of a pokie machine grants scam.

Crown alleges true control was concealed to deceive gambling authorities.

One month, 25,000 meals

BV Gourmet second chef Chris Pearce makes pickled beetroot for harvest meals.

It's been a challenging harvest, not just for the vineyard workers, but for those who feed them. 

South Canterbury

'Negotiate or face another strike'

Support workers Nicola Johns and Debs Crowe gathered on Theodosia St, near The Bay Hill, to protest against stagnant pay ...

Protesting support staff give employer two options - start bargaining, or face another strike.

Westpac admits issues

The Westpac ATM, the ony one in Fairlie, which has broken down again this week.

Westpac admits service in Fairlie not up to scratch following complaints over ATM.

SCDHB emergency plans tested

SCDHB staff during the major incident program pictured were from left registered nurse Carla McFarlene and radiographer ...

DHB staff put through paces in plane crash scenario involving large influx of patients.

'Mindless acts of damage' costly

A heat pump was pushed off the roof of Twizel Area School.

Vandalism at Twizel Area School could cost thousands to repair.

Southland

Struggle after double shooting

Ben and Verity McLean.

The families of the victims are in shock, but say they're humbled by the outpouring of support and compassion.

Deputy mayor resigns

Cr Darren Ludlow.

Darren Ludlow has resigned as deputy mayor of Invercargill.

Shark attack video

The French tourist arrives at Dunedin Hospital by helicopter after she was attacked by a shark while bodyboarding in ...

A surfer has been attacked by a shark at a beach in the Catlins in Southland.

'A role-model family' video

Verity and Ben McLean.

Verity McLean was a "happy mum". Now she's dead and her husband accused of killing her.

Ad Feedback