'Racist' passport request riles New Zealand citizen of 10 years video

Gina Chompinitkul with her husband Volker Schroeter and her passport.
Warwick Smith/Fairfax NZ

Gina Chompinitkul with her husband Volker Schroeter and her passport.

A Palmerston North woman is alleging she was racially profiled by a health centre worker who said she didn't look like a Kiwi and asked for passport proof of her New Zealand citizenship.

But the health centre says the situation was a misunderstanding and checks were important to see if patients were eligible for government help.

Gina Chompinitkul, a New Zealand citizen of 10 years, was asked to provide proof of this on a visit to The Palms Medical Centre.

Warwick Smith/Stuff

Gina Chompinitkul was asked to provide her passport at The Palms Medical Centre as evidence of her New Zealand citizenship.

The staff member allegedly told the stunned woman and her husband only people who "look foreign" had to produce a passport.

NZ passport robot tells applicant of Asian descent 'open your eyes'
Citizenship confusion costs five-time community board member
Citizen rights and obligations

Chompinitkul, originally from Thailand, was unable to visit her usual family GP over the New Year period, so went to The Palms as a casual patient when she was suffering from a cold.

She said the service was fine until it became "uncomfortable" when she was asked to provide a passport to prove her citizenship, so she could receive a subsidy.

Chompinitkul supplied her New Zealand driver licence, but was told that wasn't enough.

She had never previously been asked produce a passport in New Zealand, nor does she carry it around with her. 

Her husband Volker Schroeter​ questioned the request and said they were told by the staff member everybody had to produce a passport.

Ad Feedback

"My question in return was, so what if John Smith, the fella from Feilding comes here? And then she said to us, 'well I know when somebody is a Kiwi. I can tell. Only people who look foreign have to produce a passport'.

"The point that we are making, and my wife felt quite humiliated about, was this expression of, well, I'd call it racism.

"Because you look foreign and because you speak with an accent, you must produce a passport."

The couple ended up agreeing to bring the passport back the next day.

Palms chief operations officer Bob Lissington​ said the whole issue had likely stemmed from a misunderstanding. 

While he couldn't comment on the alleged remarks of the receptionist, racial profiling wasn't part of the centre's way of operating, he said.

When a casual patient comes to the centre, it was policy to check their name against a national register that includes the patients of every GP in the country.

If their name doesn't show up, the receptionist will ask for an NHI number or a passport as proof of citizenship to show they're eligible for the government-subsidised rates.

"That's not an uncommon practice ... I think most New Zealanders would likely be up in arms if we didn't make sure people weren't getting something the weren't entitled to."

He said Chompinitkul's name might not have shown up, even if she was registered at another GP, because of a spelling error by either the Palms receptionist or when her name was first entered on the register. 

"[I understand] it must have been frustrating, and the receptionist could possibly have handled things better, but going forward there should be less misunderstandings like this."

 - Stuff

Ad Feedback
special offers

Bill puts fair pay further from reach

Education support workers in early childhood education could have a claim that they are underpaid because their ...

NZEI union says the new Pay Equity Bill will make it harder, not easier, to reduce the gender pay gap.

Injured after riding train

The man suffered life-threatening injuries after attempting to riding a train in Otahuhu.

Man has critical injuries after jumping onto moving train in south Auckland.

From McCartney to Auckland

Chinmaya Dunster said he was expecting about 50 people at the upcoming concert.

He played at Paul McCartney's wedding and now hosts Indian classical music concerts in west Auckland.

Southern lights anniversary treat

The aurora as captured by Alistair Bain.

The trip of a lifetime got even better when the heavens put on a thrilling display.


Economy needs immigration

Wellington Chamber of Commerce chief executive John Milford.

OPINION: Being able to hire someone with the necessary skills is essential for business.

'We have nothing left' 

The house in Cannons Creek, Porirua, was fully ablaze just after 9am on Thursday.

Vasati Lopati fought the flames engulfing her Porirua home, until the windows started exploding.

Makeover at the Amora

The Amora Hotel in  Wakefield St is to close for major renovation work.

Another Wellington hotel will be shut when the Lions tour hits town.

Welly named a top beer town

Wellington has attracted accolades for its craft beers.

There are three great places in Oceania to grab a bevvy, according to Lonely Planet.


A fault with a 'maverick streak'

Briar Taylor-Silva and Professor Mark Stirling in a trench across the Akatore Fault at Big Creek east of Milton.

The Akatore fault should be treated as a ''serious hazard'', geologists say.

Southland shark attack

The surfer was attacked about 2pm.

A surfer has been attacked by a shark at a beach in the Catlins in Southland.

Double shooting scenes searched

Verity and Ben McLean.

Police are searching a park, the alleged killer's home and the Invercargill shooting scene. 

Road rage to hospital assault

Police were called to reports of a man kicking another man in the head after a car crash in Woolston, Christchurch. ...

A man was taken to Christchurch Hospital after a road rage incident, only to be arrested for assaulting hospital security.


Matariki-inspired waka sculpture

Lighting and sound on the sculpture will change based on information from a network of sensors.

An interactive steel structure is planned for Hamilton's Ferrybank precinct.

Riders hit head-on

Traffic was backed up near the scene of the fatal crash north of Tokoroa.

Two motorcyclists who died in a crash with a tanker north of Tokoroa did not know each other.

Trailer load of chips crashes

State Highway 27 is under Stop-go after a truck and trailer crashed.

A refrigerator truck full of frozen chips has overturned blocking part of a Waikato highway.

Seeking closure after Tangiwai

Beryl Donovan holds a photo of her parents, Lance and Dorothy Redman, on their wedding day in 1943, before Lance died in ...

Their father gave his life to save others at Tangiwai - NZ's worst ever rail disaster.


Pair win Top Dog title

Consistency pays off for Taranaki dog trial champion.

Man, 72, offered child bribe for nude pics

On Thursday, a Taranaki man was sentenced in the New Plymouth District Court for asking a 10-year-old girl to supply ...

A 72-year-old man described his 10-year-old victim as "a sparkling lass".

Drink driver injures woman

A 20-year-old admitted to drinking before getting behind the wheel and causing an accident, which left a woman injured.

Driver admits to drinking vodka and "Chinese" alcohol before crashing his car.

Commercial turned suburban

Cambrian Engineering has called Carrington St home for 92 years, but has recently sold their site, which is rumoured to ...

Could the buyer of one of New Zealand's oldest engineering firms turn the lot into residential land?


Off the top of my dome

The aurora at Lake Rotoiti on April 23, captured by Nelson photographer Terry Urban.

Celestial bodies will soon be visible from Palmerston North once more.

Deputy mayor row

Horowhenua councillor Ross Campbell is accused by other councilors of breaching the code of conduct.

Horowhenua mayor Michael Feyen wants to change his deputy but can't.

Saddle Rd truck fire

Motorists should expect delays on Saddle Rd after a truck and trailer unit broke down.

Driver escapes with minor injuries as break-down causes delays.

Dog bites cop

A pit bull dog has been hidden by its owner after it attacked a police officer.

A pit bull is in hiding after it chomped into a police officer's arm.


Prison for $240k fraud

Candice Preston and her husband Phillip Walker were found guilty of benefit fraud worth nearly $330,000.

A couple stood in the dock together to be sentenced for "one of the highest ranking" NZ benefit frauds.

Hone sleeping ban plan

Protests such as this in the Nelson CBD will soon be subject to a permit process under a new council bylaw.

A proposed new bylaw out for public consultation bans sleeping in the CBD and requires permits for protests.

Aurora lights up Lake Rotoiti

The red light featured is the top of the aurora. The further south, the more yellow it gets.

A strong geomagnetic storm caused a rare Aurora Australis to be visible at Lake Rotoiti.

Power out in Mapua

Jellyfish Cafe and Bar owner Debbie Lavery puts a closed sign on the popular venue because of the power failure in Mapua ...

Mapua is without any electricity after a fire in a powerbox, forcing businesses to close.


Property hunters turn to 'P houses'

This one-bedroom, one-bathroom house in Blenheim is going under the hammer with methamphetamine contamination.

As this "cosy" meth-ridden Blenheim flat shows, people know a bargain when they see one.

Yealands opts for trial

Peter Yealands won the Lincoln University Foundation's South Island Farmer of the Year in 2013. (File photo)

One of NZ's leading wine producers denies allegations he illegally dumped a winemaking byproduct.

Pokie scheme 'netted $1m a year'

Michael Joseph O'Brien was allegedly at the centre of a pokie machine grants scam.

Crown alleges true control was concealed to deceive gambling authorities.

One month, 25,000 meals

BV Gourmet second chef Chris Pearce makes pickled beetroot for harvest meals.

It's been a challenging harvest, not just for the vineyard workers, but for those who feed them. 

South Canterbury

Super friendly clash for Timaru

Crusaders supporter Toby Carpenter (left) and Highlanders supporter Olly George both think their team will win the Super ...

Crusaders and Highlanders fans are in for a treat when the two sides clash in Timaru in July.

Westpac admits issues

The Westpac ATM, the ony one in Fairlie, which has broken down again this week.

Westpac admits service in Fairlie not up to scratch following complaints over ATM.

Not just a 'little church committee'

South Canterbury branch member of the National Council of Women Prue Thirkettle, left, branch president Robin Peterson, ...

The National Council of Women SC is determined to keep an eye on council business.

Park extension mulled

DOC is looking to expand the Aoraki/Mt Cook National Park boundaries to include Godley and Tasman braided riverbeds.

Discussions underway to expand Aoraki/Mt Cook National Park boundary.


Double shooting: Three scenes searched

Verity and Ben McLean.

Police are searching a park, the alleged killer's home and the Invercargill shooting scene.

Shark attack

The surfer was attacked about 2pm.

A surfer has been attacked by a shark at a beach in the Catlins in Southland.

'A role-model family' video

Verity and Ben McLean.

Verity McLean was a "happy mum". Now she's dead and her husband accused of killing her.

Cop's murder charge

Constable Ben McLean has been an officer in Invercargill since 2007.

Officer charged with murder handed himself in at the police station 40 minutes after the deadly shooting.

Ad Feedback