To smell a dead rat: Tenant wins stinking rodent corpse dispute video


Tenant Stuart MacIntosh of Aro Valley took property managers to court, and won, after saying the smell of dead rats in his flat was too disgusting.

A man who took property managers to court in a dispute about dead rats has won a payout.

Stuart MacIntosh's case triggered a smell test last year, involving pest experts and a special "site visit" from Wellington Tenancy Tribunal adjudicator Brent Smallbone.

MacIntosh moved into the Aro Valley house last February. But things soon turned putrid, and he told managers Quinovic that a "nauseating smell" was wafting from one or more suspected rat corpses.

MacIntosh says tenants stuck in seemingly intractable (or stinky) disputes with property managers should consider the ...

MacIntosh says tenants stuck in seemingly intractable (or stinky) disputes with property managers should consider the Tenancy Tribunal.

The tribunal said Quinovic ignored advice from PestProof (PPL) experts who offered to place bait stations for the price of $80 plus GST each quarter.

To smell a dead rat, tribunal adjudicator will personally visit tenant's home
Experts sniff for clues at special kitchen hearing in Wellington over 'rat'

"If there is a dead rat carcass of some type, it will decay and the smell will disappear soon," the property manager told MacIntosh in March.

MacIntosh said uninvited rodent flatmates died under the kitchen floorboards and in his roof, making the house ...

MacIntosh said uninvited rodent flatmates died under the kitchen floorboards and in his roof, making the house practically uninhabitable.

But the rancid smell resurfaced in September, MacIntosh said, as his unwanted house guests expired after squeezing into crawlspaces, walls or the ceiling.

MacIntosh told Quinovic there were rats scampering around, "and the noise of what sounded like a rat giving birth".

"He complained of a rotting smell that he believed to be a rotting rat placenta," Smallbone wrote in the tribunal decision.

MacIntosh claimed inadequate property management enabled the rodents to move in, and a tribunal hearing went ahead on October 18, in which MacIntosh claimed three weeks' rent.

Ad Feedback

But the subjective nature of smell meant a field trip was the only way to confirm whether the property truly stank.

The next day, two PPL employees familiar with the house visited with Smallbone and Quinovic staff.

One PPL worker could not smell a rat. But the other reported a definite carcass stench.

In his order, Smallbone said Quinovic responded promptly each time MacIntosh alerted it about rat smells.

But the firm was chided for not heeding pest controllers' advice. "It is a fact that Quinovic did not do what PPL recommended to avoid rats dying in the premises."

There were three times when MacIntosh had problems with the dying rat stench, Smallbone decided.

Because the smell affected only part of the house, he awarded two-thirds of the amount sought, ordering Quinovic to pay $526.44.

This week, MacIntosh said he was largely satisfied with the outcome, but the saga made him somewhat "averse" to dealing with property management companies.

He advised other tenants trapped in disputes to take grievances to the tribunal.

The Quinovic property manager confirmed on Thursday that the company had paid MacIntosh.

"It is what it is. The adjudicator ruled. What they ruled, they ruled."

MacIntosh said he would stay at the property, at least for now.

 - Stuff

Ad Feedback
special offers

Student reaching for stars

Anushka Kharbanda, 16, is one of four young Kiwis going to the 2017 USA Space Camp in Huntsville Alabama.

Anushka Kharbanda is one of four Kiwis headed to a US space camp.

Suburb gave peace a chance

Protesters gather at North Head, Devonport in the 1980s.

Seaside Devonport on Auckland's North Shore celebrates leading the country toward its nuclear-free status.

Maori actor returns to roots

Roimata Fox is excited to return to the Maori world in upcoming play Te Puhi.

Roimata Fox stars in a Maori coming of age drama that looks at New Zealand's first beauty queens in the 1960s.

Father and son will perform together for first time

Father and son Barry and Daniel Robinson will take to the stage together for the first time on Friday.

A father and son duo will play brothers in an upcoming theatre production, and it will be the first time they have performed together.


Funeral for fallen rugby player video

Daniel Baldwin's brothers Markus, left, and Stefan lead the casket with parents Len and Eva following behind.

Hundreds farewell Daniel Baldwin, who died after playing the game he loved.

'Beware of light rail'

An artist's impression of what light rail advocates hoped trams running along Lambton Quay would look like.

Engineering expert warns of dangers of preserving light rail route for the capital.

Fraudster's mercy plea

Jenna Davidson is asking the High Court to reduce her two years and nine month jail term to home detention.

Fraudster needed gentleness, not a savage sentence, says lawyer.

Elderly fugitive appears in court

William Harding is accused of fraud.

Alleged conman William Harding, 77, had been on the run from police.


Lions' fans may skip south

Christchurch hosted a test match in 2005 when Welsh Lions Fan Simon Mathias tested his ball skills in Cathedral Square.

South Island centres unlikely to cash in on the Lions tour, with only a few hundred campervans to cross Cook Strait.

Honey factory ablaze

Fire crews are responding to a fire at a honey factory.

Firefighters are battling a blaze at a North Canterbury honey factory.

Fatal crash in Dunedin

A van and truck have crashed on Saddle Hill Rd, near Dunedin.

One person is dead after a crash on the Dunedin Southern Motorway.

Boozed driver, 164kmh

A man driving a Volkswagen Golf was clocked at 164kmh on Christchurch-Akaroa Rd on Saturday

A man caught driving at over 160kmh blew more than four times' the drink-driving limit.


Costumes at the ready

Debee-May McCarthy, owner of Tops 'N' Tales Costume Hire shop in Hamilton East, is excited the Sevens is coming to town.

The Sevens move to Hamilton is good news for the town's longest running costume store.

Nan guilty in baby case

Donna Catherine Parangi is on trial in the High Court in Rotorua charged with the manslaughter of her grandson Isaiah Neil.

A grandmother charged with manslaughter over the death of her grandson Isaiah Neil has been found guilty.

Tourist lost in the frost

Helicopter pilot Todd Dunham and crewman Bill McNeilly with Batel Rosenkrantz and SAR volunteers Matt Hazard, Dave ...

Rescuers bunked down in sub-zero conditions with a lost Israeli tourist. 

Business backs Sevens video

Lawrenson Group chief executive John Lawrenson is quietly optimistic about Hamilton hosting the sevens.

Bar owner John Lawrenson is optimistic about the Hamilton Sevens, since Dallas Fisher is in charge.


Walking sticks go walkabout

Tiki Raumati with his carved walking stick during a powhiri at Owae Marae, Waitara, in 2012.

The tale of two Taranaki men, at opposite sides of the region, who lost their walking sticks.

A farmer's fear

There are an estimated 50 Filipino farm workers around Taranaki.

OPINION: Immigration policy changes could leave farms left short-staffed.

Infection is spreading 

There are now 10 properties infected with myrtle rust in Taranaki.

Malcolm Hine is in the middle of the myrtle rust outbreak, he knows his 100 feijoa trees will get it.

Beware league tables

Bali Haque helps explain how NCEA is designed and why league tables aren't a helpful tool any more.

OPINION: Looking at NCEA pass rates on their own in a "league table" is a dangerous activity.


Skilled staff tackle grudge calls

At the Palmerston North City Council call centre, Te Rangiamohia Nikora-Davis is one of the faces behind a voice ...

UNDER THE RADAR: The council creates an art and a business out of answering phones.

RSA overhaul

The Ashhurst RSA is working with the Department of Internal Affairs on a probe of its accounts.

Poor procedures lead to a damning review and leadership changes at Ashhurst.

DHB fails woman video

A baby was stillborn after the MidCentral District Health Board failed to see signs of a life-threatening condition.

Slip-ups from the district health board led to a woman's unborn baby dying.

Teens charged with robbery

Police have arrested two people in relation to an armed robbery at a BP in Pahiatua.

A 16 and 18-year-old will appear in court over the BP Pahiatua robbery.


Party to prevent youth suicide

Motueka High School students won a competition focused on Maori youth suicide prevention with their concept of an ...

Motueka students are planning a music festival to raise awareness around youth suicide.

Hunt for a home video

Hannah Johnson says the search for a home was disheartening.

Securing a roof over her head helped one Nelson mum turn her life around.

The battle back from brain surgery

Vernon Fredericks

The road to becoming Crusader No 213 has been far from smooth for Vernon Fredericks.

On The Edge of a world record

The Edge radio station's Jono Pryor, Ben Boyce and Sharyn Casey attempt to break a world record for the amount of people ...

Radio show hosts get caught with their pants down on Tahunanui Beach.


Alternate highway no Autobahn

A tourist late for the ferry was caught doing 151kmh on State Highway 63 in the Wairau Valley in Marlborough. (File photo)

Judge tells German tourist clocked at 151kmh on quake detour "we've got to drive a lot slower here".

Love bites in Blenheim

Tom Knowles brings 'Allergic To Love: Curse of the 80s' home to Blenheim before touring the US.

Rock opera in the pub for rugby mates who don't do theatre about to tour the United States.

Man charged with burglary

Rodney Shane Wright, 45, has been remanded in custody to July 25.

But before pleading, he wants to know what he could be sentenced to.

The battle back from brain surgery

Vernon Fredericks

The road to becoming Crusader No 213 has been far from smooth for Vernon Fredericks.

South Canterbury

School heads back to the 80s

Timaru Girls' High and Timaru Boys' High School students rehearse for their joint production Back to the 80's. Pictured ...

Dig out your leg warmers, crop tops and head back to the 80s with Timaru Girls' this week.

New restaurant/bar 

Bob Mason and business partner Ross Rathgen inside the old Lone Star premises, soon to become the Bullock Restaurant and Bar.

A new restaurant and bar will open in the former Lone Star premises in Timaru. 

Attack was 'planned'

Ashburton man Kooly Managki Te Tomo is on trial for the manslaughter of Arran James Gairns in June 2014.

Trial of Ashburton man charged with manslaughter of Arran Gairns underway.

Air standards breached in Timaru

Smoke rises from a chimney on a chilly morning in Timaru. Timaru has experienced its third high pollution day this year.

Timaru has breached air standards for the third time this year.


Limehills school's $400,000 makeover

Limehills School teacher aide Kerry Henderson works with Emma Gill, Makayla Marshall and Liam Hartley, while Angus ...

Limehills has begun the new term with a $400,000 makeover which has transformed the school.

Schools ditching fizzy

Middle School pupils are excited about drinking water at school as part of a Healthy Families programme Rethink the ...

A local health campaign is encouraging Southland schools to choose water or plain milk.

Gore man jets for Thai waters

Dwayne Terry, left, and Paul Cross of Keelowcraft boat builders in Gore. The commercial sized twin engine jet boat has ...

Thai holidaymakers will soon be enjoying a supercharged sea monster from Gore.

Brothers attack off-duty policeman

An Invercargill policeman was unable to work for a week after he was assaulted while off-duty.

Two Invercargill brothers who attacked an off-duty policeman have been sentenced.

Ad Feedback