Mayors rally PM to create social welfare shake-up

Far North District Council mayor John Carter is working together with the mayors of Gisborne and Rotorua on the plan.
SUPPLIED

Far North District Council mayor John Carter is working together with the mayors of Gisborne and Rotorua on the plan.

Three mayors are lobbying the Government to create one of the biggest shake-ups to the social welfare system since the 1930s. 

The mayors from the Far North, Gisborne and Rotorua propose to set up special "demarcation zones" to eradicate intergenerational poverty and social problems.

It is proposed that welfare, health, education, employment and policing would be refocused and be overseen by the local communities to deal with the social problems in the three areas.

Rotorua Mayor Steve Chadwick said national rules were not working for some communities.
CHRISTEL YARDLEY/FAIRFAX NZ

Rotorua Mayor Steve Chadwick said national rules were not working for some communities.

Far North District Mayor John Carter said despite the efforts of a range of individuals and agencies, sub-cultures of poverty had evolved throughout New Zealand.

READ MORE: John Carter - 'They live from hand to mouth'

"Our failure to deal with entrenched poverty means we are turning our young people into unskilled dependents and, in some cases drug addicts, gang members and criminals," said Carter. 

"I'm especially concerned that our grandparents have shouldered so much responsibility for supporting some of our most difficult individuals and families. But time is running out to find an alternative, because that generation will largely be gone within a decade."

He said that he, Gisborne District Mayor Meng Foon and Rotorua District Mayor Steve Chadwick had been challenged by the Government to come up with alternative solutions to ingrained poverty in their communities.

The idea was the result of the TacklingPovertyNZ​ project - a series of one-day workshops held across the country, initiated by public policy think thank, the McGuinness Institute.

Gisborne Mayor Meng Foon said the proposal was still in its infancy.
GISBORNE HERALD

Gisborne Mayor Meng Foon said the proposal was still in its infancy.

The paper detailing the demarcation zone proposal was sent to Prime Minister Bill English on December 21, 2016.

Ad Feedback

"We all understand the legal and financial ramifications of a proposal like this, but we also see the cost that intergenerational poverty has. This is everyone's problem and we need to start talking about real solutions," he said. 

Northland MP Winston Peters said he had not been approached by Carter to pledge his support for the plan.

"The Government has not taken this seriously for a long time," he said. 

Peters added that the Government's focus on building up the economy in big cities, like Auckland, over the years had caused the rural economy across the country to be "seriously neglected".

"This is quite a frustration in the provinces that have a very big export wealth, but they're not recognised as such."

But he said the approach taken by the three mayors would not change that. 

"What they're asking for is the ability to organise the welfare system themselves, but if you don't have a top-down economic approach to change the economic settings, nothing this program will do can help in a significant way.

"If you look at what's being called for, why have they avoided the most fundamental thing, the change in economy."

Peters added that the mayors had "written to the wrong man", referring to Prime Minister Bill English, who he said had "done nothing to change" the rural economy in eight years.

WHAT ARE DEMARCATION ZONES?

The zones will "isolate and separate" the areas in the Far North, Gisborne district and Rotorua from central governance.

Although the idea was still in its infancy, the mayors proposed that the zones would be "guided by a channel captain or a group of local champions".

It was proposed that they would request full details of the services government departments supply to each zone, and would re-focus them on plans tailored to individuals and families living there.

According to the plan, the mayors said "mechanisms of both economic and social governance will need to be fully decentralised to ensure the system can be responsive to the needs of the communities. 

"The current system works to maintain the status quo, keeping people in poverty and spreading it like a virus."

NATIONAL TOOLS 'INAPPROPRIATE'

Rotorua mayor Steve Chadwick said local communities "best know what their challenges are and how to tackle them".

"However, a lack of financial and human resources means communities are hamstrung and cannot turn local knowledge into local solutions."

She said there are many good programmes tackling poverty, but these often apply national tools and measures inappropriate for complex local problems.

"The overseas development community accepts that top-down solutions applied by successive governments are significantly less effective in tackling poverty than bottom-up, community-driven approaches.

"Community leadership is needed to make the difference in our communities and we are prepared to give the idea a go if central government partners with us and ensure adequate resourcing to really give the concept legs.

'RADICAL IDEAS'

The mayors have proposed the following ideas for discussion, but said they would need to be explored and evaluated before they are implemented.

* Implement a system to ensure that young people's experience with police is the beginning of a positive lifelong relationship. This would include police, in partnership with experts, teaching courses at schools such as the road code, defensive driving, first aid and basic car mechanics. The idea proposes that these programmes form part of NCEA level 2.

* Enabling young people to be exposed to academic study while remaining in their home towns. This includes basic university courses being taught extra-murally at secondary schools, or through Skype. 

* Remove licences for operating pokies and running bottles stores. This means no new licences would be made available. 

* Removing retailing licences from large retailers to enable small business to flourish.

* People on benefits could support their community by helping or visiting old people's homes, painting public buildings, planting a public vegetable garden, teaching elderly tech skills and provide transport.

* Place free sanitary product dispensers in all schools' female bathrooms, as they are often one of the first products to removed from shopping lists when budgets are tight. 

*Provide a fast-track legal system for seasonal workers and tourists who are required to stay in a town due to relatively minor offences.

* Invite banks to provide people to consolidate debt under one loan so that people are not vulnerable to high interest rates and credit card fees.

* Establish a check list for emergency housing, ensuring these houses are close to schools, of adequate quality and well-resourced for families. The idea is to minimise disruption for children's schooling and social relationships.

* Invite major employers into schools to explain career paths, employer expectations and ideally to set up work experience programmes.

* Have doctors regularly visit all preschools in the area to assess children's health.

* Employ school bus drivers to drive an extra circuit during the day to enable otherwise geographically isolated adults to get into town and back.

* Create a local card that enables free filling of prescriptions from any chemist. There were situations where parents did not fill prescriptions because of the $5.00 fee, or because families moved around a lot and faced obstacles to free access.

* Allow the demarcation zone governance board access to all data for decision making and longitudinal research.

* Allow the board to set local priorities and targets for investment decisions around resource allocation. 

 - Stuff

Comments

Ad Feedback
special offers
Auckland

'His fate is in your hands'

Gustav Sanft pictured on the first day of his trial at the High Court in Auckland.

The jury have begun their deliberations to find whether Gustav Sanft is guilty of manslaughter.

Bringing theatre to her community video

Massive Company's emerging artist show Chance To Ignite is on at Mangere Arts Centre in August.

Sieni Leo'o Olo's family isn't into theatre, but they go to all of her performances, a world she's proud to introduce them to.

Killer's final words video

Quinn Patterson rang his sister to say goodbye after gunning down two women in cold blood.

Quinn Patterson's sister reveals the gunman's last phone call after shooting two women dead.

Heavy snow warning in place

Tekapo was temporarily cut off by snow on Thursday.

Five vehicles hit ice and skid off the road in Southland as the cold snap grips the country.

Wellington

'You're not an MP,' candidate told

Before and after. Labour's Tukituki candidate Anna Lorck altered her billboards after complaints were made to the ...

Hawke's Bay Labour candidate's billboard stated she was 'Your Local MP' - except she wasn't.

Our crumbling capital

Slip on Hutchison Rd, behind Newtown.

Wellington has become slip city, with about 400 reported this winter already, far more than usual. But why?

Log hits forestry worker

A forestry worker was in great pain after being struck by a log in rural Wairarapa. (File photo)

Injured worker struck by log winched out of forestry block and flown to hospital.

Car flips on Rimutaka hill

A car has flipped on the Rimutaka Hill road between Upper Hutt and Featherston.

Lucky escape for driver after car flips in poor weather on highway north of Wellington.

Canterbury

Truck tips, loses load video

Emergency services at the scene of a truck roll-over in central Dunedin on Friday morning.

The truck lost its load, damaging at least three cars outside a Dunedin haberdashery shop.

Sex grooming arrest

A 51-year-old man has been arrested after meeting a young person following online sexual grooming.

A man has been arrested after meeting a young person following sexual grooming online.

145 more social houses for city

Social Housing Minister Amy Adams (front) and Greater Christchurch Regeneration Minister Nicky Wagner at the site of 30 ...

Christchurch will get another 145 social housing units at a cost of $46 million.

Area 'should be red zoned'

This post-quake rebuild is in one of Christchurch's lowest-lying areas. Now it will have to go to make way for a flood ...

A newly-built home is one of 13 properties to make way for a council flood protection scheme.

Waikato

Growth gobbles up rural roads

Roadworks on Hamilton's Kay Road are a blessing in that they slow drivers down, resident Sian Wilson says.

Residents ask council for footpaths and lower speed limits on what were once rural roads.

Home burns to ground

Neighbours were the first to spot the flames surging from the 30m by 15m building around 11.30am on Thursday.

Residents were in a nearby town when they heard the fire siren.

Farmer rams cows with ute

A farm manager rammed the dairy cows from behind (file photo).

Dairy cows were running as fast as they could, but a farmer drove into them.

Sorry to see foundry go

Hauraki Prospectors Association vice presidents Nelson Valiant, left, and Lawrie Cobb with part of the Stamper Battery ...

Thames was built on gold mining and A&G Price was there every step of the way.

Taranaki

New owners for burger joint

New Prohibition owners Andy Le and Gabby Tran will be keeping the burger restaurant much the same.

A popular New Plymouth burger joint is under new ownership but the burgers won't change.

Collecting for a tangi

The men had collected 251 paua between them.

Two men were caught with 251 paua, 191 of them undersized.

Fail and move on

New Plymouth man Paul Feltoe swam more than 32 kilometres across the Catalina Channel in July.

 A couple of weeks ago New Plymouth man Paul Feltoe got a boat from Los Angeles to Catalina Island - then swam the 32.3kms back.

Firewood running out

A roaring fire maybe a thing of the past unless you've stocked up as supplies of firewood  run out in Taranaki with ...

Stock up in summer to avoid being left out in the cold.

Manawatu

Wowed over WOW

Jennie Munro in her workshop with costumes that have been finalists in Wellington's international World Of Wearable Arts ...

A Palmerston North designer has made the finals of September's wearable arts show.

No intercepting emails

Horizons Regional Council chief executive Michael McCartney sees no reason to intercept emails, unlike Horowhenua ...

Council chief executives see no reason for intercepting emails - unlike Horowhenua council's boss.

Collar-dragging teacher cleared

Clive Stevens with his grandmother Maureen Stevens.

Teacher who dragged special needs student along floor did nothing wrong, investigation finds.

Back to school

Greens co-leader Metiria Turei stopped to talk with Tanika Jeffery, 14, who was learning speech writing in te reo, at ...

Greens co-leader Metiria Turei talks education at her old high school.

Nelson

Tool time returns to preschool video

Phoenix Brimble-Morrison uses tools donated by Mitre 10 Mega to Healthkids Preschool after its previous tools were stolen.

Hand drills, hammers and saws stolen from a Nelson preschool have been generously replaced.

Man critically injured

A man has critical injuries after a car hit a tree on the Coastal Highway.

Driver trapped in a car with serious injuries after a car hit a tree near Nelson.

School first for future Mako video

25072017 NEWS PHOTO BRADEN FASTIER / STUFF
Nelson College 1st XV rugby player Leicester Faingaanuku is to play for ...

Leicester Faingaanuku was just 15 when he signed with the Tasman Makos.

Car crashes into house

A house that was damaged after a car drove into it on Toi Toi St, Nelson.

A car has crashed into a Nelson home causing substantial damage.

Marlborough

'Our niche is Marlborough'

Dog Point Vineyard co-owners and event sponsors Ivan Sutherland, left, and James Healy read up for the Marlborough Book ...

With intimate venues and stunning surrounds, the Marlborough Book Festival is a little different.

Bigger planes?

Sounds Air chief executive Andrew Crawford inside the cockpit of one of the company's 9-seat Pilatus PC-12s.

Demand for flights prompts Marlborough airline to investigate "quantum leap" to larger planes.

Blenheim bemoans unfair fares

Air New Zealand said it would not be reinstating direct flights to Christchurch from Marlborough Airport.

"It's almost like we've offended Air New Zealand somehow and they're making us pay." 

Nurses to move to hub

The district nurses will have a similar amount of storage space at the health hub, the review panel says.

Where they need more staff, new technology and better communication, review finds.

South Canterbury

Region poised for milk boost

While the forecast price rise from Fonterra is good new for South Canterbury dairy farmers, regional Federated Farmers ...

Another $25m added to South Canterbury farmers' milk payout.

Oamaru firearm theft

Police are investigating a targeted firearms burglary in Oamaru.

Police are investigating a targeted firearms burglary in Oamaru.

Taken to hospital after inhaling gas

One person has been taken to hospital after inhaling gas at a residential property in Timaru. A Street view of Avenue ...

One person has been taken to hospital after inhaling gas at a residential property in Timaru. 

Rugby player jailed

Kolinio Yabia Tamanitoakula was jailed for three years, four months and two weeks.

His distressed victim was covered in mud when she ran in front of a car to get help.

Southland

Hall off to world champs

New Zealand discus thrower Marshall Hall practices ahead of the 2017 IAAF World Championships.

Invercargill discus thrower 'committed and focused' ahead of IAAF Athletics World Championships.

Ice causing crashes

10082016. News.Kavinda Herath. Southland Times/Stuff-Ice on the Winton Lorneville Highway

Police are warning drivers to take it slow and beware of ice on the roads.

Fire guts city house

Firemen at the scene of the gutted house, which was owned by former mayor Eve Poole, on Friday morning.

A fire has gutted the house of former mayor Eve Poole in Invercargill this morning

Data won't be public

Primary Industries Minister Nathan Guy.

Primary Industries Minister Nathan Guy said the ministry had no intention to make information about individual fishing locations public.

Ad Feedback