Heritage NZ withdraws charges against Marlborough landowners over heritage dispute

The Wairau Bar and hinterland in Marlborough, an area once occupied by Maori.

The Wairau Bar and hinterland in Marlborough, an area once occupied by Maori.

Charges against two Marlborough landowners have been formally withdrawn more than a year after they were accused of disturbing material near the site of a historical massacre.

Heritage New Zealand charged Phillip and Haysley MacDonald in late 2015 after alleging they had carried out work on their land near the Wairau Bar without an archaeological permit.

The MacDonalds were accused of constructing a fenceline and clearing scrub without permission on a site close to a historical settlement, Kowhai Pa, between July and September in 2015.

Charges against Haysley MacDonald, pictured, and his father Phillip MacDonald have been dropped.

Charges against Haysley MacDonald, pictured, and his father Phillip MacDonald have been dropped.

The pa belonged to Marlborough iwi Rangitane o Wairau - which both MacDonalds are members of - and was the site of a historical massacre in the 1820s when Ngati Toa raided the area.

Heritage New Zealand charges dropped against Marlborough landowners Haysley and Phillip MacDonald
Marlborough iwi Rangitane O Wairau 'outraged' by settlement with Heritage New Zealand
Delay in settlement between Marlborough vineyard owner and Heritage NZ
Archaeological report on pa site completed

Haysley MacDonald, the owner of wine company Te Pa Wines and a sitting member of the Rangitane o Wairau trust, has always denied the charges, along with his father, Phillip MacDonald.

In July, they agreed with Heritage New Zealand on conditions for the charges being withdrawn, which included conducting an archaeological survey of the site and a contribution of $15,000.

The survey was supposed to be finished in October, but because the archaeologist was ill, it was eventually handed to Heritage New Zealand in December.

A joint statement from Heritage New Zealand and the MacDonalds said the charges, laid under the Heritage New Zealand Pouhere Taonga Act, had been formally withdrawn.

The statement said the archaeological survey showed there was evidence of past Maori occupation of the land - the Wairau Bar was one of the earliest sites of Maori settlement in New Zealand.

Ad Feedback

"This has shown some evidence of past Maori occupation as is typical of the coastal margin in Marlborough," the statement read.

"Agreement has been reached between Heritage New Zealand and Phillip and Haysley as to the way forward in the areas where evidence of archaeological material has been found."

Heritage New Zealand lawyer Geraldine Baumann, who handled the case, said it was not appropriate for her to comment. Haysley MacDonald also declined to comment.

The case had proved controversial among Rangitane o Wairau, with some iwi members slamming Heritage New Zealand over their decision not to proceed with the prosecution.

However, interim chairwoman Wendy Hynes said she was pleased kotahitanga, working together, had been chosen over litigation, adding it was beneficial for everyone with a stake in the Wairau Bar.

"We are pleased to see an outcome that is based on a respect for the land, its historical significance and working together with the ongoing research, preservation and protection of the Wairau Bar," she said.

Rangitane o Wairau staff members were told not to speak about the case. 

"This is a sensitive matter and it is important that the view of the board is expressed accurately. It is therefore entirely appropriate and business as usual that official commentary is made by the board chair."

Dr Jeremy Habberfield-Short, the archaeologist who conducted the survey, was not able to elaborate on the report, saying he was bound by confidentiality to Heritage New Zealand and Haysley MacDonald.

"The archaeological site survey will be considered by Phillip and Haysley before any further expansion, planting or other work is undertaken on land in the area," the statement said.

Peter Radich, who represented the MacDonalds, said they had made a contribution to Heritage New Zealand, but would not confirm if it was the full $15,000.

"I'm not at liberty to say anything more than what's in the statement. I can confirm it has been made but that's all I can disclose," he said.

The statement said the contribution would allow further archaeological work to take place in the area surrounding the site.

It went on to say that Heritage New Zealand and the MacDonalds had formed a constructive working relationship for the future.

"In these circumstances the prosecution matters between Heritage New Zealand and Phillip and Haysley are at an end and they look forward to working together," it read.

*An Official Information Act request has been lodged with Heritage New Zealand to provide details about their investigation into the allegations.

 - The Marlborough Express


Ad Feedback
special offers

Cop car rammed

A Police car has been rammed on Hillsborough Road, leaving it not driveable.

A suspected stolen car has reversed into a Police car, leaving it "not driveable".

Manhunt after armed robbery

The armed robbery hapened at around 6pm on Sunday night, Police said.

Police are on the hunt for two people in a sedan, after a Mt Albert TAB was robbed with firearms.

Over 50,000 litres of dumped rubbish

Sea Cleaners and the Navy teamed up to collect more than 50,000 litres of rubbish in Otara's Tamaki Strait.

Car parts, refrigerators, ovens, "anything you can think of, it's here", Hayden Smith says. 

Cause of death unknown

A woman was taken to Auckland hospital in critical condition Saturday afternoon after an incident that left one man dead.

Police are unable to confirm how a man in Glen Eden died in an incident that left a woman in critical condition.


Dancers delight video

L-R:  Kunaratnam Velautham, Artistic Director of Vehaara Arts Dance Studio, traveled ...

Colourful performers, exotic peacocks and fierce fighters came together to celebrate diversity.

Diver dies at Titahi Bay

A diver died after getting into trouble at Titahi Bay on Sunday. (FILE)

The diver, believed to be a man in his 30s or 40s, died before a helicopter arrived.

Polluted stream frustrations video

A dead eel found in the stream earlier in April.

Clean-up reveals mayor's anger with slow progress - but council's landfill also under fire.

Wellington's magic bullets video

The original Bata Bullet sneakers. Regarded as quintessentially Kiwi, they were made here, but originated in the United ...

PVC gumboots, still made at Wellington's Bata factory, are as Kiwi as Fred Dagg.


Crusaders: Five talking points

CHRISTCHURCH, NEW ZEALAND - APRIL 22: Matt Todd of the Crusaders (C) looks on during the round nine Super Rugby match ...

OPINION: who would have thought it, eh? The Crusaders, with eight consecutive wins, remain one of Super Rugby's hottest tickets.

Living wage on table

Christchurch Mayor Lianne Dalziel says the council will consider offering staff a living wage.

The Christchurch City Council is considering offering a living wage to staff.

ED braces for winter overload

The CDHB is bracing for an increase in patient numbers over winter.

Surgeons will be operating into the night and on weekends to meet expected surge in patient numbers this winter.

FBI director lands in Queenstown video

FBI director James Comey arrives in Queenstown where a top-secret meeting of the Five Eyes nations is being held.

FBI director James Comey has arrived ahead of a top-secret meeting.


From patched to pay cheque

Paora Raharaha was once a Black Power member. Now he's working towards having his own business.

An ex gang member has done a 360 on his life with steady work and hope for the future.

Ghost school's big bill

Richmond Park School in Melville, Hamilton, has sat vacant since closing 13 years ago.

The empty school on land worth millions has been empty for 13 years and costs thousands to maintain.

Shots near market

Many calls were made to emergency services reporting the gunshots, after the gang fight near a children's playground at ...

Police say "sheer luck" nobody hurt, mayor says "public not at risk".

ATM bandits sought

When she walked back to her car after using the ATM four men approached her from behind. (FILE PHOTO)

The four waited for the woman to get cash out before striking.


Price gets super call-up

Tukapa lock Leighton Price has been called into the Blues.

Leighton Price is off to the Blues for the remainder of the Super season.

Venue's doors still shut

Taranaki's Waiau Country Estate has been closed since October but the owners are looking for new tenants.

"A business needs to start thinking of the coming spring and summer season for weddings and functions."

'Snail mail' lives up to cliche

According to NZ Post letter volumes in New Zealand are declining by 8-11 per cent or a million letters a week.

Our postal experiment finds it takes a letter eight days to travel just 200 metres.

Rainbow lorikeet wins second title

Mike Harris and his granddaughter Tasman Sutherland with his rainbow lorikeet which won the title for best hookbeak at ...

"He is a bit of a character."


Suspicious blaze

Phyllis Maihi and her three children made it out of their burning house without injury.

Everybody in a Palmerston North house escaped the fire uninjured.

Internet ultimatum

This could be the future of Correspondence School learning, to the chagrin of those in remote New Zealand.

With internet-based home schooling on the rise, what happens to rural families?

Let us watch

Michael Feyen rightly told the MidCentral DHB about the success of his council's livestreaming.

OPINION: It's simple, cheap and effective, so there's no excuse not to livestream.

Marlow calling the shots in Aussie

Manawatu's Pip Marlow is on the Australian Rugby Board.

Good Sports: Manawatu women on both the New Zealand and Australian rugby boards.


The road to success

Nelson athlete Paula Canning in action.

Katrina Tikey catches up with Paula Canning to find out what keeps her going.

Nelson clubs on fire

Harlequins winger Matt Biggar, left, and Marist flanker Kasi Sami scramble for possession during their Tasman Trophy ...

Nelson and Wanderers win in Blenheim to kick-start Tasman Trophy club series. 

Mystery solved over missing vet

Lukas Oakley places poppies on the grave of Royal New Zealand Air Force warrant officer Denis Scrimgeour on Singapore's ...

The mystery over why a fallen war veteran's name wasn't read out at last year's Anzac Day commemorations has been solved.

Riders go crazy on trail

It has taken six weeks of digging, compacting and grooming to get the trail ready.

More than 100 mountainbikers share the honour of being the first to tame Crazy Horse.


Sprains and aches? Stay away!

Marlborough Netball Centre manager Janine Jordaan played through three ankle reconstructions in three years, and says ...

Health board tells "weekend warriors" to stop clogging up EDs with minor injuries.

Tramper rescued

A search and rescue team were flown into the Nelson Lakes by the Nelson Marlborough Rescue Helicopter on Friday night to ...

A search and rescue team were flown into the Nelson Lakes to locate an injured tramper.

The Malayan Emergency

Blenheim veteran Peter Callahan with his medals, including the Queen's Service Medal he was given for contribution to ...

He remembers the heat; the oppressive tropical conditions, and the dangerous wildlife - snakes, tigers and water buffalo.

Freerunning freedom video

Getting the knack of parkour are, from left, Conlan Purdie, 12, Gibson Purdie, 10, and Jack MacLean, 10, before a ...

Overcoming obstacles with parkour, one leap at a time.

South Canterbury

Ronda Rousey visits SC cafe

The Running Duck's senior barista Layaura Beattie got a quick selfie with celebrity Ronda Rousey.

A South Canterbury cafe owner was left "star struck" when Ronda Rousey stopped by.

Flora on display

Timaru Horticultural Autumn Show was held at Caroline Bay Hall, pictured are Bruce and Shirley Cormack.

The Timaru Horticulture Show autumn show drew in large crowds.

Fridge sparks 111 call

Fire Service Southern Communications shift manager Riwai Grace said it was definitely one of the stranger call outs they ...

Firefighters called to house after occupants mistook fridge beeping for smoke alarm.

Service replicates 1917 original

Temuka RSA secretary and manager Vicki Howey said the 100th service would loosely follow the 1917 original.

Temuka will mark its 100th ANZAC service by replicating its first service from 1917.


Sharks to optimise rotation

Southland Sharks coach Judd Flavell.

Southland Sharks coach Judd Flavell will be looking to optimise their squad rotation after a hard fought 95-83 NBL win over the Nelson Giants in Invercargill.

Vet clinic refurbished

Clutha Vets veterinarian John Smart, former chief executive Bruce Bissett and Jason Boyle of Edendale at the newly ...

Newly refurbished $3m veterinary clinic for Balclutha

Truck driver avoids jail sentence

The Invercargill District Court building in Don St, Invercargill.

A drink-driver has avoided jail - the woman he hit asked the judge to not imprison him.

Invest South invests in BISON

BISON co-founders Greg Fahey, CEO and Mark Fahey, CTO with a set of BISON container scales.

Invest South have announced an investment in BISON Group Limited.

Ad Feedback