Families left in limbo after inquest fails to pinpoint cause of blaze

Connor Swetman.
BRAD ROBERTS/FAIRFAX MEDIA

Connor Swetman.

An inquest into a house fire that killed three young Hamilton people has helped their families understand the blaze, but left many questions unanswered. 

Toni Maree Johnston, 23, Jake Lindsey Hayes, 19, and Connor James Swetman, 17, died when fire ripped through the six-bedroom villa in Collingwood St at 5am on November 15, 2014.

Coroner Gordon Matenga reserved his decision on Friday following a three day inquest in Hamilton District Court this week. 

Jake Hayes, 19, had just started a painting job days prior to the fire.
supplied

Jake Hayes, 19, had just started a painting job days prior to the fire.

During the week the families of the trio gathered to hear evidence from some of the 32 residents and partygoers at the villa on the Friday for a party organised by resident Jake Hayes.

READ MORE:
Coroner's inquest: Triple fatal fire started on couch
Survivor pays tribute to lost friends
Mum's pain - Hamilton triple death blaze remains a mystery

 

Toni Maree Johnston.
supplied

Toni Maree Johnston.

 

 

Investigations were unable to determine what exactly sparked the fire in a couch in the downstairs lounge, with fire investigators giving two possible causes for the blaze - a discarded cigarette butt or arson. 

Fire Service personnel sieve through debris from the Collingwood Street house fire which claimed the lives of three people.
Mike Scott

Fire Service personnel sieve through debris from the Collingwood Street house fire which claimed the lives of three people.

"It hasn't been an easy thing for you to do, emotions are still raw, I hope this will help you to move forward," the coroner told the family on Friday.

Ad Feedback

"You have been forced to come to court and to relive the horrific events of that night and I hope you never have to go through this again."

"What will always remain unknown at this stage is exactly how the fire began unless more evidence becomes available at this point. We know where it began and we clearly see the devastating effects, but we don't know how it began."

Fire damaged house on Collingwood Rd, Hamilton, as the NZ Fire Service continues its investigation.
NZ Fire Service

Fire damaged house on Collingwood Rd, Hamilton, as the NZ Fire Service continues its investigation.

During the closing statements at the inquest on Friday, Toni Johnston's mother Sue McLeish said family were frustrated the inquest had focused on the events of the party and had not explored her daughter's movements that night.

"We sat here for two days and heard a lot about a party at 192 Collingwood St and we haven't heard about Toni's story, she will be forever connected to that night."

Johnston, who was one of seven flatmates living at the villa, had been out in town on the night of the party, celebrating a new job she planned to start in Auckland a week later, and returned home by taxi at 4.20am.

She had been drinking and was last seen being taken to bed by a friend.

"She was in the wrong place at the wrong time, and will forever be linked to this fire at 192."

McLeish also quizzed the coroner on what happens to what she called "unreliable witnesses". Earlier the inquest heard an account by witness Oscar Schollum, who had changed his original statement while giving evidence. 

Schollum initially estimated he left the house at 3.45am but while giving evidence earlier this week recalled falling asleep on the couch and seeing another partygoer Bayley Reid coming down the stairs at 4.20am.

"We have listened to expert witnesses, thanks to the fire and police who have helped us understand the intensity of the fire, it's helped us track the path of the fire but my absolute frustration is the unreliability of several witnesses," McLeish said. 

She said while the fire was not necessarily arson, the evidence left a feeling that "something doesn't add up."

Coroner Matenga told McLeish that police would review all witness statements and explore any allegations.

"I'm not saying what my decision will be in my findings but if I determine that the witness may have changed some of his recollections, it's not necessarily being the same as being deliberately dishonest."

He said police had done a thorough investigation, which at this stage had found no criminal culpability. 

"This is not a closed investigation for them."

Outside court, Toni's brother Greg Johnston said the only silver lining from his sister's death a law change that required smoke alarms be installed in rental properties.  

"It's the only early detection to give everyone a decent chance. I would urge every parent to understand the flatting environment and know you do have the right to call your landlord."

Although the inquest had been thorough, it wasn't going to change anything, Sharon Otto, Connor Swetman's mother, said outside court.

"It was interesting to hear what went on, it's not going to make any difference."

She said her son was a laid back, quiet guy who would have been playing ping pong most of the night. He was found dead inside the upstairs bedroom with Jake Hayes.

"I think it was just the smoke, the timing of a few seconds, the door was open and that was the end of night."

Given the evidence there was no way to tell either way how the fire started, she said, although she would like to think it was an accident.

"You don't know."

 

 - Stuff

Ad Feedback
special offers
Auckland

Forget ladder, I can't afford to rent

Didovich says she has a good job and has been saving but still can't afford to move out of home.

OPINION: I'm a 20-year-old university graduate working in a full-time job yet I'm still living at home.

Principal a 'shining light'

Former principal Ken Havill dedicated his life to improving Western Springs College.

Ken Havill, who led Western Springs College for 19 years, has died.

Teacher force-fed kids: Crown

Lynn Euphemia Abraham, 59, has denied 11 charges of assault against a child.

Pre-school teacher washed child's mouth out with soap and taped another child's mouth shut, court hears.

Silverdale Premiers remain unbeaten

The Silverdale Premiers remain unbeaten in their fourth round.

Silverdale Premiers remain unbeaten in the fourth round of the North Harbour Championship.

Wellington

Trains cancelled, trees down gallery video

A ngaio tree blew on to cars in Todman St, Brooklyn overnight.

A night of wild weather has downed trees and caused disruption to trains.

7-hour ferry crossing

The Straitsman entering Picton harbour.

Bluebridge ferry treads carefully as it crosses Cook Strait in hurricane-force winds.

Nats' producers alerted to problem

Musician Eminem at a New York premiere.(File photo)

Judge and nine lawyers listen to Eminem track as rapper's publisher takes on National.

Tax fraudster named

20-10-15 News Photo; David White/FairfaxNZ
Wellington High Court general view generic exterior

Tax agent Leigh Anne Sammons loses suppression after swindling more than $700k.

Canterbury

Heritage rescue for convent video

The historic chapel which is part of the old Anglican convent on St Asaph St in central Christchurch.

Work to rescue a threatened 120-year-old Christchurch convent and chapel is about to start.

Rescuer wins ACC fight

Builder Bill Toomey drilled through a concrete floor of a collapsed building after the February 2011 earthquake. The ...

Bill Toomey suffered post-traumatic stress after pulling people from the collapsed PGC building.

Sold: Chch temporary village

Linwood temporary accommodation village.

Christchurch ratepayers have bought the Linwood housing village, but the price is being kept secret.

Player sent off for referee abuse

A match between Methven and Kaiapoi was called off early after an allegation of referee abuse.

A rugby match was called off after a Methven player allegedly abused the referee.

Waikato

"Forever in awe" of Murray video

Eric Murray and Hamish Bond celebrate winning gold at the Rio Olympics.

The other half of the unbeatable pair said he never doubted his crewmate.

Death rocks street video

Firefighters on Little St after being called to the fire at 3.30am.

Residents are shocked after a woman's body was found inside burnt-out Waikato home.

Call to ban duck shooting

Auckland and Waikato's duck shooting season opens in the first weekend of May and runs for one month.

But others say the avians do enormous damage to the country's native biodiversity.

'Black spot' fix planned video

The favoured corridor to link Hamilton and Tauranga is marked E2 on this image.

New four-lane expressway planned between Cambridge and turnoff to Tauranga will save lives, NZTA says.

Taranaki

South Taranaki's wild night

A door lies on a Hawera footpath beside the shed it blew off during a storm that buffeted South Taranaki on Sunday night.

Flying trampolines, power cuts, slips and fallen trees as South Taranaki cops wintry blast

Accused unfit to plead

A man charged with careless driving causing the death of  Robin Coutanche appeared in the New Plymouth District Court on ...

Charged with causing a crash which killed a man, the accused is too unwell to plead to the charge.

One injured in crash

Emergency services are at the scene of a crash on Arawhata Rd, South Taranaki.

A woman has been taken to hospital after a crash in South Taranaki.

Fun for thousands

John Mahon, owner of Mahons Amusements and Mega Fun Carnival organiser Brent Taylor pictured at the carnival that has ...

The carnival will be back again next year, organiser Brent Taylor said.

Manawatu

Women's expo draws a crowd

Melissa Frank, left, and Renee Dingwall sample Bio Farm milk with James Tait-Jamieson.

Thousands of women, and some men, turned out for the women's expo.

Crash victim named

Police have named the man who died in a crash between a motorbike and a tractor.

Fifty-one-year-old man died in crash with a tractor near Feilding.

Access problems

The Linton Military Camp's perimeter fences have remained virtually unchanged over the past two decades.

They are charged with protecting our country. But can they protect themselves?

Getting refugees on the road

Palmerston North's Red Cross is calling for volunteers to teach refugees to drive. Krishna Bahadur Rai, left and his ...

The Palmerston North Red Cross seeks volunteers to help teach refugees how to drive.

Nelson

Winter is coming

A fresh dump of snow blankets the Western Ranges, near Nelson making for a chilly start to the morning.

The Nelson region has woken to its first dump of snow for the season.

A home for $45k?

Seddon Marshall has a proposal to address Nelson's affordable housing issue, by building small, relocatable homes.

Tiny, relocatable homes the size of a single car park mooted as a solution to the affordable housing shortage.

Suicide stats show system failing

A report that details the suspected suicides of those in mental health care reflects failings in the system.

Patients at risk of suicide are not getting the right treatment, psychologist says.

Night rescue from capsized boat

Two fishermen were rescued from the sea near Delaware Bay, north of Nelson, after spending 11 hours holding onto their ...

Two fishermen sang to each other to keep spirits up during an 11-hour ordeal.

Marlborough

Seven hours in a Force 12

The Straitsman entering Picton harbour.

A ferry on Cook Strait is the last place anyone wants to be when a southerly hits - especially when it takes 7 hours.

Car set on fire

The fire is likely to be treated as suspicious.

"Cars do not just burst into flames by themselves," fire officer says of blaze.

The 50-year decision

Marlborough faces a $63m question about schooling in the region, but how much input will young people have?

The future of education in Marlborough is hanging in the balance, and soon the community will have its say.

Landing ... on SH1

Air Kaikoura Aero Club, pictured with its training plane near Mt Fyffe, supplied a service between Kaikoura and Clarence.

Cars can't use this part of State Highway 1, but Kaikoura aero club wants to use it for planes.

South Canterbury

'Great' fun for all at colour run video

Ziah Tatuava, 6, of Waimate is having a roaring good time at the second-annual Colour Me Fun Run in Timaru on Sunday.

Colourful 'old ladies' and a family of 'dalmatians' took part in Timaru's annual Colour Me Fun Run.

Three-vehicle crash 

A man is seriously injured after a three vehicle crash on SH1 east of Geraldine. (File photo)

State Highway 1 closed, man seriously injured after crash near Geraldine.

Scooter bros 'buzzing'

Kahurangi, left, giving his brother Makaia a pep talk before he competed on Saturday.

Timaru's scooting brothers have 'incredible' time at Australian Scooter Championships.

Museum social push

The South Canterbury Museum is looking to expand its social media reach beyond Facebook, using Instagram and YouTube, ...

South Canterbury Museum may use Instagram and YouTube to expand social media reach.

Southland

Who will be the next deputy mayor?

Invercargill city councillors, Darren Ludlow, Lindsay Thomas, Toni Biddle, Lindsay Abbott, Lesley Soper, Lloyd Esler, ...

Cr Lloyd Esler said there were one or two members of the council who would be putting their name forward. 

The Southland divide

Infometrics senior economist Benje Patterson.

Some Southland towns are flourishing, while others are on the decline.

Immigration used to cut wages

Labour MP for Hutt South Trevor Mallard and Invercargill Labour candidate Liz Craig at ILT Stadium Southland.

Immigration has been a hot topic for the Labour Party leading into this year's election.

Special win for Otautau video

The Otautau rugby team and supporters after their win on Saturday.

The Otautau rugby team's win on Saturday meant a lot to the western Southland community.

Ad Feedback