Firefighters were sent home early from Christchurch fire response, union says video

The Firefighters Union say they could have saved 10 of the 11 homes.
JOHN KIRK-ANDERSON/FAIRFAX NZ

The Firefighters Union say they could have saved 10 of the 11 homes.

Experienced firefighters were sent home at a crucial point in the Christchurch fire response, causing the loss of 10 homes, their union says.

New Zealand Professional Firefighters Union Secretary Derek Best has called for an independent inquiry.

He said firefighters were sent home for 90 minutes at nightfall on Monday after they had contained but not extinguished the fire.

Just an hour and a half later they were called back to the scene, but it was too late.

READ MORE:
Homes destroyed, hundreds evacuated as Christchurch Port Hills fires rage out of control
Lost homes 'gutting' for firefighters battling Christchurch Port Hills blaze
Damage beyond the flames
Photos: Christchurch Port Hills fire - day four
House burned down in front of his eyes
Christchurch Adventure Park village and base station survive night
Christchurch family devastated their home is ash


"The order to stand down was given at nightfall in day one, leaving career firefighters frustrated, bewildered and disappointed," Best said.

"The fire was left to burn out of control and the frustrated firefighters could see the flames from their stations.

"Ninety minutes later, they were called back and the fire had really got going well. Ninety minutes is quite a long time for a fire to get a good head of steam."

"They were really frustrated and quite angry - because this is their home town."

Best said their return saved a further six homes from destruction.

Ad Feedback

But firefighters had told him with confidence they believed the fire could have been extinguished had they not left, saving 10 of the 11 homes destroyed during the week.

"While the fire was large it was not really a large bush fire in terms of what they might get in somewhere like Australia.

"People over there must be able to properly deal with smaller incidents like this."

He said an inquiry was needed not just into the fire services but into the entire disaster response.

"Really the same issues from the Christchurch earthquake are still present."

Steve Turek, fire region commander for New Zealand Fire Service and Douglas Marshall, principal rural fire officer at Selwyn District Council said in a statement: "The Port Hills fire is one of the most complex in recent years.

"It has required firefighting on a number of fronts, requiring urban, rural and aerial tactics. All firefighters have worked very hard in tough conditions.

"In incidents of this size and nature, rural and urban firefighters will respond together. Decisions are made under a clear command and control structure amongst rural and urban fire officers based on a number of factors, but there is always a clearly agreed lead on all fire grounds.

"Safety is always a key factor in determining where firefighters should be placed. In the Port Hills fires, terrain, wind conditions and heat intensity have meant extra caution must be taken around how close firefighters can be to the fire.

"All large fires have an operational review undertaken after the fire has been fully extinguished. The purpose of that review is to evaluate the response and identify any opportunities for further improvement. 

"For now, our focus is on putting put the fires.

"We are very proud of the commitment and huge effort put in by firefighters, community volunteers and the many other agencies supporting the response."

Civil Defence's Christchurch controller John Mackie had said earlier criticism regarding the emergency response would be addressed later.

"The structures and the systems we currently have in place, they may not be ideal but there's a lot of people working hard out there.

"Criticism doesn't help engagement of those volunteers who have put in huge hours in the last four-five days and it's not their day job."

Early Valley Rd homeowner Ken McKenzie believed the fire could have been stopped further up, saving the two houses on his road that were lost.

"If action had been taken quicker and we'd got more resources to the site . . . it should have been able to be stopped before it headed towards town.

"If they got helicopters and bulldozers in, it could have been stopped. The issue I have is pretty much the organisation, the level above – there's something drastically wrong."

On Wednesday, Civil Defence Minister Gerry Brownlee slammed aspects of the emergency response and said he was "not at all happy" about the delay in declaring a local state of emergency and communication between officials.

Christchurch Mayor Lianne Dalziel denied local officials had been too slow to declare a state of emergency, but conceded there had been "a bit of a breakdown in communication".

Internal Affairs Minister Peter Dunne said a new agency, Fire and Emergency New Zealand, would co-ordinate all firefighting activity from July.

A Budget allocation of $303 million will be spent on merging the New Zealand Fire Service, the National Rural Fire Authority and "the fire functions of 40-plus rural fire authorities".

"There will no longer be any poor relations within the fire services of this country," Dunne said.

 - Stuff

Ad Feedback
special offers
Auckland

'Beautiful women' gunned down video

Natanya Campbell and her mum Wendy Campbell Rodgers were killed when they were making a property inspection in Northland.

A man escaped with a bullet hole in his car windscreen while a mother and daughter were shot dead when they turned up for a property inspection.

Dad pulled trigger, court hears

Gustav Sanft is on trial for the manslaughter of his 2-year-old daughter.

'Is it OK to hold a loaded gun near your 2-year-old child,' Crown prosecutor asks jury.

Pregnant car crash survivor thanks rescuers

As an oncoming car came straight towards her, all Desire Purnell could think about was that her children would be left ...

Pregnant accident survivor thanks the chopper team who came to her rescue.

Learning centre farewells beloved teacher

Janet Holdaway cuts the cake with staff.

Teacher farewelled after 20 years of service.

Wellington

Dunny view not a dummy video

The view from the proposed toilet block site overlooking Turakirae Head.

Wainuiomata lighthouse could soon be the most scenic place in Wellington to do your business.

Final cycleway options

The layout of Wellington's Island Bay cycleway, which places the bike lane between the kerb and parked cars, has been ...

Cost of solving Island Bay cycleway dilemma could top $7m and see up to 57 car parks removed.

Govt to spend $12m on school

Wainuiomata High School is set for a $12 million upgrade.

Agieng parts of Wainuiomata school to be fixed, but it'll be 2 years before work starts.

Near miss on rail line

A train on the Wairarapa line narrowly avoided disaster.

A tired protection officer told a train driver the track was clear of workers. It wasn't.

Canterbury

Man finds forest in backyard video

Philip King and Danny Summers look over the thousands of logs littering Loudon Farm.

Farm owner Philip King could not figure out why his farm was flooded - until he discovered a $100k surprise.

Snow hits the south

Heavy snow in Tekapo on Thursday morning.

Tekapo is cut off by snow and up to 50mm of rain could fall in Canty as another front bears down.

Mayor: Front up to quake mistakes

Christchurch Mayor Lianne Dalziel says the city's earthquake symposium cannot just focus on the good parts of the recovery.

Mayor raised concerns quake conference would only focus on "everything we got right".

Threat to city's pristine water

The Waimakariri River is the primary source of Christchurch's drinking water.

Christchurch's public drinking water may become contaminated with nitrates from dairy farming.

Waikato

Waikato cop under investigation

Waikato police district commander Superintendent Bruce Bird is being investigated over interfering with daughter's arrest.

Top cop allegedly put pressure on another police officer to stop the arrest of his daughter.

Cops swoop on school

Police at Knighton Normal School in Hamilton East.

Officers patrolling grounds after incident at primary school in Hamilton East.

Fonterra lifts price to farmers

Fonterra farmers are benefiting from better global dairy prices.

A rebound of confidence in the dairy industry has seen a hike in the payout.

Foundry had 'no work' coming in

All was quiet at A & G Price on Thursday morning after 100 staff learnt on Wednesday that they'd lost their jobs.

Many staff at A & G Price thought company was in strife and were looking for work.

Taranaki

So, why visit Nelson?

The Priapos Fountain at Queen's Gardens is one of the more notable attributes of the historic grounds.

What to do with a direct flight to Nelson? Here's five reasons you might want to head south.

Digital double-up

A welcome sign celebrating the Patea Maori Club's iconic song greets visitors to Patea.

Patea now has two virtual services offering medical help while the hunt for new GPs carries on.

No relief for teachers

The relief teaching shortage is affecting classroom learning, according to Kim Manukonga of SyncEd.

Getting hold of a substitute teacher isn't getting any easier.

'Very lucky' in school bus crash video

Children on the bus have been transferred to another.

High school student on a bus when it crashed said her first thought was to check on the "little ones".

Manawatu

Work starts on retirement village

26072017 news photo DAVID UNWIN/STUFF
Construction has begun on a retirement village on Napier Road.

The $50 million retirement village will have a 70-bed rest home, 18 apartments and 72 villas.

Rail the key - Greens

A new slip fell on the already-closed Manawatu Gorge road last weekend.

The Green Party proposes a twice-daily passenger train as a Manawatu Gorge alternative.

Gorge health concerns

Another slip fell on the already-closed Manawatu Gorge road at the weekend.

As the ambulances drive over the top of the cliff, patients have to wait longer.

Junior bike tracks to open

​Fletcher Collins, 4, and brother Harry Collins, 2, might be back with their bikes this summer when the Esplanade site ...

The final grant has been confirmed and a contract let for bike paths.

Nelson

Cake business on the rise

Phil Lash of Chocolate Velvet.

As the name suggests Chocolate Velvet is a business that specialises in happiness; glorious cake happiness.

Crime spree arrest

One man has been arrested as police continue to search for two others following a number of crimes across Nelson last ...

Police have made an arrest in relation to several incidents last weekend.

College sees red over dyed hair

Year 11 Nayland College student Macy Sutcliffe was told her dyed hair, initially pink then red, left, did not meet ...

A Nelson student dyed her hair pink, then red. Her school took a dim view.

High need for radiotherapy unit

Patients in Nelson Marlborough who need radiotherapy have to travel to Christchurch or Wellington for treatment.

Cost of sending patients away for radiotherapy tops $1m while support grows for the treatment to be available in Nelson.

Marlborough

Music in the mourning

The Cloudy Bay Funeral Home reception lounge doubles as a quiet place to play for members of the Marlborough Civic ...

Blenheim orchestra desperate for a rehearsal space where they won't disturb anyone has found the perfect spot - a funeral home.

Cloud of fatal crash still hangs

Lara Glover, 16, died in the car crash on February 19.

Eight teenagers were in the car, but Jayne Glover says the whole region felt the crash that killed her daughter.

Call for new radiotherapy unit

Patients in Nelson Marlborough who need radiotherapy have to travel to Christchurch or Wellington for treatment.

Cost of sending patients away for radiotherapy tops $1m while support grows for the treatment to be available in Nelson.

Health board finances in good shape

The Nelson Marlborough District Health Board says it is in good financial shape.

The health board has ended the financial year with $3.2 million in the coffers.

South Canterbury

Students sent home video

Contractors clear snow from the road at Tekapo on Thursday morning.

Schools send students home as rain continues to drench South Canterbury.

Love is the answer

Mike King's speech in Timaru focused on King's struggles in the past as well as calling parents to become more involved ...

Unconditional love and communication will help improve mental health, Mike King says.

Fonterra lifts price to farmers

Fonterra farmers are benefiting from better global dairy prices.

Farmers receive welcome surprise as Fonterra raises its farmgate forecast.

Infected cows must go

Labour spokesman for primary industries Damien O'Connor is calling for all the cows on the property where Mycoplasma ...

The 150 stricken cattle on a South Canterbury farm should be put down, MP says.

Southland

Invercargill i-Site to trial pilot to lure migrants

Venture Southland general manager of tourism, events and community Bobbi Brown and Invercargill i-Site supervisor ...

The Invercargill i-Site has been selected by the Ministry of Business, Information and Employment to run a pilot looking to entice visitors to the region to migrate.

The 9-day garage sale

A vinyl record collection does not reflect the tastes of the current owner, Smith says.

Riversdale hoarder's "rationalisation" leads to nine-day garage sale.

Fishermen demand answers

CRA8 Lobster Industry Association chief executive Malcolm Lawson said consultation on the regulation changes have been ...

Southern fishermen want Primary Industries Minister Nathan Guy to front up over concerns regarding new commercial fishing regulations.

Tougher biosecurity wanted

Ministry for Primary Industries Aquaculture analyst Finn Sumner speaks to the audience at an Invercargill public meeting ...

Southlanders have made it known to MPI staff they want to see tougher biosecurity standards for the marine aquaculture industry.

Ad Feedback