Government, church at odds over offer to restore Christ Church Cathedral

JOSEPH JOHNSON/STUFF.CO.NZ

Victoria Matthews, Bishop of Christchurch and church members issue a statement regarding the replacement or repair of the Christchurch Cathedral to members of the public and media in front of the Cathedral in the Square.

The Anglican Church and the Government appear to be at loggerheads over whether an offer has been made to help restore the "eyesore" Christ Church Cathedral.

Sunday's press conference by Bishop Victoria Matthews was the latest twist in the cathedral saga which, just days before the sixth anniversary of the February 2011 earthquake, is unresolved.

Church leaders and the Government are both claiming they have done all they can to break the deadlock.

Victoria Matthews, Bishop of Christchurch, and Moka Ritchie, a trustee of Church Property Trustees, photographed on Sunday.
JOSPEH JOHNSON/FAIRFAX NZ

Victoria Matthews, Bishop of Christchurch, and Moka Ritchie, a trustee of Church Property Trustees, photographed on Sunday.

In December, Stuff reported the Government and Anglican property trustees were unable to agree on the terms of a deal that would see the cathedral in central Christchurch restored.

READ MORE:
$25m to break cathedral stalemate
No deal on Christ Church Cathedral before Christmas
New Cabinet considering Christ Church Cathedral restoration plans
Christ Church Cathedral announcement before Christmas
Cathedral working group investigate restoration
Govt announces 'working party' for cathedral
Anglican Bishop returns to NZ to consider cathedral plans - sources

On Friday, Greater Christchurch Regeneration Minister Gerry Brownlee said he was "surprised and disappointed" no restoration deal had been made for the earthquake-damaged cathedral. 

Gerry Brownlee has been handed the foreign minister's job vacated by Murray McCully.
ROBERT KITCHIN/FAIRFAX NZ

Gerry Brownlee has been handed the foreign minister's job vacated by Murray McCully.

The Government, he said, offered $10m in cash and a $15m loan to help restore the building.

But the Church Property Trustees (CPT) maintains no binding offer was received.

"CPT reached an agreement with mandated Crown negotiators including the Christchurch working group chairman Geoff Dangerfield . . . before Christmas," Matthews said on Sunday.

The Christ Church Cathedral sits decaying in the city centre.
IAIN McGREGOR/FAIRFAX NZ

The Christ Church Cathedral sits decaying in the city centre.

"That agreement, to CPT's surprise, proved not acceptable to the minister and at the last minute a two page, non-binding, principles document was sent through to the negotiating table.

Ad Feedback

"This two page statement of principles significantly changed the terms in ways that were not acceptable to CPT as prudent trustees, with $42 million to put towards an over $100 million project."

Since then there had been "very limited informal discussion".

"A revised two page statement of principles, which is non-binding and which I believe has not been seen by Cabinet, arrived this week.

"But it was not presented by the Minister, nor did we have assurance he was in favour of every aspect of it," Matthews said.

She then called the cathedral an "eyesore" and "icon" in Christchurch.

"[It] is not standing as it is today because the church doesn't care. We've tried every which way from Sunday to either have it deconstructed to sill level, or to get help to reinstate it.

"Don't think that you're the only ones frustrated," Matthews said to a small crowd in Cathedral Square.

Brownlee said the deal involved Anglicans putting $42m towards the restoration, campaign group Great Christchurch Buildings Trust raising $15m from donors and the Government donating $10m.

Trustee Moka Ritchie said the CPT had "never received a binding offer".

"We have waited a long time and worked with everyone who has come to us to try and reach a compromise.

Roger Bridge, who is a member of the working party to considering options for the Cathedral, expected the stalemate would be solved within the next month.

"Nothing's a sure thing, but both parties are working hard with goodwill to try and resolve this problem and find a way forward.

"I think everyone's frustrated, both the Government, the church and the people of Christchurch," Bridge said.

A spokeswoman for Brownlee said the Cathedral Working Group had made "significant efforts" to achieve a positive outcome for the cathedral and the city.

"In late December, Cabinet approved an offer of support involving a $10m payment towards the cathedral's restoration, a loan facility of up to $15 million, as well as the establishment of a Project Management Office and legislation for consenting of the project.  

"That offer was presented to the CPT and negotiations have continued since then," she said.

Brownlee was under the impression the CPT would meet next week to further discuss the options offered by the government.  

"The minister remains disappointed and frustrated that an agreement has not been reached."

Comments have been closed. 

 - Stuff

Comments

Ad Feedback
special offers
Auckland

Wildlife haven plan for Orewa estuary

Godwits are just one of the 50 species of bird that can already be found in the estuary.

Orewa estuary may soon return to a thriving wildlife haven if plans to restore its borders are successful.

Auckland beaches go smokefree

Auckland beaches will be smokefree as of November.

Smoking at beaches and outdoor dining areas has been stubbed out just in time for summer.

Last crew of HMS Leander dies

World War II navy veterans Des Price and Bill Morland who both served on the ship HMS Leander.

​The last surviving member of the famous WW2 ship HMS Leander has died in Auckland aged 97.

Coast youth 'gang' emerges

KFC

A group of 17 to 21-year-olds, who call themselves the LTB, have been causing trouble on the Hibiscus Coast.

Wellington

Evans Bay camper trouble

Neighbours complain that they regularly see freedom campers getting dressed in public, doing their laundry and cleaning ...

Freedom campers doing laundry and getting dressed in public, say neighbours.

Virus closes wards

A bad strain of norovirus has hit Hawke's Bay Hospital.

Thirty Hawke's Bay Hospital staff are showing symptoms of Norovirus

Attackers sought in teen assault

Police are calling for witnesses after a 14-year-old boy was assaulted by a trio of attackers in Hastings.

A 14-year-old is in a stable condition and police are looking for three attackers.

HIV 'harm' questioned

Mikio Filitonga was found guilty of  knowingly infecting a lover with HIV.

Medical advances mean passing on infection is less harmful, lawyer tells court.

Canterbury

Restoration sparks donation surge

The earthquake-damaged Christ Church Cathedral will be restored.

Decision to restore Christ Church Cathedral sparks rise in donations, including $10,000 from the US.

Tenants mum on rents

The Ministry of Justice says there are "no current plans" to sell Christchurch's new 42,000-square metre justice precinct.

Agencies moving into Chch's new justice precinct tight-lipped about rents in the $300m building.

Historic farm and manor for sale

Glenralloch Manor, built in 1912, is the centrepiece of the farm for sale that overlooks Pigeon Bay, Banks Peninsula.

One of New Zealand's earliest sheep and beef farms, on Banks Peninsula, is on the market.

'From paradise to prison'

Lachlan Findlay and Miranda Clare were in Dunedin for the sentencing of their father, Stephen Findlay.

Miranda Clare knew her dad was involved when she heard of a murder near Dunedin.

Waikato

Mother's phone scam taxi ride

Dimpi Nirmal, left and husband Vineet have $1900 worth of iTunes vouchers as a reminder of the phone scam.

They hacked her husband's phone, threatened his life then ordered her a taxi to an iTunes store.

One dead in Waihi 

A car and a truck were involved in the serious, two-car crash on State Highway 2, depicted in this Google Maps image.

Emergency services are responding to the State Highway 2 crash.

Shot before threesome

Tiffani Jade Sutcliffe asked if a shotgun was loaded before pulling the trigger and killing Rhys Gordon Williamson

It was meant to be an evening of drug-taking and group sex. It ended in anger and death.

Maurice's short sad life

Maurice Junior Papariu Murtagh was found facedown in the carpark of a Rotorua hotel.

He started taking magic mushrooms at 7. Soon he was inhaling aerosols. At 20, he was dead.

Taranaki

Coops captured on canvas

Jordan Barnes' portrait of Colin Cooper was commissioned by the TRFU as a farewell gift for the coach.

He's painted All Blacks and Anna Paquin and now, as a farewell present, outgoing Taranaki coach Colin Cooper.

Protection for breaks

Pro surfer Courtney Conlogue, shreds a wave at Fitzroy Beach which is on a list of Taranaki Regional Council surf breaks ...

Taranaki's top surf spots have been identified so they can be protected.

Climbing Everest in Taranaki

Hasely Lobb will be climbing the equivalent height of Everest over the month of November, taking it a step at a time ...

To climb the equivalent height of Mt Everest, you'd need to do Paritutu 90 times.

Gun club misunderstanding

The Disputes Tribunal rulled there had been a misunderstanding between the New Plymouth Club  and The New Zealand ...

A venue which cancelled a booking for a gun show and auction has been ordered to pay some of the associated costs.

Manawatu

$32,500 for a landline

Bill Tooley is unable to connect a St John Medical Alarm because Chorus needs to extend its network.

Manawatū man can't connect a medical alarm because Chorus needs to extend its network.

'Science cost Lundy' video

Mark Lundy, pictured at his 2015 retrial, has twice been convicted of murdering his wife Christine and their 7-year-old ...

Mark Lundy's lawyer opens appeal against the murder convictions.

Bright lights for lost infants video

Addison Murphy, 8, left, and Ruby Marsh, 11, light lanterns in recognition of International Pregnancy and Infant Loss ...

Manawatū remembers the lives of little ones with a lantern release.

Booze plan needs proof

Bottle stores and supermarkets are at odds about whether alcohol sales should stop at 9pm. Big Barrel's Baldeep Dhillon ...

Proof is needed to support proposed tougher alcohol controls in the city.

Nelson

No fixed abode

Cindy is living with her two sons in a borrowed caravan at the Tahuna Beach  Holiday Park while trying to get a Housing ...

Cindy has lived in a cramped caravan for the last month and finally has a place to live, it just isn't in Nelson

Triumph after crash

Louise Corbett can finally relax after her epic Ironman adventure.

Six months after being broken in a cycle crash, Nelson's Louise Corbett finishes the Hawaiian Ironman. 

Campaigner facing cannabis charges

Medicinal cannabis campaigner and "green fairy" Rose Renton faces cannabis charges.

Cannabis campaigner charged with supplying chronic pain sufferers with products.

Poachers 'too lazy'

Two hunters scaled a security gate to access a 580-hectare property near Pelorus River. (File photo)

But they weren't too lazy to climb a 2-metre gate 18 times in 15 months.

Marlborough

Convoys on a roll

Soldiers on Operation Exercise Southern Katipo give sentry duty while camp is set up at Omaka; from left, Private Weir ...

Exercise Southern Katipo is underway in Marlborough with soldiers and equipment being transferred on the alternate Picton to Christchurch route this week.

Revenge backfires

Screen shots posted by Lisa Maree Moynihan attacking people she claimed ripped off her son were shared more than 100 times.

A mum decided to shame an alleged dealer on Facebook when her son didn't receive his cannabis. 

Furnace plans spark action group

Alan Hall, foreground, is leading the resurrected Blenheim Residents and Ratepayers Association to fight a proposed ...

After "investing their life's savings" into their new homes, residents have banded together to fight the furnace to the bitter end.

Poachers too lazy to go around

Two hunters scaled a security gate to access a 580-hectare property near Pelorus River. (File photo)

But they weren't too lazy to climb a 2-metre gate 18 times in 15 months.

South Canterbury

Shearing shed gutted

Bruce Rogers surveys the damage to his shearing shed after the fire on Monday night.

Fire crews forced to cut holes in wool shed to extinguish "well involved" fire near Geraldine.

'Ripped from my life'

Oamaru pensioner William Arthur Lee arrives at Timaru District Court on Monday morning with defence counsel Michael de Buyzer

Oamaru pensioner sentenced after killing a man he drove into on a pavement.

No potato shortage in Sth Canty

Heartland Potato Chips manager Charlotte Bowan with her father, owner Raymond Bowan.

Heartland Potato Chips and Makikihi Fries both doing well this season.

Burner opposition is 'about fairness'

Former South Canterbury Regional Air Plan Liaison Committee secretary Tom O'Connor, left, with former chairman Mark ...

Residents are not giving up on woodburner opposition yet.

Otago

Kiwi favourites go offshore

A Dunedin group pulled out of a plan to keep production of Pineapple Lumps, Jaffas, Buzz Bars and Pinky bars local.

Manufacturer accused of "duping" union as Jaffas, Pineapple Lumps and Pinky Bars head off to Aus.

Backyard trapping volunteers sought video

Wanaka resident Kris Vollebregt caught three rats in her first two weeks of backyard trapping.

If you have a compost bin, you have rats. And that possum in your tree? It's yours, too.

Southern United lose Irish winger

Southern United's Andy Mulligan, left, challenges Leo Villa from Team Wellington during a national league football match ...

Southern United will have to do without the services of injured Irishman Andy Mulligan this season.

Cromwell basin business booms

At least 35 businesses supported the 11ha extension of Akarua's Pisa Development Vineyard near Cromwell.

Akarua Vineyard organises impromptu fair to celebrate viticulture investment.

Southland

Men lose everything video

A house on Main Street, Wairio in Western Southland, was gutted by fire on Monday morning.

A father and son are left with only the clothes they were wearing, after a house fire.

Old boy new chief

Chris Ramsay will succeed Greg Mulvey as ILT chief executive in 2018.

A return to his home province was just the tonic for incoming ILT chief executive Chris Ramsay.

Meet the NZ Mustangs

Leonie and Garry Heywood with their 1968 Notchback Mustang ahead of the Annual National Mustang Convention at Stadium ...

Around 175 Mustangs have been rounded up for NZ's annual convention of the iconic American sports car.

Victim struck log

Duayne Insley died when he was struck by a log hanging over the river.

The man who was killed in a jetboating accident struck a log hanging over a channel of water.

Ad Feedback