Government, church at odds over offer to restore Christ Church Cathedral


Victoria Matthews, Bishop of Christchurch and church members issue a statement regarding the replacement or repair of the Christchurch Cathedral to members of the public and media in front of the Cathedral in the Square.

The Anglican Church and the Government appear to be at loggerheads over whether an offer has been made to help restore the "eyesore" Christ Church Cathedral.

Sunday's press conference by Bishop Victoria Matthews was the latest twist in the cathedral saga which, just days before the sixth anniversary of the February 2011 earthquake, is unresolved.

Church leaders and the Government are both claiming they have done all they can to break the deadlock.

Victoria Matthews, Bishop of Christchurch, and Moka Ritchie, a trustee of Church Property Trustees.

Victoria Matthews, Bishop of Christchurch, and Moka Ritchie, a trustee of Church Property Trustees.

In December, Stuff reported the Government and Anglican property trustees were unable to agree on the terms of a deal that would see the cathedral in central Christchurch restored.

$25m to break cathedral stalemate
No deal on Christ Church Cathedral before Christmas
New Cabinet considering Christ Church Cathedral restoration plans
Christ Church Cathedral announcement before Christmas
Cathedral working group investigate restoration
Govt announces 'working party' for cathedral
Anglican Bishop returns to NZ to consider cathedral plans - sources

On Friday, Greater Christchurch Regeneration Minister Gerry Brownlee said he was "surprised and disappointed" no restoration deal had been made for the earthquake-damaged cathedral. 

Gerry Brownlee has been handed the foreign minister's job vacated by Murray McCully.

Gerry Brownlee has been handed the foreign minister's job vacated by Murray McCully.

The Government, he said, offered $10m in cash and a $15m loan to help restore the building.

But the Church Property Trustees (CPT) maintains no binding offer was received.

"CPT reached an agreement with mandated Crown negotiators including the Christchurch working group chairman Geoff Dangerfield . . . before Christmas," Matthews said on Sunday.

The Christ Church Cathedral sits decaying in the city centre.

The Christ Church Cathedral sits decaying in the city centre.

"That agreement, to CPT's surprise, proved not acceptable to the minister and at the last minute a two page, non-binding, principles document was sent through to the negotiating table.

Ad Feedback

"This two page statement of principles significantly changed the terms in ways that were not acceptable to CPT as prudent trustees, with $42 million to put towards an over $100 million project."

Since then there had been "very limited informal discussion".

"A revised two page statement of principles, which is non-binding and which I believe has not been seen by Cabinet, arrived this week.

"But it was not presented by the Minister, nor did we have assurance he was in favour of every aspect of it," Matthews said.

She then called the cathedral an "eyesore" and "icon" in Christchurch.

"[It] is not standing as it is today because the church doesn't care. We've tried every which way from Sunday to either have it deconstructed to sill level, or to get help to reinstate it.

"Don't think that you're the only ones frustrated," Matthews said to a small crowd in Cathedral Square.

Brownlee said the deal involved Anglicans putting $42m towards the restoration, campaign group Great Christchurch Buildings Trust raising $15m from donors and the Government donating $10m.

Trustee Moka Ritchie said the CPT had "never received a binding offer".

"We have waited a long time and worked with everyone who has come to us to try and reach a compromise.

Roger Bridge, who is a member of the working party to considering options for the Cathedral, expected the stalemate would be solved within the next month.

"Nothing's a sure thing, but both parties are working hard with goodwill to try and resolve this problem and find a way forward.

"I think everyone's frustrated, both the Government, the church and the people of Christchurch," Bridge said.

A spokeswoman for Brownlee said the Cathedral Working Group had made "significant efforts" to achieve a positive outcome for the cathedral and the city.

"In late December, Cabinet approved an offer of support involving a $10m payment towards the cathedral's restoration, a loan facility of up to $15 million, as well as the establishment of a Project Management Office and legislation for consenting of the project.  

"That offer was presented to the CPT and negotiations have continued since then," she said.

Brownlee was under the impression the CPT would meet next week to further discuss the options offered by the government.  

"The minister remains disappointed and frustrated that an agreement has not been reached."

Comments have been closed. 

 - Stuff


Ad Feedback
special offers

From education land to housing

An artist's impression of a new 197-dwelling housing development set to be built in Massey East, west Auckland.

A Crown land housing programme gets go-ahead for first project.

Delays after rush hour crash

Emergency services have rushed to a car and bus collision on Auckland's North Shore.

Three people hurt after car hits pedestrian and crashes at bus stop in Glenfield, Auckland.

House destroyed by fire

Fire fighters are battling a house fire in Mangere, south Auckland.

The house, in Mangere, south Auckland, was empty when it caught alight.

Ritz-Carlton hotel tower gets nod

The NDG Centre, as it is loosely known, is expected to take several years to build.

A 52-level hotel and tower block takes another step closer to construction.


109, and 'feeling not so bad' video

"They say there's a time to be born and a time to die. My time to die apparently hasn't arrived yet."

Madeline Anderson, believed to be NZ's oldest person, turns 110 on Thursday.

'I don't regret it'

A jury at Wellington District Court has found the unnamed stepfather guilty of assault with intent to injure. (File photo)

A man who attacked his stepdaughter's rapist says he did what any father would do.

She's a hard road in Kapiti video

Wendy Crawford and Margaret Crawford have a go at pronouncing the Maori street names.

Locals tackle the "unpronounceable" Maori road names proposed for the old SH1.

Crash claims 'good-hearted guy'

Ross Leslie Hallgarth, 54, of Hastings, has been named as the man who died in the Saturday crash. (File photo)

 Police still looking for vehicle that failed to stop after a smash near Hastings.


Cruise ships to return video

Christchurch is to get its first custom-built cruise ship berth with this image of the proposed $56m facility released ...

Lyttelton could see some of the world's largest cruise liners when a new $56 million cruise ship berth opens.

Man waved fake gun

Emergency services have been called to an incident on Pages Rd, Linwood, on Monday afternoon.

Man holding imitation pistol stood in front of a car and demanded the driver get out.

Marlborough man found in car

The Buller Gorge (file shot).

Dog to be rehomed after Buller River crash that killed 40-year-old Marlborough man.

'Baby' shark attacked tourist

Catlins Surf School owner Nick Smart says the injured woman is recovering well.

Shark that attacked a French woman was less Jaws and more an oversized Dory.


Winter from a factory video

The snow factory has made Whakapapa operations manager Steve Manunui a happy man.

This German-made machine can bury a house in snow in a little more than 24 hours.

 Moroney: No Plan B

Labour MP Sue Moroney will leave parliament in September.

Pressure is on Labour to field a candidate in Hamilton West.

Death rocks street video

Firefighters on Little St after being called to the fire at 3.30am.

Residents are shocked after a woman's body was found inside burnt-out Waikato home.

Car and truck crash near Rotorua

St John were at the scene of the crash on SH5, near Rotorua.

A car and truck have crashed on State Highway 5 in the Rotorua region.


Former prostitute back behind bars

Jan Yorke on her way to stand trial in the High Court at New Plymouth in 1996 for the murder of Nikki Goodwin in 1995.

Former Taranaki prostitute Jan Yorke - who killed a woman in 1995 - is back in jail because she's a risk.

Caught with cannabis

A man was convicted of cultivating cannabis after police found 172 plants in a  basement.

Police looking for somebody else discovered 172 cannabis plants in a Hawera man's basement.

South Taranaki's wild night

A door lies on a Hawera footpath beside the shed it blew off during a storm that buffeted South Taranaki on Sunday night.

Flying trampolines, power cuts, slips and fallen trees as South Taranaki cops wintry blast

Accused unfit to plead

A man charged with careless driving causing the death of  Robin Coutanche appeared in the New Plymouth District Court on ...

Charged with causing a crash which killed a man, the accused is too unwell to plead to the charge.


Women's expo draws a crowd

Melissa Frank, left, and Renee Dingwall sample Bio Farm milk with James Tait-Jamieson.

Thousands of women, and some men, turned out for the women's expo.

Crash victim named

Police have named the man who died in a crash between a motorbike and a tractor.

Fifty-one-year-old man died in crash with a tractor near Feilding.

Military still talking, Hager says

Investigative journalist and author Nicky Hager will speak about his book 'Hit and Run' in Palmerston North on Wednesday.

Nicky Hager has not given up hope of an inquiry into an alleged botched SAS raid in Afghanistan.

Chased off with cat food

The Summerhays Corner Superette was robbed in February 2015.

As robbers fled, this dairy owner grabbed the nearest weapon - a can of cat food.


Fundraising rev up

Tania O'Donnell shows her 1947 Ford at the display at Founders Park on Sunday.

More than 700 people viewed an array of gleaming vehicles at Founders Park for a good cause.

Rapist jailed

A man has been jailed for six years for raping a girl in her own home.

A Nelson man convicted of raping a teenager in her own home has been sentenced to six years in prison.

Fringe Fest kicks off

Fringe festival chairperson, Daniel Allan and festival director Laura Irish address the public during the 2017 Fringe ...

A fun-filled party launched nine days and nights of the Nelson Fringe Festival.

Mediterranean fanworm spreads

Mediterranean fanworms were detected at Port Tarakohe in September.

Councils in the top of the south may join forces to tackle the Mediterranean fanworm.


Marlborough man found in car

The Buller Gorge (file shot).

A 40-year-old Marlborough man was pulled from a submerged car in the Buller River on the South Island's West Coast.

He just wanted beer

He kept going back because he wanted more alcohol, his lawyer said. (File photo)

Forty bottles of Speight's later, beer burglar caught out. Must be a real southern man.

Top marks for safety

Eltham Rd resident Alex Craig, 9, is looking forward to being able to cycle to Bohally Intermediate School.

Better connected: New cycle lane to link up three Blenheim schools.

Seven hours in a Force 12

The Straitsman entering Picton harbour.

A ferry on Cook Strait is the last place anyone wants to be when a southerly hits - especially when it takes 7 hours.

South Canterbury

'Big push' for donations

Timaru Salvation Army Lieutenants Jacob and Emma Howan have been busy organising the Red Shield Appeal which started Monday.

Sallies say half of their clients with children are affected by poverty, ahead of donation drive.

Father of two killed

Police have named the man who was killed in a quad bike accident near Waimate as Paul Dee, of Waimate.

Police name Paul Dee, 46, as man killed in quad bike crash near Waimate on Friday.

SC schools in clusters double

Glenavy School principal Kate Mansfield says lots of schools are not getting on board, but her students can only get ...

More than 80 per cent of SC schools are involved in a Community of Learning.

New Ara chairwoman

Aoraki Polytechnic merged with Christchurch's CPIT at the end of 2015.

Ara Institute of Canterbury has a new chairwoman following the resignation of Jenn Bestwick.


Who will be the next deputy mayor?

Invercargill city councillors, Darren Ludlow, Lindsay Thomas, Toni Biddle, Lindsay Abbott, Lesley Soper, Lloyd Esler, ...

Cr Lloyd Esler said there were one or two members of the council who would be putting their name forward. 

The Southland divide

Infometrics senior economist Benje Patterson.

Some Southland towns are flourishing, while others are on the decline.

Immigration used to cut wages

Labour MP for Hutt South Trevor Mallard and Invercargill Labour candidate Liz Craig at ILT Stadium Southland.

Immigration has been a hot topic for the Labour Party leading into this year's election.

Special win for Otautau video

The Otautau rugby team and supporters after their win on Saturday.

The Otautau rugby team's win on Saturday meant a lot to the western Southland community.

Ad Feedback