In search of the poison pen letter writer threatening to reveal Middlemarch's darkest secrets video

James Gunn /

Going in search of the poison pen letter writer of Middlemarch, we discover a community that looks after its own.

The shadow of the 'Taieri Pet' hangs over the Otago town of Middlemarch.

The name is given to the lenticular cloud formation often spotted above the Strath Taieri area, 80km to the west of Dunedin. 

It featured most recently above the township at the annual Strath Taieri A&P show last Saturday, but it was a different Taieri Pet that cast a shadow that day. The 408th edition of the Taieri Pet newsletter, page two to be precise.

The cloud formation known as the Taieri Pet hangs over the Otago village of Middlemarch; the threats of a poison pen ...

The cloud formation known as the Taieri Pet hangs over the Otago village of Middlemarch; the threats of a poison pen letter writer weigh heavy within the community.

"Offences have been relatively quiet in the past month, and I have mainly been around the home patch," Senior Constable Helen Fincham-Putter wrote in the monthly police column. Crimes under investigation included a historic stone cottage broken into between mid-January and early February ("appears nil taken"), two cases of unlawful hunting, and three "reports of anonymous/poison pen letters".

On the ladder: Fed up with Auckland house prices? Move to Middlemarch
Did Middlemarch serial pool pooper make clean getaway?
* Join our private train trip through the South Island on the Sunday Star-Times Readers' Rail Tour

Two of those letters were sent to local women and concerned the state of their marriages, while the other provided information of a person driving while disqualified. "As they are anonymous," Fincham-Putter wrote, "the writer is usually over-confident and highly critical in their writing."

Middlemarch senior constable Helen Fincham-Putter is throwing all the weight of the police and its forensic services ...

Middlemarch senior constable Helen Fincham-Putter is throwing all the weight of the police and its forensic services into tracking down the vitriolic writer of the poison pen letters.

That column was later picked up by national media, upsetting local residents who argued it overshadowed positive events in the town, such as the A&P Show, and the biennial Middlemarch Singles Ball to be held on April 15.

Fincham-Putter said she had been "hounded" by media since the story came out. "It is just ridiculous . . . it has been blown out of proportion."

And there was no update on the case, she said, and no story.

So . . . Middlemarch here I come.

Ad Feedback


"The duties of her married life, contemplated as so great beforehand, seemed to be shrinking with the furniture and the white vapour-walled landscape," George Eliot wrote in her most famous novel, Middlemarch.

From the lush green of the Taieri Plain, State Highway 87 takes you to a rocky landscape more akin to the wild west and even the occasional backdrop for Peter Jackson's The Hobbit.

The brilliant sun overhead has failed to penetrate the low-lying fog covering the town of Middlemarch: pop 300.

A quick photo stop reveals some graffiti, albeit in neat, block capitals, written on one of the area's distinctive rocks 'AFTER DEATH JUDGMENT".

Perhaps not the penmanship of our poison pen letters, but a message nevertheless.

As the fog starts to burn-off the surrounding Rock and Pillar Range, which resemble a Grahame Sydney painting, are revealed. 

Someone has written AFTER DEATH JUDGMENT on rocks before you enter the town of Middlemarch.

Someone has written AFTER DEATH JUDGMENT on rocks before you enter the town of Middlemarch.

It's morning. Curiously the township's main street, which lies beneath a long autumnal shadow of the ranges, is almost deserted of motor vehicles and pedestrians.

Soon, though, lycra-clad cyclists completing their last leg of the famed Otago Central Rail Trail stream through the town to stretch their legs and enjoy a coffee at one of the cafes in town.

As they cycle past the local postal agency, the possible drop-off for the poison pen letters, I go inside to pick up a copy of the Taieri Pet.

Kate Wilson represents the rural village of Middlemarch on Dunedin City Council. Every community has someone that has a ...

Kate Wilson represents the rural village of Middlemarch on Dunedin City Council. Every community has someone that has a chip on their shoulder," she says, "and they may be a very sad and lonely person."

"Strange business," the older woman behind the counter says when I ask about the page 2 goings-on.

And like so many conversations on that topic, this exchange ends as quickly as it began.

The chattiest person on the topic turns out to be the one in the most hurry – to leave Middlemarch for good.

Middlemarch, home to a poison pen writer, is covered in fog

Middlemarch, home to a poison pen writer, is covered in fog

A middle-aged woman and "husband number two" are filling up their car at a self service pump across the road from the mailbox.

The woman, who does not want to be named, lived in the town for 17 years before moving to Dunedin almost a year ago.

"I always kept to myself," she says.

Entering the Otago town of Middlemarch. home to a poison pen letter writer.

Entering the Otago town of Middlemarch. home to a poison pen letter writer.

When she first moved to the town she did a few things in her first year in Middlemarch that influenced opinions of her; she wasn't spoken to for a whole year.

"If you are not welcome in this community you are out of this community," she says, as looks left to right down the town's main road, Swansea St.

While she doesn't know the writer of the poison pen letters, she is not surprised. Freezing people out was a way of ensuring "who they want to keep in the community and who they don't want in the community".



That wasn't different to other small towns, she does note.

The town has many positive things going for it, but its transformation into a tourism town has come at a cost to some in the community, she says, while others have profited. 

You can see the transformation with three bicycle hire places, B&Bs dotted around the town and farm-stays further out.

A dead possum on a road near the Middlemarch cemetery.

A dead possum on a road near the Middlemarch cemetery.

Middlemarch is a "beautiful wee place", but not for her. Not any more.


A resident familiar with the case tells me one of the letters was posted from outside the township, with the writing "deliberately small . .  like they were disguising it".

Middlemarch's Platypus submarine

Middlemarch's Platypus submarine

Another resident, now based overseas, says: "it's a pretty town but everyone knows everyone and there are no secrets".

He, like others, believes he knows the identity of the poison pen writer. "Being the town gossip was always her thing though."

While people are reluctant to name the woman they suspect to be behind the letters, several residents provide the name – even the address – of one of the victims.

The state of her marriage was targeted by the letter-writer. The accusations, says a man familiar with the couple, ares "lies".

The woman received anonymous texts and a few letters a couple of years ago, and it was possibly the work of two people, he adds.

No one is home when I visit the picturesque property of one of the victims, so I write a brief letter – the first I have written in years – and place it in their mailbox. Not the first letter she has received lately.

But nothing, not a nibble.

Local Dunedin City Council councillor Kate Wilson has lived in the area for almost 20 years, and in "another 15 I'll be a local".

Wilson says the poison pen matter was not intended for wider consumption, "Every community has someone that has a chip on their shoulder, and they may be a very sad and lonely person. but it is certainly not representative of people around here.

"And it doesn't mean it is true . .  maybe it is just a really sad person."

The community is focused on next month's singles dance, she says, and no-one is talking about the poison pen.

Yet everyone knows of the case, and soon everyone knows a reporter is in town asking questions.


"I'm not talking to you," says one female Middlemarch resident when asked about the possible identity of the writer. "It's an unfortunate business," adds another.

"Don't put my name in the paper," both exclaim.

Meet Sergeant Kevin Davidson, who opened one of the letters sent to the Mosgiel Police Station.

That letter, in neat, small handwriting, related to a "kid that was driving without a licence".

"She indicated it was one of a number."

She? Well, the handwriting appeared to be written by a female based on "the extent of my forensic examination", says Davidson, who declined to release a copy of the letter.

And the anonymous information appeared to have some credibility, with police speaking to a person named in the letter as driving unlawfully. "It has been brought to their attention as to what their responsibilities are under the Land Transport Act, we can't take it an further as we don't have specified incident recorded."

It isn't uncommon for police to receive anonymous information but it is difficult to determine the credibility of the information, he says.

"It is really weird . . . but it is not unusual."

Writing anonymous letters about the state of a person's marriage isn't illegal, and Davidson believes the person was either "acting in good faith, or just stirring".


I head to the museum just as it opens up, and after a few minutes I'm asked if I am that reporter that rung the day before. 

Guilty as charged, I say.

"We have so many interesting things happening here," the lady, who declines to be named, tells me. "And to have a person, maybe unwell, to have something like this being talked about around New Zealand is undermining our whole district."

"I find it trivial. I understand why the policewoman reports on the original crimes. I can understand why it was in our Taieri Pet."

She then reminds me about another Taieri Pet story that made national headlines. That concerned a serial pool pooper who defecated three times in the local pool, forcing its closure. And while that offender appears to have made a clean getaway, flushing out the poison pen writer will be an even harder challenge.

Maybe I should just do as the lady recommends: focus my attention on the museum's platypus submarine, designed and built in 1873 to prospect for gold.

Maybe she's right.  The submarine is internationally important and well-preserved with the dry Middlemarch climate helping to keep its large iron shell relatively free of rust.

A submarine out of water. A poison pen writing anonymous letters to residents of a small Otago town.

As I leave Middlemarch I hope the anonymous writer reads the thought of the month within Issue 408 of the Taieri Pet.

"It doesn't matter who hurt you or broke you down. What matters is who made you smile again." – Unknown.

 - Sunday Star Times


Ad Feedback
special offers

Fatal Northland crash

The crash occurred on Kapiro Road, north of Kerikeri.

A crash involving a car and a motorbike in Kerikeri has left one person dead.

'Phantom' to remain jailed

Loizos Michaels, pictured before being sent to prison. He has been decline parole twice.

A conman who calls himself 'The Phantom' and once duped Jonah Lomu has been denied parole.

Thousands gather in Auckland

The Anzac service at the Auckland War Memorial on Anzac Day 2017.

A crisp, clear morning greeted thousands of Aucklanders at the War Memorial Museum Anzac Day service.

One house but two homes video

The house is designed with two distinct "wings" to give each couple their own space. The only shared space is the foyer.

Buying a first home in Auckland's Grey Lynn was little more than a dream for two young couples - until they pooled their resources.


Services draws thousands video

Willie Apiata greets a soldier with a hongi during the Anzac Day National Commemoration Service at Pukeahu National War ...

Thousands stood in silence in remembrance of those who have fought under the Anzac banner.

Crook denied parole 

Kelly Leigh Crook was jailed for her role in the murder of Matt Stevens, which she helped attempt to cover up by faking ...

Kelly Leigh Crook lured a man to a deadly ambush then attempted to cover up murder by faking a car crash scene.

Protest mars service video

Newshub was interviewing peace activists Ellie Clayton and Laura Drew when they were interrupted by David Broome, and ...

"Do it tomorrow, do it the day before - but today is wrong, wrong, wrong." Father and son clash with peace activists.

Rentals smelly, musty and mouldy

Rental homes are more than twice as likely to have poorly maintained features than owner-occupied buildings, according ...

Rental homes are twice as likely to smell musty, and three times more likely to feel damp.


Wreath behind locked gates video

Jim Lilley, left, Allan Luchford and Cathy Luchford lay their poppies at the Christchurch Citizens' War Memorial.

The Christchurch Citizens' War Memorial has been off limits for six years. But this Anzac Day is different.

Climbers' bodies found

The bodies were found in the Darren Mountains.

The bodies two missing people have been recovered in Fiordland.

River surges to life

Sarah McCall and her family stand on the banks of the Eyre River, normally a dry riverbed, which surged to life on Good ...

"I don't know how it's doing that; I think someone's filling it up," 6-year-old Ruby McCall suggests.

Rentals smelly, musty and mouldy

Rental homes are more than twice as likely to have poorly maintained features than owner-occupied buildings, according ...

Rental homes are twice as likely to smell musty, and three times more likely to feel damp.


'Today means everything to me'

The Anzac dawn service attracted thousands to Hamilton's Memorial Park.

It's the one day the world remembers yet every day reminds this family of the price of war.

Body found in bush


A hunter alerted police to the grim find just after 1pm on Anzac Day.

Five hurt in highway crash

Emergency services are at the scene (file photo).

Two people suffered moderate injuries - three others got away with scrapes and bruises.

Stolen war medals come home

Sam Healy and daughter Jorji, 9, are reunited with their family's war medals.

A year ago thieves stole Sam Healy's grandfather's war medals. On Anzac Day eve, she got them back.


Teen to take on snooker's best

New Plymouth's Mario Hildred, 16, in preparing to take on the world's best in China later this year.

"Obviously I feel a lot of pressure when I get a high break to keep going to get more."

Anzac Day in Waitara

The Anzac Day Parade in Waitara before the civic service.

The weather was perfect for the Anzac Day services held around the mountain on Tuesday.

Missing Taranaki man

Jared Shaun McLean has not been heard from since Saturday.

"We all are actually worried, it's just unlike him to do this."

Bramhill for Greens

Dr Stuart Jeanne Bramhall has been picked as the Green Party's candidate for the New Plymouth electorate in the 2017 ...

Long time environmental activist Stuart Bramhill is the Green's candidate for New Plymouth. 


Gorge could be closed for weeks

About 3,500 cubic metres of earth is blocking the Woodville end of State Highway 3 through the Manawatu Gorge.

Manawatu Gorge set for another long closure after two slips block lanes.

Woman badly hurt

Police are at the scene of a crash in Dannevirke, where a motorcycle hit an elderly woman.

An elderly woman is in a critical condition after being hit by a motorcycle in Dannevirke.

Child basher in denial

Peter Ross Moran wants to live near a child whose brain he damaged.

He caused his victim's brain to become "watery mush", but still denies doing anything wrong.

Smoke and coffee to start the day video

Vietnam War vet Alby Armstrong gets ready for the dawn service in Palmerston North.

Alby Armstrong thinks about other soldiers when he's at a dawn service.


Richmond remembers lost heroes

Poppy laying during the Anzac Day service at War Memorial Gardens, Richmond.

Anzac Day crowds overflowed into the streets around Richmond's memorial gardens.

A city pays tribute video

Anzac Day dawn parade and service at Anzac Memorial Park, Nelson.

Thousands woke before dawn to attend Anzac Day dawn service in Nelson.

Nelson: The new Silicon Valley?

Markus Erdmann and Vivian Escorsin are part of the entrepreneur group Local.Foundation who are organising a business ...

Business group says Nelson has potential to become "start-up hub of New Zealand".

Flowers revive wartime memories

World War II veteran Allan Carson holds poppies from Flanders Fields in Belgium, brought back from a visit there in ...

A Nelson man's souvenir from a WW1 battlefield stirs up two generations of memories.


Pak 'n Save's unusual policy

Two German men have stolen meat, cheese, beer and herbs from Pak 'n Save Blenheim.

What to do with food found on a shoplifter's person? Put it back on the shelves, of course.

Anzac day treats

Kaikoura council earthquake recovery economic lead Mel Skinner with a plate of Anzac cookies from Wellington's Good ...

The Good Bitches' homebaking brings a sweet reassuring note to earthquake recovery effort.

'It's a reality check'

Dawn services at the Seddon Memorial Hall.

Friends, family remember those who made the ultimate sacrifice in Anzac commemoration.

'The supreme sacrifice'

Australian Army veteran Betty Binnie gets her two remounted medals pinned to her chest by RAAF Squadron Leader Marcus Watson.

Rocked to the core by earthquakes, the people of Ward stand strong to remember the fallen this Anzac day.

South Canterbury

Honouring sacrifice

War veterans march on Memorial Ave towards the cenotaph at the Anzac Dawn Service in Timaru.

A crowd of a few hundred stood at the cenotaph in Timaru to commemorate Anzac Day.

Raising awareness 

Volunteer firefighter and former NZ Army infantryman  Maaka Mckinney is escorted into Timaru from Waimate by Timaru ...

Maaka McKinney is raising awareness for depression among first responders.

New book on war hero

Tom O'Connor has published a book on Waimate war hero Eric Batchelor.

The life of one of New Zealand's most decorated soldiers has been detailed in new book.

Man killed in crash

A man is dead after a crash on Freehold Creek Bridge at Lake Ohau.

One person has died after a single-vehicle crash on a bridge in the Waitaki District.


50-year-old receipt returned

Sue Samson with the 50-year-old receipt left in the Winton Night 'n Day store on April 6.

They'd kept their honeymoon receipt for five decades. So when a shopkeeper found it, she knew she had to return it.

Climbers' bodies found

The bodies were found in the Darren Mountains.

Bodies recovered from Fiordland after missing pair "suffered a fall".

Nasa balloon seen from Chch

Ashley Marles managed to photography the balloon with his own observatory.

That "bright stationary object" is headed for outer space - with an Anzac poppy in tow.

Gore's Anzac service

Gore High School pupil Jake Miller with Gore RSA padre Bruce Cavanagh before he left on the Anzac exchange.

A Tamworth student carried Australia's flag at Gore's Anzac Day service.

Ad Feedback