Rates shock discussion creating confusion: Hardaker

The recent debate on the state of the city's books "completely contradicts the facts as I know them to be and is ...
CHRISTEL YARDLEY

The recent debate on the state of the city's books "completely contradicts the facts as I know them to be and is creating confusion", former Hamilton mayor Julie Hardaker said.

Even Julie Hardaker is stunned by Hamilton City Council's recent rates shock.

The former mayor is part of a chorus of concern in response to a 12 per cent rate hike proposal from Mayor Andrew King, which came on the back of a grim presentation of the city's accounts.

Another ex-mayor, Margaret Evans, called for an independent audit of the city books, as has first-term Councillor Geoff Taylor, who said there appeared to be gross mismanagement at play.

An annual 3.8 per cent rate rise will get Hamilton City Council to a sustainable position, chief executive Richard ...
CHRISTEL YARDLEY/FAIRFAX NZ

An annual 3.8 per cent rate rise will get Hamilton City Council to a sustainable position, chief executive Richard Briggs said. The mayor is asking if we need to get there sooner.

King has said the previous council under-rated for six years, but chief executive Richard Briggs says the rates question is about how fast councillors want to get Hamilton City Council to financial sustainability.

READ MORE:
Former Hamilton mayor Margaret Evans calls for independent audit of council 'bombshell'
Hamilton Mayor proposes 12 per cent rates rise
The road to Hamilton's shock rates rise proposal
Proposed 12 per cent rise out, but cuts in, warns mayor

Hardaker said the recent debate on the state of the city's books "completely contradicts the facts as I know them to be and is creating confusion".

"When you've been told that things are going so well, it's very difficult when you get told it's not going well," ...
CHRISTEL YARDLEY/STUFF

"When you've been told that things are going so well, it's very difficult when you get told it's not going well," Hamilton Mayor Andrew King said.

The mayor from 2010 to 2016 was known for her meticulous approach, and said she was satisfied the city books were in good shape when she finished last October.

"I had 100 per cent confidence in management and the advice that was being given. Based on what I read in the newspapers, there seems to be a lot of contradiction about that advice and that gives me cause for real concern," she said.

"[My] council took the advice of management and the buck stops with the CEO and management in giving accurate advice."

Councillor Angela O'Leary spent a weekend going through the books and said she found nothing to concern ratepayers.
CHRISTEL YARDLEY/FAIRFAX NZ

Councillor Angela O'Leary spent a weekend going through the books and said she found nothing to concern ratepayers.

There are challenges ahead of the new council, but that's business as usual, she said.

Ad Feedback

Councillors have made decisions, which is their choice, but they also have the choice to ask staff to find budget savings elsewhere.

"You can't rate the public for everything. You have to make priority decisions."

Briggs agrees there has been confusion and understands where Hardaker is coming from.

Annual 3.8 per cent rate rises will get council to a sustainable financial state, he said.

"The challenge the mayor has put forward is: are we getting there fast enough, given the growth challenges that are heading our way?"

More discussions will follow in the 10-Year Plan process, when council will also look at issues such as cost structures and levels of service provided to the city.

Council has to prioritise its spending every year, Briggs said, but there's an extra challenge in 2018/19 because of added depreciation costs from when council's assets were revalued.

Mayor Andrew King defended Briggs, saying he was just the messenger.

"He's being shot when all he's done is tell the people what's happened.

"When you've been told that things are going so well, it's very difficult when you get told it's not going well," he said.

"We need to live within our means."

The rates shock episode was a hit to the city's reputation, Cr Angela O'Leary said.

"I did spend all weekend going over all of the annual reports and annual plans and finance reporting ... since 2014. There was nothing I found, absolutely nothing, that would cause ratepayers to have any concern about the way that the books have been run and whether or not we've been rating correctly.

"The messages that are coming out, they just don't stack up with everything that I know and everything that has been reported."

 - Stuff

Ad Feedback
special offers
Auckland

Board boundaries questioned

Local board boundary changes may be necessary to reflect the community new residents of developments identify with, and ...

Milldale residents will identify as being part of the Hibiscus Coast but the Rodney Local Board will reap their funding.

Housing fears in Northcote

North Shore ward councillor Chris Darby said people can't live in consents.

"No one can afford a $650,000, so why is it affordable? Massey University professor asks.

Migrant strikes chord

Founder and principal of the Albany School of Music, Grace Dong Liu, was named Migrant of the Year at the  New Zealand ...

Judges sing the praises of a music school's founder at immigration awards.

Council: East Auckland cliff prone to landslips

A large landslip on August 20 has affected properties in Clovelly Road, at Auckland's Eastern Beach.

Following a significant residential landslip on Sunday, Auckland Council confirms the Clovelly Road cliff has a history of instability.

Wellington

Wainui to be Wellington's Mayfair?

The bucket fountain on Cuba St.

Voting for capital version of famous board game throws up unexpected suggestions.

Lawyer unremorseful

Former Napier lawyer Gerald McKay was struck off in 2014 after the New Zealand Lawyers and Conveyancers Disciplinary ...

Jailed lawyer has entitlement issues and 'treats prison staff like receptionists'

Meeting leads to rape charge

A man is accused of raping a woman who thought she was coming to his home for a business meeting.

He had put out flowers and opened champagne for the woman he would be accused of raping.

Brothers' $2.4m fight

Robert Burnside, son of Jim, has been involved in a court fight with his brother Alec.

Judge tells sons of wealthy Hawke's Bay businessman to stop the "unreasonable mutual suspicion" and infighting.

Canterbury

Canty house pops up in field

Hillcrest, a 140-year-old colonial villa from Marshlands, Christchurch has come to rest in the middle of a field near ...

Out to pasture: No longer wanted, 140-year-old homestead sold and popped in a field.

$280k elderly scam

At least 30 elderly women have been scammed out of a total of $280,000 by a group of scammers, including Brendon Karl ...

22-year-old Christchurch man admits using a phone scam to con at least 30 elderly women living alone.

Armed robber-on-a-bike jailed

Brent James Atkinson, 48, has been jailed for the robbery of two Christchurch Kiwibank branches. He told police he ...

Man who hit two banks and escaped on a red bike jailed for more than seven years.

Hospital after playground collision

Two schoolgirls were taken to Christchurch Hospital, one in a serious condition, after a collision at Cobham ...

Schoolgirl in serious condition in hospital after a playground collision with another student.

Waikato

Staff's last resort

The front glass doors of the BP in Horotiu were smashed by four robbers armed with a metal bar.

Petrol station staff resort to parking car in front of doors to stop ram raiders.

River crash victim dies

Rescuers extract the two people from the car towing a trailer that plunged into the Waikato River at Cambridge on ...

The 60-year-old woman died in Waikato Hospital on Monday afternoon.

Rail promise for Hamilton

Labour leader Jacinda Ardern announces her plan to create a commuter railway connection between Auckland, Hamilton and ...

Billions of dollars' worth of roads will not help ease congestion - but rail will, Labour says. 

Tuheitia reaffirms Māori Party

Waikato Tainui Kīngi Tuheitia Pootatau Te Wherowhero Vll at the 11th annual Koroneihana, celebrating his ascension to ...

Māori King Tuheitia also dismissed Māori TV in an address at Tūrangawaewae​ Marae.

Taranaki

Hello You

Loralee Chittenden has opened Hawera's newest women's clothing store.

...says Hawera's newest clothing store.

Tapping into history

Rob Green, of Heritage Taranaki, has been part of a group which has developed a free app exploring the history of the ...

Modern technology being used to transport people back to the battlefields of Taranaki's civil war.

Shocking recognition

TIES on the Fonterra job that has got them into the finals for the Master Electricians Excellence Awards.

After entering a second time, they're in the finals again.

From office to garden

Amanda Kendrick swapped her 9-5 job for a lawn full of produce.

She traded her 9 to 5 job for a slice of the good life. 

Manawatu

Wasting less, recycling more

Sam Battman is woking inside and outside the Palmerston North City Council building to make recycling easier for people.

Palmerston North recyclers given a boost. Just don't throw away that broken wine glass.

No partner rule rare

Palmerston North Boys' High School year 12 student Zain Collins was not impressed at the no-date, no-ticket rule at his ...

Many Manawatu schools do not require pupils to take a partner to the formal ball.

Stalled projects provoke angst

Palmerston North's Cuba St, outside Distinction Hotel, as it could look after the delayed streetscape makeover.

Palmerston North city debt drops, but promises are not fulfilled.

River works urgent

Erosion at the Ashhurst Domain is made worse by flooding in May.

Agreements are being sought for the protection of the Ashhurst Domain.

Nelson

Food cart back in business

Food truck owner Karen Gonzalez, left, serves Priyanthi Bojaraj in November before she was forced to close her business ...

A food cart near St Arnaud has reopened on the alternate highway after four months in limbo.

The missing Link

Nick Smith said he's hopeful Nelson's Southern Link could be included in an upcoming regional transport announcement.

The Southern Link has not been included on the govt's 'national significance' list.

Red Cross burglar pleads guilty

Aaron James Waharoa will be sentenced in October after he pleaded guilty to burglary and unlawfully taking a motor ...

A 41-year-old man has admitted to breaking into a Nelson Red Cross service centre.

Sabotage at the sanctuary

A section of the Brook Waimarama Sanctuary fence that was cut out over the weekend ahead of a poison drop.

Holes cut in Brook sanctuary fence, locks glued and trees felled ahead of poison drop.

Marlborough

Fresh approach?

Labour has printed another 5000 signs to replace the ones featuring former leader Andrew Little.

Come on Labour, let's do this. Campaign signs still selling the old "approach" in Marlborough.

Log spears family bach

The felled tree trunk pierces into the living room.

Family demands answers after felled tree destroys Marlborough Sounds bach.

Missing man likely dead

Marlborough Sounds man William Kerry Blair disappeared in March 2014. (File photo)

But how Kerry Blair died in the Marlborough Sounds still remains a mystery.

Food cart back in business

Food truck owner Karen Gonzalez, left, serves Priyanthi Bojaraj in November before she was forced to close her business ...

NZTA put $10,000 towards making the lay-by safer for drivers pulling over.

South Canterbury

Man's car found in canal

Missing Twizel man David Fountain.

A police dive team has found missing man David Fountain's car in a canal near Twizel.

Food course launched

The new food processing course would begin at Ara Institute of Canterbury next year.

New qualification to prepare students for life in the food processing sector launched.

Rare kaki released into wild

51 kaki will be released in the Mackenzie Basin on Tuesday.

Fifty one of the world's rarest wading bird are being released in the Mackenzie Basin.

Council silent on burner comments

Woodburner.

Council has no public position on candidate's advice to halt consent applications.

Otago

Ongoing Otago post-flood relief

Milton Scout Group members Cy Smith and Blake Michelle, both 10, hand over groceries to recipient, Fiona Miller who was ...

Post-flood relief provided by offenders and scouts in South Otago.

Fire at Dunedin hospital

Four people have been injured after an incident at Wakari Hospital in Dunedin on Tuesday morning.

Four people have been injured after a suspicious fire broke out at a Dunedin hospital.

Balclutha Santa parade paid for by pokies

The Problem Gaming Foundation of New Zealand is urging councils not to use pokie machine funding.

Pokie funding to pay for Balclutha Santa Parade to continue.

From The News Desk: My pokie funding dilemma.

Clutha Leader reporter Mary-Jo Tohill.

From The News Desk: My pokie funding dilemma.

Southland

Polyfest hits new heights video

Members of the Otatara Kindy on stage at Polyfest 2017

''They like the sense of whanau, they feel like they are a part of something."

Hospitality at the heart of the south

Ronald McDonald Family Room supervisor Helen Walker and volunteer Susan Stenton at the Ronald McDonald House ...

Southland's inaugural Purple Work Shirt Day is raising funds for Ronald McDonald House.

'Stubbornness' gets Grieve home

Dwight Grieve from Fiordland leads Jack McNaughton and Buddy Small in the early stages of the Southland championships in ...

Stubbornness and a want to succeed have helped Dwight Grieve claim the Southland Road Championship title in Te Anau on Saturday.

Quick thinking prevents injury

Fire crews attend a house fire on Dipton street, Invercargill, on Sunday afternoon.

An Invercargill family had a close shave following a house fire in Kingswell.

Ad Feedback