Judge slams Child, Youth and Family for misleading information - Minister launches review

Social Development Minister Anne Tolley is a "bit cross" that Child, Youth and Family told her they'd done a full review ...

Social Development Minister Anne Tolley is a "bit cross" that Child, Youth and Family told her they'd done a full review into how they got their information to the courts so wrong.

The government is launching an inquiry into how Child, Youth and Family put a three-year-old girl at risk with its unsubstantiated and unverified reports.

Social Development Minister Anne Tolley said it's "really disturbing" she had been consistently given advice that a full review had been done into how CYF told the court the girl's father was violent when it was actually the boyfriend of her drug-taking mother at fault.

"It's always a bit difficult for a minister to interfere when something is before the Family Court but I have to be able to rely on (CYF's) assurances that they've done a full investigation and a full investigation means outside people having a look at what's happened and what's taken place," she said.

RNZ

A judge has told Child Youth and Family it put a Wellington toddler at unacceptable further risk by giving misleading information about her father to the Family Court.

Radio New Zealand reported CYF told the court it was the girl's father who was violent but those reports were wrong and Family Court Judge Anthony Walsh described the reports as unsubstantiated and unverified.

READ MORE:
Secret recording captures Child, Youth and Family admitting errors over toddler's death
Vote for the name of the new Child, Youth and Family agency
Child abuse rise sparks Child, Youth and Family review
Chris Trotter: Child, Youth and Family changes may be far reaching for Maori

 


"CYF acknowledged it had provided incorrect information about the father being violent ... Understandably the misleading information distressed the father and compounded his frustration particularly with CYF," he wrote.

The delays meant it took five months for the father to get care of his daughter and he was now suing CYF for $10,000 legal costs plus to pay for therapy for his daughter.

The chief social worker would conduct the full review ordered by Tolley and would speak to a range of people including those who made the decision, gave the advice and the father.

Child, Youth and Family  has been criticised for a judge who says its wrong information but a young girl in danger. ...

Child, Youth and Family has been criticised for a judge who says its wrong information but a young girl in danger. (File photo)

"I was assured on a number of occasions that a full investigation had taken place but from what I can gather it's the same people taking a look at what they've done and saying, yep we've done it ok, the decisions we made were right.

Ad Feedback

"That's not a full review or independent oversight," she said.

Labour leader Andrew Little said there should be an expectation that "professionals working with families in a stressed and vulnerable situation" make every effort to get it right.

While he acknowledged mistakes can be made, he said, the father of the child had every right to be "aggrieved".

"I want to know the systems in place in MSD are so good and so robust the chances of this ever happening again are pretty remote," he said.

CYF has apologised to the father and said he could ask the Chief Executive's Advisory Panel for a review if he was not happy.

CYF sent a statement saying it would take a close look at its practice, as it always did if the Family Court raised concerns.

Prime Minister Bill English said there was a much higher lever of awareness now, which meant "people are more likely to complain if it's wrong than used to be the case".

More complaints was "healthy" because it meant the agency was more likely to get it right in future, he said.

 - Stuff

Ad Feedback
special offers
Auckland

Substation conversion wows

Back in the 1940s Auckland Electric Power Board buildings were constructed in an industrial Deco style. This one, in ...

With its 30cm-thick solid concrete bunker-style walls, this Herne Bay home is here to stay.

Driver uses footpath in traffic jam video

Note the driver on the far left, driving along the footpath in Manurewa.

Brazen Auckland driver was spotted taking over the whole footpath in bid to beat congestion.

Love letter to One Tree Hill

One Tree Hill at dawn.

Nothing gets my pulse running like your tranquil slopes and I miss you terribly.

Rugby player collapses on field

The player was rushed to Middlemore Hospital.

Man fighting for his life after incident at World Masters Games in Auckland. 

Wellington

Survival kits a 'recipe for disaster'

Emergency survival kit contents.

Consumer NZ finds pre-made survival kits lack key items or contain poor-quality gear.

Bay revamp in 2018 video

An artist's impression of what the revamped Shelly Bay could look like.

Face-lift for Wellington's derelict Shelly Bay could leave ratepayers $1.5m a year better off.

Broadhurst quits rugby

James Broadhurst made his test debut for the All Blacks in their 2015 Rugby Championship test against South Africa in ...

One-test All Black hangs up boots after struggling to recover from concussion.

Stepdad wanted to hit rapist more

A unnamed man from Paraparaumu has denied assaulting Jason Haward, who raped his 15-year-old stepdaughter.

He tells court: "I presume any father put into that situation would react in the same way."

Canterbury

What happened to SoMo? video

Thompson believes Sydenham will be "the place to be" in about five years.

Sydenham is bouncing back, but will it take five more years to become "the place to be"?

Spags gets new digs

280417 NEWS Photo: Joseph Johnson
Spagalimis Pizza restaurant in Victoria Street has been closed for some time for ...

Spagalimis pizzeria is moving into the Harlequin Public House building and will reopen in weeks.

Shark attack victim doing 'OK' video

The French tourist arrives at Dunedin Hospital by helicopter after she was attacked by a shark while bodyboarding in ...

What a difference a day makes for the tourist who survived a Southland shark attack.

CBD precincts rising

The ANZ Centre offers shops, a cafe called Arbo and an espresso and wine bar, Arborista.

Goodbye empty lots, derelict buildings and road cones - hello Melbourne-style vibe.

Waikato

Beach commute gets safer

NZTA central North Island regional Director Parekawhia Mclean and MP David Bennett on SH23.

Highway between Hamilton and Raglan is in line for $9m in safety improvements.

Cops hunt ram raiders

Police are following up leads in the case (file photo).

A silver Mazda or similar vehicle was seen leaving the area around the liquor store.

Leave Garden Place alone

As more people move into Hamilton central city to live, these open spaces become more important as public amenities.

OPINION: It's time to talk about how cars fit in with a modern and vibrant city, write Rowena Hay and Aaron Wong.

Celebs in karst-studded landscape

Race Director Tim Day and Organiser Paul Charteris on the trail.

TV presenters Sam Hayes and Mike 'action man' McRoberts prepare for Waitomo trail run.

Taranaki

McFarlane on leave of absence

Long serving Waitara councillor Craig McFarlane is still recovering in hospital after suffering a stroke in February.

Council colleagues keen for deputy mayor to have time to recover

Passport giveaway 

27042017 News GRANT MATTHEW/FAIRFAX NZ

Alice Glasser lost her passport when she gave away her backpack and other ...

An act of kindness by American woman living in New Plymouth backfired when she left her passport in items she gave away.

Volunteer 'always learning'

Puke Ariki volunteer host Adrienne Nightingale has been volunteering at Puke Ariki since 2003.

After 14 years, a dedicated Puke Ariki volunteer says she is almost 'one of the artifacts'.

Hammer attack plea

A police scene guard was set up after the September 25 attack in Nevada Dr, New Plymouth last year.

The hammer blows knocked the victim off his feet as blood flowed profusely from his head.

Manawatu

A slushy success video

There's been plenty of water on the ice rink's surface.

Water on Palmerston North's ice rink doesn't put off thousands of skaters.

Fire ravages home

With a house ablaze, three people got out in time.

Three people escape a house fire in Roslyn, Palmerston North.

Motorcyclist dies

A man is dead following a motorcycle and tractor crash in Manawatu.

A man is dead after the motorcycle he was riding collided with a tractor in Manawatu.

We're stuck with the gorge

Drone shot of the 2017 Manawatu Gorge slip, blocking State Highway 3 at the Woodville end.

OPINION: Manawatu Gorge closures may be costly but the alternative options are even pricier.

Nelson

Crash upsets the apple cart video

Emergency services workers and a crane operator work to clear the blockage to the road after a truck crash on the ...

Traffic delays continue after cruck carrying thousands of apples spills load near Nelson.

Rental costs surge

Median rental prices in Nelson have jumped to $380.

Nelsonians can now be expected to pay $380 for a rental property in the region.

Mapua power restored

Jellyfish Cafe and Bar owner Debbie Lavery puts a closed sign on the popular venue because of the power failure in Mapua ...

Power is back on in Mapua after an outage caused chaos on Thursday.

Severe weather warning for region

Nelsonians are advised to take their umbrellas if they plan on leaving the house this weekend.

A wet weekend is on the cards for Nelson, as a front brings three days of rain.

Marlborough

A real Kaikoura 'cliffhanger' video

A digger working to clear SH1 near Kaikoura was buried by a slip.

Dramatic video shows a digger high up on a cliff face on the Kaikoura Coast, half-buried by a slip.

Air force keeps quiet

United States Air Force personnel in the Anzac parade on Tuesday.

Troops on the ground and planes in the sky, but little is known about US Air Force in Marlborough.

The lowdown

Co-owners Simone and Chris Hill with dog Sam

If you haven't yet popped into Cinnamon House Design in Blenheim, it's worth a visit.

The $500m quake bill

Road damage and closures was one of the big costs from the Kaikoura earthquakes.

The Kaikoura earthquakes are expected to cost New Zealand around half a billion dollars.

South Canterbury

Parents remember 'talented' son

Rowan Yeager died following a crash near Lake Ohau on Anzac Day. This photo, supplied by friend Andrew Weatherall, shows ...

A man killed in crash near Lake Ohau was just a week away from moving into a house he built by hand.

Strong winds lash SC

Police were called to the scene of a camper van crash on Friday afternoon, thought to be caused by the wind.

Emergency services kept busy by incidents caused by strong winds.

Judge sceptical of medical note

Timaru District Court.

Judge questions medical note provided to excuse Timaru man from court appearance.

Power line blocks road

A power line is down on Kent St in Timaru.

Alpine Energy is on the way to fix a downed power line on Kent St, in Timaru.

Southland

Shark attack video

The French tourist arrives at Dunedin Hospital by helicopter after she was attacked by a shark while bodyboarding in ...

A surfer has been attacked by a shark at a beach in the Catlins in Southland.

Struggle after shooting

Ben and Verity McLean.

Families say they're humbled by the outpouring of support and compassion.

Deputy mayor resigns

Cr Darren Ludlow.

Darren Ludlow has resigned as deputy mayor of Invercargill.

SDHB propose axing 23 jobs

Southern DHB chief executive Chris Fleming.

"There will be some people very positive about what we're proposing, and there will be some negativity."

Ad Feedback