Matahina Dam responsible for flooding, say residents video


Work on rebuilding Edgecumbe's flood wall began last week.

Edgecumbe residents are blaming the Matahina Dam for the flood that swamped their small town.

The criticism echoes a similar complaint made after the 2004 Edgecumbe floods.

Not enough water was released through the dam prior to the heavy rains, say some.

The Matahina Dam was venting water through its overflow chute.

The Matahina Dam was venting water through its overflow chute.

But the Bay of Plenty Regional Council say that management of the dam cannot be blamed.

Edgecumbe evacuated in '500-year event'
Cut off by flooding, Ruatoki people are survivors 
The eel was a sign, the call was urgent: Get out of Edgecumbe

Resident Graeme Bourk told RNZ he was less than 20 metres from the floodwall before it collapsed.

The dam is near the township of Edgecumbe.

The dam is near the township of Edgecumbe.

He said the dam should have been spilled for at least a month to avoid the flooding.

A similar event happened on the other side of Edgecumbe in 2004 and TrustPower, which operates the dam, said it would never happen again, Bourk says.

Colin Holmes, the former mayor of Whakatane, agreed with Bourk's comments and said TrustPower panicked and opened the dam too late.

"Exactly what happened in 2004. Poor information, poor flood management protocols between the regional council and Trustpower. Result: disaster," he told RNZ.

Ad Feedback

However, the Bay of Plenty Regional Council say the water was already at a minimum level before the flood.

"TrustPower started lowering the levels in Matahina Lake from Monday lunch time - well before the predicted rainfall," said flood manager Peter Blackwood.

"Council activated its Whakatane flood room at midday on Wednesday and [the experts] worked round the clock to minimise flood damage and protect communities.

"The flood management plan for the Matahina Dam is designed to take 100 m3/s off the flood peak," the release said.

"We exceeded this by taking off 110 cumecs per second. If we hadn't used the storage in Matahina dam, 12 per cent more water would have flowed down the river at the peak of the flood.

"Tough decisions were made well and our data shows that those have paid off."

Blackwood said river levels were at one in 500 year levels and the stopbanks are only designed for 1 in 100 year levels. "Ex-cyclone Debbie rainfall levels were very high. On the Rangitaiki, sites logged between 200-320mm in 48 hours," Blackwood said.

"Stop banks in the Eastern Bay are designed for a one-in-100 year event. At their peak, river flows were more than 30 per cent larger than this."

Council flood manager Roger Waugh, told RNZ that TrustPower did exactly what was asked of them.

TrustPower, at the orders of the council, started increasing flows on Monday and by Wednesday night, all spill calls were one.

The dam was still being re-filled on Friday.

The failure of the concrete section of stopbank in Edgecumbe "happened very, very quickly". It was not known why yet, but there was seepage underneath it, Waugh said.

* Comments on this story are now closed.

 - Stuff


Ad Feedback
special offers

Sport: Papakura Netball results

Hui Hui Kotahi U15
Back Row, from Left to Right: Shakaya Peeni-Rata (Manager), Breeze Peeni-Rata, Mary Jane Finau, Paris ...

Here's the latest results from the Papakura Netball Centre games from Saturday, June 24.

Fire at Auckland home

Fire crews on the scene at the Miranda St house.

The blaze started in a bedroom and ripped through the rear of the house.

Gearing up for legendary rugby cycle tour

Grange Leaman, left, Tanya Leaman, Rich Horwood and Adam Harper are looking forward to an exciting challenge which will ...

A bit of friendly fire expected as Franklin locals join All Blacks and British Lions charity cycle ride.

Behind the scenes of the Coast's famous page

Greg Taylor spends about 60 hours per week on the Hibiscus Coast Facebook page.

Greg Taylor is well-known for his jokes on the Hibiscus Coast Facebook page.


Student takes Government to court video

University of Waikato law student Sarah Thomson is taking on the Government in court.

Law student takes Paula Bennett to court over Government's position on climate change.

Love appeal declined

Sir Ngatata Love failed to appeal his conviction and sentence for obtaining property by deception.

Disgraced Sir Ngatata Love has failed to appeal his conviction and sentence.

Lions touch down in Welly video

Loose forward Sean O'Brien walks through a "guard of honour" set up by the fans.

The British and Irish Lions rugby tour has finally rolled into the capital.

Death of the malls?

Johnsonville residents are worried their local mall is dying a slow death, with McDonald's being the latest tenant to ...

They're not dead yet, but it's getting hard not to kill them off.


Alleged burglar denies charge

Brendon Smith appears in the Christchurch District Court via video-link from Christchurch Men's Prison.

A woman filmed him and told him to "drop my stuff" after he allegedly burgled her home.

Police FB 'freak shows'

Police use Facebook to find suspects, fugitives and missing people, but "nasty" comments plague their pages.

Facebook is a great way for police to find suspects, but some of the comments are less than savoury. 

Kicked in the head

Police are investigating a brawl outside Dunedin Casino (file photo).

A man was taken to hospital after a brawl outside Dunedin Casino.

Fisherman disappears

Slope Point is the southernmost point of the South Island.

Search sparked after police find only man's car and some fishing equipment.


Protesters block mine access

Protect Karangahake chairperson Duncan Shearer and other protesters Suse Durcan and Beccy Dove walk slowly in front of ...

Police called in as anti-mining protesters made their point.

Student versus state video

University of Waikato law student Sarah Thomson is taking on the Government in court.

Hamilton law student says "a lot of people have their hopes" on court case.

Street fracas after crash

One resident's Toyota Vitz ended up taking out a fence after being struck by another vehicle.

"Everyone was really going crazy," witness says of Hamilton crash where a girl, 13, was hospitalised.

Rest home cuts loom

Rest home operators say cuts to services or staff numbers is inevitable in the wake of a landmark deal to increase wages ...

Waikato rest homes could cut staff in the wake of increased wages for aged care workers.


Skate park to be lit up

Vinny Horwell, 2, from Lepperton flies through a puddle on his bike at the East End Skate Park on Sunday.

A team of four are working towards getting lights for the East End Skate Park.

Stolen car 'well on fire'

A car reported stolen went up in flames.

Police are now looking for three teens seen leaving the scene.

Winter festival launched

The Marfell Community  op shop will have a stall at the Winter Festival, says Ruth Pfister (right), pictured with ...

A community festival will liven up Marfell this Saturday.

Bubble build's no trouble

25062017 News Photo ANDY JACKSON/Fairfax NZ.   Bubble house build, A glass house made from plastic bottles at the ...

Vegetables, not fizzy drink, will be found in these bottles.


A new home

Amina Muhammad Juma, left, and Taskeen Jafari, from Afghanistan, watch World Refugee Day celebrations.

A rainbow of cultures and stories were celebrated with song, dance and food.

Escape from blaze

A Palmerston North family home, on Featherston St, was destroyed when a fire tore through it in on Monday morning.

A Palmerston North house was on fire, but its residents got out.

Schools running at a loss

Peter Brooks.

Almost 40 per cent of Manawatu schools outspent their income during 2015, data shows.

Neighbourliness put to the test

An artist's impression of the proposed roof over the Whanganui velodrome.

OPINION: Does the optimism of mayors reflect real people's views?


Nelson's crowd-sourced Christmas

The new design is hoped to be a significant upgrade on the former Nelson Christmas tree on the Church Steps.

The NCC has $100,000 to spend on Christmas and wants the public to design its tree.

'Dead in the water' video

Smoky Fry in the hazelnut orchard that gets flooded from the Tasman District Council stormwater drain overflow.

Hazelnut growers threaten to fill TDC stormwater drain with concrete after floods cost thousands in lost crops.

Poison fight heads to court

The Brook Valley Community Group is taking legal action to challenge the new regulations for pest control.

Community Group takes legal action ahead of Brook Sanctuary aerial poison drop.

What makes Nelson so special?

A veiw looking over Nelson from the Centre of New Zealand.

The Regional Development Agency wants to hear what you love about living here.


Tagging inspires theatre mural

Marlborough Civic Theatre Trust chairman Kevin Moseley wants the Marlborough community to have input into a mural design ...

A daring piece of graffiti on a Blenheim theatre has led the trust behind the building to consider their own artwork as a replacement.

Driver admits guilt

Lara Glover, 16, died in the car crash on February 19.

Teen admits dangerous driving causing death but challenges police version of events.

Two drivers hospitalised

Fire, ambulance and police attended the crash on New Renwick Rd.

Fire, ambulance and police respond to two-car crash.

Bail pending fraud sentencing

Coffey was accused of helping deceive his former employer, the Department of Internal Affairs.

Former gambling inspector Kevin Coffey gets bail until fraud sentencing.

South Canterbury

Foodbank applauds bag appeal

Timaru Salvation Army Lieutenants Emma and Jacob Howan are hopeful that the physical bag in Monday's paper will prompt ...

Timaru foodbank operator hopes appeal will help restock at crucial time of the year.

Black spot targeted

John and Linda Cant, grandparents of Ruby Marris, 5, who was killed in a head-on collision near Moeraki in February ...

New safety system installed on high-risk stretch of road near Moeraki.

Coldest night of the year

Canterbury's coldest night of the year created a frosty start to the work week.

Timaru has woken to the coldest morning of the year with a temperature of -3.7C.

One dead in plane crash 

A member of the Otago Aero Club was killed in the crash.

One person has died after a small plane came down near Middlemarch in Otago.


Struggle to keep Maori language alive

Former Te Wharekura o Arowhenua school principal Arni Wainui.

''If we lose our language we lose a large part of who we are and who we identify ourselves as."

Search underway

Slope Point is the southernmost point of the South Island.

Search and rescue operation underway in Southland after fisherman reported overdue.

Pet dog shot dead

Max's owner found his body on Friday evening near the front gate of their property.

"Playful, friendly" labrador found dead at home with a bullet in his chest.

Strip and dip at Winter Fest video

A bright orange birdman leaps from the wharf on Queenstown's lakefront.

Scene of unseasonal jollity unfolds on Queenstown's lakefront as near-nude men and women fall over one another and rafts lose crew.

Ad Feedback