Anger and questions over Edgecumbe Flood as talk turns to legal action video

CHRIS McKEEN/Stuff.co.nz

Work on rebuilding Edgecumbe's flood wall began last week.

With nothing but the clothes on their backs and heads full of questions, Edgecumbe are evacuees sit waiting for answers - and they are angry. 

Some question why the stopbank wall collapsed, why water was not released from the Matahina Dam earlier and why did all the systems designed to protect their homes fail? Others wonder when their insurance will pay out. They are the lucky ones. Many didn't have insurance.  

But all are asking who is responsible and who is liable.

Whakatane Regional Council community board member Graeme Bourk wants answers about why Edgecumbe flooded.
MATT SHAND/STUFF

Whakatane Regional Council community board member Graeme Bourk wants answers about why Edgecumbe flooded.

Whakatane Council community board member Graeme Bourk planned to organise a community gathering to bring a class action lawsuit against whoever is found to be responsible. 

"There are a lot of angry people here wanting answers," he said. "I'm glad they are on my side. I wouldn't want to go up against them."

READ MORE: 
Anger and questions over Edgecumbe Flood
Matahina Dam responsible for flooding: residents
Frustrations over lack of alerts in Edgecumbe flood
SPCA rescues 50 animals from flood-stricken Edgecumbe in one day
* Watch: a kayak across flooded Edgecumbe farmland

Some of the damage from the flooding in Edgecumbe.
TOM LEE/FAIRFAX NZ

Some of the damage from the flooding in Edgecumbe.

Bourk said if a class action were to go ahead, it would be done to help those without insurance to recover some of their belongings and rebuild their lives. 

"I'm one of the lucky ones," he said. "There are people here who have lost everything. We're going to hold everyone to account."

By everyone, he means Trustpower, which owns the Matahina Dam, Pioneer Energy, which owns the Aniwhenua Dam, and the Whakatane Regional Council, which manages the stopbanks. 

Locals won't be allowed home for some time, officials say.
TOM LEE/FAIRFAX NZ

Locals won't be allowed home for some time, officials say.

Bourk was at ground zero when the College St stopbank collapsed on Thursday. He believed a chain of errors built up.

Ad Feedback

"I was about 50 feet away when it [the stopbank collapse] happened," he said. 

"Water was coming through the wall and underneath it. Its foundations had gone.

Debris strewn across properties from the floods.
TOM LEE/FAIRFAX NZ

Debris strewn across properties from the floods.

"A [regional council contractor] digger and a truck were there putting metal up against the foundations to bolster it. As soon as the digger moved the load up to the wall, the whole thing collapsed and two metres of water came flying in.

"They were just doing their job. But they [regional council] should have engineers there. It was an extreme situation to be in."

He felt the council failed to assess the seriousness of the situation and sought to put a Band-Aid solution on too-large a problem. Furthermore, cracks had been appearing in the stopbank wall for years and he believed it needed to be reinforced earlier.

The destruction in the town is widespread.
TOM LEE/FAIRFAX NZ

The destruction in the town is widespread.

Bourk said the last-minute effort to bolster the wall was just one part of a long chain of errors by council and the power company. If any one of those errors had not been made, the stopbank might not have collapsed, he said. 

"Trustpower is saying there was nothing more than could be done, but that's nonsense," he said. 

"The Aniwhenua Dam [another dam on the Rangitaiki River] was empty at the time of the flood. Why wasn't water put in there?"

Edgecumbe residents want to know why more water wasn't spilled from the Matahina Dam to ease the pressure on the stopbanks.
Chris McKeen

Edgecumbe residents want to know why more water wasn't spilled from the Matahina Dam to ease the pressure on the stopbanks.

The Aniwhenua Dam is operated by Pioneer Energy Ltd. CEO Fraser Jonker said the dam was undergoing maintenance at the time of the flood but operated under its flood management procedure once the weather worsened. 

Jonker said the dam has very little storage facility. 

"Even if we changed our flood procedure, which you should never do, at the time, I do not think it would have made a difference," he said.

"At this stage, as CEO, I am confident my people did the right thing."

Bourk adds that dam water should have been let flow out of Matahina Dam earlier, knowing the storm was coming, to help alleviate the pressure on the river and, failing that, intentionally breaching the stopbanks elsewhere, which might have saved the town. Also, regional council should have opened Reid's Canal, a floodwater system installed after the flood of 2004, earlier, to relieve pressure on the stopbank wall. 

Whakatane Mayor Tony Bonne said what happened in Edgecumbe was a "design failure" and the root causes of the flood will be investigated.

Bonne was able to answer some of the questions put by Bourk.

He said he was aware the Aniwhenua Dam was empty and he, too, questioned that when he was given a flyover of the flood zones. The answer was that it wouldn't have stopped the flood.

"It can't store much water," he said. "It's a very small dam."

When asked if the digger action could have contributed to the collapse of the stopbank wall, he only replied: "My understanding is they were reinforcing the wall."

Regarding Bourk's questions about the Matahina Dam, he said it was letting water out of the spill gates leading up to the flood, which lessened the impact of the flood. For more technical questions, he deferred to Bay of Plenty Regional Council flood manager Roger Waugh.

"The stopbank wall fell over quick and we still do not know why," Waugh said. 

"The wall had been there for decades and went through the 2004 event. It was a foundation failure. We had seepage in parts underneath the wall. We do not know why this occurred."

Waugh said Trustpower and regional council, the controllers of the dam, had released the Matahina Dam to its lowest level leading up to the flood and said in doing so, reduced the impact of the flood by 100 cubic metres. 

In a statement from Trustpower chief executive Vince Hawksworth, "As stated by the Bay of Plenty Regional Council, the Matahina Dam was emptied in advance of the flood to provide as much storage capacity available. 

"The storage available in the Matahina Dam, during a major flood event, is only a fraction of the total volume of water contained within the flood.  Therefore, it is not possible to stop any significant flood event; rather, it is matter of using what storage is available to reduce downstream flows during the peak of the flood event – and this is what was achieved. 

"The available storage was then utilised through the event to reduce peak outflows, reduce risk downstream particularly during hours of darkness, and to assist the Bay of Plenty Regional Council in their effort to manage the impacts of the event.
 
"This was an unprecedented weather event. Ex-cyclone Debbie rainfall levels were very high – on the Rangitāiki, sites logged between 200-300mm in 48 hours.
 
"If the storage in Matahina Dam had not been used, 20 per cent more water would have flowed down the river at the peak of the flood.
 
Waugh said the river was currently flowing at 400 cubic metres per second. At the peak of the event, it was 750 to 830 cubic metres per second.

"If we hadn't used the dam, we would have had over 900 cubic metres coming through," he said.

When the breach occurred, he estimates 100,000 litres a second were pouring into the town. 

"We were here thinking of our plan to stop it," the council's regional works engineer Tony Dunlop said.

He sent the contractor out to organise it, went half a minute down the road, when he got the call it was breached. 

The police had already begun asking people to self-evacuate. "They had minutes," Bonne said.

"It's the old story - if it had happened during the night, there would have been deaths."

Many of the evacuees, however, swap stories of the 2004 flooding and what was different about this flood and now. Fred Mansell said it was blind luck that saved the town in 2004, as a natural stopbank breached, which eased pressure off the town wall as water spilled into farmland. He, too, has questions.

"The river was about the same height, but then the wall held," he said. "They should have breached the river somewhere else to save the town."

Mansell said he was not aware of any upgrades to the wall since the 2004 event.

"The wall was seeping through but it held. The didn't do anything to fix it. They should have made it thicker or stronger somehow."

Waugh countered that by saying an intentional breach in the stopbank would not be good practice. 

"If we were to do that, the flood would become uncontrollable," he said. 

With public meetings being held with evacuees over the next few days, the residents hope they will be able to get some more concrete answers to their questions and hopefully identify anyone liable to bring the class action suit against. 

For now, their immediate thoughts are getting back into their homes to discover how much damage the flood has caused. 

"No one died," Bourk said. "But people are really affected and have lost pets. I think when people go back in and see what has happened, this town will start to boil over. It will be very emotional and people will want to know who is liable."

 - Stuff

Ad Feedback
special offers
Auckland

Young disabled man to be deported

Sagar Narayan relies on his family for help.

Immigration NZ says he's a burden on the health system. His dad says he'll die if he's sent back to Fiji.

South Auckland house ablaze

At least two fire crews remain at the Maurice St home. (FILE)

A bedroom fire prompted two fire crews to put out the blaze in Papakura.

Who buys liquor at 7am?

Under new regulations, you won't be able to reconstruct this photograph after 9pm. (FILE)

So you can buy booze at the crack of dawn but not after 9pm. And apparently that's OK.

Cost of ultrasounds on the rise

Some radiology clinics are charging pregnant women more and more for routine ultrasounds due to what they say is a lack ...

Auckland clinics say underfunding is forcing them to charge mums-to-be for routine checks.

Wellington

Bank theft accused

Bank branch manager Fiona Barber is accused of taking funds from her bank.

Fiona Barber worked for ANZ for 32 years. She is accused of taking over $134,000 over six years.

Scared at the wheel

How courteous are you when driving?

Most Kiwis have no faith in other drivers, but apparently don't own their bad driving.

Alcohol, speed in crash death

Koro Peachey, 37, of Wainuiomata,  died in a motorcycle crash in Upper Hutt.

Koro Peachey was speeding, he'd been drinking, and the motorbike's front wheel was on backwards.

Fired for swearing

Pak 'n Save.

Supermarket worker heard bad-mouthing her managershould not have been fired, ERA says.

Canterbury

Stuck in rebuild limbo

Michelle and David McLean's home rebuild was demolished before it could be completed.

Michelle McLean wants to warn people about cross leases after her property got stuck in a rebuild deadlock.

'Special part of the city'

Landscape work on the CTV site is due to begin next week.

The CTV site, where 115 died, to become a "peaceful place to sit and reflect".

'Auntie Dai' paid out

Dai Bing was working as the manager of the Auntie Dai's Dumplings restaurant in the Christchurch Bus Interchange ...

Company ordered to repay woman whose name adorns dumpling restaurant chain.

From Happy to Braveheart

Sixty residents and staff at the Diana Isaac Retirement Village in Christchurch combined their talents to produce this ...

First he had a global viral video hit with retirees singing pop songs - now he wants to change people's minds about Christchurch.

Waikato

Virtual cave tour

Ruakuri Cave will be the first cave system in New Zealand to be brought onto Google Maps.

Google goes underground, allowing you to explore one of NZs hidden gems from home.

CBD is hot property

Hamilton CBD, seen from teh east side of the Waikato River, is experiencing increased occupancy amid a stroing of new ...

Waiting for a tenant doesn't work any more, Hamilton commercial real estate leader says.

Toilet training in paradise

Raglan hopes to stop any unnecessary wastewater overflows by reminding people of what should and shouldn't go into the ...

Holiday destination plagued by sewage spills takes toilet etiquette to the street.

Casino robbery lead

Police want to speak to this man in relation to the robbery of a man from the Hamilton's SkyCity Casino.

Police want to speak to this man after a winner was followed and robbed at knifepoint.

Taranaki

A man without Viices

McComb said he would love to perform at Homegrown or the Reading Festival in the UK at some point.

Viices, aka Jake McComb, "only really made enough to pay for parking" the first time he busked.

Jury out in sex case

A jury of eight men and four women have begun deliberations at a sex trial in  the New Plymouth District Court. (File Photo)

A jury is considering verdicts in a case involving sex allegations which date back 10 years.

No 8 Taranaki's best player

Toa Halafihi has been named Taranaki player of the year.

Taranaki give out players of the year awards.

Tantrum free shopping

Holly Vandenberg, with niece India Miller Rain Vandenberg, has started up the Panda Crew website where people can ...

Would you use a subscription service to buy your baby clothes?

Manawatu

A rural shemozzle

Libby Masefield having fun with bulls' balls in her mouth.

What started as a yarn at the pub has become a rural event attracting 5000 visitors a year. 

Appeal continues video

Mark Lundy, pictured at his 2015 retrial, is appealing his convictions for murdering his wife and daughter.

Lundy's appeal expected to cover petrol and public perception.

Milner-Skudder surgery complete

Nehe Milner-Skudder dislocated his shoulder after an awkward fall during the All Blacks' win over Springboks earlier ...

Injured All Blacks star hopes to be back in late April or May after successful operation.

Life-changing bikes introduced video

Tetraplegic Marina Theron hopes to one day use the bike freely.

Walking bikes put the rehabilitation of people with crippling illnesses into motion.

Nelson

Milk dance creative, entertaining

The Creamery was part of the Nelson Art's Festival.

The Nelson Musical Theatre was transformed into a cheese factory for The Creamery - an interpretive show about the world of cheese.

Final drop begins

A small number of protesters show their disdain for the third poison drop at the Brook Sanctuary.

Final poison drop starts as part of the Brook Sanctuary operation.

Man critical after Suter Gallery fall

The Suter Art Gallery in Nelson, where an independent contractor fell on Tuesday, sustaining critical injuries.

A man is fighting for his life after falling while carrying out work at the Suter Art Gallery.

GP practice accredited

Collingwood Health is now Foundation Standard certified.

After failing to meet accreditation standards in the given timeframe, Collingwood Health has now achieved them

Marlborough

A rose for Red Cross

There are 2500 roses ready to sell at the fundraiser on Thursday.

Preparations are underway for Red Rose Day tomorrow.

Bridging the gap

Sounds Air chief executive Andrew Crawford says if the research stacks up 19-seater Beechcrafts could be flying between ...

Sounds Air could be flying 19-seaters between Christchurch and Blenheim by early next year.

Corporate rowing crews battle it out

30082017 News Photo: TOM LEE/STUFF - Sport - Rowing NZ team media day at Lake Karapiro. Mens eight

Corporate 8 crews optimistic at Wairau Rowing Club's annual challenge.

'Skylarking' caused fatal crash

Lara Glover, 16, died and four others were injured in the car crash on February 19.

Teen driver caused fatal crash by swerving his parents' SUV from side to side while doing close to 100kmh.

South Canterbury

First crack at musical direction

Matt Deavoll is trying his hand as musical director for upcoming South Canterbury Drama League show Variety.

Deavoll's been in the orchestra, and on the stage. Now, for the first time, he's the musical director

Fees for monitoring

South Canterbury Chamber of Commerce chief executive Wendy Smith said she hoped the move was a "genuine"  attempt to ...

Timaru residents who break the terms of their resource consents will have to pay.

Loan nearly paid off

Phar Lap Charitable Trust member Noel Walker says the trust is chipping away at the loan it received to cover the ...

Trust still chipping away at loan eight years after Phar Lap statue was erected outside race track.

Shearing shed gutted

Bruce Rogers surveys the damage to his shearing shed after the fire on Monday night.

Fire crews forced to cut holes in wool shed to extinguish "well involved" fire near Geraldine.

Otago

Qtown businesses losses continue

Businesses claim insurance for being affected by Mall'spartial closure during its repair.

"It's normally full outside...Not many people like sitting outside and looking at the building site."

Cromwell basin business booms

At least 35 businesses supported the 11ha extension of Akarua's Pisa Development Vineyard near Cromwell.

Akarua Vineyard organises impromptu fair to celebrate viticulture investment.

Ngāi Tahu elder dies

Kuao Langsbury speaks during a Waitangi Day celebration at Ōtākou Marae.





Copyright Photo, Otago Daily Times, ...

A tangi has been held for Kuao Langsbury, a Ngāi Tahu elder and key negotiator of their settlement with the Crown.

Captain Cook closes again

The Captain Cook Hotel in Dunedin has closed until a "suitable" new operator can be found.

The Captain Cook, an iconic Dunedin bar, has shut its doors once more.

Southland

The Lim hymn: Let's Eat

Celebrity chef Nadia Lim shares her latest book, Let's Eat, with Julie Allan, Sarah Johnson and Gabrielle Berger Sidwell ...

Despite releasing seven cookbooks in seven years, inspiration is never far away for celebrity chef Nadia Lim.

Bravery awards given

Nightcaps men Conrad Waihape, left, and Phil Manson were presented with Bravery awards at a Southland District Council ...

"It was pretty dark and bloody hard to see..."

Let's talk, Southland: Kirwan

Sir John Kirwan visited Northern Southland College, Lumsden, on Tuesday afternoon.

Mental health speeches "powerful, timely, relevant".

Aparima College to get new principal, board of trustees

Aparima College commissioner Nicola Hornsey.

Embattled Aparima College in Riverton is set to have elections to form a board of trustees after its new principal is recruited.

Ad Feedback