Q&A: What is a one in 500-year flood, and does that really apply to Edgecumbe? video

CHRIS McKEEN/Stuff.co.nz

Work on rebuilding Edgecumbe's flood wall began last week.

Edgecumbe's flood has been identified as the greatest flood on record  - but is it truly "a 500-year flood", as has been suggested?

Bay of Plenty Regional Council made the claim after the Rangitaiki River burst through stopbanks designed for a one-in-100 year flood event, gushing into hundreds of homes and forcing 1600 people to evacuate.

Though the weather has cleared, houses remain sodden and filled with mud, and some will be condemned due to structural damage. Residents will be allowed to return briefly to fetch necessities, but it could be up to 10 days before many occupants can go home to inspect the damage and find out what they've lost. 

The Edgecumbe flood burst through stopbanks designed to stand up to 100-year floods.
CHRIS MCKEEN/FAIRFAX NZ

The Edgecumbe flood burst through stopbanks designed to stand up to 100-year floods.

Meanwhile, work is ongoing to assess how the flood really stacks up against others in New Zealand's history - and how soon we might expect a repeat.

READ MORE:
Edgecumbe and Bay of Plenty have shaky, flood-prone histories
Photo essay: Edgecumbe in ruins
Kayaking into Edgecumbe

 
Whakatane Mayor Tony Bonne, right, says it was a "one-in 500-year" flood, but Bay of Plenty Regional Council won't ...
TOM LEE/FAIRFAX NZ

Whakatane Mayor Tony Bonne, right, says it was a "one-in 500-year" flood, but Bay of Plenty Regional Council won't release the data that assessment was based on.

WHAT IS A '500-YEAR FLOOD'?

Prepare for a maths lesson.

The label "a 500-year flood" refers to what experts call a "return period" or "recurrence interval" - an estimate of how long until the next disaster of the same size or intensity.

Water gushed into hundreds of homes, forcing 1600 people to evacuate.
Chris McKeen

Water gushed into hundreds of homes, forcing 1600 people to evacuate.

Alongside climatic events, like rainfall, floods and tornadoes, return periods can also be applied to earthquakes, tsunami and volcanic eruptions.

Ad Feedback

When we talk about flooding return periods, a one-in-100-year flood means a one per cent chance, on average, of a repeat event in the same spot occurring in any given year, regardless of when the last one was.

A one-in-10-year flood would have a 10 per cent chance; for a one-in-500-year flood, it's 0.2 per cent in any given year.

The council and locals will need to assess whether future stopbanks need to have a higher level of protection.
TOM LEE/FAIRFAX NZ

The council and locals will need to assess whether future stopbanks need to have a higher level of protection.

Of course, New Zealand doesn't have 500 years of flood records - in fact, many cities and towns' records only go back a matter of decades - meaning a hydrologist's job of predicting flood flows for a 500-year event is challenging.

HOW DO WE KNOW HOW BIG A 500-YEAR FLOOD IS?

Without a longer historical record, experts can only make an estimate.

"When you've got a short record, then you're quite uncertain about those very long return periods, or very low-probability events," Niwa hydrologist Roddy Henderson says.

"You're both uncertain about the magnitude of them, or if you get one, you're uncertain about what its exact return period is."

He gives the example of looking at 50 years worth of flood records, finding the most extreme flood, and assuming it was a one-in-50-year event, or perhaps a one-in-100-year event.

The best guess, he says, "often is somewhere in between those two ... You end up with an estimate where the biggest record is maybe 1-½ to 1-¾ times the length of record - that's your sort of expectation".

Estimating what a 500-year flood would look like is, therefore, a challenge, with climate change, climate cycles and weather patterns, and different ways of analysing data internationally all adding to the difficulty.

DID EDGECUMBE REALLY HAVE A ONE-IN-500-YEAR FLOOD?

Bay of Plenty Regional Council has repeatedly said Edgecumbe is experiencing a 500-year flood - a claim "based on technical information from the regional council", according to Whakatane Mayor Tony Bonne.

The council is refusing to make that information public.

The Rangitaiki River's flood records go back to 1952, and it's fairly hard to estimate exactly how big a 500-year flood would be from 65 years of data. 

The town's stop banks were built for a 100-year flood, and the council says the flood was "30 per cent bigger" than that.

However, on Saturday, council flood manager Roger Waugh walked the original estimate back, saying: "Once the analysis has been done, it's likely to be in the order of a 200 to 500-year flood."

Henderson says it'll be some time before the flood's actual return period is known.

"To get something exceptional after 50 years of recording does put you up quite likely beyond 100 [years] usually, but to be precise about it, no, I certainly wouldn't be going that far at this stage before someone's had a chance to have a good look at the data."

The regional council and Niwa staff were still working to assess the flood's flows, "and until that's done, it's not really feasible to put a return period on the event", he says.

While we could assume this week's flood is the biggest Edgecumbe - or New Zealand - will ever get, Henderson says that's probably not the case.

"The fact that we've seen it that large means there probably could be something a bit bigger. And so the debate is all around, right at that end, exactly how rare were those biggest three that we've seen and how much bigger could it get."

DOES IT REALLY MATTER?

To a degree, yes - but it's not the biggest issue here.

Auckland University associate professor Dr Asaad Shamseldin, an expert in hydrology and water engineering, says the main point is that regardless of the flood's return period, the town's stopbanks were inadequate to stop it.

"The debate should focus on whether they should increase the level of protection, rather than trying to debate whether it's 200 or 500 or 300 or 350 ... You are talking about events which are very, very rare, and their estimation is very, very uncertain," he says.

"The most crucial thing is that [the floods] exceeded the design capacity, and the issue here, the dilemma which will face the politicians and the council and the public is: Should we go for more protection?"

While Edgecumbe could build higher stopbanks, other options might be raising floor levels, or relocating parts of the town.

A higher level of protection, he adds, will have extra costs - and the council and locals will need to decide how much they're willing to pay.

HOW DO OTHER EVENTS MEASURE UP?

* In 1978, a "100-year flood" swept through Southland. Just six years later, another flood saw waters at Invercargill's airport rise 1.48m deeper

* A magnitude 7 quake in Wellington would be a one-in-500-year event

* Flooding in St Louis from Hurricane Katrina was described as a 500-year flood

* Auckland's Volcanic Field has an estimated return rate of 900 years

* Japan's 2011 magnitude 9 quake, which sparked a deadly tsunami, was a one in 1000 year event

* The Okataina Volcanic Centre, including Mt Tarawera - which erupted in 1886 - has a return rate of about 4000 years

* The Greendale fault, responsible for kicking off the Canterbury earthquakes, is estimated to be a one in 10,000-20,000 year event.

 - Stuff

Ad Feedback
special offers
Auckland

Wanted man arrested

Manuel sped away from police, running a red light, before hitting another car at the intersection of St Lukes Road and ...

A 35-year-old man has been arrested after dramatic events in St Lukes on Wednesday.

Fog dogs flights

Fog restrictions have been in place at the airport since the early hours of the morning. (FILE PHOTO)

Hundreds of passengers' travel plans disrupted as flights delayed and cancelled at Auckland Airport.

'Disruptive passenger' arrested

Police were called after reports of a disruptive passenger on an Air New Zealand flight at Christchurch airport (file photo).

Woman arrested for assault after spitting at Air NZ crew member on flight from Auckland to Christchurch.

Kent's battle for his kids

Seth, left, Kent and Shawna Allen from Pukekohe.

Pukekohe solo dad given just a year to live still has plenty of fight, even with his life on the line.

Wellington

Street name ruffles feathers

One Lower Hutt resident has argued against his street being named after the karearea. Ben Blackler argued the name would ...

Karearea Lane would be "problematic" and impractical, Lower Hutt resident claims.

Grow up, Wellington

Wellington's housing density could change in suburban areas if the Housing Forum recommendations are adopted.

Housing crisis can be solved by raising height limits in the suburbs, a report says.

Train improvements delayed

A planned upgrade of the Hutt Valley rail line has been put on hold while funding is sought.

Upgrades to capital's commuter trains put on ice while the council searches for $30m.

Capital buses to stop

Commuters are in for headaches as the new operator of Wellington's bus fleets hits an impasse with the drivers' union.

Some commuters are in for headaches as bus drivers hold stopwork meeting.

Canterbury

Mayor fears 10 years of delay

Bishop Victoria Matthews blamed delays on Brownlee's foreign trips.

Lianne Dalziel wants the Govt to buy and restore the Christ Church Cathedral if a funding deal is rejected.

Man in need sent home

Robert Read suffered post natal depression after his son Slade's birth, in 2013. He now helps others through a Facebook page.

Robert Read set up a Facebook page to help people contemplating suicide after the system let him down.

Indecent assault filmed, put online

.

An assault on a teenage girl was filmed and uploaded to a private social media page.

Adventure park wins design gong

Christchurch Adventure Park cafe, pictured here before the February fires, won a commercial architecture award.

Christchurch Adventure Park buildings saved from February's fires win a design award.

Waikato

Kent's battle for his kids

Seth, left, Kent and Shawna Allen from Pukekohe.

Solo dad given a year to live still has plenty of fight, even with his life on the line.

Big boost for dairy

Since last year's low final price of $3.90, dairy income will soar by $4.2 billion once this season's final payout has ...

Loan payments, repairs and infrastructure are priorities for dairy farmers in the wake of better prices.

Docs fear winter rush

Waikato Hospital was over capacity this week.

No guarantee that Waikato Hospital won't again be stretched to overcapacity.

River death verdict: Not guilty

Neville Patrick Harris has been found not guilty of  manslaughter in the High Court in Hamilton.

Did Neville Harris kill Tama Retimana in trying to protect a woman? No, a jury has decided.

Taranaki

Frank's shed comes down

Frank Amor's shed was described as an eyesore by one neighbour.

Frank loved his shed. The council did not. After 30 years it is finally gone.

Go on, knock it down

The town could look quite different to what it does today if Dey's plan is followed.

Gavin Dey reckons the answer to saving Stratford is to knock half its shops down.

Soggy sewer overflow

Treated sewage from Hawera is pumped about 2km out to sea off the coast.

A South Taranaki iwi is irked by a council move to dispose of extra treated wastewater through its offshore outfall.

The 1 per cent debate

Councillor Rick Coplestone said it didn't really matter how much rates went up by.

He's a councillor who doesn't care how much rates increase. Say what?

Manawatu

Another crack at worlds

Palmerston North's Kaitlyn Watts, here playing Megan Craig in the final of the Nelson Squash Open in March, is off to ...

Kaitlyn Watts is heading to another junior world squash championships.

Neighbours from Hell?

Hells Angels has set up base in the Palmerston North suburb of Hokowhitu.

A Hells Angels gang pad has sprung up in an upmarket area of Palmerston North.

Typhoid spreads

Typhoid has spread to Palmerston North.

A teenager in Palmerston North Hospital is confirmed as being infected.

Ex-Black Cap to artist

Ex-Black Cap Chris Martin's painting for a celebrity art auction raising money for disabilities charity Parent to ...

Black Caps' cult hero takes time out from grocery store to paint a work of art.

Nelson

Big bill for camping bylaw

02022017 FEATURE PHOTO BRADEN FASTIER /  FAIRFAX NZ
Freedom Campers at the Trafalgar Centre car-park at the end of Paru ...

Enforcing a proposed freedom camping bylaw could cost $100,000 a year.

Thieves ransack bakery

A police officer tapes off the front of the Mapua Village Bakery after the robbery early on Wednesday.

Three men smashed their way into the Mapua Village Bakery and threatened a worker.

Yoga bandit leaves class barefoot

Clients at  Nelson yoga school were forced to leave without their shoes after a thief stole their footwear on Tuesday ...

A Nelson yoga class was left barefoot after a thief stole shoes from a locker area.

Ferry benefits questioned

The terminal for the proposed Whanganui to Motueka ferry would be developed in the Moutere Estuary with open water ...

Proposed ferry between Motueka and Whanganui may deliver jobs, but at what cost?

Marlborough

Don't burst their bubble

Artist Mieke Davies came up with the idea of speech bubbles, to be filled in by young people in Marlborough.

Hundreds of "speech bubbles" in Blenheim alley waiting to be filled with the voices of young people. 

Affordability issues

Marlborough Sustainable Housing Trust chairwoman Bev James, right, in front of the first house the trust completed in ...

Rents are on the rise, and incomes are not keeping pace, leaving more families struggling to get a foot on the ladder.

Purpose-built priority

St Andrews Property Group is developing the former Country Life Motel, south of Blenheim, to house more than 400 ...

Vineyard contractors encouraged out of rental market as Blenheim faces housing shortage.

A new world for libraries

Children's library assistant Emily Fredrickson applies radio tags to books ahead of the new self-service system.

Self-service kiosks like those in supermarkets will soon appear in the libraries of Marlborough.

South Canterbury

Smokefree stir at Caroline Bay

Carnival volunteer Dave Woolstencroft often enjoys a cigarette at Caroline Bay, which health promoters have asked the ...

Carnival volunteer says complete smoking ban reminiscent of a 'police state". 

Enough meth to kill

Ashburton man Arran Gairns drowned with a lethal amount of methamphetamine in his blood.

Arran Gairns had a lethal level of meth in his blood when he died, toxicologist says.

SCDHB to appeal overtime decision

The South Canterbury District Health Board is appealing a ruling that staff should be paid for all of an on call shift, ...

South Canterbury District Health Board takes ruling over pay to the Employment Court.

Art show features national works

Lyttelton artist Martin Cole with Plunket art show committee member Sue Geaney set up Cole's sculptures made of ...

Timaru's 40th Plunket Art Show to feature works of more than 40 New Zealand artists.

Southland

60-minute challenge: Something is brewing

Eye reporter Joanna Griffiths learns how to make cyser mead with Southland Bee Society member Pat Hoffmann

I don't have the best track record with home brewed alcohol.

Uncovering the past

Donna Hawkins is working on a project in Southland on cemeteries.

Uncovering Southland's past in cemeteries.

Protecting your eyesight

Dipton man Mike Smith has macular degeneration and will be talking about the condition at a free public seminar in ...

Having someone stick a needle in his eye is no big thing for Dipton man Mike Smith.

Amundsen new deputy

Cr Rebecca Amundsen has been appointed deputy mayor by Invercargill Mayor Tim Shadbolt, after Cr Darren Ludlow resigned ...

Invercargill Mayor Tim Shadbolt has appointed his new deputy mayor.

Ad Feedback