MBIE worried ministers won't like their long-overdue housing affordability measure

MBIE's headquarters in Wellington. The Ministry have been working on a Housing Affordability Measure since 2013.
CAMERON BURNELL/FAIRFAX NZ

MBIE's headquarters in Wellington. The Ministry have been working on a Housing Affordability Measure since 2013.

A new Government measure of housing affordability is more than a year late, and officials are worried ministers might not like what they see.

Cabinet first asked the Ministry of Business Innovation and Employment (MBIE) and Statistics New Zealand to create the Housing Affordability Measure (HAM) in 2012, filling a gap in official government statistics. The measure will show whether housing is unaffordable for both renters and first home buyers in specific areas and at specific income bands all across the country.

It is now long-overdue. The suite was meant to be released in 2015, then 2016, then February of 2017. It remains unclear whether it will make it out before the election, with officials noting its political sensitivity and the possibility that ministers would "disagree" with the measure.

MBIE officials worried that "there could be a lack of ministerial agreement with the measures".
JOHN KIRK-ANDERSON/FAIRFAX NZ

MBIE officials worried that "there could be a lack of ministerial agreement with the measures".

Currently the Government lacks a proper housing affordability measure. This leaves the media and academia relying on third party data, and allowed Prime Minister John Key to point journalists to a handful of cheap Trade Me listings when asked about the housing crisis last year - there were no official numbers to rebut him with.

READ MORE: 
* Trade Me pinpoints watershed moment property market took off
* Auckland fourth least affordable of nine countries
* Provinces suffer big decline in housing affordability

This measure has been kept mostly secret, but popped up in an Official Information Act release from Treasury earlier this year. A Stuff request for more information on the project was delayed for months, but has finally been released, albeit with heavy redactions.

The documents paint a picture of an ambitious but troubled project, one that would give household level data on affordability for both renters and first home buyers at a "Tier 1" statistics level, the same quality as GDP and inflation numbers.

A spokeswoman for MBIE refused to answer any questions about the measure, including how many people were working on it, prior to the public release. Documents in the information release tell us much about how that release may play out.


An MBIE briefing considers the risks and benefits of a 2017 release. Emphasis added by Stuff.

RELEASE IT QUIETLY OR RELEASE IT LOUDLY?

Ad Feedback

MBIE officials put careful work into planning the roll out of what would undoubtedly be politically sensitive numbers, particularly in an election year.

At one point in October 2016, in a hurry to finally get the measures out, MBIE considered a "soft" release of the suite that November. This option, detailed in a memo to the Building and Housing Governance Board of MBIE, would involve "publishing the results paper and methods paper on MBIE's website with a minimum level of media engagement" and informing ministers as part of routine weekly status report.

This lay in contrast to a "hard" rollout in 2017, where media was properly engaged and ministers were given fuller briefings. One of the risks of this strategy, again detailed in that October 2016 memo, was that "there could be a lack of ministerial agreement with the measures" and that "2017 is an election year, and this is a politically charged topic".

The Kaikoura Earthquake, which massively damaged Statistics House, put both options off the table. It remains unclear when the measure will be released, but a later memo indicates it is likely to be in a "hard" manner.

WHAT THE MEASURE IS

HAM will make it easy to check whether an area is what the Government officially considers unaffordable - not just for first home buyers, but for renters too, and at several different income bands, going all the way back to 2002. It will be based on actual rents and mortgage payments made by individual households - not just averages.

The project is built with data from the tax returns, rents from bonds registered with MBIE, Reserve Bank interest rates, and Core Logic sales data. All of this data will be matched to specific households. While it is based mostly on Statistics NZ data MBIE have led the project. 

The two main measures will look at whether a renting household can afford to continue to rent and whether a renting household can afford to buy.

"Affordability - both current and historical - will be measurable by locality, household income level ... housing tenure, and a range of house characteristics (size, age, etc)," the principal analyst wrote in a October 2015 briefing to Minister Nick Smith.

Instead of looking at housing as a percentage of income, the measure would set levels of "residual" income left over after housing costs for different income percentiles. A change late in 2016 meant that the "unaffordable" marker would be raised for lower income households, as the older measure - which used a consistent ratio across income groups - was "unrealistically low".

Economist Shamubeel Eaqub said HAM will be very useful, but would not substantially shift the housing narrative.

"It doesn't really matter how you measure it. It's going to look bad, because it is bad."​

THE GAP HAM WILL FILL

Throughout the entire housing crisis the Government has lacked an actual measure on when a property or area becomes "unaffordable".

The price data media relies on comes from third parties likes REINZ and TradeMe. And the analysis of that data is left to the third parties too - sites like interest.co.nz, universities, and think tanks like Demographia. 

These third parties use internationally agreed upon measures - like that housing costs shouldn't exceed a third of a household's income - to decide when housing hits "unaffordable" territory. The sparse statistics that the Government do keep on this issue, mostly extracted from the Household Economic Survey, use the same measure.

Treasury and others will occasionally cite the third party data, but it lacks the imprimatur of government-quality numbers. This is why Prime Minister John Key was able to point to a few Trade Me results for homes under $500,000 in Auckland when he was challenged on the housing crisis last year: there was no real Government data to rebut him with.

Making HAM a "Tier 1" number - much like GDP or inflation - will give it serious statistical rigour. 

 - Stuff

Comments

Ad Feedback
special offers
Auckland

More HIV diagnoses than ever

New Zealand AIDS Foundation executive director Dr Jason Myers said condoms were "still the best way" to prevent HIV ...

"There's no reason why it won't keep on increasing if we don't improve prevention," researcher says.

Judge: Council wrong over cycle trail

Ken Rintoul says he's happy with a court decision, after a judge found Far North District Council breached its own processes.

In fracas over cycle trail construction, a judge says council could not unilaterally exclude a local contractor.

Poetry event to connect youth

Albany Senior High School students and Upper Harbour Local Board Youth Caucus members, chairperson Amy Irvine and deputy ...

Upper Harbour's Hearing Everyday Youth celebrate Youth Week.

Silverdale cheerleaders victorious video

All Star Infinity Cheerleaders were celebrating victory in Hawaii last week.

After months of intense training, Prodigy and Odyssey surprised the crowd with their energetic performance.

Wellington

When brain tumours glow fluoro video

Brain tumour surgery has become easier for neurosurgeons thanks to a new drug called Gliolan - which highlights the ...

Alice Chambers' life should be longer, thanks to a drug that made her brain tumour glow.

Uni hall booze ban video

Uni

Night of drunken destruction trashes Victoria University hall in The Terrace.

New arena for Wellington

An enthusiastic crowd rocks to The Pixies performing at Vector Arena (now the Spark Arena) in Auckland. Wellington is in ...

A 10,000-seater arena for concerts and events looks set to get the green light.

No ticket to ride

The future of public transport is coming, and it is a future in which you will be able ride a bus with just your bank card.

A bank card may soon be all you need to use public transport across NZ - unless you're in Auckland.

Canterbury

Battle to save historic house

A century-old home burnt down near Little River in Canterbury on Monday morning.

A human chain of firefighters and farm workers dragged furniture out of a beloved Banks Peninsula house before it was engulfed by flames.

Food factory on fire

The cause of a fire at a food dehydration processing factory near Ashburton is not yet known (file photo).

Fire at food factory near Ashburton under control, but cause not yet known.

Refund for dodgy car

Harry and Heather Rae Ngarae have handed back the keys to their Subary Legacy after a dodgy deal at a Christchurch car ...

Elderly couple will get money back after salesman lumped them with a broken car.

From hospital to heart attack

Craig Caddy suffered a heart attack just after visiting Burwood Hospital with chest pains, but he insisted on driving ...

Man collapsed just minutes after complaining of chest pains at a Christchurch hospital. He died days later in intensive care.

Waikato

Bomb claims Kiwi's pen pal video

A triptych of Skye's best friend, Georgina Callander, including the centre shot of Georgina posing with American popstar ...

Best friends spoke that morning but Manchester explosion left 'horrible gut feeling'.

Priest's new victims

Mark Mannix Brown, 74, after appearing in the Hamilton District Court on Tuesday.

Mark Mannix Brown, 74, was jailed in the 1990s for similar offending.

Couple claim $27m Lotto prize

The winning lotto was brought from Thames Four Square owned by Sukhpal Singh.

A Thames couple have come forward with the golden Lotto ticket.

Ham East rejuvenation starts

The new playground in Steele Park, as shown in the concept design for the Hamilton East Neighbourhood Plan.

But one councillor says Hamilton East is already thriving and will continue to do so if council keeps its sticky fingers out of it.

Taranaki

'Business as usual' at Coastal

Principal of Coastal Taranaki school in Okato, Janelle McKenzie, has resigned after just over a year in the job.

Board of trustee members had a catch-up with staff in the wake of principal's departure but it was "business as usual".

Woken by stalker

Hanz  Browne was jailed for two years when he appeared in the Hawera District Court on Tuesday. (file photo)

She screamed after waking up to find a stalker staring at her from the foot of her bed.

'High risk' pregnancy appeal

Virginia Rose James, 33, had earlier pleaded guilty to two charges of forgery and one representative charge of obtaining ...

She was jailed for stealing $705,000 but wants out, saying her pregnancy is "high risk".

TV games show needs families

Family Feud auditions are being held in New Plymouth on June 24.

Family feud fans rejoice, the game show needs more Taranaki families to feud.

Manawatu

Euthanasia a 'good death'

Professor Jan Bernheim founded palliative care group Not Necessarily Terminal.

Professor Jan Bernheim says that if euthanasia is to be made legal in NZ, it should not be made too complicated.

Liquor shop opposed

Palmerston North's first Black Bull is soon to open unopposed in Rangitikei St. A second in the new Milson shopping ...

A church and a retirement village sit next to the proposed Black Bull branch.

Typhoid tests carried out

Palmerston North Hospital has tested 11 children for typhoid.

28 people have been tested for typhoid, including 11 children under 5.

No guarantees for democracy

Gerald Ford didn't need any votes to become Unites States President.

OPINION: Some things are more important than the right to vote.

Nelson

Quit smoking incentive to help unborn children

Stacey Russell, second from right is on the Pepi First programme which is run and supported by Sonia Hepi-Treanor, left, ...

An incentivised programme has helped Motueka woman Stacey Russell to quit smoking. 

Drunk driver in dock

A photo of the crash scene on Whakatu Dr taken from a passing vehicle and posted on Facebook.

A drink driver in Nelson damaged four vehicles and seriously injured a woman.

Iwi challenges water bottling

Te Waikoropupu Springs is considered sacred to local iwi.

A plan to bottle thousands of cubic metres of water from a Tasman spring has been dealt a blow after a local iwi appeal.

Poverty hitting region's youngest

Kay Guyton runs Angel in My Street and works to support Stoke families and children in poverty.

The report has found more than 1400 children in Nelson and Tasman live below the poverty line. 

Marlborough

Hundreds farewell Bevan Moody video

Waitohi rugby player Bevan Moody collapsed on the field earlier this month.

Street closed for emotional haka after funeral of rugby player who died on the field.

Tatts, shoes for drugs

Tinnies of cannabis normally sell for about $20, a police summary of facts says. (File photo)

A cannabis dealer caught with a wallet full of $20 notes wasn't all about the money.

School track causes bike boom video

The new cycle track at Mayfield School has been a huge hit with pupils, from left, Vee-jay Koroheke, Payton ...

Cycle track around the school has pupils clocking up the kilometres without realising.

Beer burglar jailed

Walter Narayan was told about the outdoor fridge as a place where he could get beer, his lawyer said. (File photo)

He went back to the well one too many times. The well being someone else's outdoor fridge.

South Canterbury

'It's not an easy subject' video

Ryan Weaver-Cogger's mother Michelle Cogger hopes mental health educator Mike King will encourage young people and the ...

Bereaved mothers bringing mental health educator Mike King to South Canterbury to help lift the taboo around suicide.

$700,000 upgrade

Smithfield Plant manager Nigel Cuthill has sent out a letter to residents informing them of the $700,000 to the plant- ...

Alliance will spend $700k to upgrade plant following odour complaints.

Brekkie for a good cause

Pink Ribbon Breakfast at the Arowhenua Marae in Temuka. Pictured are Wendy Moore (left) and Shirley McPherson (right).

The Arowhenua Marae was transformed into a sea of pink to support a good cause.

Ara concerns voiced

Ara Institute of Canterbury's Timaru campus.

Ara criticised for a lack of communication with South Canterbury stakeholders.

Southland

Bluff oyster numbers decline

Bluff Oyster Festival Chairman John Edminstin in front of the crowd at the Bluff Oyster Festival.

The results of a recent NIWA survey has shown replenishment rates in the Foveaux strait Oyster fishery have lowered since 2012.

Aurora on show

Te Anau resident Chris Watson captured this stunning panorama from the Ivon Wilson Park on the outskirts of the town.

Photographers were out in force on Sunday capturing the dazzling Southern Lights.

Barclay supporting centre

Lumsden Maternity's contract with the Southern District Health Board expires on July 31.

Clutha-Southland MP Todd Barclay says he will not let the Lumsden Maternity Centre close.

Sea lions could scupper fishery

A juvenile sea lion in Port Pegasus in January 2016. In New Zealand sea lions are ranked as "nationally critical" on the ...

Would a new aquaculture project on Stewart Island affect the sea lion colony?

Ad Feedback