Disabled boy held in mental health unit a human rights breach, Children's Commissioner says

Children's Commissioner Judge Andrew Becroft says the case is a good test of the newly-formed Oranga Tamariki.
LAWRENCE SMITH/FAIRFAX NZ

Children's Commissioner Judge Andrew Becroft says the case is a good test of the newly-formed Oranga Tamariki.

A disabled teenager's ongoing placement at a mental health facility is totally unacceptable, the Children's Commissioner says. 

For almost seven weeks, a disabled 15 year-old boy in government care, has been held in a Child, Adolescent and Family unit at Princess Margaret Hospital, while departments try to find a long-term solution.

Children's Commissioner Judge Andrew Becroft said human rights lawyers would have a "very strong argument" the boy's treatment breached the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child (UNCROC). 

A 15 year-old boy, with down syndrome, has spent almost seven weeks living at a unit at Princess Margaret Hospital.
JOHN KIRK-ANDERSON/FAIRFAX NZ

A 15 year-old boy, with down syndrome, has spent almost seven weeks living at a unit at Princess Margaret Hospital.

The almost seven weeks he had spent in the facility was beyond "short term".

READ MORE: 
CYF struggles to find home for violent, intellectually-disabled teen
Down syndrome boy failed by Child, Youth and Family, say former caregivers

"This sort of intervention is blatantly unacceptable. 

"We're getting in to a serious concern and arguable convention breach territory," Judge Becroft said. 

On March 6, the teenager, who has Down syndrome and cannot be named for legal reasons, was transferred to the unit after a violent incident at a Christchurch home for people with disabilities. It was the latest in a string of random violent outbursts.

The UNCROC sets out children's rights and governments' responsibilities to fulfil them. It applied to everyone under age 18.

Judge Becroft said it needed to be more widely recognised and upheld in New Zealand. 

Ad Feedback

"There is a clear argument here for a lack of application of the convention by Oranga Tamariki."

The Commissioner had received four complaints in fewer than three weeks, which all raised issues with the lack of specialised, professional, expert 24/7 care facilities for high-needs children and young people.

"I don't underestimate the challenge in providing those sorts of care facilities, but we don't have a continuum of care and protection facilities in NZ, especially at the top end. I think that three weeks into the life of Oranga Tamariki, this is exactly the sort of issue [that] will be a real test for the new organisation."

Oranga Tamariki Canterbury regional manager Blair McKenzie said they agreed that the hospital was not an ideal option, but there was no safe alternative for him yet.  

"It's important to recognise he has extraordinarily high needs and the need to ensure any potential caregiver or facility can cope with his health needs."

McKenzie said the boy would remain at the unit while the Ministries of Health, Education and Oranga Tamariki found him a suitable long-term home.

"We are making sure his needs are being met in his current situation. He is kept active, attends school each day and has a dedicated support worker. Realistically this is the only placement option until agencies can find an appropriate placement that meets his very high needs."

Human rights lawyer Sonja Cooper echoed Judge Becroft's comment about the situation breaching the boy's rights. 

"Our teens with complex needs all too often end up in [Oranga Tamariki] residences or psychiatric hospitals when they should be in less restrictive environments."

"This is a real issue - that a first world country has such limited options."

 

 - Stuff

Comments

Ad Feedback
special offers
Auckland

How realistic was Shorty St's eruption?

The Shortland Street Hospital was covered in ash and rocks.

No one knows when the next volcanic eruption will hit, how big it will be, or where a new cone could form.

Govt scheme to increase housing

Hundreds of homes are planned for south Auckland under the Government's Crown Land Scheme. (file photo).

People wanting to buy a new house in south Auckland may soon be in luck.

Cop killer found in ceiling

Daniel Luff during his appearance in the High Court, in Palmerston North, for the murder of Feilding policeman Duncan Taylor,

Prison scholar Daniel Luff reportedly found hiding in prison ceiling cavity.

Kids come to league with nothing stuff nation video

Otara Scorpions chairman Willie Maea in front of the club's Verne Wilson mural.

The kids go without food, without love, without money. This rugby league club offers breakfast, sport and a way out of the stereotypes.

Wellington

Saved in the nick of time

Animal welfare inspector Gina Kemp carries Storm out from the ravine.

For three weeks a two-year-old pitbull was trapped at the bottom of a ravine in a park.

$98m boost for rail

Wellington rail commuters are on the receiving end of a Budget boost for the country's rail infrastructure.

Rail commuters on the receiving end of a Budget boost for Hutt, Melling and J'ville lines.

Mall meeting draws hundreds

Plans to redevelop Johnsonville Shopping Centre have been in the pipeline for years, with residents fed up with the slow ...

"What should the beating heart of the northern suburbs is on life support."

Road opponents band together

A Wellington lobby group fears a similar proposal to the controversial Basin flyover could be on the cards.

Lobby group formed amid fears of another central Wellington flyover plan.

Canterbury

Family 'impressed' by Budget video

Melanie and Rod Brown with 3-year-old son Harrison. The new tax thresholds announced in the Budget will mean families ...

Christchurch couple Rod and Mel Brown have a 3-year-old and another on the way.

'Dirty 30' named gallery

The heritage Peterborough Centre is mired in an insurance dispute.

Owners of derelict properties on a list of "dirty 30" in Christchurch could lose them if they do not take action.

Post-quake architecture boom

This building at 18 Butler St won an enduring architecture award.

OPINION: People with insurance cash to burn are creating homes and buildings they wouldn't otherwise dream of.

Police seek three missing men

Michael Craig McGrath went missing on Sunday evening.

Police issue separate advisories seeking sightings for three missing men in the South Island.

Waikato

Waikato welcomes the Blue Card

Waikato will introduce the Blue Card initiative into rugby from June 3.

Waikato Rugby is the latest union to implement the Blue Card initiative as part of NZ Rugby's programmes to combat concussion.

Fines for calf abuse

Wayne Lyall Henry, 47, and Norman Arthur Baker, 71, were sentenced in the Hamilton District Court on Thursday in ...

One calf was dragged by its hind leg, others were left to die without water or shelter.

Budget reaction mixed

Steven Joyce delivers his first Budget as Finance Minister.

City businesses are happy, but a budget adviser thinks individual gains will be quickly swallowed up.

Contractor considering legal options

The earthworks that cost a South Waikato excavation company $19,000.

Excavation company pinged for breaching the RMA is considering legal options.

Taranaki

The business of beards video

Ngahina Wharehoka won the best beard trim in the Master section of the Barber Craft competition in Auckland last weekend.

There's two types of bearded men - those who can't be bothered shaving and those chasing trends.

Crash victim named

Police have identified the victim of the crash as 52-year-old Cherie Bidois from Waitara.

Police have identified 52-year-old Cherie Bidois, of Waitara, as the sole fatality in a crash in Gore on Friday.

Sport heroes needed

17022017 Sport Photo ANDY JACKSON/Fairfax NZ.    Super rugby, pre season, Hurricanes V Crusaders at Boarder rugby club ...

There are plenty of sportspeople who make the grade but just three will make the Hall of Fame.

Man trap in home

James Misepeka will be sentenced in the New Plymouth District Court in August, after pleading guilty to charges ...

Offender told police it was a 'good day to die' after making threats to burn down the house he was holed up in.

Manawatu

Gorge gouge delays

The gorge is expected to be closed for at least another week while the damage is repaired.

A crumbling retaining wall has pushed back the reopening of the gorge another week.

Man killed in crash

A man was badly hurt in a crash in Palmerston North and died shortly afterwards in hospital.

Witness says driver may have had a heart attack behind the wheel.

Budget a mixed bag

Feilding couple Ian and Katie Burgers, with their two children Liam and Rebecca, see some good things and bad things in ...

Budget 2017 has no major tax shake-up for average Manawatu families.

Cop killer found in ceiling

Daniel Luff during his appearance in the High Court, in Palmerston North, for the murder of Feilding policeman Duncan Taylor,

Daniel Luff, killer of Duncan Taylor, is reportedly found hiding in prison ceiling cavity.

Nelson

Robbery 'guts' Mapua bakery boss

24052017 NEWS PHOTO BRADEN FASTIER
Mapua Village Bakery owner and baker Sean Carley gets back to business so not to ...

Mapua Village Bakery owner Sean Carley is picking up the pieces after a brazen robbery that has left him and his staff shaken.

Player passes away

Waitohi prop Bevan Moody during his final game of club rugby, against  Nelson at Neale Park on Saturday.

Family and friends are mourning for Bevan Moody, who has died after collapsing in a club rugby match.

Store broken into for third time

Garry Higgins of Richmond Roast House and Cafe has been burgled three times since Easter.

The Richmond Roast House and Cafe owner says his store has been broken into three times since the Queen St upgrade.

'Shanty town' fears gallery video

A fire pit, chili bin, rubbish and car seats in the bush at Reilly st.

Old cars, campsites and piles of rubbish left behind at popular freedom camping spot.

Marlborough

Steroids: Not for milk-livered men

Blenheim man Jacob Martin was caught with 20 Nolvadex capsules in his sports bag earlier this month, which landed him in ...

Bodybuilders scared of developing breasts turn to prescription drugs to beat the side-effects. For some, that includes lactating.

Bevan Moody dies

Waitohi prop Bevan Moody during his final game of club rugby, against  Nelson at Neale Park on Saturday.

Family and friends are mourning for Bevan Moody, who has died after collapsing in a club rugby match.

Grape marc's 'complete solution'

Leachate runoff and ponding from grape marc dump sites in Marlborough. (File photo)

This could be a turning point in how the wine industry deals with its waste.

Act of kindness

Carol Reardon with t-shirt her family sent for her birthday.

An off the cuff quirky comment and simple act of kindness has raised more than $20,000.

South Canterbury

Trust lost after salmon released video

High Country Salmon assistant farm manager Josh Wyber was devastated to find 6000 salmon had been illegally released ...

Salmon farm ramps up security measures following illegal release of 6000 fish.

Jubilee report released

Jared Reese Husband, 47, of Timaru, was one of three men killed when FV Jubilee sank on October 18, 2015.

Running hose may have led to the deaths of three fishermen, report says.

'Manipulative' woman to blame

The man accused of the manslaughter of Ashburton man Arran Gairns was 'manipulated' by female associate, defence counsel ...

Manslaughter accused was 'manipulated' by mastermind, defence counsel says.

Volunteers rue mower theft video

A $6000 ride on lawn mower was stolen from Te Aitarkihi Trust which runs the Multi Cultural Centre on Bridge Street, ...

Volunteers of Maori Multicultural centre near Timaru hit by theft for a second time.

Southland

Deep south trees go viral

A Catlins macrocarpa stock shelter belt is going viral thanks to US lifestyle website Brightside.me.

A Catlins macrocarpa stock shelter belt is going viral thanks to US lifestyle website Brightside.me. 

Live: The Budget

Labour leader Andrew Little uses a dollar coin to illustrate his point.

Labour leader Andrew Little dismisses Finance Minister Steven Joyce's Budget.

Two chemical spills in Invercargill

Fire crew in full protective gear cleaning up a chemical spill, of polyaluminium chloride, which fell of the back of a ...

Fire crew in full protective gear cleaned up a chemical spill following an earlier spill on the same stretch of road.

SBHS topple rivals

Southland Boys' High halfback Tim Price passes the ball during the interschool game against Otago Boys' High School in ...

Southland Boys' High School works hard in a thrilling win over Otago Boys' High School.

Ad Feedback