Disabled boy held in mental health unit a human rights breach, Children's Commissioner says

Children's Commissioner Judge Andrew Becroft says the case is a good test of the newly-formed Oranga Tamariki.
LAWRENCE SMITH/FAIRFAX NZ

Children's Commissioner Judge Andrew Becroft says the case is a good test of the newly-formed Oranga Tamariki.

A disabled teenager's ongoing placement at a mental health facility is totally unacceptable, the Children's Commissioner says. 

For almost seven weeks, a disabled 15 year-old boy in government care, has been held in a Child, Adolescent and Family unit at Princess Margaret Hospital, while departments try to find a long-term solution.

Children's Commissioner Judge Andrew Becroft said human rights lawyers would have a "very strong argument" the boy's treatment breached the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child (UNCROC). 

A 15 year-old boy, with down syndrome, has spent almost seven weeks living at a unit at Princess Margaret Hospital.
JOHN KIRK-ANDERSON/FAIRFAX NZ

A 15 year-old boy, with down syndrome, has spent almost seven weeks living at a unit at Princess Margaret Hospital.

The almost seven weeks he had spent in the facility was beyond "short term".

READ MORE: 
CYF struggles to find home for violent, intellectually-disabled teen
Down syndrome boy failed by Child, Youth and Family, say former caregivers

"This sort of intervention is blatantly unacceptable. 

"We're getting in to a serious concern and arguable convention breach territory," Judge Becroft said. 

On March 6, the teenager, who has Down syndrome and cannot be named for legal reasons, was transferred to the unit after a violent incident at a Christchurch home for people with disabilities. It was the latest in a string of random violent outbursts.

The UNCROC sets out children's rights and governments' responsibilities to fulfil them. It applied to everyone under age 18.

Judge Becroft said it needed to be more widely recognised and upheld in New Zealand. 

Ad Feedback

"There is a clear argument here for a lack of application of the convention by Oranga Tamariki."

The Commissioner had received four complaints in fewer than three weeks, which all raised issues with the lack of specialised, professional, expert 24/7 care facilities for high-needs children and young people.

"I don't underestimate the challenge in providing those sorts of care facilities, but we don't have a continuum of care and protection facilities in NZ, especially at the top end. I think that three weeks into the life of Oranga Tamariki, this is exactly the sort of issue [that] will be a real test for the new organisation."

Oranga Tamariki Canterbury regional manager Blair McKenzie said they agreed that the hospital was not an ideal option, but there was no safe alternative for him yet.  

"It's important to recognise he has extraordinarily high needs and the need to ensure any potential caregiver or facility can cope with his health needs."

McKenzie said the boy would remain at the unit while the Ministries of Health, Education and Oranga Tamariki found him a suitable long-term home.

"We are making sure his needs are being met in his current situation. He is kept active, attends school each day and has a dedicated support worker. Realistically this is the only placement option until agencies can find an appropriate placement that meets his very high needs."

Human rights lawyer Sonja Cooper echoed Judge Becroft's comment about the situation breaching the boy's rights. 

"Our teens with complex needs all too often end up in [Oranga Tamariki] residences or psychiatric hospitals when they should be in less restrictive environments."

"This is a real issue - that a first world country has such limited options."

 

 - Stuff

Comments

Ad Feedback
special offers
Auckland

Women's Work exhibition

Exhibition considers how gender stereotypes pertaining to Pacific arts are challenged in Aotearoa-New Zealand.

Mead has gone mainstream

Mac's Love Buzz mead is available until mid-August.

One of the world's oldest styles of alcohol is offering a taste of something new.

Fire causes 'substantial damage'

Fire fighters are battling a blaze at a rural house near Warkworth, north of Auckland.

Occupants of the burning house - near Warkworth, north of Auckland - fled and are safe.

Fatal Northland crash

The crash occurred on Kapiro Road, north of Kerikeri.

A crash involving a car and a motorbike in Kerikeri has left one person dead.

Wellington

OBU, Norths top Swindale

Tawa's Pepesana Patafilo tries to break clear of the Johnsonville defence on Tuesday.

Two big wins for the leaders of the Swindale Shield on Anzac Day.

Tackling pre-loading

Police on Wellington's Blair St. Authorities are planning to close Blair and Allen streets on weekend nights to traffic ...

Plans are afoot to close Courtenay Place party zone to traffic from 10pm at weekends.

Mystery behind bright sky light video

The dashcam captured the bright light on Wellington's Featherston St.

People report seeing a meteor-like bright light shoot across the sky.

Missing hunter found

Search and rescue operation on Mt Taranaki.

A search team airlifted the 62-year-old man unharmed from the Kaweka Ranges.

Canterbury

Killed climbers were experienced

Conor Smith was one of two men killed in a fall while climbing in Fiordland.

Loss of "experienced, competent" pair in Fiordland devastating, says NZ Alpine Team spokesman.

More cafe casualties video

17032015. 123rf.
 We Are Closed Sign

apologize, art, artwork, banner, business, cartoon, closed, color, design, dirty, ...

High rents, road works, more competition and lack of patrons creating trouble for some Christchurch outlets.

Motorcyclist seriously injured

A motorcyclist was seriously injured in a collision with a car in Hei Hei, Christchurch, on Tuesday evening.

The rider suffered head injuries and broken bones in the crash.

Canterbury river surges to life

Sarah McCall and her family stand on the banks of the Eyre River, normally a dry riverbed, which surged to life on Good ...

When they got near, the Canterbury riverbed was dry, but within minutes it was clear something was happening.

Waikato

Mead has gone mainstream

Mac's Love Buzz mead is available until mid-August.

One of the world's oldest styles of alcohol is offering a taste of something new.

Crash scene a 'mess'

The crash scene at the intersection of Cross and Cameron roads.

One person is dead and two are injured after a serious crash near Morrinsville.

Period pain not a female only gig

'Mum kept me home' – Kiwi girls missing school because they can't afford sanitary products

OPINION: Any man who claims he has not suffered is either genuinely celibate or has not been married long enough, Tom O'Connor writes.

Body found in bush

Thames

A hunter alerted police to the grim find just after 1pm on Anzac Day.

Taranaki

Former farming flatmates face off

James Lawn (right) came out on top of the Young Farmer regional competition.

Former flatmates to battle it out in the national Young Farmer of the Year competition.

Anzac Day in Waitara

The Anzac Day Parade in Waitara before the civic service.

The weather was perfect for the Anzac Day services held around the mountain on Tuesday.

Teen to take on snooker's best

New Plymouth's Mario Hildred, 16, in preparing to take on the world's best in China later this year.

"Obviously I feel a lot of pressure when I get a high break to keep going to get more."

Missing Taranaki man

Jared Shaun McLean has not been heard from since Saturday.

"We all are actually worried, it's just unlike him to do this."

Manawatu

The military child

Military families should take the chance Anzac Day presents to give themselves a pat on the back.

COLD COFFEE: As part of a military family, I see first-hand the effects our lifestyle has on family.

Woman badly hurt

Police are at the scene of a crash in Dannevirke, where a motorcycle hit an elderly woman.

An elderly woman is in a critical condition after being hit by a motorcycle in Dannevirke.

Feeling the burn

Rob Kent feels the burn at the 2016 Palmerston North heat of the NZ Chilli Eating Champs. He is returning to defend his ...

Hot food fanatics prepare their guts for the spiciest competition in the land.

Gorge could be closed for weeks

About 3,500 cubic metres of earth is blocking the Woodville end of State Highway 3 through the Manawatu Gorge.

Manawatu Gorge set for another long closure after two slips block lanes.

Nelson

Mystery behind bright sky light video

Stephen Moore's dashcam captured a bright light shoot across the Wellington sky.

People in Nelson report seeing a meteor-like bright light shoot across the sky.

Crews under pressure

The volume of trucks and heavy goods vehicles passing through Murchison has surged over the past six months.

Murchison volunteers respond to year's worth of crash call-outs in just four months.

Farmer's craft milk plan pays off video

Julian Raine with bottles of Aunt Jean's milk produced at the Raine farm in Stoke.

Nelson dairy farmer on a mission to bring back "how milk used to be" to the market.

Nelson: The new Silicon Valley?

Markus Erdmann and Vivian Escorsin are part of the entrepreneur group Local.Foundation who are organising a business ...

Business group says Nelson has potential to become "start-up hub of New Zealand".

Marlborough

First building uncovered?

Archaeologist Reg Nichol with a doll's leg and blue, enamel cup he found during excavations for Blenheim's new riverside ...

An archaeologist has found the burned remains of what could be Blenheim's first building, a gin palace and general store.

Quake doesn't stop me

Bill Lonsdale, left, and Lesa B'do have been cut off from one another by the November 14 earthquake.

Cut off from Kaikoura, Bill Lonsdale takes a plane, a car and a boat to see his love.

Race numbers swell

Saint Clair Vineyard Half Marathon director Chris Shaw among the vines, in Marlborough.

The earthquake and closure of SH1 couldn't trip up Marlborough's biggest running race, which has seen a surge in numbers.

I just want to go home

Amberley Rest Home manager Tracey Dimmock-Rump and 83-year-old Celia Wigmore, who has been without a place to call home ...

Injured and shipped out after the earthquake, finding a place to call home has been hard for this 83-year-old.

South Canterbury

Honouring sacrifice

War veterans march on Memorial Ave towards the cenotaph at the Anzac Dawn Service in Timaru.

A crowd of a few hundred stood at the cenotaph in Timaru to commemorate Anzac Day.

Raising awareness 

Volunteer firefighter and former NZ Army infantryman  Maaka Mckinney is escorted into Timaru from Waimate by Timaru ...

Maaka McKinney is raising awareness for depression among first responders.

New book on war hero

Tom O'Connor has published a book on Waimate war hero Eric Batchelor.

The life of one of New Zealand's most decorated soldiers has been detailed in new book.

Man killed in crash

A man is dead after a crash on Freehold Creek Bridge at Lake Ohau.

One person has died after a single-vehicle crash on a bridge in the Waitaki District.

Southland

50-year-old receipt returned

Sue Samson with the 50-year-old receipt left in the Winton Night 'n Day store on April 6.

They'd kept their honeymoon receipt for five decades. So when a shopkeeper found it, she knew she had to return it.

'Two shot' in city

Police cordoned off Otepuni Ave in Invercargill after a shooting incident.

Police indicate two people have been shot and one person is in custody following an armed incident in Invercargill.

Kiwi climbers die in Fiordland

The pair were roped together traversing a "climber's Mecca" when a fall cost them their lives.

The pair were roped together traversing a "climber's Mecca" when a fall cost them their lives.

Nasa balloon seen from Chch

Ashley Marles managed to photography the balloon with his own observatory.

That "bright stationary object" is headed for outer space - with an Anzac poppy in tow.

Ad Feedback