Seabed mining hearings process labeled 'flawed' after more info sought

South Taranaki iwi oppose Trans Tasman Resources to mine the seabed for iron ore
MONIQUE FORD / Fairfax NZ

South Taranaki iwi oppose Trans Tasman Resources to mine the seabed for iron ore

A request for new information, from a company wanting to dredge the seabed off the Taranaki coast, should have been made earlier and not during the final hearings stage, groups opposing the mining proposal say.

The Environmental Protection Authority decision making committee has asked Trans Tasman Resources (TTR) to provide more information to its seabed mining application two months into the hearing process.

The authority committee had asked for further information about levels of noise output, and the size of the sediment cloud, which occurred during dredging. 

Taranaki groups oppose the proposal to mine the seabed.
MONIQUE FORD / Fairfax NZ

Taranaki groups oppose the proposal to mine the seabed.

It defended its request by saying it was obligated under law to seek the information throughout the process and had wide powers to do so.

READ MORE:
* South Taranaki iwi says seabed mining still has too much uncertainty

* Seabed mining could meet Government's export goal, says ministry
* Massive blue whale population found in proposed seabed mining area
* Outrage over limited hearing locations for seabed mining locations

However anti-mining group Kiwi's Against Seabed Mining (KASM) spokesman Phil McCabe said the late call for more documentation showed the consultation and application process was flawed and not as robust as it should be.

Kiiw's Against Seabed Mining spokesman Phil McCabe says the hearings process is flawed
Gerry Henley

Kiiw's Against Seabed Mining spokesman Phil McCabe says the hearings process is flawed

"The information should have been supplied from the beginning," he said.

"Bringing it in now at this late stage means the process isn't robust."

McCabe said the additional information would be useful but it should have been introduced earlier in the process.

The organisation was run by volunteers and paid for experts to investigate issues out of donations.

Ad Feedback

The under-resourced group did not have an open cheque book, or unlimited time, and was fighting a well funded company, he said.

"We knew from the beginning of the process there were key bits missing from TTR's application.

"We told the EPA that it was incomplete and they didn't send it back to TTR.

"Now the EPA is looking for more information to consider during the hearings because the application from TTR is insufficient."

Forest and Bird, and South Taranaki iwi, Ngati Ruanui, both supported KASM's stance.

In a joint statement with Greenpeace, KASM called the request "contrary to natural justice and the Exclusive Economic Zone Act", and accused the EPA of "going off the rails" to ask for more evidence at a late stage.

Trans Tasman Resources have applied to dredge up to 50 million tonnes, over 65 square kilometres, of seabed a year off the South Taranaki Bight to retrieve and export 5 million tonnes iron ore annually for up to 35 years.

It is the second application the 45 per cent owned foreign company had made to dredge the iron sands in three years.

Hearings to consider the application began in Wellington in mid-February, and New Plymouth in March, and were set to end on March 20.

The latest request for more information will set the end of the hearings back to late May.

A decision by the EPA on whether the application is successful may not be known until late June.

McCabe said the group would consider applying for a judicial review of the hearings process because it was flawed and prejudiced submitters opposing the application.

"It's an option for us but it is not a small process to trigger a review and it can be lengthy," he said.

"If the information was available from the beginning, there could have been more submissions made in opposing it."

The EPA had originally accepted the application as complete but had now "turned around" and asked for new information.

McCabe said the authority should have asked for more information seven month ago.

"This new information may make the application look very different than it did at the beginning of the process," he said.

'To have a considerable amount of information put on the table at the end of the process means that opportunities for proper public engagement in the process have now been lost."
 

 - Taranaki Daily News

Comments

Ad Feedback
special offers
Auckland

Author finds her voice

Helen Tau'au Filisi is holding an art exhibition and releasing a new children's book as part of Samoan language week.

A passionate writer and artist, it took some years before Helen Tau'au Filisi first published a book, now she's releasing her fifth children's book.

Warbirds commemorates D-Day

The New Zealand Warbirds Association is gearing up for its Warbirds Open Day at Ardmore Airport.

High performance aircrafts are on show for Ardmore's Warbirds Open Day.

Hall throws into champs reckoning

Southland discus thrower Marshall Hall.

Southland discus thrower Marshall Hall has recorded the second best distance in New Zealand history.

Pedestrian in serious condition

Traffic has been redirected into Hauraki side streets after a pedestrian was hit by a car on the corner of Lake Rd and ...

A man has been taken to hospital in a serious condition after being hit by a car on Auckland's North Shore.

Wellington

Election 'delaying Basin plans'

Wellingtonians have been waiting years for a solution to the rush hour traffic that clogs up the Basin Reserve ...

Councillor claims Government is playing politics with Wellington's transport system.

Manc Aid in capital video

Rob Whelan is teaming up with Red Cross to help get the funds to England.

Wellington musicians to raise money for those affected by Manchester bombing.

Heritage building owner ignored

An artist's impression of the proposed apartment and hotel complex - Lambton on Waititi - seen from the bus terminal in ...

Council approved 10-storey hotel and apartment complex without notifying the owner of the heritage residence next door.

Fraudster doctored CV

Fraudster Joanne Harrison's travel expenses have been made public, as have her CVs.

Leave town and change your name: More detail of Joanne Harrison's $725k fraud emerges.

Canterbury

House burns down

Firefighters extinguishing the blaze.

A man escaped unharmed before his rural house became engulfed in flames.

Funding freeze

St Asaph St is set to be altered again to reinstate car parks.

Ex-rebuild minister suspended Accessible City funding amid discontent over controversial roadworks.

Man's mysterious disappearance

Michael Craig McGrath went missing on Sunday, May 21.

Michael McGrath kept below the radar until he went missing about a week ago.

Waves were 'over our heads'

Fishing boat Kutere beached at Cobden, near Greymouth, on May 29.

Fisherman was asleep in a berth as the boat went across the bar with no-one at the helm.

Waikato

Giant climb for her father

Emily Webb is climbing Mt Kilimanjaro in September so has upped her training at Fastlane Fitness.

Emily Webb will be crying happy tears when she conquers Mount Kilimanjaro.

War on myrtle rust video

Pohutukawa trees are one species potentially affected by myrtle rust.

DOC staff so worried about a catastrophic myrtle rust outbreak, they're flying to remote areas to collect seeds.

Cricketer strangles pregnant partner

Northern Districts and Auckland representative cricketer Cody Andrews was sentenced in Hamilton District Court on Monday.

Judge says cricketer's heavily pregnant partner "must have been terrified".

Maternity service shake-up

Waikato DHB community and clinical support executive director Mark Spittal.

Maternity services in South Waikato and King Country are earmarked for an overhaul.

Taranaki

Library goes all in on 3D video

Nanette Cook, HaweraPlus library officer, with two black unicorns printed on the library's new 3D printer.

Books are old school. Now a library ain't nothing till it's got a 3D printer.

Psychic versus skeptic

Sensing Murder psychic Sue Nicholson in action.

He's as skeptical as they come so why did this cop sign up for Sensing Murder? One psychic wants to know.

Road threat to kokako being managed

Volunteers carry the kokako into the Pirininihi Forest after an eighteen-year absence.

At risk kokako have returned to Taranaki after a twelve year absence.

A safe $20,000

The Stratford TSB Pool Complex 's budget took a tumble with the $20,000 of unplanned upgrades.

It doesn't matter there's never been an accident, incident or near-miss, it still needs $20,000 of safety upgrades.

Manawatu

Bugler bound for Belgium

Tim Cook is a real estate agent with Harcourts in Palmerston North. He is one of three army buglers bound for Belgium to ...

Playing the Last Post isn't an easy job, but someone has to do it.

Unexplained death

Palmerston North Hospital management is accused of not being upfront about an unexplained death on its grounds.

"This man was in their arms looking for support and he ended up dead."

Robber's 'slasher-like' weapon

Footage from the robbery of a Liquorland store in Palmerston North.

Police release CCTV showing the thieves, who hit a shop attendant with the tool in a Palmerson North robbery.

Right first time is ultimately simpler

This is just the start of temporary works in the Manawatu River at the Ashhurst Domain to divert the flow from slamming ...

OPINION: The meeting that ran upside down, or around in a circle.

Nelson

Waimea dam plan 'head and shoulders' above other options

John Hutton says he believes the proposed dam is the best water augmentation option he has seen.

The proposed dam ticks all the boxes at a relatively good cost, says interim project director John Hutton.

'Sparkling light' killed

Police divert traffic on the Coastal Highway after a fatal car crash.

A young woman described as a "bright sparkling light" was killed in a crash on the Coastal Highway.

School's race against time

Josephine, left, Maia and Stu Rankin read the adventure race map with friend Carol Hufflett, during Nelson Central ...

The Central Challenge had families and groups searching high and low for clues in a fundraising event.

Cheapskates owners roll on

Chris Kirby of Cheapskates is handing over the reins of his Nelson streetwear store he has run for the last 20 years.

New owners, new location, but a Nelson retailer says the time is right to roll out the door.

Marlborough

Teen charged after fatal crash

A roadside memorial to Blenheim teenager Lara Glover near Spring Creek, north of Blenheim.

Sixteen-year-old Lara Glover died in a car that was carrying eight teens when it crashed.

Like father, like son

Rob Horsenail with son Charlie, 3, wearing a uniform made out of one of his dad's old, sooty outfits from the front line.

Dressed in dad's dirty uniform, Charlie already knows what he wants to be.

Start spreading the news video

Jodie and Jonny Keen are the owners of Marlborough's newest food truck, JJ's.

Blenheim beats little town blues by taking bite out of Big Apple's cafe culture, with more food outlets per capita.

'The scape goats'

Workers Accommodation Marlborough owner Mandy Matthews in one of the residential properties she manages in Blenheim.

Property manager says RSE workers live in four or five-bedroom houses, while MSD is looking for one-bedroom houses.

South Canterbury

Seeking right woman for the job

The rights say one actor must be white, one must be black and the third must be Asian

Timaru show could be abandoned unless actor found for very specific role.

Protection help sought

Urban designer Nigel Gilkison made a submission on behalf of the Timaru Civic Trust. The trust bought the 1871 Landing ...

"The onus is put on the owners... essentially they get no compensation for having to do that."

Dollar-a-stay plan for Mackenzie

Tourists at Lake Pukaki, Aoraki (Mount Cook) near Twizel.

New scheme to encourage visitors to donate to Mackenzie fund.

Timaru killer re-jailed

Leif Wulff died from stab wounds on the beach at Timaru's Caroline Bay, pictured, in 1991. (FILE PHOTO)

Caroline Bay killer Robin Pitney re-jailed for cutting off electronic bracelet.

Southland

Stage two of cycle trail opened

Three members of the Southland Community Trust were some of the first to experience the new section after the opening of ...

The newest section of the Te Anau to Manapouri cycle trail is open for use, with people of all ages welcomed out for a spin.

Steel break record 

The Southern Steel squad after their victory over the Northern Stars.

Southern Steel have broken a franchise record with their 82-58 win over the Northern Stars.

Passion for singing video

Max McCauley has entertained many thousands of country music fans.

Country music singing has taken Max McCauley all over the New Zealand.

Te Anau fights for maternity centre

A large crowd of supporters turned out in Te Anau on Saturday afternoon to march.

The Te Anau community bands together to fight for better rural maternity funding.

Ad Feedback