Mormon church accused of perpetuating 'savage' Samoan stereotype

Depictions of Samoan people have stirred controversy.
SUPPLIED

Depictions of Samoan people have stirred controversy.

A Mormon church's exhibition which encourages people to superimpose their face on a Samoan warrior has been slammed as exploiting a culture for amusement.

A "discovery centre" at a Church of Jesus Christ of the Latter-day Saints in Utah, in the United States, allows visitors to learn about different cultures around the world.

However, the depiction of a shirtless Samoan has been labelled as perpetuating a "barbarian" and "savage" stereotype for white people's entertainment, by prominent Kiwi academic and Mormon, Gina Colvin.

Canterbury academic Gina Colvin says the Church of Latter-Day Saints has a cultural history of plundering Pasifika ...
GEORGE HEARD/FAIRFAX NZ

Canterbury academic Gina Colvin says the Church of Latter-Day Saints has a cultural history of plundering Pasifika cultures for spectacle and display.

The University of Canterbury academic discovered the exhibit on a recent trip to the United States.

READ MORE:
Massey racism provokes call for university name change
Sir Peter Leitch says 'racist' comments misinterpreted
* Housing, retail space planned for Temple View, Hamilton

 
Depictions of Samoan people have stirred controversy.
SUPPLIED

Depictions of Samoan people have stirred controversy.

"I was appalled," she said.

"The Pacific Islands, for Mormon people has always been a place of spectacle, all they want to know is the music and the dance and they empty us of any other kind of identity. Pacific Islanders and Maori have often been used for their amusement, but never really understood."

Colvin, who describes herself as a "multi-generation life long Mormon", has published several papers on the faith.

Mangere MP Su'a William Sio said Samoa had close ties to the Mormon religion.
JAMES IRELAND/FAIRFAX NZ

Mangere MP Su'a William Sio said Samoa had close ties to the Mormon religion.

She said Pacific Islanders were being exploited for the amusement of white Americans. The exhibit comes with commentary which states "traditionally, obesity is considered a status symbol in Samoa". 

Ad Feedback

Colvin said it was an example of appropriation of culture.

"It reduces people to a limited range of identifiers."

The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints held its 185th Annual General Conference in Salt Lake City in 2015. But ...
GEORGE FREY/REUTERS

The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints held its 185th Annual General Conference in Salt Lake City in 2015. But still faces accusations of perpetuating colonial attitudes.

By comparison, other cultures were fully dressed, with European cultures displayed as "dapper" and "civilised", she said.

The Samoan culture perpetuated the "warrior identity".

"It just reinforces that barbarian, savage identity."

Colvin questioned how much consultation had been conducted with Samoan people.

"Knowing white people are going to put their faces on your customary dress.

"But they don't do that."

She said people did not want to understand more, something she called "a very colonial mindset".

"I think they tend not to ask critical questions, it is an amusement for them."

Church spokeswoman Irene Caso said the church's intention was one of education and its message was one of unity and love.

She said the response from both members and nonmembers had been "extremely positive".

"This experience is intended to be a celebration of our patrons' cultures and heritage.

"The universal message of the church is one of unity and love." 

Caso said the experience was intended to be a gathering place where families could create memorable, fun connections to their ancestors.

Labour Pacific Island affairs spokesman Aupito Su'a William Sio hadn't seen the centre, but said it was trying to promote awareness about Samoa exists.

"The church may be attempting to present the values in the best way it can."

He said Samoa had close ties to the Mormon religion.

Sio said he was raised Catholic but has since become a member of the Mormon church.

He said it was traditional for a man to be shirtless and wearing a lavalava.

"That is acceptable traditional wear and is still acceptable today and practised today."

Sio said he was "grateful" that Colvin had raised the issue.

"This centre and [Colvin's] response highlights that we as a people need to now more about Samoa."

 - Sunday Star Times

Comments

Ad Feedback
special offers
Auckland

More synthetic cannabis call-outs

Police say more will die from synthetic cannabis use if something doesn't change.

Police see further people under influence of drug, while coroner decides whether or not to hold inquests into seven deaths.

Anger over sediment at Orewa beach

Julian Joy snapped a shot of the sediment slick leaving the Orewa estuary on July 13.

Once beautiful, Orewa beach is now covered in slimy, sticky silt.

Sawn-off shotgun 'unsafe'

Gustav Sanft is on trial in the High Court in Auckland.

Expert at trial says gun that killed girl could have fired without trigger being pulled.

Silt pours into pristine waterways

The sediment plumes happen like clockwork after rain events, Pete Townend said.

Truckloads of sediment are entering waterways in Auckland and the system to stop it is ''broken''.

Wellington

Sun rises on new WWI sculpture

Sunrise through the sculpture 'Jacob's Ladder' by Helen Pollock, erected on the Hawke's Bay farm of Michael and Jane Hardy.

A plan to sculpt a head of ex-politician Sue Bradford became something more profound.

Car lands in bushes

Shane Williams looks at the scene where his friend drove off the scenic lookout at Wainuiomata hill.

Car crashes through barrier on busy road and lands in bushes above Lower Hutt.

Up close with a big bore video

The exploratory drill at work in Wellington Harbour.

Drilling work to find a backup water supply to the capital shows promising signs.

Drains: Not sexy, but needed

When the drains block, fixing them isn't pleasant.

OPINION: Most Kiwis just want the country to not turn into Atlantis every time it lightly drizzles, rather than fancy council projects.

Canterbury

MPs battle over billboard spot

A campaign poster for National MP Nuk Korako was nailed over top of one for Labour MP Ruth Dyson in St Martins, Christchurch.

Nuk Korako's sign was nailed directly over Ruth Dyson's red one, but both say they're right.

Flood roads still closed

The clean up begins after two months of rain fell in two days. Pictured: Diana McKay cleans flood debris off Waimea Tce ...

Christchurch state of emergency staying despite floodwaters receding.      

Boris welcomes Kiwis on OE

British Foreign Secretary Boris Johnson (centre) arrives at Takahanga Marae in Kaikoura about 9am on Monday with Civil ...

UK foreign secretary Boris Johnson says it should be as smooth as possible post-Brexit.

Snow on way but not severe

John Parks' property on the Taieri Plains is 90 per cent covered in water.

Another chill southerly is due, but it will be more a boon to skiers than burden to farmers.

Waikato

'C' brand fails to click

One of the proposed posters with the re-brand. Some in the community weren't happy that a stock images has been used for it.

Business loves Cambridge's new branding. The people? Not so much.

Death on the footpath

Police tape guards the scene in North Street, Te Awamutu.

Body discovery scream startles couple as they nestle in for prime time tele.

SH25A closed for days

The slip on Stahe Highway 25a which is causing massive delays and detours.

Main road over Coromandel Peninsula won't be clear until at least Thursday.

Man allegedly slit throat of rival

Sameh Khalil Salem Ali, 42, is on trial in the Hamilton District Court on a charge of attempted murder.

Accused allegedly said to cop: "What else would you do if you found him with your missus?"

Taranaki

Fallen soldier remembered

Ralph Doughty, of Stratford, Taranaki, was awarded the Military Cross for his heroic actions in World War One.

The difference between life and death was a matter of seconds for a Kiwi soldier who died 100 years ago.

High steaks game

Jacqueline and Robin Blackwell have a friendly rivalry.

It's just as much about bragging rights at home as it is about national recognition for the Blackwell family.

NZ's first virtual medical centre

Dr Lance O'Sullivan is running the pilot project in Patea.

Patea's only doctor left, so the small town is now embracing new virtual technology to find a solution to its vacancy.

The queens are coming

Priscilla, Queen of the Desert has been announced as the New Plymouth Operatic Society's 2019 show.

Get ready for the ride of your life, the battered old bus Priscilla is coming to New Plymouth.

Manawatu

Holiday park up for award

Former owner of Himatangi Beach Holiday Park Dennis Penney with his most recent hospitality award.

The Himatangi Beach Holiday Park is a finalist in the 2017 Spirit of Hospitality Awards.

Conman allowed to sue

Brian Hunter has multiple convictions, including for impersonating a pilot and a lawyer.

A serial conman says probation officers' negligence cost him, and he's going to sue.

Robber stabs staff member

A staff member at a Levin food store on Queen St has been stabbed in the hand during a robbery.

A staff member of a Levin food store has been stabbed in the hand during a robbery.

Manawatu Gorge alternative urgent

Contractors work in the Manawatu Gorge earlier this year. Their efforts have so far been futile.

OPINION: For over 130 years, bits of the Manawatu Gorge have been falling down.

Nelson

MTBs get down and dirty

Tasman De Leeuw after his run in Nelson Mountain Bike Club's winter downhill series at Kaka, in the Matai Valley.

The Nelson Mountain Bike Club's downhill winter series turned into a mud bath.

Pain relief battle

Yvonne Gill has been using opioid painkillers for 10 years to manage pain from a medical mishap.

 A Nelson woman is angry at doctors for stopping access to strong painkillers.

Koha Shed turns two video

21072017 NEWS photo / MARION VAN DIJK / STUFF
 
The Koha Shed Nelson  founders Cara Glenhill, left, and Janine Brennan ...

Hundreds of items have passed through the Nelson Koha Shed, helping thousands of people.

Nelson reign supreme video

Nelson players and management celebrate their club championship success.

Nelson turn it on to hammer Wanderers in Nelson Bays club rugby final. 

Marlborough

Boris likens hongi to headbutt

British Foreign Secretary Boris Johnson (centre) arrives at Takahanga Marae in Kaikoura about 9am on Monday with Civil ...

Flamboyant British Foreign Secretary Boris Johnson was welcomed onto Takahanga Marae in Kaikoura this morning.

End of the Manhattan

23072017 News Photo- RICKY WILSON/STUFF
The Manhattan Cafe has been sold after 28 years of ownership by 
Murray and Mary ...

Blenheim's longest-running cafe calls it a day.

No longer a pipe dream

Seddon residents should be able to drink water straight from the tap once the treatment plant is completed by May.

Clean water coming soon. Filtration Technology Ltd will design and build treatment plant in Seddon.

Never too late to dance

Taking up ballet has been a good move for Derryn James, of Blenheim, who is pursuing her childhood passion once more.

Taking up ballet has been a good move for Derryn James, of Blenheim, who is pursuing her childhood passion once more. 

South Canterbury

'Tough as teak' ex-AB dies

Tom Lister played eight tests as an All Black against, Australia, France, Wales, South Africa and the 1971 British and ...

South Canterbury's most-capped test All Black Tom Lister dies, aged 73.

Farmer rescued

Flooding caused several vehicles to be stranded with one man stranded on the roof of his car at night on Friday, not ...

Farmer stranded on car roof during heavy flooding was "incredibly lucky" to be saved.

Fundraising group proposed

Timaru District Council hopeful Murray Cleverley wants to fundraise for the refurbishment of the Theatre Royal.

Community group proposed to help bankroll multi-million dollar upgrade of theatre.

Response praised gallery video

A car stuck in the middle of Evans St with two occupants. Two police officers pushed the car off the road.

Timaru mayor praises response to storm, as attention turns to the clean up effort.

Southland

"The culinary world has just lost a gentleman"

Scott Richardson, pictured here in 2015, in his role as a catering and hospitality teacher at Southland Boys' High School.

Well-known Invercargill chef Scott Richardson died this morning in Dunedin Hospital.

'Business as usual'

Aparima College principal Kaye Day. The latest Governmental report on the College said "urgent" improvement in ...

A troubled Southland secondary school is to continue as usual, despite its leadership coming under fire.

Hotel facing potential delays

Invercargill Licensing Trust general manager Greg Mulvey in front of the proposed site of the ILT's new multi-million ...

The Invercargill Licensing Trust has unearthed some speed bumps in its plans to build a new inner city hotel.

Defending champions on fire

Wensley's Fire cyclists from left to right, Nick Barclay, Marty Jillings, Ben Coley and Tai-Anne Blair set off in the ...

The fire service team has confirmed its the fastest emergency service in Invercargill.

Ad Feedback