174 noise complaints - just the sound of a big happy family

Bruce Balle says he has nine children who live at the family home with their own partners and children - "of course we ...
MAHVASH ALI/FAIRFAX NZ

Bruce Balle says he has nine children who live at the family home with their own partners and children - "of course we can be loud," he says.

They are just a big and happy clan living in their family home, says the Auckland man who was fined $1500 after 174 noise complaints from his neighbours. 

At a March 30 hearing Judge David Kirkpatrick ordered west Auckland man Bruce Palle to pay $1500 for failing to comply with a direction by Auckland Council noise officers to reduce the noise coming from his home.

The charge related to a single Excessive Noise Direction (END) notice issued on September 1 and breached on September 3, 2016. 

The father-of-nine said he refused to attend the hearing because the court got his name wrong - he said it's Balle not Palle.

READ MORE: One house, 174 noise complaints and 40 excessive noise directions

His family could be noisy - that's because there were at least a dozen people in his house at any time. 

Balle said there were times when some of his children and their friends had one drink too many and decided to stay the ...
MAHVASH ALI/FAIRFAX

Balle said there were times when some of his children and their friends had one drink too many and decided to stay the night at the Arran St house.

"I am not saying that we are not noisy. We are just a big family that has children, and they have children and partners. Of course we can be loud."

The Arran St resident said the frequent parties at his house were well-attended, and sometimes "half of Avondale" turned up.

There were also times when some of his children and their friends had one drink too many and decided to stay the night, he said. 

Neighbours of this Avondale home said they often slept with pillows over their ears to drown out their noisy neighbours.
MAHVASH ALI/FAIRFAX NZ

Neighbours of this Avondale home said they often slept with pillows over their ears to drown out their noisy neighbours.

The head of the "big Maori family" said quarrels only happened when random strangers tried to crash their parties.

Ad Feedback

Balle said his Avondale home was surrounded at close proximity by a number of houses, and he was not surprised neighbours thought the family was noisy.

Auckland Council officers had attended 174 noise complaints at the Arran St house, and its residents issued with 40 END notices between September 2013 and September 2016. 

Auckland Council issued an Arran St, Avondale property with 40 excessive noise directions.
MAHVASH ALI/FAIRFAX

Auckland Council issued an Arran St, Avondale property with 40 excessive noise directions.

Neighbours complained of partying, brawling and the incessant "boom boom" of bass coming from the property.

At the hearing Judge Kirkpatrick noted the outcome from about three-quarters of the complaints found noise to not be excessive.

Balle said the family complied every time a noise complaint officer asked them to quieten down. 

An END notice was only issued when an enforcement officer found excessive noise after a complaint.

If noise was found excessive a second time within 72-hours after an END notice was issued, the officer could return with police and seize music equipment.

Failure to comply with a single END notice could result in an infringement fee of $500. 

Balle said he had lived on the street for at least eight years. In that time he claimed only one resident had ever approached him directly asking the family to quieten things down. 

Neighbours preferred to go through council, he said.

Neighbours claimed they did not want to approach the family because they feared retribution.

One neighbour said he suspected a number of letterboxes on the street had been smashed by the "noisy residents" after a neighbour made a complaint. 

Balle said his mailbox was regularly damaged as well and it was not his family who smashed them.

"We are on our third one."

He said he was disappointed the courts didn't correct his surname after he told them it wasn't right.

"It's just a respect thing. If they want to prosecute me, then they must get my name right."

If they had, Balle would have represented himself in court.

The court decision showed a summons to Balle to attend the first appearance hearing was issued on November 15, 2016.

It was served to his daughter on November 23, 2016.

Another summons for the March 30 hearing was issued on February 20 this year, it was also served to his daughter.

The Ministry of Justice said it was responsibility of the prosecuting agency to supply correct details.

Auckland Council refused to comment, citing privacy reasons.

 - Stuff

Ad Feedback
special offers
Auckland

Typhoid in Palmerston North

Typhoid has spread to Palmerston North.

A child in Palmerston North Hospital is confirmed as being infected.

Shock in the Fox

The Pt Chevalier Pirates' celebrate during happier times. The team's 2017 unbeaten record has ended, falling to Glenora ...

Only two points separate the top four teams in the Fox Memorial competition.

New Zealand's must-try dishes

The Nest, by L'oeuf.

How many of these 40 dishes can you tick off?

Early puberty and poverty linked

Early puberty has been linked to physical, behavioural and mental health issues post-childhood and is more likely to ...

Impoverished children used to be the last to go through puberty; these days the opposite is true.

Wellington

Hutt's infill housing dilemma video

Real estate agent John Ross supports building apartments in suburban shopping centres, but believes the best way to get ...

Realtor says greenfield developments, not infill, will solve Lower Hutt's housing shortage.

Our crowded schools

Newtown School was operating at 142 per cent capacity, according to Ministry of Education figures.

Almost a quarter of Wellington region's schools at risk of overcrowding, or already over capacity.

Plan for ATM no-beggar zones

Beggars near an ATM machine in Manners St, Wellington, on Tuesday. Businesses in the city consider it to be one of the ...

Wellington businesses want perimeters marked around ATMs to prevent intimidation of customers.

Light rail 'not as easy as it sounds'

An artist's impression of what light rail advocates hoped trams running along Lambton Quay would look like.

Engineering expert points out that simply switching from bus to light rail is not simple.

Canterbury

Cathedral Sq site for sale

05092011 News Photo: John Kirk-Anderson/The Press


Red Zone tour, ANZ building, Cathedral Square.

Family will sell its prominent Cathedral Square property for the first time in nearly 100 years after abandoning rebuild attempts.

Horse struck and killed

A motorist struck and killed a horse that ran in front of her crash in Christchurch on Wednesday morning (file photo).

A horse is dead and a car stuck in a ditch after two collisions just minutes apart in Christchurch.

St Asaph St changes planned

07042017 News Photo Stacy Squires/Fairfax NZ
Christchurch CBD new cycle lanes. PHOTO: St Asaph St.

About 25 car parks could be reinstated on St Asaph St after Christchurch business leaders threatened legal action.

New Zealand's must-try dishes

The Nest, by L'oeuf.

How many of these 40 dishes can you tick off?

Waikato

Early house blaze 

The fire engulfed the two storey house measuring 20 by eight metres in rural Pirongia.

An elderly resident has lost everything in a blaze that sent his home up in a "ball of fire".

ED is overloaded

Waikato Hospital is in overload and above capacity.

Unless it's a "real emergency", people are urged to see their GPs or ring the Healthline first.

Myrtle rust spread continues

Myrtle rust is a fungal disease that is found on plants such as pohutukawa and manuka. As of Tuesday, May 23, it had ...

The spread of Myrtle rust is continuing by the day, with the disease found in the Waikato.

Dangerous man wanted by police

Police are looking for Thomas Coffin, who sometimes uses the name, Tom Bell.

Thomas Coffin is dangerous and possibly carrying a firearm. He is not to be approached, police say.

Taranaki

Anti-bullying tactics

Kerehoma addresses bullying in his classes, and helps the children find ways to make themselves safe.

Clayton Kerehoma works on anti-bullying tactics with his Brazilian Jui Jitsu class.

Father facing death

Shane Petersen said he has to stay strong for his children CJ, 6, and Chloe, 8.

Dad-of-two Shane Petersen has been told that his days are numbered - but he is refusing to just give up.

Snip, snip, secrets slip

Councillor Graham Kelly was suspended from two council committees after the report was discussed.

Come in for a trim, get a side of confidential information.

Fancy a round with Jordie Barrett

Photo: Reuters - All Blacks captain Richie McCaw

How much would you pay to play golf with Jordie Barrett?

Manawatu

Cloverlea School bike track opens

Makaiah Jennings tries out the new bike track.

Kids are riding rings around their teachers at Cloverlea School on a new bike track.

Typhoid spreads

Typhoid has spread to Palmerston North.

A child in Palmerston North Hospital is confirmed as being infected.

A cry for help

Rex Rosacker rang mental health services for a family member, but they said they couldn't help.

He rang mental health services. He rang police. But he had to rescue a family member.

'Wife could be next'

Police investigate a robbery at the Rangiora Mini Mart in Palmerston North.

Manawatu man fears his wife could be in danger as thieves raid Manawatu dairies.

Nelson

Rise and shine

A bird is the point of focus in Nelson Intermediate School pupil Ben Palmer's picture of the sunrise on Tuesday.

Schoolboy Ben Palmer was up at the crack of dawn to take a cracker shot of the sunrise.

Kaye to save Salisbury?

For now, it remains business as usual at Salisbury School, says Education Minister Nikki Kaye.

​New Education Minister will carefully consider the future of Salisbury School.

Plan to stop spread of wilding pines

Wilding conifer control in Abel Tasman National Park is near completion, but requires many years of management.

Forestry companies are looking at ways to curb the spread of wild conifers on DOC land.

From party house to art house gallery

Doll heads in a birdcage. Who'd have thought?

This dinky Nelson home has been transformed from party place to artists' abode.

Marlborough

Big names behind surf comp

Surfer Alan Te Moananui.

Kaikoura Boardriders Coldwater Classic has plenty of heavies behind it as big sponsors come on board.

Purpose-built priority

St Andrews Property Group is developing the former Country Life Motel, south of Blenheim, to house more than 400 ...

Vineyard contractors encouraged out of rental market as Blenheim faces housing shortage.

Three in contention

Lauren Murray had another good night under the goal hoop for Harlequins Radich Law on Tuesday.

 First round honours in the premier netball competition will be fought out between three teams.

Food cart's unlikely ally

The Wheely Wild Food Cart on the side of State Highway 63 in November.

Roadside food truck was ticking along nicely; then came the quake, the customers, the complaint and the shut down.

South Canterbury

New venture for empty site

Bob Mason and business partner Ross Rathgen inside the old Lone Star premises, soon to become the Bullock Restaurant and Bar.

A new restaurant and bar will open in the former Lone Star premises in Timaru. 

Violence before death

The violence surrounding the death of Ashburton man Arran Gairns has been described in the High Court at Timaru.

Jury hears of yelling, splashing and violence on night before man found dead in ditch.

Waimate web plan approved

Waimate District Council has approved $40,000 to develop a marketing website for the district.

Waimate's council to spend up to $40,000 on new website.

School heads back to the 80s

Timaru Girls' High and Timaru Boys' High School students rehearse for their joint production Back to the 80's. Pictured ...

Dig out your leg warmers, crop tops and head back to the 80s with Timaru Girls' this week.

Southland

Brass teacher and pupil perform service for community

The youngest and oldest Balclutha Brass Band members, Alanah Anderson,10, and Bill Cross, 86.

Noteworthy service to community for Balclutha brass teacher and pupil.

Amundsen new deputy

Cr Rebecca Amundsen has been appointed deputy mayor by Invercargill Mayor Tim Shadbolt, after Cr Darren Ludlow resigned ...

Invercargill Mayor Tim Shadbolt has appointed his new deputy mayor.

Who is in the Stags mix?

Marist second five-eighth Matty Johnson is one of the Stags midfield contenders for 2017.

Logan Savory takes a look at who he thinks could be contention for the 2017 Stags squad.

Sea Lions establishing colony on Stewart Island

A juvenile sea lion in Port Pegasus in January 2016.

Southland's plans for aquaculture could be scuppered by sea lions looking for love.

Ad Feedback