Tribunal finds 'provocative' Fairfax cartoons did not breach Human Rights Act

The Al Nisbet cartoon that ran in The Press in May 2013.
Al Nisbet

The Al Nisbet cartoon that ran in The Press in May 2013.

A tribunal has found Fairfax Media did not breach the Human Rights Act in publishing two "provocative" cartoons in its newspapers.

Labour MP Louisa Wall and South Auckland youth group Warriors of Change took the company and The Press and Marlborough Express newspapers to the Human Rights Review Tribunal over cartoons published in 2013. Fairfax Media, which publishes the two newspapers, also owns Stuff.

Cartoonist Al Nisbet produced two cartoons about the Government's breakfast in schools programme. One depicted a group of adults, dressed as children, eating breakfast and saying "Psst . . . If we can get away with this, the more cash left for booze, smokes and pokies". The other showed a family sitting around a table littered with Lotto tickets, alcohol and cigarettes and saying "Free school food is great! Eases our poverty and puts something in you kids' bellies".

The cartoon that ran in The Marlborough Express.
AL NISBET

The cartoon that ran in The Marlborough Express.

Wall said the cartoons were "insulting and ignorant put-downs of Maori and Pacific people". She argued they breached section 61 of the Human Rights Act.

READ MORE:
* Full decision: Human Rights Review Tribunal
Cartoons 'provocative, negative, insulting'
Editor defends cartoon decision
Cartoons targeted 'bludgers', not race

Section 61 states: the written matter or words must be "threatening, abusive, or insulting" and the second requirement is that the written matter or words must be "likely to excite hostility against or bring into contempt any group of persons" in New Zealand on the ground of the colour, race, or ethnic or national origins of that group. That is, the written matter or words must: [189.1] Be threatening, abusive or insulting; and [189.2] Be likely to excite hostility against or bring into contempt any group of persons on one of the specified grounds. 

Cartoonist Al Nisbet said the cartoons were not racist, and directed at anyone who complained about poverty.
EMMA DANGERFIELD/FAIRFAX NZ

Cartoonist Al Nisbet said the cartoons were not racist, and directed at anyone who complained about poverty.

Wall said she was disappointed by the result and may consider taking the action further.

"I do not agree with that interpretation of section 61 of the Human Rights Act and am particularly concerned at the assertion that an objective assessment of whether the cartoons were likely to bring a group of people into contempt is one that can only be made by a person who is not Maori or Pacific. 

"I will take some time to peruse the decision, to discuss it with the Warriors of Change and the witnesses that gave evidence and to determine whether it is a matter that should be looked at by a higher Court."

The tribunal's ruling, released on Friday, found the cartoons may have "offended, insulted or even angered", they were "not likely to excite hostility against or bring into contempt any group of persons in New Zealand on the ground of their colour, race, or ethnic or national origins".

Ad Feedback

For that reason their publication was not unlawful.

"In a free and democratic society it is essential that the "space" within which issues (including race) can be raised and debated must be kept as broad as possible," the ruling found.

At the tribunal hearing in 2014, Wall argued for a lower threshold in interpreting s61 of the Human Rights Act, allowing consideration for "subjective offence". She initially lodged a complaint with the Human Rights Commission, which found no breach and took no action.

The tribunal agreed. "Our holding is that parliament has framed the s61 racial disharmony provision in appropriately narrow terms," its decision said. "It would be wrong to characterise this decision as a ruling that there is a "right to insult". There is no such right."

Attacks on the functioning of democratic institutions and the free communication of information and ideas highlighted the need for a vigilant free press, the tribunal found, permitted to offend, shock or disturb on occasion.

"It is important the press continue to speak truth to power.

"It should also be remembered that in the aftermath of the murder of twelve persons (including cartoonists) in the attack on the Paris offices of the magazine Charlie Hebdo on 7 January 2015 it was appropriately observed by Salman Rushdie that the art of satire has always been a force for liberty and against tyranny, dishonesty and stupidity."

The Press editor-in-chief Joanna Norris welcomed the tribunal's "strong" decision.

"[It] squarely rejects the misguided notion that publication of material offensive to some should be unlawful, finding in favour of freedom of expression.

"Freedom of expression underpins a free and fair democratic society. If New Zealanders are not free to express views, even those that offend, outrage or upset some people, all human rights are threatened."

She pointed to the tribunal's finding that the cartoons were "unquestionably about a subject of public interest".

"The cartoons published by the Marlborough Express and The Press provided a controversial viewpoint on the efficacy of the Food in Schools programme. The fact that children are going to school hungry is a challenging issue with a great many causes and deserves thorough discussion through a variety of viewpoints. To attempt to suppress a view on this matter because it is offensive to some people is deeply troubling and a failure to properly confront the real issues."

 - Stuff

Ad Feedback
special offers
Auckland

She did this - thanks to Auckland

A first-hand knowledge of Auckland's many social and economic woes gave Jacinda Ardern a foot forward in the general ...

She knows the city's problems first-hand - and successfully tapped into its simmering issues to lead the next government

Morris murderer loses appeal

Connor Morris was fatally struck by a sickle during a fight in West Auckland in 2014.

The man who bludgeoned Millie Elder-Holmes' partner to death with a sickle in an Auckland gang fight will stay behind bars.

Bonneval's fate decided

Bonneval looking relaxed in her box at Flemington on Wednesday.

A confusing and at times bizarre contrast of opinions between a Kiwi trainer and Victorian stewards is finally over.

A Scottish mentalist read my mind video

Colin Cloud has honours in forensic investigation, now he performs as a magic show.

It feels like a violation to have someone enter your mind. It's frustrating and confusing but also awe-inspiring.

Wellington

Praise pours in for Ardern video

Labour leader Jacinda Ardern has received plenty of congratulations after confirming a coalition deal with NZ First.

News that Jacinda Ardern will become PM has been met with elation at home and abroad.

NZ First picks Labour

Labour Leader Jacinda Ardern will be the country's new prime minister.

Jacinda Ardern will become prime minister as the Labour Party regains power after nine years in the cold.

Masseur denies indecent allegations

Keith Dobson, 53, faces 11 charges of indecent assault on six female former clients.

Allegations of indecent touching during massage "flabbergasted" former Hutt masseur.

Napier not keen on Māori seats

Napier City Council civic buildings

Maori council wards 'perceived as creating a division' by some Napier residents.

Canterbury

Live: NZ has a new government

JACINDA DEFCON

Labour leader Jacinda Ardern will finalise the deal with NZ First and the Greens on Friday, but promises a new government within a week.

Sumner Rd delayed video

Aerial photos from January show the extent of the damage to Sumner Road. This photo is looking towards Lyttelton.

The reopening of a key Chch road has been pushed back by at least a year.

Woodburner testing criticised

Consumer NZ's advice to people who burned firewood was to make sure the wood was well-seasoned.

Low-emission woodburners could still be a significant cause of pollution, Consumer NZ says.

Man denies shooting woman

Luke Adam Nickless has appeared in the Christchurch District Court charged with wounding with a firearm with intent to ...

A 34-year-old has denied shooting a woman at a home in Canterbury.

Waikato

Retired farmer sailing away

Roy Woolerton, 80, spent 16 years building his catamaran, but it's now in the water at Westhaven Marina in Auckland.

The hand-built 14.5m offshore cruising cat has two engines and four double berths

Surviving Labour Day

Expect heavy traffic this Labour weekend (file photo).

It's been carnage on the roads this year. Here's how to take it easy this long weekend.

Emotional send-off for soldier

Sergeant Wayne Taylor, 42, died during a maritime counter-terrorism training exercise off the Coromandel Peninsula on ...

The death of Sergeant Wayne Taylor has left a huge hole, his family say.

Four injured in crash

Two cars have collided in the Athenree Gorge.

Two trapped and two more injured after smash in gorge near Waihi.

Taranaki

Cato needs a co-host

Suzy Cato is famous for her Children's TV show Suzy's World

Children's TV star Suzy Cato now hosts a radio show and wants a Taranaki kid to join her on it.

Coalition reaction

Jacinda Ardern and Winston Peters

"It's the start of a distinguished political career for Jacinda Ardern," says New Plymouth Labour Party candidate Corie Haddock.

Sex case verdicts

A jury has returned its verdicts in a Taranaki sex abuse case which was heard in the New Plymouth District Court. (File ...

A jury has found a man guilty of half the historical sex abuse charges he was alleged to have committed.

Traffic light knocked down

The crash happened at the intersection of Devon St East and State Highway 3.

Traffic on New Plymouth's northern route is down to one lane as a result of a crash.

Manawatu

Second bite at life

Hordes of people lining up to order at a food truck Thursday event last summer. The orders are set to return in November.

Thursday nights in Palmerston North just got appetising again.

Labour back in power

Winston Peters announces a coalition deal with Labour.

Jacinda Ardern will become prime minister as the Labour Party retakes power after nine years in the cold.

Live: NZ's new leaders

new govt thumnails

NZ First leader Winston Peters announces he will form a government with Labour.

Hemopo clearly Turbos' best

There was no better for the Turbos this season than Jackson Hemopo, who was also the team's top lineout target.

With the Turbos' season over, rugby writer Shaun Eade looks at the top performers.

Nelson

Dam consultation plan gets nod

05102017 NEWS PHOTO/ CHERIE SIVIGNON

Tasman district councillor Dana Wensley.

It's time for the public to have a say on the proposed Waimea dam.

Military manoeuvres

Military light operational vehicles involved in Exercise Southern Katipo 2017 roll off the HMNZS Canterbury at Port Nelson.

 Nelson gets a glimpse of the Southern Katipo military exercise as soldiers and supplies roll out of Port Nelson.

Fruit jobs in balance

T&G Foods plant in Nayland Rd, Nelson will either be sold, consolidated or shut.

Apple processing plant in Nelson faces closure amid dropping volumes of juice fruit.

Charge follows scare

A policeman at the Stoke Railway Reserve looks for a man who was allegedly seen with a knife in the area.

Police charge teen with possession of an offensive weapon after knife scare in Stoke.

Marlborough

Bar gets new lease of life

Paddy Barry's Irish Bar, on Scott St, closed in 2017.

The owner of two popular night spots in Blenheim is seemingly looking to open a third.

Charity shop to close

Pams Shop Charitable Trust president Bev Dixon says the trust tried everything they could to keep the store open. (File ...

Sales had dropped significantly to the point where the shop had not made a charitable donation in a year.

Embracing cultural differences

The Yealands Wine Group, based in Seddon, is one of the largest wine companies in New Zealand.

It's easy to dish out the criticism when corporates don't do their bit for ethical practices, so it's important to recognise when they do.

Hijacker could get $25,000

Abdille said a government rule change stopped her reuniting her family in 2004.

Asha Abdille injured two pilots in 2008. Now, she's out of jail and could be in the money.

South Canterbury

When Taiyo met Tom video

Japanese student Taiyo Watanabe finally met his hero gold medal winning shot put world champion Tom Walsh in Timaru on ...

Aspiring Japanese shot putter surprised by unexpected meet and greet with hero Tom Walsh.

'Wonderful news' video

Labour MP Jo Luxton

"So many people in NZ need this," Rangitata-based Labour MP says

Testing criticised

Consumer NZ's advice to people who burned firewood was to make sure the wood was well-seasoned.

Consumer NZ says low-emission woodburners could still cause significant pollution.

$820k revamp for hospital

Henderson Building foreman Simon Bartlett carrying out construction at the Bidwill Trust Hospital.

Bidwill Hospital's nine surgeons will be based on site once upgrade is complete in June.

Otago

ORC boss loses job

Peter Bodeker's contract as the Otago Regional Council's chief executive will not be renewed.

The Otago Regional Council's chief executive is out of a job after the council decided not to renew his contract.

Racing boss turns to golf tourism

Owner of Highlands Motorsport Park and Hampton Downs, Tony Quinn.

Highlands Motorsport Park boss Tony Quinn wants to build a golf course and residential development at the back of his racetrack.

Pilot Graeme Frew confirms Full Noise for Wanaka

Reno rookie of the year, Graeme Frew.

Record-breaking rookie Reno racer Graeme Frew to bring V-12 powered Yak-3 aircraft to Wanaka's airshow.

Aerial rat attack in Matukituki Valley

Native robins are thriving at Aspiring Flat after being reintroduced to the area several years ago.

DOC opens new front in the Battle for our Birds in the Mt Aspiring National Park near Wanaka.

Southland

Unique tanker in truck parade

Bill Richardson Transport World tourism co-ordinator Amelia Munro will accompany the museum's Texaco Tanker in Sunday's ...

A one-of-a-kind Texaco tanker will be paraded in Invercargill for possibly the last time.

Principals praise parent volunteers

Invercargill Middle School principal Stan Tiatia.

"I think we are really lucky that the good old Southland way is to get in and help."

Kiwis need to talk about driving

NZ Transport Agency regional relationships director Jim Harland with a steering wheel tag that provides tourists with ...

Before criticising out international drivers, Kiwis need to start looking at their own driving ability, an NZ Transport Agency director has said.

Gore dairy owner wary of safety

Sunbeam Milk Bar owner Eddie Cooney is appreciative of support from the Gore community following an armed robbery in his ...

Three robberies have taken their toll on Gore dairy owner Eddie Cooney but he's not hanging up the closed sign.

Ad Feedback