Tribunal finds 'provocative' Fairfax cartoons did not breach Human Rights Act

The Al Nisbet cartoon that ran in The Press in May 2013.
Al Nisbet

The Al Nisbet cartoon that ran in The Press in May 2013.

A tribunal has found Fairfax Media did not breach the Human Rights Act in publishing two "provocative" cartoons in its newspapers.

Labour MP Louisa Wall and South Auckland youth group Warriors of Change took the company and The Press and Marlborough Express newspapers to the Human Rights Review Tribunal over cartoons published in 2013. Fairfax Media, which publishes the two newspapers, also owns Stuff.

Cartoonist Al Nisbet produced two cartoons about the Government's breakfast in schools programme. One depicted a group of adults, dressed as children, eating breakfast and saying "Psst . . . If we can get away with this, the more cash left for booze, smokes and pokies". The other showed a family sitting around a table littered with Lotto tickets, alcohol and cigarettes and saying "Free school food is great! Eases our poverty and puts something in you kids' bellies".

The cartoon that ran in The Marlborough Express.
AL NISBET

The cartoon that ran in The Marlborough Express.

Wall said the cartoons were "insulting and ignorant put-downs of Maori and Pacific people". She argued they breached section 61 of the Human Rights Act.

READ MORE:
* Full decision: Human Rights Review Tribunal
Cartoons 'provocative, negative, insulting'
Editor defends cartoon decision
Cartoons targeted 'bludgers', not race

Section 61 states: the written matter or words must be "threatening, abusive, or insulting" and the second requirement is that the written matter or words must be "likely to excite hostility against or bring into contempt any group of persons" in New Zealand on the ground of the colour, race, or ethnic or national origins of that group. That is, the written matter or words must: [189.1] Be threatening, abusive or insulting; and [189.2] Be likely to excite hostility against or bring into contempt any group of persons on one of the specified grounds. 

Cartoonist Al Nisbet said the cartoons were not racist, and directed at anyone who complained about poverty.
EMMA DANGERFIELD/FAIRFAX NZ

Cartoonist Al Nisbet said the cartoons were not racist, and directed at anyone who complained about poverty.

Wall said she was disappointed by the result and may consider taking the action further.

"I do not agree with that interpretation of section 61 of the Human Rights Act and am particularly concerned at the assertion that an objective assessment of whether the cartoons were likely to bring a group of people into contempt is one that can only be made by a person who is not Maori or Pacific. 

"I will take some time to peruse the decision, to discuss it with the Warriors of Change and the witnesses that gave evidence and to determine whether it is a matter that should be looked at by a higher Court."

The tribunal's ruling, released on Friday, found the cartoons may have "offended, insulted or even angered", they were "not likely to excite hostility against or bring into contempt any group of persons in New Zealand on the ground of their colour, race, or ethnic or national origins".

Ad Feedback

For that reason their publication was not unlawful.

"In a free and democratic society it is essential that the "space" within which issues (including race) can be raised and debated must be kept as broad as possible," the ruling found.

At the tribunal hearing in 2014, Wall argued for a lower threshold in interpreting s61 of the Human Rights Act, allowing consideration for "subjective offence". She initially lodged a complaint with the Human Rights Commission, which found no breach and took no action.

The tribunal agreed. "Our holding is that parliament has framed the s61 racial disharmony provision in appropriately narrow terms," its decision said. "It would be wrong to characterise this decision as a ruling that there is a "right to insult". There is no such right."

Attacks on the functioning of democratic institutions and the free communication of information and ideas highlighted the need for a vigilant free press, the tribunal found, permitted to offend, shock or disturb on occasion.

"It is important the press continue to speak truth to power.

"It should also be remembered that in the aftermath of the murder of twelve persons (including cartoonists) in the attack on the Paris offices of the magazine Charlie Hebdo on 7 January 2015 it was appropriately observed by Salman Rushdie that the art of satire has always been a force for liberty and against tyranny, dishonesty and stupidity."

The Press editor-in-chief Joanna Norris welcomed the tribunal's "strong" decision.

"[It] squarely rejects the misguided notion that publication of material offensive to some should be unlawful, finding in favour of freedom of expression.

"Freedom of expression underpins a free and fair democratic society. If New Zealanders are not free to express views, even those that offend, outrage or upset some people, all human rights are threatened."

She pointed to the tribunal's finding that the cartoons were "unquestionably about a subject of public interest".

"The cartoons published by the Marlborough Express and The Press provided a controversial viewpoint on the efficacy of the Food in Schools programme. The fact that children are going to school hungry is a challenging issue with a great many causes and deserves thorough discussion through a variety of viewpoints. To attempt to suppress a view on this matter because it is offensive to some people is deeply troubling and a failure to properly confront the real issues."

 - Stuff

Ad Feedback
special offers
Auckland

5 of Auckland's best winter eats

Sean Connolly cooking at his Italian restaurant "Gusto".

Winter menus are a delight, as the season draws to a close make sure you indulge in the best on offer.

'The boy couldn't breathe' video

Video showed men masked and dressed in Mr Four Square costumes apparently attacking two teens on a train from Britomart ...

Two teens were on their way home for dinner when they were punched and kicked by a group of men dressed as Mr Four Square.

Big win for Blenheim

A million-dollar winner, but Powerball not struck.

Blenheim Lotto player strikes it lucky with $1m win.

Police investigate gay hate pastor

A police spokesman said "police are aware of [Robertson's remarks], and are taking it seriously".

Logan Robertson says gay couples marrying deserved a bullet in the head. Police say they're taking it seriously.

Wellington

Rental WoFs for capital

Wellington Mayor Justin Lester says the council wants to "lift rental standards and make better accommodation available ...

Wellington becomes first to introduce voluntary warrant of fitness for rental properties.

Hutt hostage situation

Emergency services at the cordon on Kings Crescent, near High St, Lower Hutt.

Police confirm hostage standoff at a cordoned off Lower Hutt house.

Torrential rain, gales

MetService has warned northerlies could get to 130kmh in exposed areas of Wellington, Marlborough and the Canterbury ...

Gales hit central NZ while heavy rain is falling across parts of the South Island - and there's more to come.

Brothel building for sale

Il-Bordello is on Vivian St.

"More bang for your buck" for this brothel building.

Canterbury

Wooden stadium for Chch?

NZ First party leader Winston Peters wants Christchurch's new stadium to be built out of wood.

Winston Peters wants the Government to make a major injection into stadium - but only if it's built from wood.

'Pushed to the edge' video

Hennie Murray and his friends narrowly missing being hit by an avalanche while driving along the Mt Hutt access road on ...

Hennie Murray was among the thousands leaving Mt Hutt skifield when "everything turned white".

Free parking in Christchurch?

An artist's impression of the Lichfield St car parking building, due for completion in October.

Idea to offer free parking at new parking building may be put before councillors for a vote.

Chilly weekend ahead

July snow just east of Lake Tekapo

Winter has more in store for Canterbury before the expected milder spring weather arrives.

Waikato

Mum dies in Cook Islands

The Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Trade is aware of the death of a New Zealander in the Cook Islands.

Much-loved Waikato wife and mother Michelle Robertson died in Rarotonga, aged 37.

Nationwide hunt for gunman video

Police are looking to locate Rollie James Heke, 36. He is believed to be armed and dangerous and should not be approached.

The search for "unpredictable" Rollie James Heke has been elevated to a national level.

Ghost school to be bulldozed

The Ministry of Education says some of the buildings had asbestos.

Buildings at the Hamilton school have sat vacant for 13 years.

Iwi stalls bottling

An application to take 6.9m litres per day from the Blue Spring near Putaruru is on hold.

Raukawa's concerns put an application to bottle billions of litres from Putaruru's Blue Springs for export on hold.

Taranaki

Kiwi rose living the dream

New Zealand and Taranaki Rose of Tralee Niamh O'Sullivan said the Rose of Tralee festival has been a surreal experience.

New Zealand's Rose of Tralee Niamh O'Sullivan is taking on the world in Ireland.

Arts Festival begins

The Taranaki Arts Festival Trust's Cleo Wood and Suzanne Porter have been busy working on the Festival's final touches.

It really does sound like one of the best jobs...where we do we sign up?

Kids hailed for rescue video

Sarah and Charlie Strand and Frikkie du Preez from Hawera Intermediate School are being hailed as heroes.

Their own racing hearts didn't stop three intermediate students from helping an elderly woman in distress.

A very sick winter

Admissions to hospital for influenza hit a record high at Taranaki Base Hospital in July.

Getting sick in Taranaki has never been easier thanks to this year's influenza strain.

Manawatu

Weaving cultural ties

Tanemahuta Gray in his Feilding home.

Tanemahuta Gray is a choreographer and director who now calls Feilding home.

The political outsider

Adrienne Pierce is aiming to take Palmerston North for National at the election.

A newbie to the Manawatu political scene has an uphill battle to turn Palmerston North blue for National.

Free ink draws crowds video

Jamee Mitchell's new tattoo.

An offer of free tattoos drew a line of keen punters staunchly queuing in winter downpours.

Sudden death shocks

Ambulance staff alerted police to the woman's death on Wednesday morning.

Police are investigating the unexplained death of a woman at a Palmerston North flat.

Nelson

Kids benefit from bike build

Skyla Ruebe, 8 of Motueka with the new bicycle she received from Night & Day franchisees and support staff during a ...

Nine kids from the Nelson region given new bikes.

From the cage to the stage video

Meg Cole, her daughter Ella Dols and their SPCA rescue cat Gypsy, who won numerous prizes at the Nelson Cat Show.

An SPCA "ball of fluff" rescue kitten ended up winning best in show at the Nelson Cat Show.

Ankle defence fails

Nelson Police "inadvertently" kept a man with a fractured ankle at the station, instead of getting him medical attention.

A man who claimed police broke his ankle arresting him for drink driving has failed to get his conviction overturned.

Smoke or steam?

Emissions from South Pine in Annesbrook, Nelson.

Richmond's air pollution has breached national air quality standards four times this year.

Marlborough

Shocked, less than shocked

Jeff Hynes found this pile of rubbish dumped near the Grovetown Lagoon on Friday.

Two very different responses as illegal dumping cases pile up in Marlborough.

Big win for Blenheim

A million-dollar winner, but Powerball not struck.

Blenheim Lotto player strikes it lucky with $1m win.

NZ cyclocross titles at stake

The national cyclocross championships will be held near Blenheim on Saturday. Marlborough riders Antony Clark, left, and ...

 The New Zealand cyclocross championships will be staged in Marlborough for the first time on Saturday.

Teen killed in bridge crash

Marlborough 19-year-old George Holland died in a crash in Wairau Valley.

Man killed in crash between a truck and a ute in Wairau Valley was 19-year-old George Holland.

South Canterbury

Walking for hope

Timaru woman Michelle Cogger has organised a hope walk to raise awareness of suicide prevention.

Timaru mother organises community Hope Walk to create awareness around suicide.

Hospital rebuild plan

South Canterbury District Health Board chief executive Nigel Trainor said it had decided to shift a planned ...

Proposal to redevelop Timaru Hospital moves up a gear with plans afoot to rebuild.

FastPost ... anything but

Veronica Fellows wants to know why it took six days for a birthday card she posted to her to her grandson to arrive.

Timaru woman Veronica Fellows questions why a birthday card took six days to travel 4km by post.

Clamping down on free-for-all

The building on Sophia St was inspected in March this year and found to be unsafe in the event of an earthquake. The ...

Council says people must stop snapping up reserved parks in earthquake-prone building.

Southland

'Chaotic' DHB department

The entrance to Dunedin Hospital.

Some patients have waited up to three years for a follow-up appointment due to dysfunction within a DHB department.

Cow neglect 'appalling'

Castlerock Dairies Limited and the managers who ran two farms were fined $60,000 in total in the Invercargill District ...

At least 193 cows on a Lumsden farm had to be euthanised in "one of the worst examples of long-term neglect".

Film festival growing in Gore

Theatre manager Peter Cairns at Gore's St James Theatre ahead of them hosting the New Zealand International Film ...

The Gore leg of the New Zealand International Film Festival is proving popular with Southland film buffs.

Missing runner found

A runner was missing for three-and-a-half hours in Southland before being tracked down by a search and rescue team on ...

A missing runner was found cold, but safe, after becoming lost with no cellphone battery.

Ad Feedback