Tribunal finds 'provocative' Fairfax cartoons did not breach Human Rights Act

The Al Nisbet cartoon that ran in The Press in May 2013.
Al Nisbet

The Al Nisbet cartoon that ran in The Press in May 2013.

A tribunal has found Fairfax Media did not breach the Human Rights Act in publishing two "provocative" cartoons in its newspapers.

Labour MP Louisa Wall and South Auckland youth group Warriors of Change took the company and The Press and Marlborough Express newspapers to the Human Rights Review Tribunal over cartoons published in 2013. Fairfax Media, which publishes the two newspapers, also owns Stuff.

Cartoonist Al Nisbet produced two cartoons about the Government's breakfast in schools programme. One depicted a group of adults, dressed as children, eating breakfast and saying "Psst . . . If we can get away with this, the more cash left for booze, smokes and pokies". The other showed a family sitting around a table littered with Lotto tickets, alcohol and cigarettes and saying "Free school food is great! Eases our poverty and puts something in you kids' bellies".

The cartoon that ran in The Marlborough Express.

The cartoon that ran in The Marlborough Express.

Wall said the cartoons were "insulting and ignorant put-downs of Maori and Pacific people". She argued they breached section 61 of the Human Rights Act.

* Full decision: Human Rights Review Tribunal
Cartoons 'provocative, negative, insulting'
Editor defends cartoon decision
Cartoons targeted 'bludgers', not race

Section 61 states: the written matter or words must be "threatening, abusive, or insulting" and the second requirement is that the written matter or words must be "likely to excite hostility against or bring into contempt any group of persons" in New Zealand on the ground of the colour, race, or ethnic or national origins of that group. That is, the written matter or words must: [189.1] Be threatening, abusive or insulting; and [189.2] Be likely to excite hostility against or bring into contempt any group of persons on one of the specified grounds. 

Cartoonist Al Nisbet said the cartoons were not racist, and directed at anyone who complained about poverty.

Cartoonist Al Nisbet said the cartoons were not racist, and directed at anyone who complained about poverty.

Wall said she was disappointed by the result and may consider taking the action further.

"I do not agree with that interpretation of section 61 of the Human Rights Act and am particularly concerned at the assertion that an objective assessment of whether the cartoons were likely to bring a group of people into contempt is one that can only be made by a person who is not Maori or Pacific. 

"I will take some time to peruse the decision, to discuss it with the Warriors of Change and the witnesses that gave evidence and to determine whether it is a matter that should be looked at by a higher Court."

The tribunal's ruling, released on Friday, found the cartoons may have "offended, insulted or even angered", they were "not likely to excite hostility against or bring into contempt any group of persons in New Zealand on the ground of their colour, race, or ethnic or national origins".

Ad Feedback

For that reason their publication was not unlawful.

"In a free and democratic society it is essential that the "space" within which issues (including race) can be raised and debated must be kept as broad as possible," the ruling found.

At the tribunal hearing in 2014, Wall argued for a lower threshold in interpreting s61 of the Human Rights Act, allowing consideration for "subjective offence". She initially lodged a complaint with the Human Rights Commission, which found no breach and took no action.

The tribunal agreed. "Our holding is that parliament has framed the s61 racial disharmony provision in appropriately narrow terms," its decision said. "It would be wrong to characterise this decision as a ruling that there is a "right to insult". There is no such right."

Attacks on the functioning of democratic institutions and the free communication of information and ideas highlighted the need for a vigilant free press, the tribunal found, permitted to offend, shock or disturb on occasion.

"It is important the press continue to speak truth to power.

"It should also be remembered that in the aftermath of the murder of twelve persons (including cartoonists) in the attack on the Paris offices of the magazine Charlie Hebdo on 7 January 2015 it was appropriately observed by Salman Rushdie that the art of satire has always been a force for liberty and against tyranny, dishonesty and stupidity."

The Press editor-in-chief Joanna Norris welcomed the tribunal's "strong" decision.

"[It] squarely rejects the misguided notion that publication of material offensive to some should be unlawful, finding in favour of freedom of expression.

"Freedom of expression underpins a free and fair democratic society. If New Zealanders are not free to express views, even those that offend, outrage or upset some people, all human rights are threatened."

She pointed to the tribunal's finding that the cartoons were "unquestionably about a subject of public interest".

"The cartoons published by the Marlborough Express and The Press provided a controversial viewpoint on the efficacy of the Food in Schools programme. The fact that children are going to school hungry is a challenging issue with a great many causes and deserves thorough discussion through a variety of viewpoints. To attempt to suppress a view on this matter because it is offensive to some people is deeply troubling and a failure to properly confront the real issues."

 - Stuff

Ad Feedback
special offers

'All four engines have failed'

The Boeing 747, called "The City of Edinburgh", the day after its terrifying flight.

A jumbo jet carrying Kiwis plunges from the sky in the pitch black near Indonesia.

A day in the life of Westside actor Shane Cortese

Shane Cortese, aged 17, second from left, in his room at the Majestic Hotel, with friends Shane Christensen, left, ...

Each week, we ask a famous Kiwi to share a photo memory.

Trapped and injured after crash

The fire service are working to extricate a person trapped in their car after a crash in west Auckland.

A person is trapped with serious injuries after an Auckland car crash.

Auckland's combustible buildings video

Auckland Council's general manager of building control, Ian McCormick, said staff have manually checked for buildings ...

Anger among residents of Auckland apartment high-rise identified as having Grenfell Tower combustible cladding.


Bars to share info on patrons

0307 2005 NEWS.
Party goers queue to get into the nightspots in Courtenay Place after the All Blacks vs Irish and ...

Go Pro footage and bouncer intel will be used to get Wellington's bar-goers to behave.

Barred from rest home

A Hastings woman has been trespassed from her mother's rest home. (file photo)

Woman says she's been deprived of time with her mum, which she can never get back.

Garner: It was Winston's week

There's only winner this week – the smiling travelling salesman, Winston Peters, writes Duncan Garner.

OPINION: NZ First leader beaming as National and Labour have weeks they'd rather forget.

Hammer attack in Hawke's Bay

Despite taking hit after hit from a robber's hammer, a scrap metal yard employee prevented the offender from getting a cent.

Scrap yard employee left bloody and bruised but sent thief packing, empty-handed.


Movie creates Pecking Order video

Brian Glassey, Pecking Order star and national show competitor, with one of the roosters he's entering in the National ...

Visitors to premiere poultry show in Chch more interested in film stars than feathered entrants.

School shorts 'too cold'

School, generic, uniform, schoolbag, bag, books,

Mum pulls sons from school after it refused to provide warmer clothing options as part of its winter uniform.

Steve Gurney in cycle crash

Steve Gurney posted on social media from his hospital bed after the crash in Queenstown.

Kiwi multisport great Steve Gurney breaks five ribs crashing into a post on a cycle trail.

Accused of Ponzi fraud

Christchurch manager of WorldClaim NZ Guy Sayers has been ordered to surrender his passport.

Quake advocate Guy Sayers allegedly pushed WorldClaim clients to invest in a Ponzi scheme.


Rural docs' passion confirmed video

Australian GP registrar Justin Gladman joined the Royal Flying Doctor Service in early 2017. He is a graduate of ...

Training doctors away from tertiary hospitals is helping boost rural GP numbers across the ditch.

Foreign 'brain drain'

Flinders University professor of paediatrics and child health Kevin Forsyth says New Zealand needs to do more to curb ...

New Zealand prides itself on playing fair. But its use of overseas doctors is causing angst offshore.

Kiwi students back Aussie model

Mekha John is a third year medical student at Flinders University in South Australia.

Kiwi med students say an Australian model of training would work well in New Zealand.

Razor-laced balls at dog park

Heather Gowans often throws a tennis ball for her dog at Day's Park and is horrified Peppa could have bitten into one of ...

Tennis balls containing razor blades have been found in popular Hamilton dog park.


Word to your mother

21062017 News Photo ANDY JACKSON/Fairfax NZ.   Brittany Bourgoise runs her own nail technician business from home.  Kids ...

Brittany Bourgoise is a mumpreneur and reckons other mothers can become one too.

Activist joins council

Environmental activist Emily Bailey has been appointed as an iwi representative to the regional council policy and ...

Former Urewera raids activist looking forward to being part of making decisions on regional council

Marae dream over

The initial design of the Ngamotu Marae, which was to be located on Ocean View Pde site, was to cost $4.5 million and ...

Theft linked to scrapping of $4.5 million New Plymouth marae proposal.

A man and his kereru

Kereru like to flock but are usually only seen in ones and twos.

OPINION: Sometimes you get what you want and it just isn't enough.


No more limits

Cameron Holland, 20, had a brain injury after a car crash when he was 11.

A double blow robbed him of his father and gave him a serious brain injury.

Twisted web of lies

Nakita Sue will serve six months' home detention.

Woman stole man's life savings with sob stories and threats to post nude pics.

House fire shocks resident

Fire risk management officer Andrew Cotter examines a kitchen after a house fire.

Seeing flames tear through his home was the last thing a man from Bulls expected.

Kiwi seriously injured in London

Manawatu man Joel Perry is recovering in hospital after an assault and mugging while on his way home in London.

A vicious attack on a New Zealand tourist has left him in hospital and struggling to get home.


Doughnuts selling like hot cakes

Josiah Smits of the Smoking Barrel Cafe and Restaurant with some of his famous donuts at his High St, Motueka business.

A Motueka cafe is struggling to meet demand for its syringe-injected gourmet doughnuts.

Retirees for Richmond

Andrew Spittal says the aim is to develop about 550 to 650 sections on the site.

A $130m retirement village is tipped as part of a proposed $350m development in Richmond, near Nelson.

Greens target Nelson

Nick Smith has held the Nelson seat for 21 years.

The Green Party is campaigning to break Nick Smith's 21-year grip on Nelson.

Meet the Kiwi helping Oracle

Boat Build Manager Tim Smyth with the saw blade used by the giant CNC Milling machine  used on America's Cup yacht Oracle.

If Oracle turn it round to beat Team NZ, it will be thanks in part to a boat builder from Nelson.


Warehouse dumps faulty sheets

Packs of flannelette sheets slashed and dumped in a skip outside The Warehouse Blenheim.

Well, it's not like there's a charity called Sheets 'n Things right beside them. Oh wait ...

Landlords want change

Tasha and Jamie McCracken want landlords to have more rights to evict tenants if a positive meth test suggests they are ...

Meth damage no different to "someone picking up a sledge hammer, walking onto your property and swinging it around".

Falcons face Timaru

MBC First IV rugby team the Falcons.

The Marlborough Boys' College First XV take on Timaru Boys' High at noon today.

Dancing in Vanuatu

Blenheim Momentum Dance Company owner Jessica Foley-Taylor, at rear, is going to Vanuatu on a dance charity mission. ...

Dance teacher swaps studio for Pacific Island village as she heads off on dance mission.

South Canterbury

Marking Matariki in Waimate video

Waimate Main School kapa haka group members are, from left, Summer Pay, 8, Maddison Longman, 8, and Ashley Guy, 7.

Attendee numbers have grown, and performances have improved, since Matariki celebrations began in Waimate six years ago.

RSA restructure looms

South Canterbury Returned and Services' Association president Greg O'Brien.

Restructure looms as South Canterbury RSA tries to improve its financial situation.

Clone sought for vet practice video

Stepping back after 40 years at the Veterinary Centre Waimate is vet Dougall McLachlan.

Dougall McLachlan's colleagues want his last pair of work gumboots to last a very long time.

$1.1m for new lights

Netcon chief executive Steve McCoy with an LED light of the type his company has already installed in Temuka. The Timaru ...

Work to replace Timaru's street lights can start next month thanks to boost.


Young performers face the music

Monique Clementson (Deloris), Annie Sherborne, and Rachael Scott (Sister Mary Patrick) at rehearsals for the ...

Young performers are gaining exposure and touring the country for Sister Act the musical.

Arrested after threats

08072016 Newsphoto. SIMON MAUDE / FAIRFAX NZ. Generic, stock, NZ Police, police car, The po po, police. 08-N-policeC

A 54-year-old man was arrested after threatening Work and Income staff.

Father 'evil', grief-stricken mum says

Police staff at the Riverton home where three-month-old Honour Ashworth was injured.

Grieving Southland mother says her soul was "ripped to pieces" when she found out her partner caused her infant son's death.

Green Party takes off

Green Party of Aotearoa New Zealand Invercargill candidate Rochelle Surendran speaks at a Green Party Launch in Invercargill.

Green Party co-leader comments on Clutha-Southland MP resignation during Invercargill visit.

Ad Feedback