City council under fire for dog-killing method

The council has changed its killing methods, from shooting dogs, to a lethal injection, to firing a pin into their brains.
File photo

The council has changed its killing methods, from shooting dogs, to a lethal injection, to firing a pin into their brains.

The Invercargill City Council's method of killing dangerous dogs has been described as "archaic" and has come under fire from the New Zealand Institute of Animal Management.

The city council has changed its killing methods over the years, from shooting dogs earmarked for euthanasia, to taking them to the vet for a lethal injection, to firing a pin into their brains with a "humane gun", commonly known as a captive bolt.

The council's environmental and compliance manager John Youngson said they stopped shooting dogs that were considered dangerous about two years ago and instead used vets to administer lethal injections.

However, Youngson said it was stressful for the dogs to go to the vet, as well as being time-consuming for animal control staff.

So about six months ago the council voted to kill unwanted dogs with a captive bolt which fired a pin into their brains, he said.

The council changed to using the captive bolt because it was more humane, he said.

Southland SPCA chair Rachel Hucklebridge.
Kavinda Herath

Southland SPCA chair Rachel Hucklebridge.

The dogs were put into a restraint before being killed.

The dogs killed in this manner had died instantly, but a backup plan was in place in the event it didn't work as planned. 

"It's worked out cheaper but it wasn't based on price," he said of the new method of killing the animals.

"The only reason it's cheaper is we are putting down less animals."

Ad Feedback

The council's new killing method for dangerous dogs has been criticised by the New Zealand Institute of Animal Management, which consists of practising animal control officers around the country.

The institute's national president, Les Dalton, was not impressed the city council was using a captive bolt to kill dogs.

Most councils in the country used lethal injection to kill dogs and less than a handful of councils used a captive bolt, he said.

"It's archaic in this day. That's the view of the institute."

The lethal injection was "far more humane" than the captive bolt because the captive bolt had more room for operator error, he said.

It could also be "psychologically horrible" for the operator if they got it wrong when using the captive bolt.

Even when they got it right, the captive bolt method was messy, with blood coming from the dog's nose and brain matter often coming out of the hole shot into the animal's head, he said.

It was "very unusual" for a council to go back to the captive bolt after using the lethal injection.

"I have got my views and I think the lethal injection is far more accurate and less stressful for the operator, Dalton said.

He planned to ring the city council to discuss the issue.

Shooting a dog in any form was not a good look in terms of public perception, he added.

"It goes down like a lead balloon."

SPCA Southland chairwoman Rachel Hucklebridge said the captive bolt was classified as a humane way of killing the dogs.

"The concern I have is the psychological effect on the person that has to do it." 

Cr Rebecca Amundsen, chair of the city council's regulatory services committee which deals with the animal control issues, said councillors chose to euthanise dogs with the captive bolt instead of lethal injection because it was more humane, and the SPCA had supported it.

When told Dalton's views, she said "that's not the impression we were given when the report came to council".

"We were told it was instant and a much better way of doing it."

People would be concerned no matter what method the council used to kill dogs, she said.

 - The Southland Times

Comments

Ad Feedback
special offers
Auckland

A Life Story - Virginia Burns

Virginia Burns organised events for the LGBT community for more than a decade.

Virginia Burns helped create big, sparkly, sequinned events in the LGBT community.

Sailors happily welcomed home

Takapuna native Sub Lieutenant Michael Linehan, 22, and his parents Mark and Jean Linehan.

Balloons, flowers and hand-made signs welcomed home the Navy after six months away.

Meat-free chicken on the shelves

Would you eat a steak grown in a lab?

At least one leading chef agrees a new product made from peas does taste like chicken - as promised.

Shooter practised on vests

Neighbours described Quinn Patterson as a loner who liked to fire off guns "on a daily basis".

Man who killed a mother and daughter test fired his guns against bulletproof vests, friend says.

Wellington

Fake signs for new expressway video

28072017 ROBERT KITCHIN/STUFF
L-R: 
Protestor Nick Fisher (in yellow jacket) from the Expressway noise action group ...

Sleep-deprived locals fight back against the trucks rumbling past their bedroom windows.

Cafe family's plea fails

Java Point Cafe owner Steve Jensen has lost faith in the system after his family's residency application was rejected ...

Associate immigration minister rejects US family's last-ditch bid to stay in NZ.

Aggravated robbery in Hastings

Police are investigating an aggravated robbery in Heretaunga St, Hastings.

Weapon used, but no-one injured as a Hastings store is robbed of cash.

Vege garden in the city centre

27072017 ROBERT KITCHIN/STUFF
L-R: 
Wellington City Council horticulture team leader Phillipa Garratt amongst  ...

Brightly coloured silverbeet sprouts among the traffic along Lambton Quay.

Canterbury

Canterbury's best houses

The Canterbury House of the Year new home supreme winner was this home in Mt Pleasant built by John Creighton Builder Ltd.

Take a look inside Canterbury's award winning homes.

Land status queried

11122015 News photo: Supplied/Colliers. The 40,000 hectare Mt White Station is for sale for the first time in nearly 100 ...

Century-old error that put land earmarked for national park into pastoral lease is now being investigated.

Warning over icy roads

Canterbury roads could be treacherous this weekend as chilly overnight temperatures create the risk of widespread black ice.

Everything is stacking up for a potentially catastrophic weekend on frosty South Island roads, Canterbury police say.

Canty man dies in Bali

Tourists fly into Bali to land at Ngurah Rai International Airport.

A Kiwi who died on holiday in Bali was a well-liked truck driver working in Australia.

Waikato

Ferrari clocked at 210kmh

A Ferrari California T similar to the one Hui Zhang was driving when he was pulled over after speeding at 210kmh on the ...

Businessman roared on when cop spotted late model Ferrari California on expressway.

Ambos turned away

Waikato Hospital's emergency department has been stretched to its limits this winter (file photo).

Packed medical clinics are sending ambulances on to Waikato Hospital's ED.

Shot Kiwi's legal woes

Simon Rawlinson's Hamilton house

Concerned friends told the Kiwi who was shot dead in the Philippines to come home.

Pilot jumped before passengers

Chief executive Roy Clements says the Skydive Taupo pilot believed the crashing plane was empty when he jumped out.

Taupo pilot criticised for leaving two passengers on his crashing skydiving plane as he jumped out in mid-air.

Taranaki

Foodbank confessional

New Plymouth District councillor Mike Merrick managed the New Plymouth Foodbank for five  years.

Former Foodbank says don't judge Metiria Turei "until you have lived it, seen it, witnessed it".

Track warning

DOC warn tracks on Mt Taranaki will be icy underfoot after a southerly storm passes through

If you are heading up Mt Taranaki expect slow progress with heavy snow and icy tracks.

Asbestos removal continues

Ambulances at the ready at their Barrett Street Hospital base in New Plymouth circa 1981.

The demolition work at Barrett St Hospital has no set end date and will "cost us just over a million dollars".

Looker's visa approved

New Plymouth woman Abbey Looker, pictured with her father, Grant, has been allowed back into the UK after a visa botch-up.

A NZ woman has had her UK work visa finally approved after a two-month delay and a 10 year travel ban threat.

Manawatu

Blind as a baby, driving at 25 video

Tommy Roberts was told he would never drive. But hi-tech glasses have enabled him to get his driver's licence.

Tommy Roberts put on his bioptic glasses and aced the driver's licence test he was told he couldn't go for.

Council battles go on

Horowhenua mayor Michael Feyen is butting heads, once again, with chief executive David Clapperton.

Horowhenua District Council has had a mountain of issues since last year's election.

In the dark

I drive the main road.

Candle-light suppers the order of the night in Feilding during power outage.

Labour promises fast fix to gorge

Labour Party leader Andrew Little is promising a new road to replace the Manawatu Gorge route that is likely to run ...

Labour plan to build an alternative route near Manawatu Gorge as fast as possible.

Nelson

Marty Banks: I'll be back

Marty Banks' Highlanders career came to an end in last weekend's quarterfinal loss to the Crusaders.

Makos legend hopes to notch 50 caps with the Makos after fulfilling his Italian commitments.

Fatal crash in Appleby video

A man has died after crashing into a tree on the Coastal Highway.

A 32-year-old man has died after a serious crash near Nelson on Friday morning.

Nelson's 75-year-old Masters grad

Bruce Dyer, 75, has graduated from Auckland University of Technology with a Masters in Philosophy.

Bruce Dyer hopes his Masters degree will benefit the region.

Cafe plans for historic building

The new owners of the former Greengrocer Store in The Wood will keep its facade and hope to put in a cafe.

After 20 years as a greengrocer, a heritage building in The Wood could become a cafe.

Marlborough

'Our niche is Marlborough'

Dog Point Vineyard co-owners and event sponsors Ivan Sutherland, left, and James Healy read up for the Marlborough Book ...

With intimate venues and stunning surrounds, the Marlborough Book Festival is a little different.

Power to the people

Marlborough Lines managing director Ken Forrest shows off the newest addition to the company fleet, an all-electric ...

A lines company is letting residents take a spin in its new electric car.

Bigger planes?

Sounds Air chief executive Andrew Crawford inside the cockpit of one of the company's 9-seat Pilatus PC-12s.

Demand for flights prompts Marlborough airline to investigate "quantum leap" to larger planes.

Blenheim bemoans unfair fares

Air New Zealand said it would not be reinstating direct flights to Christchurch from Marlborough Airport.

"It's almost like we've offended Air New Zealand somehow and they're making us pay." 

South Canterbury

No support for tourist tax

Prime Minister Bill English at Roncalli College, in South Canterbury.

Mayor tells PM tourism is creating strain on district he doesn't want ratepayers to pay for.

Truck driver airlifted

SH1 is closed near Makikihi after a truck rolled at the intersection of Kingsbury Rd.

A 22-wheeler truck has rolled seriously injuring the driver and closing SH1 near Makikihi.

Troops stage op in Waimate

Private  Nathan Hammond keeps a watchful eye out at a vehicle checkpoint in Waimate.

Waimate has been turned into a foreign nation infiltrated by insurgents- but only for a week.

Disease hits top farm

Aad and Wilma van Leeuwen's herd has been struck by the cow disease Mycoplasma bovis, and 150 of their cattle will have ...

Rich-list farming dynasty which owns world's "largest robotic farm" devastated by cow disease.

Southland

Fire guts former mayor's house

Firemen at the scene of the gutted house, which was owned by former mayor Eve Poole, on Friday morning.

Flames engulfed the late Eve Poole's Invercargill home while its occupants welcomed baby.

Mass killing fantasies

Southland man Tony Gow has been sentenced in the High Court at Invercargill after admitting a raft of firearms offences, ...

A Southland man who fantasised about mass killings could not get the mental health help he needed, court told.

World champs beckon

New Zealand discus thrower Marshall Hall practices ahead of the 2017 IAAF World Championships.

Invercargill discus thrower 'committed and focused' ahead of world championships.

Ice causing crashes

10082016. News.Kavinda Herath. Southland Times/Stuff-Ice on the Winton Lorneville Highway

Police are warning drivers to take it slow and beware of ice on the roads.

Ad Feedback