City council under fire for dog-killing method

The council has changed its killing methods, from shooting dogs, to a lethal injection, to firing a pin into their brains.
File photo

The council has changed its killing methods, from shooting dogs, to a lethal injection, to firing a pin into their brains.

The Invercargill City Council's method of killing dangerous dogs has been described as "archaic" and has come under fire from the New Zealand Institute of Animal Management.

The city council has changed its killing methods over the years, from shooting dogs earmarked for euthanasia, to taking them to the vet for a lethal injection, to firing a pin into their brains with a "humane gun", commonly known as a captive bolt.

The council's environmental and compliance manager John Youngson said they stopped shooting dogs that were considered dangerous about two years ago and instead used vets to administer lethal injections.

However, Youngson said it was stressful for the dogs to go to the vet, as well as being time-consuming for animal control staff.

So about six months ago the council voted to kill unwanted dogs with a captive bolt which fired a pin into their brains, he said.

The council changed to using the captive bolt because it was more humane, he said.

Southland SPCA chair Rachel Hucklebridge.
Kavinda Herath

Southland SPCA chair Rachel Hucklebridge.

The dogs were put into a restraint before being killed.

The dogs killed in this manner had died instantly, but a backup plan was in place in the event it didn't work as planned. 

"It's worked out cheaper but it wasn't based on price," he said of the new method of killing the animals.

"The only reason it's cheaper is we are putting down less animals."

Ad Feedback

The council's new killing method for dangerous dogs has been criticised by the New Zealand Institute of Animal Management, which consists of practising animal control officers around the country.

The institute's national president, Les Dalton, was not impressed the city council was using a captive bolt to kill dogs.

Most councils in the country used lethal injection to kill dogs and less than a handful of councils used a captive bolt, he said.

"It's archaic in this day. That's the view of the institute."

The lethal injection was "far more humane" than the captive bolt because the captive bolt had more room for operator error, he said.

It could also be "psychologically horrible" for the operator if they got it wrong when using the captive bolt.

Even when they got it right, the captive bolt method was messy, with blood coming from the dog's nose and brain matter often coming out of the hole shot into the animal's head, he said.

It was "very unusual" for a council to go back to the captive bolt after using the lethal injection.

"I have got my views and I think the lethal injection is far more accurate and less stressful for the operator, Dalton said.

He planned to ring the city council to discuss the issue.

Shooting a dog in any form was not a good look in terms of public perception, he added.

"It goes down like a lead balloon."

SPCA Southland chairwoman Rachel Hucklebridge said the captive bolt was classified as a humane way of killing the dogs.

"The concern I have is the psychological effect on the person that has to do it." 

Cr Rebecca Amundsen, chair of the city council's regulatory services committee which deals with the animal control issues, said councillors chose to euthanise dogs with the captive bolt instead of lethal injection because it was more humane, and the SPCA had supported it.

When told Dalton's views, she said "that's not the impression we were given when the report came to council".

"We were told it was instant and a much better way of doing it."

People would be concerned no matter what method the council used to kill dogs, she said.

 - The Southland Times

Comments

Ad Feedback
special offers
Auckland

No happy ending for toy story

Albany House has had a theft from the neighbouring hub construction site and also the toys this year.

It's been a merry-go-round for a community organisation trying to get their stolen toys back.

Addressing the isolation of heart related illnesses

Paul Newman pictured here with his wife Donna shares his  journey from debilitating illness to recovery following a ...

On line storytelling hub provides emotional relief for those living with heart disease.

Kerikeri nursery reopens after myrtle rust findings

Kerikeri nurseryman Tom Lindesay is glad to be back open for business after one month in lockdown following myrtle rust ...

It's been a tough month for Kerikeri Plant Production after myrtle rust was found there - but they've finally been allowed to reopen.

Mud pies from mud kitchens video

Ella Verryt, 5, enjoying Swanson Playcentre's Mud Kitchen.

An Auckland couple are putting mud pies on the menu at kindergartens across the country.

Wellington

Every beat a new life

Four-year-old Ashley Hamilton doesn't let the hole in her heart stop her from enjoying life. She recently starred in a ...

Four-year-old Ashley loves to try new things including acting and doesn't let a hole in her heart stop her

Investigation widens

Former MoT manager Joanne Harrison had a stint at Corrections - before she was jailed.

Another public agency has had to investigate after hiring fraudster Joanne Harrison.

Crash after police chase

Emergency services are at the scene of a car that hit a powerpole near the intersection of Hereford St and Champion St ...

 A police chase has ended with police and a fleeing car hitting lamp posts.

More plans for Eva St

Student housing in the Eva and Leeds Street Laneway could be refurbished for another restaurant to be added to the urban hub.

Wellington's hipster laneway could see more development in two buildings that house students.

Canterbury

Security guard buries $130k

Security guard Tony John Williams, 37, stole $179,300 from an ATM machine and buried most in his garden.

Tony Williams raided the ATM he was meant to guard, burying most of the cash in his garden.

Flight 'spitter' charged

Kiri Marsh outside the Christchurch District Court after she was charged with assault.

Kiri Marsh, 32, allegedly spat at flight attendant and yelled for plane to ''go faster''.

Thick fog hid crash scene video

A member of public came across the crash about two hours after the car hit a tree on Tuesday morning.

Locals heard the crash, but could not find the wreckage. Two hours later, a young man was found dead.

Belief in dog wins it a home

Holden wrapped in a blanket in his first night at home with Carole Worley

All he wanted to do was be with people, but people did not want him.

Waikato

Bomb claims Kiwi's pen pal video

A tryptic of Skye's best friend, Georgina Callander, including the centre shot of Georgina posing with American popstar ...

Best friends spoke that morning but Manchester explosion left 'horrible gut feeling'.

Couple $27m richer

The winning lotto was brought from Thames Four Square owned by Sukhpal Singh.

A Thames couple have come forward with the golden Lotto ticket.

Taking on the ski season

The Mount Ruapehu 2017 season kicks off on June 3.

Fun kicks off on Mt Ruapehu this weekend and new staff are raring to go.

Bye Tinder, hello speed dating

There's promise in speed dating, Tomek Pietkiewicz says.

After failing on Tinder, one Hamilton man thinks he has the answer for singles in the city.

Taranaki

Euthanasia in NZ liable to abuse

Professor Jan Berheim is a Belgian medical expert and euthanasia advocate. He was invited to New Zealand by the ...

A law change would protect caregivers from undue prosecution.

Nutrition key to fitness

Haney Kahu has made the transition from prop to triathlete through hard work and attention to his diet.

Former prop says age not a barrier to fitness.

Hall to turn 100, present planned

The Whareroa Social Hall of 1918, better known as the Ramanui School Hall today.

A hall that is turning 100 has been moved and had a 'bit of a whack up' in the past, will hopefully be renovated again.

Big Jims to reopen

Taranaki plant nursery Big Jim's has been cleared to reopen, two weeks after after myrtle rust was detected on plants.

Positive myrtle rust findings grow as nurseries reopen

Manawatu

Balancing act for A+ grades

Farming is in the blood for Sam Pike.

Growing up on a Rangitikei farm Sam Pike always knew an agricultural career was in the blood.  

Event fund established

Major events such as the New Zealand PGA golf championship held at the Manawatu Golf Club will be eligible for a share ...

Ratepayers district-wide will contribute to a proposed $100,000 fund for "major events". 

Flytipping a $52,000 headache

The Manawatu District Council is cracking down on illegal fly-tipping.

More than 140 reports of wrongful dumping recorded this year in Manawatu and Rangtikei.

'Slasher-like' weapon

Footage from the robbery of a Liquorland store in Palmerston North.

Police release CCTV showing robbers, who hit a shop attendant.

Nelson

Iwi challenges water bottling

Te Waikoropupu Springs is considered sacred to local iwi.

A plan to bottle thousands of cubic metres of water from a Tasman spring has been dealt a blow after a local iwi appeal.

Nelson still top

Housing construction has helped fuel Nelson's run at the top of an economic scoreboard.

Nelson stays New Zealand's top-performing region in an economic scoreboard.

Poverty hitting region's youngest

Kay Guyton runs Angel in My Street and works to support Stoke families and children in poverty.

The 2016 Technical Report on Child Poverty found more than 1400 children in Nelson and Tasman were living below the poverty line. 

Talley's fighting consent terms

Talley's has applied for a 35-year term for a bundle of permits it seeks.

Talley's is challenging some of the proposed conditions to its continued discharge from its Motueka site.

Marlborough

Paradise found in Pelorus

Debra and Michael Brennan moved to Pelorus after seeking an alternative to city life.

Exhausted by city life, Debra and Michael Brennan sought a change... and boy did they find it.

Beer burglar jailed

Walter Narayan was told about the outdoor fridge as a place where he could get beer, his lawyer said. (File photo)

He went back to the well one too many times. The well being someone else's outdoor fridge.

Praise the paua pearl video

Pearl inserts are used to grow the stones.

Paua farmers on the edge of the Marlborough Sounds say their love of the marine mollusc borders on worship.

Meth accused back in court

Four men facing meth-dealing charges are back at the Blenheim District Court.

Four men were charged after police raided six properties earlier this month.

South Canterbury

Brekkie for a good cause

Pink Ribbon Breakfast at the Arowhenua Marae in Temuka. Pictured are Wendy Moore (left) and Shirley McPherson (right).

The Arowhenua Marae was transformed into a sea of pink to support a good cause.

Rubbish fire suspicious

A fire at the back of the Sanford factory is being treated as suspicious

 A fire near Timaru's port is being treated as suspicious

Seeking right woman for the job

The rights say one actor must be white, one must be black and the third must be Asian

Timaru show could be abandoned unless actor found for very specific role.

Protection help sought

Urban designer Nigel Gilkison made a submission on behalf of the Timaru Civic Trust. The trust bought the 1871 Landing ...

"The onus is put on the owners... essentially they get no compensation for having to do that."

Southland

Bluff oyster numbers decline

Bluff Oyster Festival Chairman John Edminstin in front of the crowd at the Bluff Oyster Festival.

The results of a recent NIWA survey has shown replenishment rates in the Foveaux strait Oyster fishery have lowered since 2012.

Aurora on show

Te Anau resident Chris Watson captured this stunning panorama from the Ivon Wilson Park on the outskirts of the town.

Photographers were out in force on Sunday capturing the dazzling Southern Lights.

Barclay supporting centre

Lumsden Maternity's contract with the Southern District Health Board expires on July 31.

Clutha-Southland MP Todd Barclay says he will not let the Lumsden Maternity Centre close.

Sea lions could scupper fishery

A juvenile sea lion in Port Pegasus in January 2016. In New Zealand sea lions are ranked as "nationally critical" on the ...

Would a new aquaculture project on Stewart Island affect the sea lion colony?

Ad Feedback