Mental health advocates support Mike King's stance on suicide prevention

Kevin Stent/Fairfax NZ

Prime Minister Bill English gives his view on Mike King quitting suicide panel.

The chief executive of the Mental Health Foundation says he supports Mike King's criticism of the Government-led suicide prevention strategy.

The comedian and mental health advocate resigned from New Zealand's suicide prevention panel, saying the Government's draft plan was "deeply flawed". 

But it's not just the Government's plan, the Ministry of Health has pointed out. It's a framework for how New Zealanders can work together to reduce suicide, and Kiwis are encouraged to take part in the public consultation process. 

Mike King resigned from a suicide prevention panel, saying the Government's draft plan is "deeply flawed".
GRANT MATTHEW/Fairfax NZ

Mike King resigned from a suicide prevention panel, saying the Government's draft plan is "deeply flawed".

King said the decision to resign was nothing personal.

READ MORE:
* Prevention strategy 'the responsibility of all of us'
Kiwis feel abandoned by mental health system - Mike King 
Mike King's anti-suicide crusade

What's the best approach to prevention strategies? 

Shaun Robinson, chief executive of the Mental Health Foundation.
SUPPLIED

Shaun Robinson, chief executive of the Mental Health Foundation.

Mental Health Foundation chief executive Shaun Robinson said the Government's 38-page strategy document failed to set specific targets and he agreed with many aspects of King's criticism.

"By resigning he's definitely calling public attention to the issue. I understand his frustration. He's prepared to draw attention to the issue of suicide prevention and make it a public issue.

"The number one thing about the draft strategy is it has no concrete targets.

Dr Kerry Gibson said change was needed in the approach to prevention.
Supplied

Dr Kerry Gibson said change was needed in the approach to prevention.

"So it makes statements about wanting to reduce the number of deaths: that's a wishy-washy non-specific target."

Ad Feedback

Robinson said a World Health Organisation target aimed to reduce suicide by 20 per cent over 10 years, and this kind of target could be applied in New Zealand.

"I see no reason at all why New Zealand shouldn't do that."

The strategy's language did not help understanding, it did not help people in distress, and it did not help people at risk, he said.

What's needed then?

Robinson said commitment to targets, better and earlier access to mental health services, more education around mental health in schools and among the adult population, all helped to improve knowledge and mental health literacy.

Nationwide director of mental health services Dr John Crawshaw.
SUPPLIED

Nationwide director of mental health services Dr John Crawshaw.

Redoubling efforts to tackle underlying ills, such as child poverty, domestic violence, neglect, homelessness, and bullying, was needed.

"This is not just a Ministry of Health problem," he said.

Prime Minister Bill English, on Monday, said people "go on panels with the best of intentions" and he was not sure what exactly had happened.

"I'm sure he's saved lives with the work that he's done."

Speaking to Stuff, King said he and other members of the panel were under the impression a suicide reduction target of 20 per cent over 10 years was meant to form part of the strategy.

He said he worked well with the Ministry of Health and the panel and there was nothing personal behind his resignation.

"The reason for my disappointment was what we agreed on is not reflected. First and foremost was a reduction of suicide by 20 per cent over 10 years.

"We're not being heard. [The strategy] appears to cover everything by promising nothing."

University of Auckland associate professor and clinical psychologist Dr Kerry Gibson said change was needed in the approach to suicide prevention.

"We need to listen more to the people who are most involved in this issue - people who have had loved ones commit suicide, people who have attempted suicide and also young people whose networks are often affected by suicide.

"I think professionals need to do a lot more listening and finding out what different groups of people say works for them."

Gibson studies youth suicide and research found that despite a focus on media reporting of suicide, it was apparent young people did not get their knowledge and understanding of suicide from mainstream media.

"They get it from conversations with each other - often through social media or text message.

"The restriction on media reporting on suicide means that when a suicide happens at a school, for example, the only people who don't know about it are the adults.  The young people have often been talking about it since the early hours of the morning when the first Facebook messages started coming through.

"We need to recognise that attempt to control the mainstream media's reporting on suicide has only resulted in a gap between the way that professionals and adults discuss suicide and young people talk about it in their own networks.  

"We need to create more two-way conversations on the issue of suicide that include adults and young people and help professionals understand the way that young people think about this issue and what they feel will help them. 

"In general, other countries have tended to have a more open approach to talking about the problem of suicide than New Zealand. 

"I think we could learn from some of these.

"Linking suicide to mental health problems has had pros and cons. It has allowed some people to get access to professional help when they are depressed but young people say they are afraid of being labelled with a mental health diagnosis. This makes them reluctant to approach counsellors or other professionals for help.

"It would be helpful to acknowledge that there are many reasons why a young person might think about suicide and having a mental health problem is only one of them.

"Young people often try and help other young people who are feeling suicidal - and would much rather do this than ask an adult for help.

"Often going to an adult is the very last resort after a group of young friends have tried to look after a suicidal peer for some time.

"It would be good to recognise that young people are already playing an important role in suicide prevention and that they need some support in this."

The suicide prevention research field is vast. 

A wealth of research is available at the click of a button, award-winning e-therapy tools are available in New Zealand, and increasingly mental health is accepted as part of the national conversation.

One systematic review - the gold standard of research involving in-depth analyses of all available research - published in The Lancet said there was mounting evidence that restricting access to lethal means, such as gun control, making it more difficult to obtain certain types of painkiller, and teaching mental health in schools, helped reduce suicide.

But, the review said, no single strategy clearly stands above the others.

WHERE TO GET HELP

*Lifeline (open 24/7) - 0800 543 354
*Depression Helpline (open 24/7) - 0800 111 757
*Healthline (open 24/7) - 0800 611 116
*Samaritans (open 24/7) - 0800 726 666
*Suicide Crisis Helpline (open 24/7) - 0508 828 865 (0508 TAUTOKO). This is a service for people who may be thinking about suicide, or those who are concerned about family or friends.
*Youthline (open 24/7) - 0800 376 633. You can also text 234 for free between 8am and midnight, or email talk@youthline.co.nz
*0800 WHATSUP children's helpline - phone 0800 9428 787 between 1pm and 10pm on weekdays and from 3pm to 10pm on weekends. Online chat is available from 7pm to 10pm every day at www.whatsup.co.nz.
*Kidsline (open 24/7) - 0800 543 754. This service is for children aged 5 to 18. Those who ring between 4pm and 9pm on weekdays will speak to a Kidsline buddy. These are specially trained teenage telephone counsellors.
*Your local Rural Support Trust - 0800 787 254 (0800 RURAL HELP)
​*Alcohol Drug Helpline (open 24/7) - 0800 787 797. You can also text 8691 for free.

For further information, contact the Mental Health Foundation's free Resource and Information Service (09 623 4812).

 - Stuff

Ad Feedback
special offers
Auckland

US Coastguard calls in to NZ video

Petty Officers (Second Class) Chris Parmenter and Mandi Stevens supervise the deployment of a rescue raft from a US ...

A sinking boat fired flares and patients were winched out of choppy waters. Fear not, it was just a drill.

430 bungy jumps in 24 hours video

Mike Heard smashed the previous record, 158, for the most bungy jumps in 24 hours.

Aucklander Mike Heard has set the new Guinness World Record for the most bungy jumps done in 24 hours.

Auckland restaurants ban reviewers

Darish (chef and co-owner) and Barbara (mother and co-owner) who own and operate Cazador on Auckland's Dominion Road.

Popular eatery bites back at weekend review, while another says critics are "not welcome" altogether.

Auckland boat shed selling for $700,000

The boathouses on Ngapipi Rd are well known to Auckland commuters.

It's got no value as a functioning boat shed and you'd have to fight to use it as a home.

Wellington

Street name ruffles feathers

One Lower Hutt resident has argued against his street being named after the karearea. Ben Blackler argued the name would ...

Karearea Lane would be "problematic" and impractical, Lower Hutt resident claims.

Grow up, Wellington

Wellington's housing density could change in suburban areas if the Housing Forum recommendations are adopted.

Housing crisis can be solved by raising height limits in the suburbs, a report says.

Train improvements delayed

A planned upgrade of the Hutt Valley rail line has been put on hold while funding is sought.

Upgrades to capital's commuter trains put on ice while the council searches for $30m.

Capital buses to stop

Commuters are in for headaches as the new operator of Wellington's bus fleets hits an impasse with the drivers' union.

Some commuters are in for headaches as bus drivers hold stopwork meeting.

Canterbury

Robbery victim: 'I felt for him'

Secondhand bookshop worker Carol Bell hugged the man who robbed her at knifepoint.

She could have been angry at the man who robbed her at knifepoint. Instead, she hugged him.

Chch's 'dirty 30'

Harley building on Cambridge Tce is understood to be one of the council's "dirty 30" derelict buildings.

Derelict properties said to be holding up the rebuild could be taken by the Crown.

Flight passenger 'disruptive'

Police were called after reports of a disruptive passenger on an Air New Zealand flight at Christchurch airport. (FILE PHOTO)

Police have been called to deal with a disruptive passenger at Christchurch Airport.

$3000 of plumbing tools stolen

Thieves targeted two Wigram building sites, including this one.

Plumbing firm staff turned up to work on Monday to find the tools gone.

Waikato

Massive moving monsters arrive

Daytona Barker, 7, Eloise Careswell-King, 7, and Kamryn Sewell, 8, learn about life before dinosaurs.

A new Waikato Museum exhibition uncovers life before the dinosaurs.

Docs fear winter rush

Waikato Hospital was over capacity this week.

No guarantee that Waikato Hospital won't again be stretched to overcapacity.

River death verdict: Not guilty

Neville Patrick Harris has been found not guilty of  manslaughter in the High Court in Hamilton.

Did Neville Harris kill Tama Retimana in trying to protect a woman? A jury will now decide.

Manhunt blocks SH1 

Police have placed a cordon on State Highway 30, near Whakamaru, during a manhunt on Wednesday.

Police warn motorists to avoid hitchhikers as they search for a man after a firearms incident.

Taranaki

Frank's shed comes down

Frank Amor's shed was described as an eyesore by one neighbour.

Frank loved his shed. The council did not. After 30 years it is finally gone.

Go on, knock it down

The town could look quite different to what it does today if Dey's plan is followed.

Gavin Dey reckons the answer to saving Stratford is to knock half its shops down.

Soggy sewer overflow

Treated sewage from Hawera is pumped about 2km out to sea off the coast.

A South Taranaki iwi is irked by a council move to dispose of extra treated wastewater through its offshore outfall.

The 1 per cent debate

Councillor Rick Coplestone said it didn't really matter how much rates went up by.

He's a councillor who doesn't care how much rates increase. Say what?

Manawatu

Neighbours from Hell?

Hells Angels has set up base in the Palmerston North suburb of Hokowhitu.

A Hells Angels gang pad has sprung up in an upmarket area of Palmerston North.

Typhoid spreads

Typhoid has spread to Palmerston North.

A teenager in Palmerston North Hospital is confirmed as being infected.

Ex-Black Cap to artist

Ex-Black Cap Chris Martin's painting for a celebrity art auction raising money for disabilities charity Parent to ...

Black Caps' cult hero takes time out from grocery store to paint a work of art.

Museum without walls

Andy Lowe, from Te Manawa, accepts the inaugural Arts Access Museum Award.

Te Manawa wins prestigious award recognising the museum's diversity.

Nelson

Big bill for camping bylaw

02022017 FEATURE PHOTO BRADEN FASTIER /  FAIRFAX NZ
Freedom Campers at the Trafalgar Centre car-park at the end of Paru ...

Enforcing a proposed freedom camping bylaw could cost $100,000 a year.

Thieves ransack bakery

A police officer tapes off the front of the Mapua Village Bakery after the robbery early on Wednesday.

Three men smashed their way into the Mapua Village Bakery and threatened a worker.

Yoga bandit leaves class barefoot

Clients at  Nelson yoga school were forced to leave without their shoes after a thief stole their footwear on Tuesday ...

A Nelson yoga class was left barefoot after a thief stole shoes from a locker area.

Ferry benefits questioned

The terminal for the proposed Whanganui to Motueka ferry would be developed in the Moutere Estuary with open water ...

Proposed ferry between Motueka and Whanganui may deliver jobs, but at what cost?

Marlborough

Don't burst their bubble

Artist Mieke Davies came up with the idea of speech bubbles, to be filled in by young people in Marlborough.

Hundreds of "speech bubbles" in Blenheim alley waiting to be filled with the voices of young people. 

Affordability issues

Marlborough Sustainable Housing Trust chairwoman Bev James, right, in front of the first house the trust completed in ...

Rents are on the rise, and incomes are not keeping pace, leaving more families struggling to get a foot on the ladder.

Purpose-built priority

St Andrews Property Group is developing the former Country Life Motel, south of Blenheim, to house more than 400 ...

Vineyard contractors encouraged out of rental market as Blenheim faces housing shortage.

A new world for libraries

Children's library assistant Emily Fredrickson applies radio tags to books ahead of the new self-service system.

Self-service kiosks like those in supermarkets will soon appear in the libraries of Marlborough.

South Canterbury

Smokefree stir at Caroline Bay

Carnival volunteer Dave Woolstencroft often enjoys a cigarette at Caroline Bay, which health promoters have asked the ...

Carnival volunteer says complete smoking ban reminiscent of a 'police state". 

Enough meth to kill

Ashburton man Arran Gairns drowned with a lethal amount of methamphetamine in his blood.

Arran Gairns had a lethal level of meth in his blood when he died, toxicologist says.

SCDHB to appeal overtime decision

The South Canterbury District Health Board is appealing a ruling that staff should be paid for all of an on call shift, ...

South Canterbury District Health Board takes ruling over pay to the Employment Court.

Art show features national works

Lyttelton artist Martin Cole with Plunket art show committee member Sue Geaney set up Cole's sculptures made of ...

Timaru's 40th Plunket Art Show to feature works of more than 40 New Zealand artists.

Southland

60-minute challenge: Something is brewing

Eye reporter Joanna Griffiths learns how to make cyser mead with Southland Bee Society member Pat Hoffmann

I don't have the best track record with home brewed alcohol.

Uncovering the past

Donna Hawkins is working on a project in Southland on cemeteries.

Uncovering Southland's past in cemeteries.

Protecting your eyesight

Dipton man Mike Smith has macular degeneration and will be talking about the condition at a free public seminar in ...

Having someone stick a needle in his eye is no big thing for Dipton man Mike Smith.

Amundsen new deputy

Cr Rebecca Amundsen has been appointed deputy mayor by Invercargill Mayor Tim Shadbolt, after Cr Darren Ludlow resigned ...

Invercargill Mayor Tim Shadbolt has appointed his new deputy mayor.

Ad Feedback