Courts are not the answer to begging, says lawyer: 'You can't legislate away poverty'

Using council bylaws against soliciting to crack down on beggars could be inconsistent with the Bill of Rights Act, ...
FILE

Using council bylaws against soliciting to crack down on beggars could be inconsistent with the Bill of Rights Act, Victoria University senior law lecturer Dean Knight said.

Three Napier beggars are likely to become the centre of a test case over councils' ability to tackle begging, with their lawyer telling a court:  "Quite frankly, the council can't legislate away poverty."

Myles Hemopo, 40, Major Keelan, 47, and Turei Cooper, 31, who are often seen sitting with cardboard signs in the city centre, appeared before two justices of the peace in Napier District Court on Friday.

Duty lawyer Phil Jenson said: "They are entitled to their day in court, and this matter really needs to be clarified.

Myles Hemopo, one of three Napier men to have been charged in connection with begging in the city.
MARTY SHARPE/ FAIRFAX NZ

Myles Hemopo, one of three Napier men to have been charged in connection with begging in the city.

​"Otherwise they will be coming back again and again on this matter.

READ MORE:
* Napier City Council clamping down on syndicate of beggars earning $100 a day each

Does Palmerston North actually have a serious begging problem
Beggar guilty of fraud for begging for food and shelter while on benefit
Wellington's beggars using rosters and comical gestures to earn more money
Police say people who give to beggars are also funding criminals

"When poverty gets to the state where it breaks out onto the street, we should really face it."

Criminology lecturer Ronald Kramer, of Auckland University, said after the hearing that using criminal law to address problems such as homelessness and poverty would only make them worse.

"I don't think it has any deterrent value at all. The only thing it will do is push the problems somewhere else, or encourage it to take different forms."

He did not believe Napier City Council was concerned with poverty at all, but about preserving businesses interests, and cleaning up the streets so middle-class consumers did not find them offensive.

Ad Feedback

Hauling beggars before the courts was putting "a very poor Band-Aid on a very deep wound".

It's a superficial solution to a deeply ingrained social problem".

Victoria University senior law lecturer Dean Knight said it was possible using the bylaw against soliciting to crack down on beggars could be inconsistent with the Bill of Rights Act.

The three men's alleged offending occurred on various dates in May. Keelan faces charges of soliciting for money and breaching city bylaws, Hemopo of breaching a bylaw, and Cooper of soliciting for money and disorderly behaviour.

The men, who Jensen said were all were "under the aegis of mental health", were remanded at large until next month.

Outside court, Hemopo said he and the others minded their own business and were not aggressive.

"They move us on, usually the cops. They're usually good about it, but there's the odd cop who doesn't like it full stop, and that's why we're at court."

He said he lived on the street. He would rather be in a house, but for various reasons he could not be.

"People are very generous. That's why I still do it. Because they give us heaps of money."

Napier City Council began foot patrols of the city in March as part of a campaign to deter donors from giving beggars money.

It said there were 10 men known to beg in the city as part of a syndicate, and they were "cashing in on the kindness of strangers", earning about $100 a day then spending it on "illegal drugs such as highly addictive synthetic cannabis", or gambling.

Earlier this month, the council's community planning manager, Natasha Carswell, said the campaign had resulted in a reduction in the number of beggars.

There had been 10 patrols over nine days by police, council staff and mental health workers.

"In terms of the number of beggars, we believe the campaign has helped lower it," she said.

"We are seeing around six people around the city, which is about half the number we saw before our campaign began, and the six are not begging as frequently."

There had been a small number of "abusive interactions", she said, but overall the patrols had been well received and there was work under way to plan for next summer.

 - Stuff

Comments

Ad Feedback
special offers
Auckland

$1m taken from mum's accounts

Stephen Jackson sold his mother's home while she was writing a will sharing it equally between her children, the High ...

Auckland man sold his parents' house and took hundreds of thousands from his ailing mother's bank account.

Dog rescued from cliff

The rescued dog with its owner and a member of the rescue team.

Auckland firefighters rescued a marooned dog by abseiling down a cliff with harnesses.

Changing world, changing politics

Massey University associate professor Grant Duncan said economic and technological changes are having a flow-on effect ...

An upcoming lecture at Massey University explores trust and distrust in a changing political landscape.

Auckland airport in the clear video

This isn't the first time this week that fog has grounded planes in Auckland.

Over 80 flights had been cancelled or delayed as fog hit the city's airport.

Wellington

Finding a home for stories

Brucey Downs, 27, is one of the many Kiwis affected by homelessness.

"Being homeless is a roller coaster that goes up and down, it's complicated that way."

Shot theory no joke

Jim Morton lost his left eye, on the right of this photo as you look at it, in a shooting incident. A Fish and Game ...

All hunters should start wearing safety glasses, says man who claims shot can ricochet off of ducks.

A market for drugs

Associate Health Minister Peter Dunne's dramatically changed his views on drug policy over the past eight years.

Government minister says legalisation of cannabis is the 'logical way forward'.

Champion of science

Dave Hansford wrote a book about the pest poison 1080 because "someone had to".

"A great deal of anti-1080 sentiment isn't about 1080," says author.

Canterbury

How's this for a bachelor pad?

The Carlton Butchery penthouse by MAP Architects 26.5.17

Luxurious Christchurch 'bachelor pad' in The Carlton Butchery wins major award.

Consent $63 per year

Blair Colligan plans to bottle water alongside the Waimangaroa River in Buller.

There may soon be signs of life in a dormant, West Coast town: a water bottling plant.

Alleged grope on flight

Police arrested a man at Christchurch Airport after the alleged incident. (FIle photo)

Passenger arrested after allegedly assaulting a woman on Jetstar flight.

Man killed in crash

The cause of the crash is not yet known.

A 26-year-old man is dead and another seriously injured after crashing into a house in Christchurch.

Waikato

Rubber duckies on the loose

Hundreds of rubber ducks are dumped into the water.

Hamilton's lake meets a different type of bird life.

Suspicious blaze at caryard

The Fire Service received a call about the blaze at 3.10pm. Two crews from Waipa attended the scene, plus two trucks ...

At least one person has suffered burns in the Te Awamutu blaze.

Canoe racing home

Canoe Racing CEO Mark Weatherall

Canoe racing high performance athletes will transition to their new headquarters in Cambridge starting pre-Christmas.

Sevens skeptics won't quit

Public reaction to the news that the Sevens are moving to Hamilton has been largely positive. But not everybody's cheering.

Official assurances only go so far with twitchy ratepayers haunted by Hamilton's V8 debacle.

Taranaki

Sale from beyond the grave

The Tariki Hall committee members want to sell the hall and give the proceeds to charity because the income doesn't meet ...

To sell this rural hall, permission was needed from the original trustees - who have long been dead.

Winery trial to come

In times past Tim Finn, Bic Runga, Dave Dobbyn  performed at the Sentry Hill Winery.

The liquidation saga of Sentry Hill Winery is heading to trial.

Goons make it two

Suburban Goons were winners of the best band in the Taranaki regional final of Smokefreerockquest for the second time ...

They won last year and now the Suburban Goons have done it again.

Sacrificing your self 

A longing for relationships is hard wired into our DNA.

OPINION: To be in community we need to sacrifice some measure of individual right and freedom.

Manawatu

Lifetime of work destroyed

John Bramley, with his dog Moose, lost 50 years worth of woodturning work and equipment in a shed fire at his Palmerston ...

It was a shed holding half a century of his life. It was gone in minutes.

Three car pile-up

Police were called to a minor car crash at George St on Saturday.

A person is in hospital after three-car pile-up at a busy Palmerston North street.

Shot theory no joke

Jim Morton lost his left eye, on the right of this photo as you look at it, in a shooting incident. A Fish and Game ...

All hunters should start wearing safety glasses, says man who claims shot can ricochet off of ducks.

Fed up in Foxton

Flooding on Wednesday morning, at the Blue Bell motel on SH1 in Foxton.

Frustrated residents say Foxton's stormwater system can't cope, after repeated floods.

Nelson

Protesting for right to protest

Lewis Staton aka Hone Ma Heke at the protest at the 1903 Square during Saturday's protest, having recently been released ...

Former prime minister calls on the city council to with withdraw a draft bylaw that would require a permit to protest.

Fatal crash near Mot

Motueka Volunteer Fire Brigade volunteers divert traffic on the Coastal Highway after a fatal car crash.

A person has died and another is seriously injured in a two-vehicle crash near Motueka.

What now for Tom?

Thomas Lay is being evicted from  Bridge Street Backpackers and is looking for a new place to live.

Thomas Lay is worried. A Nelson backpackers - his home of seven years - has been forced to sell up.

'Cowboy poachers' under spotlight

Bryce Buckland saw six of the runaway deer at Marsden Valley Cemetery last month. Three men face prosecution after ...

Three men who shot at deer from a car in a residential area could face hefty charges.

Marlborough

'Gentle giant' mourned after rugby death video

Bevan Moody died after suffering a cardiac arrest while playing for Waitohi last weekend.

Bevan Moody, who died after suffering a cardiac arrest while playing for Waitohi, remembered as a young family man with a quick wit.

Oldest Facebooker?

Jean Leslie, 99, uses Facebook to connect with relatives like her granddaughter Melissa Tripe.

Even with just 62 'friends', this 99-year-old still gets fed up with some of the stuff other people 'like'.

'Armed and dangerous' man sought

Michael John Hughes, 36, is considered armed and dangerous.

Police looking for a man believed to be armed and dangerous after he allegedly committed offences across the South Island.

The recycle of life

The majority of recycled glass in Marlborough stays in New Zealand.

From kerbside to dockside; the journey of Marlborough's recycling.

South Canterbury

Rural location no barrier video

Kate Ivey juggles her expanding business with caring for her three children and helping run the family farm.

Mother of three says living in the 'middle of nowhere' is no barrier to business success.

'Out of character'

Timaru police are looking for 53-year-old Murray Wall, missing since Thursday.

The disappearance of a Timaru man is "completely out of character", police say.

Guilty of manslaughter

Timaru Court.

Kooly Managki Te Tomo found guilty of the manslaughter of Arran Gairns.

Accommodation boost

Finance Minister Steven Joyce announced his first Budget on Thursday.

The Government has recognised parts of SC have become more expensive.

Southland

Your chance to cast a vote

Cyclist Eddie Dawkins.

Your chance to have your say for the 2016/2017 Southland Sports Awards.

Busman's holiday gets beached video

Jeff Leeden got his 1964 VAL Bedford bus, Chubby Cheeks, stuck in the sand on Oreti Beach.

Aussies thought they'd take their housebus for a jaunt on the sands. This was nearly its final stop.

Health professionals unhappy

Association of Salaried Medical Specialists Ian Powell.

A medical union has accused the Government of "continued neglect" with its annual health budget announcement on Thursday.

Council's 'Gypsy Day' u-turn

Cows are moved, near Rakaia.

It's deemed too offensive so a new name for sharemilkers moving cows to farms is needed.

Ad Feedback