Courts are not the answer to begging, says lawyer: 'You can't legislate away poverty'

Using council bylaws against soliciting to crack down on beggars could be inconsistent with the Bill of Rights Act, ...
FILE

Using council bylaws against soliciting to crack down on beggars could be inconsistent with the Bill of Rights Act, Victoria University senior law lecturer Dean Knight said.

Three Napier beggars are likely to become the centre of a test case over councils' ability to tackle begging, with their lawyer telling a court:  "Quite frankly, the council can't legislate away poverty."

Myles Hemopo, 40, Major Keelan, 47, and Turei Cooper, 31, who are often seen sitting with cardboard signs in the city centre, appeared before two justices of the peace in Napier District Court on Friday.

Duty lawyer Phil Jenson said: "They are entitled to their day in court, and this matter really needs to be clarified.

Myles Hemopo, one of three Napier men to have been charged in connection with begging in the city.
MARTY SHARPE/FAIRFAX NZ

Myles Hemopo, one of three Napier men to have been charged in connection with begging in the city.

​"Otherwise they will be coming back again and again on this matter.

READ MORE:
* Napier City Council clamping down on syndicate of beggars earning $100 a day each

Does Palmerston North actually have a serious begging problem
Beggar guilty of fraud for begging for food and shelter while on benefit
Wellington's beggars using rosters and comical gestures to earn more money
Police say people who give to beggars are also funding criminals

"When poverty gets to the state where it breaks out onto the street, we should really face it."

Criminology lecturer Ronald Kramer, of Auckland University, said after the hearing that using criminal law to address problems such as homelessness and poverty would only make them worse.

"I don't think it has any deterrent value at all. The only thing it will do is push the problems somewhere else, or encourage it to take different forms."

He did not believe Napier City Council was concerned with poverty at all, but about preserving businesses interests, and cleaning up the streets so middle-class consumers did not find them offensive.

Ad Feedback

Hauling beggars before the courts was putting "a very poor Band-Aid on a very deep wound".

It's a superficial solution to a deeply ingrained social problem".

Victoria University senior law lecturer Dean Knight said it was possible using the bylaw against soliciting to crack down on beggars could be inconsistent with the Bill of Rights Act.

The three men's alleged offending occurred on various dates in May. Keelan faces charges of soliciting for money and breaching city bylaws, Hemopo of breaching a bylaw, and Cooper of soliciting for money and disorderly behaviour.

The men, who Jensen said were all were "under the aegis of mental health", were remanded at large until next month.

Outside court, Hemopo said he and the others minded their own business and were not aggressive.

"They move us on, usually the cops. They're usually good about it, but there's the odd cop who doesn't like it full stop, and that's why we're at court."

He said he lived on the street. He would rather be in a house, but for various reasons he could not be.

"People are very generous. That's why I still do it. Because they give us heaps of money."

Napier City Council began foot patrols of the city in March as part of a campaign to deter donors from giving beggars money.

It said there were 10 men known to beg in the city as part of a syndicate, and they were "cashing in on the kindness of strangers", earning about $100 a day then spending it on "illegal drugs such as highly addictive synthetic cannabis", or gambling.

Earlier this month, the council's community planning manager, Natasha Carswell, said the campaign had resulted in a reduction in the number of beggars.

There had been 10 patrols over nine days by police, council staff and mental health workers.

"In terms of the number of beggars, we believe the campaign has helped lower it," she said.

"We are seeing around six people around the city, which is about half the number we saw before our campaign began, and the six are not begging as frequently."

There had been a small number of "abusive interactions", she said, but overall the patrols had been well received and there was work under way to plan for next summer.

 - Stuff

Comments

Ad Feedback
special offers
Auckland

Three Kings getting masterplan

Up to 1500 new dwellings are set to go in on the Three Kings Quarry site. The Puketapapa Local Board chairman Harry Doig ...

Local board push for a "masterplan" upgrade of the Three Kings Plaza. 

Can Auckland handle the America's Cup?

How will Auckland come up with the money for the next regatta?

Auckland is hoping to be confirmed as host of the next America's Cup, but questions remain over the hefty price tag.

Maramarua power their way past Tuakau

Maramarua goal attack Ivana Rowland awaits a pass into the circle.

Maramarua finding momentum in early stages of Pukekohe Premier Gold netball competition.

'I feel like all my work is worth it'

Boyi Yan grew up in China but is changing the lives of kiwi kids everyday.

 Boyi Yan has been an early childhood teacher for less than two years, and loves what she does.

Wellington

'League must be banned forever!'

Warriors halfback Shaun Johnson's silky skills are a welcome sight on most footy fields, with the possible exception of ...

Masterton is keen to lure the NZ Warriors to town, but an archaic rule may present a problem.

Police probe death

James Whenauroa died in hospital after suffering critical head injuries.

James Whenauroa was found with critical head injuries. A week later, he died in hospital.

Lions thriller ends even video

Wing Tommy Seymour dives over for the first of the British and Irish Lions' tries against the Hurricanes.

Draws rarely come more exciting than this one between the Hurricanes and Lions.

Coles takes the field at last

Hurricane Dane Coles and Lions skipper Sam Warburton hongi after the treasured korowai is presented at Wellington Stadium.

But it was just a ceremonial role, as he presented Lions captain with a korowai.

Canterbury

Beautiful, but abandoned gallery

This beautiful Colonial mansion in North Canterbury, built in 1885, has been abandoned by its UK owners whose dream fell ...

UK owners abandon North Canterbury colonial mansion after their dream falls through.

Digital school shakeup

Education MInister Nikki Kaye acknowledged it could be controversial given there were already  concerns about the amount ...

The primary school curriculum, right from year 1, is set to change to prepare children for their digital futures.

Secret tyre mountain

A tyre mountain on a suburban Christchurch property is being slowly dismantled after complaints and environmental concerns.

In a green pocket of Christchurch hides a tyre pile so vast it can be seen via satellite.

Still fighting ex-wife

Earl Hagaman died on May 25 at the age of 92.

Rich-lister Earl Hagaman's will instructs trustees to fight any claim by ex-wife "to the fullest extent".

Waikato

Rail trail contributes millions

The Waikino Station Cafe is a popular stop on the Hauraki Rail Trail.

The Hauraki Rail Trail has brought an estimated $39m return to the region.

League ref fleeces club

Dwayne Hibbs stole $13,620 from Waikato Rugby League Referees Association coffers.

Ref siphoned $13,620 from Waikato Rugby League Referees Association to feed his gambling addiction.

Cuts to sand mine jobs

Kaumatua Patrick Maikuku, pictured on the Taharoa Destiny, is unhappy about the prospect of job losses at the sand mine.

Part of Waikato iron sands operation is going and so are 16 jobs, worker says.

Yes to zoo camping plan

It would cost about $15.7m to make the Hamilton Zoo Master Plan happen, councillors heard. But the money decisions come ...

A master plan for Hamilton Zoo gets the tick, but not the money to pay for it.

Taranaki

Firm, but go easy on the swing

27062017 News GRANT MATTHEW/FAIRFAX NZ

Superindendent Domenico Squatriti and committee member Craig Waite in a new ...

Enjoy a cold one after fighting to escape a firm and fluffy glass sand bunker

Jetstar reduces flights

Jetstar is reducing the number of flights in and out of New Plymouth over the next four months.

The weekly number flights will drop from 40 to 28.

Woolshed burns down 

Fire crews were dampening down the scene after it burnt down overnight.

A woolshed has burnt down overnight at a rural property in South Taranaki.

Biesiek stands by signs

Councillor Shaun Biesiek said that the ticket for driving in a prohibited area should not have been overturned.

The councillor who initiated the 'boy racer bylaw' said the ticket should stand.

Manawatu

History comes alive

The Fantasy in Lights display returns to Feilding this month, but with a new host.

Bright lights will dawn on the Coach House Museum in this year's Fantasy in Lights display. 

Glimpsing alcohol OK

Melody's New World's proposed alcohol display area passes the test.

Impulse booze buying not encouraged by shoppers catching a look at packaging.

Elderly fear road crossings

Joy Carter and Doreen Broadbent lead a group of elderly residents across the Kimbolton Rd and Aorangi St intersections.

Elderly residents are crossing the road in fear as concerns about Feilding traffic grow.

Black in blue

Otere Black is leaving the Hurricanes to join the Blues.

Manawatu's Otere Black has signed with the Blues for Super Rugby next year.

Nelson

Baristas give it their best shot

Nelson College students Jason Peng, left and Robbie Cookson will compete in the Secondary School division barista ...

Two budding baristas are hoping to grind their way to glory at a national coffee contest.

Jobs 'in jeopardy'

Waimea Nurseries director Bruno Simpson warns the company may have to move its operations to the North Island if it ...

Waimea Nurseries boss could move from Nelson to North Island if dam doesn't get built, taking 75 jobs with him.

River runs through dam debate

Rhys Barrier, of Fish & Game, in the Waimea River as it flows at about 3700 litres a second.

Dam or no dam, maintaining "life force" of Waimea River is essential, says Fish & Game.

Funding boost for 'bursting' school

Waimea College principal Scott Haines overlooking the site for new classrooms with Associate Minister of Education Tim ...

Region's biggest school given $4m for new classrooms after roll "sky-rocketed".

Marlborough

Swimming deer stuns mussel farmer

Clearwater Mussels owner John Young spotted this deer taking a swim through one of his mussel farms, on the western side ...

Deer makes like a dolphin and takes a midwinter dip in the Marlborough Sounds.

Car crash on SH6

Fire and police attended a two-car crash on Wednesday about 7.30am.

A car is blocking the middle of a state highway after crashing into another car.

Church burglar steals children's money

Harvest Life Church elder John Etheredge outside the Nelson St church after it was burgled.

Burglar ransacks church, steals money raised by children for children.

Pools reopen

Four pools at the Marlborough Lines Stadium 2000 aquatic centre have been chemically treated.

After three tests and a chemical treatment, the aquatic centre is back in action.

South Canterbury

Tears, relief on Grasmere St video

Grasmere St resident Don Boot gives one of the remaining condemned pin oaks a final hug before it is cut down on Tuesday.

Some residents watched in horror as condemned pin oaks were cut down on Grasmere St.

Sugar policy difficult

A national policy on sugary drinks in council workplaces would be difficult to regulate and pose problems when ...

Councillors unimpressed by proposed national sweet drinks policy.

Gearing up for Jump Jam

Timaru South School Jump Jam Extravaganza team The South Stars at Tuesday's dress rehearsal.
Back row, from left, Zoe ...

More than 500 South Canterbury pupils are preparing to show off their moves on the big stage.

Police morale high

Senior Sergeant Dylan Murray, of Timaru, said police were often involved in community organisations and were genuinely ...

Despite reports of stress, Senior Sergeant says police culture in SC is "excellent".

Southland

Steel netball fever builds video

Southern Steel captain Wendy Frew surrounded by Waverley Park Kindergarten kids, including son Archie, at their Steel ...

Stadium Southland boss Nigel Skelt has challenged the crowd to transfer the stadium into a sea of Steel colour.

Steel's dedicated fans video

Alva, 88, and Jack Faul, 92, are dedicated Southern Steel supporters and are excited about Wednesday night's grand final.

Are Jack Faul, 92, and his wife Alva, 88, the Southern Steel's most dedicated couple?

Recycling habits slammed

Southland disAbility Enterprises general manager Hamish McMurdo is unhappy with the number of dangerous materials people ...

From sex toys to live ammunition and even dead animals, South recycling habits are a cause for concern.

Speeding up transport for mums

Southland Hospital run by Southern District Health Board, in Invercargill.

Pregnant mums in rural areas are getting improved access to emergency transport because of a new policy, the Southern DHB says.

Ad Feedback