Courts are not the answer to begging, says lawyer: 'You can't legislate away poverty'

Using council bylaws against soliciting to crack down on beggars could be inconsistent with the Bill of Rights Act, ...
FILE

Using council bylaws against soliciting to crack down on beggars could be inconsistent with the Bill of Rights Act, Victoria University senior law lecturer Dean Knight said.

Three Napier beggars are likely to become the centre of a test case over councils' ability to tackle begging, with their lawyer telling a court:  "Quite frankly, the council can't legislate away poverty."

Myles Hemopo, 40, Major Keelan, 47, and Turei Cooper, 31, who are often seen sitting with cardboard signs in the city centre, appeared before two justices of the peace in Napier District Court on Friday.

Duty lawyer Phil Jenson said: "They are entitled to their day in court, and this matter really needs to be clarified.

Myles Hemopo, one of three Napier men to have been charged in connection with begging in the city.
MARTY SHARPE/FAIRFAX NZ

Myles Hemopo, one of three Napier men to have been charged in connection with begging in the city.

​"Otherwise they will be coming back again and again on this matter.

READ MORE:
* Napier City Council clamping down on syndicate of beggars earning $100 a day each

Does Palmerston North actually have a serious begging problem
Beggar guilty of fraud for begging for food and shelter while on benefit
Wellington's beggars using rosters and comical gestures to earn more money
Police say people who give to beggars are also funding criminals

"When poverty gets to the state where it breaks out onto the street, we should really face it."

Criminology lecturer Ronald Kramer, of Auckland University, said after the hearing that using criminal law to address problems such as homelessness and poverty would only make them worse.

"I don't think it has any deterrent value at all. The only thing it will do is push the problems somewhere else, or encourage it to take different forms."

He did not believe Napier City Council was concerned with poverty at all, but about preserving businesses interests, and cleaning up the streets so middle-class consumers did not find them offensive.

Ad Feedback

Hauling beggars before the courts was putting "a very poor Band-Aid on a very deep wound".

It's a superficial solution to a deeply ingrained social problem".

Victoria University senior law lecturer Dean Knight said it was possible using the bylaw against soliciting to crack down on beggars could be inconsistent with the Bill of Rights Act.

The three men's alleged offending occurred on various dates in May. Keelan faces charges of soliciting for money and breaching city bylaws, Hemopo of breaching a bylaw, and Cooper of soliciting for money and disorderly behaviour.

The men, who Jensen said were all were "under the aegis of mental health", were remanded at large until next month.

Outside court, Hemopo said he and the others minded their own business and were not aggressive.

"They move us on, usually the cops. They're usually good about it, but there's the odd cop who doesn't like it full stop, and that's why we're at court."

He said he lived on the street. He would rather be in a house, but for various reasons he could not be.

"People are very generous. That's why I still do it. Because they give us heaps of money."

Napier City Council began foot patrols of the city in March as part of a campaign to deter donors from giving beggars money.

It said there were 10 men known to beg in the city as part of a syndicate, and they were "cashing in on the kindness of strangers", earning about $100 a day then spending it on "illegal drugs such as highly addictive synthetic cannabis", or gambling.

Earlier this month, the council's community planning manager, Natasha Carswell, said the campaign had resulted in a reduction in the number of beggars.

There had been 10 patrols over nine days by police, council staff and mental health workers.

"In terms of the number of beggars, we believe the campaign has helped lower it," she said.

"We are seeing around six people around the city, which is about half the number we saw before our campaign began, and the six are not begging as frequently."

There had been a small number of "abusive interactions", she said, but overall the patrols had been well received and there was work under way to plan for next summer.

 - Stuff

Comments

Ad Feedback
special offers
Auckland

'Business as usual' soon video

Tanker HMNZS Endeavour is back on standby because of Auckland's ground fuel re-supply efforts, Judith Collins said.

Energy Minister Judith Collins says Auckland airport's fuel crisis is coming to end.

Connecting through memories

Year 5 Albany Primary School pupil Yash Arora, 10, said the game was fun for residents and students.

Albany Primary pupils are taking part in a programme to form connections with older adults with dementia.

Te Papa to go fully solar

The Age
News
04/04/2013
picture Justin McManus.
Hoppers Crossing has the highest number of Solar Panel instillation in ...

Wellington museum plans to power itself entirely by sunlight within a decade.

Waiting for help

Ten per cent of children between 0 and 19 are made to wait more than two months for mental health support across New ...

One in 10 young people in NZ seeking mental health help will be on a waiting list for more than two months.

Wellington

Parties for the nearly departed video

Ken Turner and partner Sarah Angus.
Ken has terminal cancer and held a "living wake" for family and friends last weekend.

"Living wakes" have become a final festivity of life in the face of death.

Fire victim's protest

A cordon was put up outside Parliament after the man set himself alight.

Man who died after setting himself alight had been in dispute with Family Court.

Road projects hit Kāpiti housing

John and Julianne O'Kane watch their former family home in Paraparaumu being carted off to make way for the expressway ...

Market not delivering what community needs, taskforce tells council.

How the sevens were lost

In total, less than 18,000 spectators attended the Wellington Sevens across both days - the stadium's capacity is 32,500.

Organisers were in losing battle for an event Wellington had fallen out of love with, emails show.

Canterbury

New shops and foodcourt planned

A new foodcourt and seating areas for diners will be added at the southern end of Northlands mall.

Christchurch's Northlands Mall is planning to embark on another extension.

Fire coms broke down

Christchurch Mayor Lianne Dalziel says more regular updates were needed from the Selwyn District Council during ...

Selwyn council didn't update Chch mayor's office for nearly eight hours during Port Hills fires.

No charges over fatal crash

Christchurch man Bruce Imrie says it is a "big relief" not to be charged over the crash that killed his wife.

Tough five months for man who "blanked out" moments before a crash that killed his wife.

Upset at noisy basketball court video

The court is about 30 metres from the nearest property.

A Christchurch woman claims the constant thumping of basketballs from a nearby half-court is turning her into a wreck.

Waikato

Footbridge a priority

A footbridge across the Waikato River could connect central Hamilton to Parana Park and Memorial Park. Pictured is an ...

There's a push for more work on plans for a pedestrian bridge to link central Hamilton and Parana Park.

Tyre pile warning

Waikato Regional Councillor Kathy White said used tyres need to be made a priority under the Waste Minimisation Act.

Industry insiders say they're shocked at a tyre stockpile growing by "thousands" each day.

Mack cheats death, again video

Sharla Pearce was terrified her dog would die after falling down a Waikato River bank. Fire rescue came and rescued Mack ...

After surviving death row, a "goofball" pooch found himself in another spot of trouble.

Killer highway's $6m salve

Two people were killed on SH3 between 2005 and 2014.

Rumble strips, side barriers and intersection improvements on the way for SH3.

Taranaki

Unlocking dementia's secrets video

11092017 News Photo ANDY JACKSON/STUFF.  The Ticking Timebomb, a series looking at the rising issues of alzheimers ...

Dementia has a terrible effect on many Kiwi lives, and the situation will get worse. 

Sir Richard's award

Sir Richard Faull holds up his "second brain", as he explained to the students at New Plymouth Boys' High that they were ...

"If you're a plumber, be the best plumber in the world, if you're a jet pilot, be the best jet pilot in the world."

Armed cops in street

Firefighters don hazmat suits at the scene on Turakina St.

Officers who entered a suspected clandestine lab have been put through a decontamination shower.

Justice 'not being seen'

A Taranaki lawyer claims his legally blind client's access to justice is under threat because the man can't get his ...

Lawyer argues legally blind client's "access to justice" at risk because no-one is helping him to get new glasses.

Manawatu

Welcome to town: Colyton video

Dairy cows and cattle make up a good portion of the Colyton population.

The small settlement isn't a dream destination for tourists, but it keeps good time.

Teachers investigated

One teacher has been struck off and two others are under investigation after behaving inappropriately towards students. ...

One teacher struck off and two others investigated for inappropriate relationships with students.

Turbos surge late to beat Northland

Manawatū's Newton Tudreu races in for his intercept try in the first half.

Manawatū Turbos turn on a strong finish to beat Northland 39-25.

Population boom

Manawatū/Whanganui is now home to  236,900 people, the highest the  region's population has been since 1990.

A "once-in-a-lifetime opportunity" for the region's economy.

Nelson

Makos legend back in the fold

Robbie Malneek last played for the Tasman Makos during the 2015 Mitre 10 Cup season.

Robbie Malneek, the only player to reach 100 caps for the Tasman Makos, has been handed an unlikely recall.

Car-free summer

Kerry and Garry Ford of Ford's restaurant and bar in upper Trafalgar Street, which will become a pedestrian zone over ...

The top of Nelson's Trafalgar St is going to be traffic free for four months this summer.

New SHAs approved

12072017 NEWS PHOTO MARTIN DERUYTER/ STUFF

The former Green Grocer Store on the corner of Grove St and Tasman St in The ...

Seven new SHAs approved by the Nelson City Council including a tiny house project.

Bugged by litter bugs

Ali Lawley and her son Charlie Calderbank, aged 10, on Franklyn St next to Nelson College.

Braemar Eco village residents want littering outside Nelson College to stop

Marlborough

Environment judge called in

Leachate run-off and ponding from grape marc dump sites in Marlborough. (File pic)

A prominent winemaker and a new company he is linked to - dubbed the "complete solution" to grape marc - are to be dealt with by the Environment Court.

'Stupid thing to do'

Blenheim District Court.

A man has admitted shooting out a window at the health hub in the central business district.

Leap in rateable values

New capital values across Marlborough show a big increase for Picton properties. (File pic)

Some properties have seen their capital value incease by a whopping 28 per cent.

Whale carcass washes ashore gallery video

A blue whale carcass washed ashore at Glenburn Station in Wairarapa on Wednesday.

A blue whale suspected to be the same one spotted dead in the water near d'Urville Island has washed ashore.

South Canterbury

Hydro 'dangerous'

Timaru's Hydro Grand Hotel has been assessed as being a dangerous building likely to cause injury or death.

Damning report says Hydro Grand is dangerous, likely to cause injury or death.

Time to spring forward

Butcher Jim Bower's early mornings will be even darker and busier when Daylight Saving kicks in on Sunday.

Dust off the barbecue, it's time for long evenings as Daylight Savings starts.

Gully change approved

An aerial view of Broughs Gully, in the Timaru suburb of Oceanview.

The Brough's Gully site could yield at least 180 sections if the decision survives appeal.

Timaru's next tourism attraction?

In May a High Court Judge ruled the Rangatira be sold to pay off more than $170,000 owed to PrimePort.

Fisherman hopes community will save ship with Hollywood connection from the scrap heap.

Otago

Woman rescued, police thank app

A Christchurch woman was found on Ben Lomond, near Queenstown, about 12am on Friday.

A Christchurch woman was rescued from a Queenstown mountain after her husband tracked her location through a phone app.

Eyes to the sky in Alexandra

Neil Sutherland, who lives at the Alexandra Airport at his hanger, will be displaying his home-built plane at the Wings ...

It's not every day planes down the main street of Alexandra.

Budding booze baron busted

Richard Gray in the Dunedin District Court

A Dunedin man says he feels better after he was busted for selling home brew to two teens who later ended up in hospital.

Six-figure golden handshake

Aurora Energy boss Grady Cameron's exit package means he will make nearly $1 million in a year.

Otago lines company boss's 'excessive' exit package means he'll make nearly $1m this year.

Southland

Prendergast wants dialogue before ministerial review

John Prendergast, former chief executive of the Community Trust of Southland.

"An independent set of eyes transparently reviewing and reporting publicly on this matter would be very beneficial ..."

Where is Amber-Lee?

Amber-Lee Cruickshank, pictured age one, went missing on October 17, 1992.

Police travelled to Australia looking for answers about what happened to toddler Amber-Lee Cruickshank 25 years ago.

Fighting for those who can't

Southland Boys's High School student  Malachi Agnew, 12, in front, has organised students at his school to have a mufti ...

When Malachi Agnew is rasing money he's trying to save the lives of his mates.

Ballet etiquette 101

I've seen Romeo and Juliet, I don't need the story narrated to me.

OPINION: I love a trip to the ballet but not when the person behind me can't stop talking.

Ad Feedback