Removing mangroves often doesn't end well, but Niwa has found out what does work

Mangroves are native plants but they are spreading and not everyone welcomes their advance.

Mangroves are native plants but they are spreading and not everyone welcomes their advance.

Removing mangroves rarely results in the desired return of a sandy beach, a Niwa study has found, but there are ways to improve the chances of success.

A guide based on the research was launched on Friday, and warns that mangrove removal often leaves areas looking unattractive and smelling bad.

NIwa researchers examined around 40 removal sites with varying characteristics - small to large, sheltered to exposed, muddy to sandy. They found removal of mangroves rarely resulted in a return of sand flats.

SUPPLIED

The mangrove-mowing hovercraft is being trialled at Athenree.

Many mangrove removal areas showed immediate and long-term adverse impacts, the report said. Those impacts included sediments that lacked oxygen, were often black in colour and smelled of sulphur. 

READ MORE:
Hovercraft to mow mangroves in Tauranga
Mangrove removal begins in Mangere
From chopper to chipper for mangroves
Residents move against mangroves

There was only minimal dispersal or decomposition of plant remains, high levels of hydrogen sulfide associated with rotting plant material, bacterial mats, and large and prolonged algal blooms. Vehicle track marks could be seen for years after removal.

Mangrove removal in Manukau Harbour.
AUCKLAND COUNCIL

Mangrove removal in Manukau Harbour.

While sandier sediment could return, it was unlikely in areas with little tidal and wave action.

Plant material should always be taken right away from removal sites, the report said. "Post-removal monitoring and observations have revealed that the mulched material often does not get washed away and decomposes slowly, resulting in long-term adverse impacts, which have been observed to continue at least five years after removal."

At some places where mangroves were removed illegally, vegetation was left behind, and studies showed woody debris was likely to take decades to decompose.

A mower hovercraft has been purpose-built to manage mangrove seedlings around Tauranga Harbour.
SUPPLIED

A mower hovercraft has been purpose-built to manage mangrove seedlings around Tauranga Harbour.

The best chance for a return of sand was when a strip of plants was removed from the seaward side of a mangrove forest, the report said.

Ad Feedback

"Strip clearances on the shoreward side of a mangrove forest have limited flow and are slow to recover. Strip pathways through the middle of mangrove forests are rapidly recolonised by seeds from neighbouring trees. Large clearances are also slow to recover."

The part of mangroves below ground pose a big problem.

Up to 87 per cent of total biomass in New Zealand mangrove forests was below ground, and could take decades to decompose after the above-ground part of plants was removed, the report said. High densities of root material remained at many sites years later.

A trial was carried out using a digger to remove the main stump and surrounding dense root material of mangroves. But the root material was fine and soft, and the efforts to remove it were largely unsuccessful and caused considerable sediment disturbance.

Mangroves live in the northern half of the North Island and have expanded the extent of their coverage during the past half century, mainly seaward across tidal flats, the report said.

The expansion was thought to be a result of increased sediment runoff from surrounding land, and such things as the building of causeways.

"This has increased the suitability of many estuarine areas for mangroves, through increasing muddiness, reducing current flows and exposure, and increasing the height of tidal flats."

While applications for permission to remove mangroves had increased in recent decades, removal of the plants was only a "temporary fix" unless the amount of land-based sediments and nutrients entering waterways was minimised, the report said.

Mangroves were also an important bird habitat, used for foraging, roosting and nesting, but weren't so important for fish.

As a way to avoid the long-term problems caused by the use of heavy machinery and vehicles in the removal of mangroves, a hovercraft with a mower for controlling the spread of seedlings was being trialled on estuaries within Tauranga Harbour.

The cost of resource consents for mangrove removal ranged between $12,000 and $230,000 per operation, the report said. It put the cost of removal at between $1000 and $5000 per hectare, but also said removal costs were known to have exceeded $50,000 per hectare. Ongoing seedling removal cost about $1000 per hectare annually.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 - Stuff

Ad Feedback
special offers
Auckland

Hunt on for produce poisoners

Two orchard sites in Kerikeri have been sprayed with Calypso spray, a potentially harmful substance.

About $240K of kiwifruit dumped after hazardous chemical sprayed at orchard.

'All four engines have failed'

The Boeing 747, called "The City of Edinburgh", the day after its terrifying flight.

A jumbo jet carrying Kiwis plunges from the sky in the pitch black near Indonesia.

A day in the life of Westside actor Shane Cortese

Shane Cortese, aged 17, second from left, in his room at the Majestic Hotel, with friends Shane Christensen, left, ...

Each week, we ask a famous Kiwi to share a photo memory.

Trapped and injured after crash

The fire service are working to extricate a person trapped in their car after a crash in west Auckland.

A person is trapped with serious injuries after an Auckland car crash.

Wellington

Bars to share info on patrons

0307 2005 NEWS.
Party goers queue to get into the nightspots in Courtenay Place after the All Blacks vs Irish and ...

Go Pro footage and bouncer intel will be used to get Wellington's bar-goers to behave.

Ready to roar

British and Irish Lions' fans are in good spirits after notching up victories against the New Zealand Provincial ...

All you need to know for the Lions' visit to Wellington.

Barred from rest home

A Hastings woman has been trespassed from her mother's rest home. (file photo)

Woman says she's been deprived of time with her mum, which she can never get back.

Garner: It was Winston's week

There's only winner this week – the smiling travelling salesman, Winston Peters, writes Duncan Garner.

OPINION: NZ First leader beaming as National and Labour have weeks they'd rather forget.

Canterbury

Christchurch into 'Goldilocks years'

The Hoyts' EntX cinema complex is under construction in Colombo St.

City leaders say conditions are "just right" for big progress in the CBD in the next three years.

School shorts 'too cold'

School, generic, uniform, schoolbag, bag, books,

Mum pulls sons from school after it refused to provide warmer clothing options as part of its winter uniform.

Murky politics in the deep south video

Tony Wilson, mechanic at Dipton Engineering, said many of the locals in the valley didn't bother themselves with ...

The mysterious machinations of murky Southland politics revealed.

Overdue apology for school closures

Students leave Avonside Girls at the end of a school day in September 2012 after learning their school was slated for ...

OPINION: The rarest of birds has popped up to see daylight. A government apology.

Waikato

Foreign 'brain drain'

Flinders University professor of paediatrics and child health Kevin Forsyth says New Zealand needs to do more to curb ...

New Zealand prides itself on playing fair. But its use of overseas doctors is causing angst offshore.

Racer flees cops

Police pursued the Toyota Corolla to Ohaupo Road, where the vehicle was spiked at 2.40am on Saturday.

A 23-year-old woman fled from police after being busted doing burnouts in Frankton.

Fire at chicken plant

Inghams Enterprises, Waitoa.

The small fire required a large response because of chemicals at the site.

Rural docs' passion confirmed video

Australian GP registrar Justin Gladman joined the Royal Flying Doctor Service in early 2017. He is a graduate of ...

Training doctors away from tertiary hospitals is helping boost rural GP numbers across the ditch.

Taranaki

Banking on the change in money

23062017 News GRANT MATTHEW/FAIRFAX NZ

Banking Industry. People use less cash and more tech to pay for goods.
Steve ...

We're spending more than ever before so why's it getting harder for banks to stay open?

Word to your mother

21062017 News Photo ANDY JACKSON/Fairfax NZ.   Brittany Bourgoise runs her own nail technician business from home.  Kids ...

Brittany Bourgoise is a mumpreneur and reckons other mothers can become one too.

US-owned grain facility planned

A palm kernel storage shed near Ngamotu Beach in New Plymouth.

Multinational US food processor to set up storage and distribution facility in Taranaki.

Last video store standing

United Video owner Sam Bansal says he is still here and open for business.

They're becoming as rare as hen's teeth, and now New Plymouth only has one left.

Manawatu

More refugee support

Bhutan refugees Dirga Maya Poudel,  Bir Bahadur Poudel and Gopal Poudel could be joined in Palmerston North by more ...

More refugees could be calling Palmerston North home, if ideas escalate into funded plans.

Page the midwife

Firefighters and midwives are among those who will continue using pagers after Spark exits the public pager system at ...

Critical services will still use pagers after Spark opts out of the old technology.

Palmer slams Horizons

Sir Geoffrey Palmer, architect of the Resource Management Act

Council's court loss over farm run-off an example of local government failures, Palmer says.

No more limits

Cameron Holland, 20, had a brain injury after a car crash when he was 11.

A double blow robbed him of his father and gave him a serious brain injury.

Nelson

Who killed Kevin O'Loughlin?

Kevin O'Loughlin, 30, who was stabbed to death on the corner of a Nelson carpark on May 2, 1993. His murder has not been ...

Who was the man behind one of Nelson's only unsolved murders?

Retirees for Richmond

Andrew Spittal says the aim is to develop about 550 to 650 sections on the site.

A $130m retirement village is tipped as part of a proposed $350m development in Richmond, near Nelson.

Doughnuts selling like hot cakes

Josiah Smits of the Smoking Barrel Cafe and Restaurant with some of his famous donuts at his High St, Motueka business.

A Motueka cafe is struggling to meet demand for its syringe-injected gourmet doughnuts.

Greens target Nelson

Nick Smith has held the Nelson seat for 21 years.

The Green Party is campaigning to break Nick Smith's 21-year grip on Nelson.

Marlborough

Warehouse dumps faulty sheets

Packs of flannelette sheets slashed and dumped in a skip outside The Warehouse Blenheim.

Well, it's not like there's a charity called Sheets 'n Things right beside them. Oh wait ...

Landlords want change

Tasha and Jamie McCracken want landlords to have more rights to evict tenants if a positive meth test suggests they are ...

Meth damage no different to "someone picking up a sledge hammer, walking onto your property and swinging it around".

Falcons face Timaru

MBC First IV rugby team the Falcons.

The Marlborough Boys' College First XV take on Timaru Boys' High at noon today.

Dancing in Vanuatu

Blenheim Momentum Dance Company owner Jessica Foley-Taylor, at rear, is going to Vanuatu on a dance charity mission. ...

Dance teacher swaps studio for Pacific Island village as she heads off on dance mission.

South Canterbury

Marking Matariki in Waimate video

Waimate Main School kapa haka group members are, from left, Summer Pay, 8, Maddison Longman, 8, and Ashley Guy, 7.

Attendee numbers have grown, and performances have improved, since Matariki celebrations began in Waimate six years ago.

RSA restructure looms

South Canterbury Returned and Services' Association president Greg O'Brien.

Restructure looms as South Canterbury RSA tries to improve its financial situation.

Clone sought for vet practice video

Stepping back after 40 years at the Veterinary Centre Waimate is vet Dougall McLachlan.

Dougall McLachlan's colleagues want his last pair of work gumboots to last a very long time.

$1.1m for new lights

Netcon chief executive Steve McCoy with an LED light of the type his company has already installed in Temuka. The Timaru ...

Work to replace Timaru's street lights can start next month thanks to boost.

Southland

Young performers face the music

Monique Clementson (Deloris), Annie Sherborne, and Rachael Scott (Sister Mary Patrick) at rehearsals for the ...

Young performers are gaining exposure and touring the country for Sister Act the musical.

Arrested after threats

08072016 Newsphoto. SIMON MAUDE / FAIRFAX NZ. Generic, stock, NZ Police, police car, The po po, police. 08-N-policeC

A 54-year-old man was arrested after threatening Work and Income staff.

Father 'evil', grief-stricken mum says

Police staff at the Riverton home where three-month-old Honour Ashworth was injured.

Grieving Southland mother says her soul was "ripped to pieces" when she found out her partner caused her infant son's death.

Green Party takes off

Green Party of Aotearoa New Zealand Invercargill candidate Rochelle Surendran speaks at a Green Party Launch in Invercargill.

Green Party co-leader comments on Clutha-Southland MP resignation during Invercargill visit.

Ad Feedback