Removing mangroves often doesn't end well, but Niwa has found out what does work

Mangroves are native plants but they are spreading and not everyone welcomes their advance.

Mangroves are native plants but they are spreading and not everyone welcomes their advance.

Removing mangroves rarely results in the desired return of a sandy beach, a Niwa study has found, but there are ways to improve the chances of success.

A guide based on the research was launched on Friday, and warns that mangrove removal often leaves areas looking unattractive and smelling bad.

NIwa researchers examined around 40 removal sites with varying characteristics - small to large, sheltered to exposed, muddy to sandy. They found removal of mangroves rarely resulted in a return of sand flats.

SUPPLIED

The mangrove-mowing hovercraft is being trialled at Athenree.

Many mangrove removal areas showed immediate and long-term adverse impacts, the report said. Those impacts included sediments that lacked oxygen, were often black in colour and smelled of sulphur. 

READ MORE:
Hovercraft to mow mangroves in Tauranga
Mangrove removal begins in Mangere
From chopper to chipper for mangroves
Residents move against mangroves

There was only minimal dispersal or decomposition of plant remains, high levels of hydrogen sulfide associated with rotting plant material, bacterial mats, and large and prolonged algal blooms. Vehicle track marks could be seen for years after removal.

Mangrove removal in Manukau Harbour.
AUCKLAND COUNCIL

Mangrove removal in Manukau Harbour.

While sandier sediment could return, it was unlikely in areas with little tidal and wave action.

Plant material should always be taken right away from removal sites, the report said. "Post-removal monitoring and observations have revealed that the mulched material often does not get washed away and decomposes slowly, resulting in long-term adverse impacts, which have been observed to continue at least five years after removal."

At some places where mangroves were removed illegally, vegetation was left behind, and studies showed woody debris was likely to take decades to decompose.

A mower hovercraft has been purpose-built to manage mangrove seedlings around Tauranga Harbour.
SUPPLIED

A mower hovercraft has been purpose-built to manage mangrove seedlings around Tauranga Harbour.

The best chance for a return of sand was when a strip of plants was removed from the seaward side of a mangrove forest, the report said.

Ad Feedback

"Strip clearances on the shoreward side of a mangrove forest have limited flow and are slow to recover. Strip pathways through the middle of mangrove forests are rapidly recolonised by seeds from neighbouring trees. Large clearances are also slow to recover."

The part of mangroves below ground pose a big problem.

Up to 87 per cent of total biomass in New Zealand mangrove forests was below ground, and could take decades to decompose after the above-ground part of plants was removed, the report said. High densities of root material remained at many sites years later.

A trial was carried out using a digger to remove the main stump and surrounding dense root material of mangroves. But the root material was fine and soft, and the efforts to remove it were largely unsuccessful and caused considerable sediment disturbance.

Mangroves live in the northern half of the North Island and have expanded the extent of their coverage during the past half century, mainly seaward across tidal flats, the report said.

The expansion was thought to be a result of increased sediment runoff from surrounding land, and such things as the building of causeways.

"This has increased the suitability of many estuarine areas for mangroves, through increasing muddiness, reducing current flows and exposure, and increasing the height of tidal flats."

While applications for permission to remove mangroves had increased in recent decades, removal of the plants was only a "temporary fix" unless the amount of land-based sediments and nutrients entering waterways was minimised, the report said.

Mangroves were also an important bird habitat, used for foraging, roosting and nesting, but weren't so important for fish.

As a way to avoid the long-term problems caused by the use of heavy machinery and vehicles in the removal of mangroves, a hovercraft with a mower for controlling the spread of seedlings was being trialled on estuaries within Tauranga Harbour.

The cost of resource consents for mangrove removal ranged between $12,000 and $230,000 per operation, the report said. It put the cost of removal at between $1000 and $5000 per hectare, but also said removal costs were known to have exceeded $50,000 per hectare. Ongoing seedling removal cost about $1000 per hectare annually.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 - Stuff

Ad Feedback
special offers
Auckland

Plans for second pool underway

West Wave Pool and Leisure Centre can have over 1 million visitors in a year.

Hang on west Aucklanders, a new public pool facility is on its way.

Auckland Māori ward considered

Maori Party co-leader Pita Sharples agreed, with former Minister of Local Government and ACT leader Rodney Hide, to ...

Auckland Council to vote on whether to introduce Māori councillor option in next election.

Court rules against beneficiary

Niki Rauti has lost her fight and will now face eviction from her Glen Innes home.

Auckland social housing tenant loses year-long struggle to stay in home of three decades.

Eight more allege sex abuse

Alosio Taimo will go on trial in July 2018.

Auckland school volunteer facing 81 charges after more people come forward.

Wellington

RocketLab makes it pay

Rocket Lab is planning a launch next month from the Māhia Peninsula.

The first one failed but the next test launch from the Māhia Peninsula will carry satellites.

Outbreak's $21m bill

April Singh, 41, of Havelock North, who contracted Guillain Barre syndrome after coming down with campylobacteriosis in ...

The Havelock North gastro outbreak made 5500 people sick, now the bill has been added up.

'A lovely, caring man'

Sid Hanzlik, who died after a small fire outside parliament, is understood to have been aggrieved after dealings with ...

Neighbour tells of shock at death of Sid Hanzlik after fire on Parliament grounds.

Where is Lester on Shelly Bay?

Wellington Mayor Justin Lester will not vote on any Shelly Bay issues because one of the developers contributed $2000 to ...

Wellington mayor has stood aside from voting on one of the city's biggest issues.

Canterbury

Heritage project ready to go

25092017 news supplied
An artist's impression of the restored Public Trust building in central Christchurch.

The new owners who rescued Christchurch's old Public Trust building are close to starting work on renovations.

Truck blocks SH7

Motorists travelling through the Lewis Pass should expect lengthy delays after a truck crash on Wednesday morning. (File ...

Motorists travelling through the Lewis Pass should expect lengthy delays after a truck and trailer rolled.

Where you pay 38c more for petrol

Petrol prices in the Southern Lakes average about 23 cents a litre higher than in the North Island.

The core price of petrol is the same across the board, but they'll charge what they can.

Running club nightmares

When my boss volunteered me for the run, I thought a couple of hikes in the hills would make for some great Instagrams. ...

One outing in my spandex completely negates the horrific things I did to my body all week.

Waikato

Shot-up Holden for sale

Turners strongly recommends that you view the vehicle before bidding.

Car at centre of shoot-out and subsequent manhunt has turned up on the Turners lot.

Trio in serious crash

Hamilton City councillors Mark Bunting, James Casson, and Dave Macpherson got frustrated with the slow process and put ...

Man cut free of Honda Integra wreckage after latest smash at notorious intersection.

Man killed by falling tree named

Arthur Hinds had been working on a property in Whenuakite, north of Tairua.

Man killed by tree he was cutting down was conservationist Arthur Hinds.

Go on, have a decent lunch

When Noel Cimadom saw the 1908 Cambridge post office site, he changed his to plan to move closer to Auckland, to open ...

Italian who brought a bit of Europe into Cambridge's historic post office offers some perspective.

Taranaki

Lives cut short remembered

Sir Jerry Mataparae and Brigadier Evan Williams attended the commemoration of 10 New Zealanders who were killed in a ...

Two Taranaki men were among 10 Kiwis killed in a train accident during the First World War.

Fewer ships hurts port

Port Taranaki ceo Guy Roper forecasted stable future after challenging year.

Port Taranaki's profits dropped 6.5 per cent last year, its annual report says.

Parliament fire victim's protests

Sid Hanzlik, who died after a small fire outside parliament, is understood to have been aggrieved after dealings with ...

In the days before his fiery death, Sid Hanzlik was outside Wellington's courts with banners.

A socially challenging job

Artist Paul Rangiwahia has been invited to speak at Taranaki Base Hospital in conjunction with Social Workers Day.

Death, illness and abuse and grief are all part of the job for a hospital social worker.

Manawatu

Pedalling a green dream

Green Bikes general manager Peter Cooke likes giving old bicycles a new lease of life.

Meet the man giving new life to old bikes in Palmerston North.

Scarce on detail video

Contractors fix the damaged Manawatū Gorge road in May, before it was deemed unsafe for workers.

About 300 people attended a meeting in Woodville to discuss gorge alternatives.

Motorist kills sheep

State Highway 2 was blocked near Pahiatua by a crash on Tuesday evening.

A car crash near Palmerston North left sheep dead. The driver was unharmed.

Putting NZ First

Don't dare ask Winston Peters who he's going to choose to be New Zealand's next Government. There are democratic ...

OPINION: Peters' plan to follow a "democratic process" is the biggest untruth of them all.

Nelson

Weta get prime real estate

Nelson Central School Enviro Agents Claudia Rigg, left, Alex Gavin, Ashlee Eves, Ruby Mead, Caitlin Solly and Nelson ...

The weta around Nelson Central School are getting the royal treatment from 

Street upgrade overrun

Poppy Thai owner Pobsak Srithong says he has paid the debt he owed to his landlord.

A revised construction programme for Queen St upgrade at Richmond has been released.

Farmers' Market heads riverside

Miriam Clark, manager of Nelson Farmers Market, in Morrison Square.

Nelson's Farmers' Market is to shift from the CBD to a new riverside location.

Cricket great coming to town

Former NZ cricket captain and diarist, Walter Hadlee.

Sir Richard Hadlee set to launch late father's 1949 cricket tour diary in Nelson.

Marlborough

Man faces 65 drugs charges

Ricky Michael Boyd, 27, has been charged with offering to sell drugs several times a week over about five months. (File ...

He allegedly offered to sell meth and cannabis several times a week for months.

Battle to save the park

Marlborough Sounds ward councillors have convinced the Marlborough District Council to put the proposed truck park out ...

There are more trucks hanging about Picton and plans are in place to pave over a park. Not everyone is happy.

Driver trapped after truck rolls

Fire crews are working to free the person trapped after a truck and trailer unit rolled.

The driver of a truck and trailer unit became trapped after rolling their vehicle north of Kaikoura.

Pay win becomes a loss

Aberleigh Rest Home, in Blenheim, sent a letter to staff last month announcing its restructure plans.

Care workers jobs to go after equal pay win, replaced by "home assistants". Rest home says it's all it can afford.

South Canterbury

Grand response limited video

Timaru's 105-year-old Hydro Grand Hotel, owned by developer Allan Booth, has been called unsafe as it awaits demolition.

Dangerous designation appears no automatic move to demolition.

Reports 'tip of iceberg'

Raising awareness around elder abuse will help increase the number of reported incidences of abuse, Templeton says.

Age Concern establishes new elder abuse role following concerns of unreported abuse.

Swooping magpies concern

Shirley Halkett is dive bombed by a protective magpie while cycling in the Scenic Reserve.

Cyclists call for signage warning of the dangers of nesting magpies in a Timaru reserve.

Family violence a major issue

Councillor Steve Wills said family violence was a major issue in South Canterbury.

Steve Wills has been appointed South Canterbury's first White Ribbon Ambassador.

Otago

South Island's only NZ First MP shown ropes

Clutha-Southland New Zealand First candidate Mark Patterson, centre, with his family on election night, from left, his ...

NZ First's only South Island MP shown the ropes at Parliament.

Fuel for frustration

Clutha Leader reporter Mary-Jo Tohill.

From The News Desk - Fuel for frustration.

Where you pay 38c more for petrol

Petrol prices in the Southern Lakes average about 23 cents a litre higher than in the North Island.

The fundamental price of petrol is the same across the board, but they'll charge what they can.

Car parking restrictions coming

Queenstown Lakes District Council proposed to build three new bus stops on Camp St, two near Shotover St roundabout.

"To make transport more efficient, economic and possibly more enjoyable, a behavioural change is required." Tony Pickard

Southland

Deveron St groups make their case

Number 10 youth leader Emma Prinsloo, on right, with youth behind her making their case to councillors.

Invercargill citizens have restated their pleas to save the youth centre at 10 Deveron St at an Invercargill City Council meeting on Tuesday.

Rough waters

Federated Farmers representatives speak to their submission on the Proposed Southland Water and Land Plan at Environment ...

Legal challenges are "inevitable" if the proposed Water and Land Plan goes ahead.

New crossing under trial

Civil Works and Construction Ltd, of Christchurch, works on the new trial pedestrian crossing at James Hargest College ...

Now you see it - now you see it.

Volunteers earn their reward

South Alive manager Cress Evans, community development coordinator Nikki Aaron and chairperson Robyn Hickman with the ...

South Alive say it was the hard work of their volunteers that saw them win the supreme award at the Trust Power Awards in Invercargill.

Ad Feedback